News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The AirPods Effect by oceanplexian on Friday June 19, 2026 @01:27PM (#48600871)
Yeah, great article. But it should get to the point.

The reason you need to physically remove yourself is because of the insane lunatics that blast trash music and do a dance while aggressively panhandling or screaming at you for trying to commute quitely on the train to work. A hallmark of daily life when I worked in SF and in NYC.

A great way to fix the fake problem would be to aggressively enforce the existing laws, starting with tickets, and if that doesn't work, incarceration. Apparently it's not politically correct to do that though so I guess we are all second class citizens who need to live in a low trust society where people are increasingly isolated.

Re:The AirPods Effect by cglan on Friday June 19, 2026 @01:46PM (#48601093)
Coming back to the states after traveling abroad is always astonishing. For all our wealth, it genuinely feels worse than somewhere like Brazil in many of our big cities
Re:The AirPods Effect by pclmulqdq on Friday June 19, 2026 @03:38PM (#48602381)
The Brazilian government keeps the crime contained to specific areas, where it gets extremely bad. In the US, a generalized lack of enforcement means small amounts of nuisance crime spread around.
Re:The AirPods Effect by ares623 on Saturday June 20, 2026 @12:54AM (#48606444)
uhh, could it be perhaps you've just been living in the "specific areas" where crime is "contained" in the US.
Re:The AirPods Effect by pclmulqdq on Saturday June 20, 2026 @09:42AM (#48609174)
If you mean “cities” then yes. Google the word “favela” if you want to see how things work in Brazil.
Re:The AirPods Effect by nonethewiser on Friday June 19, 2026 @04:51PM (#48603117)
It has nothing to do with wealth. It’s just policy.
Re:The AirPods Effect by retired on Friday June 19, 2026 @07:18PM (#48604454)
There is a difference between being a tourist somewhere and actually living there.
Re:The AirPods Effect by throwawaytea on Friday June 19, 2026 @08:54PM (#48605157)
Being a tourist in SF is probably way worse than being a resident that knows what to avoid doing and where to avoid going.
Re:The AirPods Effect by finales on Friday June 19, 2026 @01:33PM (#48600934)
People can’t understand you can’t have both protecting the poor and not enforcing laws against the poor at the same time
Re:The AirPods Effect by vicnov on Friday June 19, 2026 @05:42PM (#48603598)
You can be poor and obey the law. You can protect the poor and enforce the law.

It is the weird identity politics is what gets in the way.

Re:The AirPods Effect by braiamp on Friday June 19, 2026 @06:03PM (#48603797)
There's a easier solution by crime caused by poor people: they stop being poor. The fact that nobody tried is the thing that should be studied instead.
Re:The AirPods Effect by mpyne on Friday June 19, 2026 @07:24PM (#48604526)
I grew up poor and that was never an inducement to commit crime. I took plenty of "food I didn't want" off my friends' hands at lunch in middle and high school, but never even thought of crime.

Although my parents weren't rich they still tried to teach right from wrong, respect for others and all the rest.

And not to put too fine a point on it, but there's plenty of examples of rich assholes who act as if money makes them immune from justice.

Re:The AirPods Effect by Empact on Friday June 19, 2026 @07:04PM (#48604327)
There's abundant evidence against this belief:

  * Lottery winners do not commit less crime than those who do not win the lottery: https://www.nber.org/papers/w31962
  * Studies of identical twins adopted and raised apart shows that crime is more correlated with genetics than environment: 45% nature vs 18-27% nurture https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25936380/
  * "While individual study estimates vary, meta-analyses have suggested the level of heritability of antisocial behavior is approximately 40–60%. Shared environmental factors have been estimated to explain approximately 11–14% of the variance in antisocial/criminal behavior and non-shared environmental influences approximately 31–37%" https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6640871/
  * “Black men raised in the top 1 percent – by millionaires – were as likely to be incarcerated as white men raised in households earning about $36,000.” https://www.prisonpolicy.org/blog/2018/03/19/race-class-debate/
Re:The AirPods Effect by Izkata on Friday June 19, 2026 @07:30PM (#48604573)
Indenting that triggered monospace code formatting, which is preventing those from becoming links.
Re:The AirPods Effect by habinero on Friday June 19, 2026 @11:09PM (#48606005)
I'm hearing this high pitched sound, does anyone else hear that?

I clicked and scrolled through several of those studies, and those snippets are incredibly misleading. I would recommend not using these in debates, unless you want to come across as a poor researcher acting in bad faith.

The very last one says nothing about genetics at all, that's saying the justice system is biased.

The second to last is part of a much more nuanced section talking about environmental impacts and the role that can play in biological expression. It literally says:

> Thus, just as biological mechanisms can influence environmental responses, environmental stressors can affect biological expressions.

I stopped reading at that point.

Re:The AirPods Effect by snovv_crash on Friday June 19, 2026 @06:40PM (#48604137)
The poor are impacted by lawlessness far more than the rich. No private security or fancy neighbourhoods. Cutting down on actually harmful bad behaviour (and by this I mean dealers and muggers, not broken taillights) is the best thing you can do for poor people.
Re:The AirPods Effect by gacgacgac on Friday June 19, 2026 @06:58PM (#48604287)
This is nonsense. You absolutely can have both -- typically by building systems to eliminate poverty and reduce income inequality.
Re:The AirPods Effect by itake on Friday June 19, 2026 @02:36PM (#48601688)
I’ve been in the Baltic countries for a few weeks. I do not see any of the behaviors you mentioned, but all the behaviors mentioned in the article.

I don’t think this is a bad music problems

Re:The AirPods Effect by jasonfarnon on Friday June 19, 2026 @07:25PM (#48604531)
You also see the behavior in the middle of the woods on a hike, or as the article mentions at upscale cafes. The whole point of the article is the near universality of wearing airpods. So a comment dwelling on US urban subways tells you more about the comment-writer's preoccupations then any sociological insight. And a top comment tells you mainly something about the preoccupations/demographics of the site.
Re:The AirPods Effect by tverbeure on Friday June 19, 2026 @02:47PM (#48601813)
> if that doesn't work, incarceration.

Sure, let’s “solve” a minor problem in the grand scheme of things with a much larger evil.

Re:The AirPods Effect by gfody on Friday June 19, 2026 @02:53PM (#48601888)
incarceration is going too far, all you need is a few enforcers with shock wands like in Demolition Man
Re:The AirPods Effect by playerm1 on Friday June 19, 2026 @03:08PM (#48602049)
Maniac has responded with a scornful remark!
Re:The AirPods Effect by nonethewiser on Friday June 19, 2026 @04:55PM (#48603149)
Wont someone please think of the unstable homeless person threatening people on the street.

Incarceration is more humane for everyone than letting sick people live on the street.

Re:The AirPods Effect by habinero on Friday June 19, 2026 @11:21PM (#48606065)
Threatening to revoke the rights and freedoms of your fellow citizens and put them in a hellhole is pretty antisocial and sociopathic behavior, my dude. That makes me suuuuper uncomfortable.

Oh no, better throw you in jail so I don't have to think about you. Don't mind the moldy bugs in your food, that's just extra protein.

Re:The AirPods Effect by georgemcbay on Friday June 19, 2026 @04:16PM (#48602782)
> The reason you need to physically remove yourself is because of the insane lunatics that blast trash music and do a dance while aggressively panhandling or screaming at you for trying to commute quitely on the train to work.

I've lived (and commuted on public transit) for years in many metros including SF, NYC, Boston and DC and can't recall even a single such interaction.

I'm sure it happens, I'm also sure it happens far less often than your competing anecdote suggests.

Re:The AirPods Effect by bradleyjg on Friday June 19, 2026 @02:53PM (#48601884)
I’d say it’s the opposite. We get non enforcement and anti enforcement because lots of people aren’t directly affected.

Different neighborhoods, work from home, private transportation to work, or—admittedly to a lesser degree—AirPod insulation.

If we were really all this together quality of life in our cities would be taken far more seriously.

Re:The AirPods Effect by SubmarineClub on Friday June 19, 2026 @05:49PM (#48603662)
No, it’s because city politics in the US are dominated by naive bleeding-heart type leftists who are willing to overlook any and all forms of antisocial behavior if it’s committed by a poor and/minority individual.
Re:The AirPods Effect by habinero on Friday June 19, 2026 @11:13PM (#48606025)
Considering that's where all the people and money are in this country, it's clearly not a problem for most folk. You're entitled to your outlier opinion, of course.
Re:The AirPods Effect by kranke155 on Friday June 19, 2026 @02:51PM (#48601853)
Incarceration would be nuts.
Re:The AirPods Effect by nonethewiser on Friday June 19, 2026 @04:59PM (#48603179)
For what exactly? And unstable homeless person threatening people on the street?

Harassing people and living on the street is already crime. Camping in public, public nuisance, loitering, obstructing sidewalk, etc.

Re:The AirPods Effect by hnav on Friday June 19, 2026 @05:51PM (#48603681)
I have come to the conclusion that until I am part of the landed gentry, the erratic homeless are a positive impact on my life. They may be a nuisance and cost me a stolen package here and there but when the “let them eat cake” types move into the neighborhood is when I get priced out. That is to say like inflammation is a symptom of something being wrong in the body, their plight is emblematic of the struggle that affects everybody but the upper crusts of society. You can try to treat the symptom in either case but there are much deeper structural problems.
Re:The AirPods Effect by snovv_crash on Friday June 19, 2026 @06:42PM (#48604157)
Do you also think we should get rid of sealed sewers and keeping the roads intact in order to bring down property prices?

Maybe this is a sign of deeper structural issues and we shouldn't regress as a civilization but rather fix what the actual problems are.

Re:The AirPods Effect by hnav on Friday June 19, 2026 @07:26PM (#48604540)
I’m not saying that we need to regress further as a society. I was merely providing a counterpoint to the argument that the homeless need to have their agency stripped because they’re a negative value to “productive” society.
Re:The AirPods Effect by snovv_crash on Saturday June 20, 2026 @05:33AM (#48607790)
Their negative value isn't to productivity, but to your personal safety and quality of life, and frankly their safety and quality of life too. Accepting that people who cannot look after themselves need to be looked after by the community rather than left outside to die, I personally feel, should not be a controversial position.
Re:The AirPods Effect by eur0pa on Friday June 19, 2026 @01:42PM (#48601036)
Oh lord not the laws and especially not the tickets
Re:The AirPods Effect by pclmulqdq on Friday June 19, 2026 @04:35PM (#48602970)
This is why they cane people in Singapore for nuisance crime. Incarceration is expensive and fines don’t have the right effect.
Re:The AirPods Effect by milesskorpen on Friday June 19, 2026 @02:09PM (#48601370)
While that does happen occasionally in SF, it's <5% of my commutes.
Re:The AirPods Effect by vkou on Friday June 19, 2026 @02:29PM (#48601614)
It's been 0% of my commutes in Seattle. Yet the NC headphones are also everywhere, including on my head.
Re:The AirPods Effect by cloverich on Friday June 19, 2026 @04:16PM (#48602780)
TBF seattle is particularly bad - it's famously unfriendly compared to other cities.
Re:The AirPods Effect by klardotsh on Friday June 19, 2026 @10:28PM (#48605773)
Wildly unfriendly and standoffish, but also extremely unaccepting of dinguses blasting music without headphones on trains and buses. You win some, you lose some. I’ll embrace the silence and make my friends outside of transit and elevators, I think. (Bias disclaimer: PNW dweller for the past 9 years)
Re:The AirPods Effect by vkou on Friday June 19, 2026 @02:28PM (#48601601)
Pretty sure my commute of 12 years had exactly zero aggressive panhandling (or unaggressive panhandling), yet just about every single person on it was wearing some flavour of them.

I've also just been in Japan, where nobody's commute has panhandling of any kind, and guess what, everyone there is tuning the world out with their headphones, too. Despite it being kind of verbotten to make noise on the subway, and the few conversations that were happening on it were very quiet.

I wasn't wearing mine during that trip. Because a relatively quiet space was actually pleasant for me to be in. American cities are so fucking noisy, and as a consequence, even people respectful of their surroundings tend to be loud.

Re:The AirPods Effect by andrepd on Friday June 19, 2026 @02:14PM (#48601422)
Eh I don't think so. Commutes are as clean and peaceful as they can be in the Netherlands or Switzerland and people are no less buried in their phones with noise-cancelling earbuds on.
Re:The AirPods Effect by KolmogorovComp on Friday June 19, 2026 @03:17PM (#48602152)
Why is this downvoted? This is correct.
Re:The AirPods Effect by vkou on Friday June 19, 2026 @03:33PM (#48602336)
People like blaming everything that is wrong in their life on lack of law enforcement against the undesirables.

It's a tale as old as time.

Re:The AirPods Effect by plutokras on Friday June 19, 2026 @04:59PM (#48603171)
Can confirm. Traveling via public transport in Switzerland is remarkably uneventful. It's a stark contrast to my Eastern European home country, where it is a gamble due to a certain demographic's anti-social behavior.
Re:The AirPods Effect by Foobar8568 on Saturday June 20, 2026 @01:01AM (#48606485)
I commute every day in Switzerland, and we have people blasting music, shouting, putting feet on seats, taking 3 seats etc, including in 1st. I actually stopped traveling in 1st, it could be more noisy and chaotic than 2nd and the price difference wasn't worth it.
Re:The AirPods Effect by retired on Friday June 19, 2026 @07:23PM (#48604519)
The Netherlands has plenty of crazies using public transport. Every other window on the train has the emergency number on it for a reason. I refuse to travel in second class, hate being close to people that blast music, use drugs, puke or eat a broodje pindakaas.

The Netherlands even has segregated busses for asylum seekers because there was too much violence. Dutch people have their own busses and asylum seekers are required to use a separate bus with extra security. Upside is that asylum seekers don’t have to pay for a ticket.

Re:The AirPods Effect by andrepd on Saturday June 20, 2026 @04:45AM (#48607517)
You make it sound like it's an absolute warzone (your demographic certainly likes to push that narrative even in the most uneventful of places!). Yes I've taken trains back home from nights out at 4:30 in the morning where there were drunk girls talking loudly and (gasp!) trash on the floor. There's certainly no-one "blasting loud music" in the average train and definitely not "doing drugs".

Ofc there's a non-zero number of crazies, violent people, sexual harassers, etc. That's a certainty in a system with 400 million trips a year! But then please don't leave your home, there can be an ax murderer lying in wait at any corner!

Re:The AirPods Effect by retired on Saturday June 20, 2026 @10:31AM (#48609498)
I would see people doing drugs about twice a week during my commute pre-Covid
Re:The AirPods Effect by nonethewiser on Friday June 19, 2026 @04:52PM (#48603128)
It’s a mixture of naivety and foreign influence campaigns.
Re:The AirPods Effect by teaearlgraycold on Friday June 19, 2026 @05:51PM (#48603675)
What's interesting is how the culture of the homeless people seems to differ across SF. Civic Center to 6th & Market is consistently the worst in my experience in terms of volatile people.

Tenderloin these days is relatively peaceful (plenty of people on the streets but they're just getting high with their friends).

Mission is chaotic, extra poop on the sidewalk, sometimes masses of people 50+ deep. But also the people on the street seem to mostly know and take care of each other. Higher density of people selling stolen goods. If I take Muni bus 14 home at 3AM it's a bunch of people shuttling to shelters but being polite (although not always lucid), exchanging cans of soda, etc. However I've heard quite a few stories from 38 with people being threatening or worse.

Re:The AirPods Effect by throwforfeds on Friday June 19, 2026 @05:55PM (#48603725)
I haven't seen showtime on the subway here in NYC in a long time. And even when it happened more often, they generally would dance for all of one stop before moving to the next train car. So, what, like ~3 minutes of your commute?

Much more annoying to me these days are all the people that have decided it's acceptable to stare at their phone and zombie walk out of the train and up the stairs, completely oblivious to the world around them. They're not even making noise, just walking straight into other humans in a busy station while scrolling tiktok.

Re:The AirPods Effect by SllX on Friday June 19, 2026 @06:34PM (#48604089)
I’ll add onto this the PA system & noise from the trains themselves. BART isn’t exactly a quiet train system, and MUNI is far too comfortable blasting announcements & propaganda through its PA system telling you not to commit crimes.

Those speakers by the way are an ADA requirement, and the only information that should be coming out of them are the stop announcements & any comms from the driver that may be necessary. Anything else in four different languages is not required, including the track telling you not to stand too close to the doors on the bus.

Re:The AirPods Effect by deet on Friday June 19, 2026 @08:08PM (#48604822)
While commuting can be chaotic, I don't think what you're calling out is the central point of the article.

Spaces that are less chaotic - coffee shops, gyms, even elevators - are places that people used to be able to strike up random short conversations with each other. Sometimes these would become longer. Sometimes they even turned into friendships.

It still happens of course, but I, like the author, am saddened that casual socialization seems to be on the decline.

I like to say Hi to people in elevators. Some reciprocate. Some find it awkward. But I don't even bother saying Hi to those wearing AirPods since that would be rude, interrupting them. Could an interaction have brightened our mutual days? Could we have become friends? Who knows, AirPods preempted it from the start.

Re:The AirPods Effect by clukic on Friday June 19, 2026 @11:28PM (#48606089)
This reply is perfect. The anger encapsulated in it captures the exact crux of the post. The point, of course, is that advances in personal technology have coincided with a cultural shift where people feel entitled to personal isolation in public spaces.

When I moved to NYC 30 years ago, one of the things that made me fall in love with the city was the way that living in such close proximity to so many others seemed to create so much more empathy. The same effect, I now see working in reverse, minimizing contact with others with by disappearing into technology has the effect of making people less empathetic. Instead of reaching into their pocket for a subway performance, or a homeless person, people might prefer to see them arrested for the crime of violating their all important personal barriers.

Re:The AirPods Effect by pie_flavor on Saturday June 20, 2026 @12:34AM (#48606367)
I don't feel entitled to personal isolation from people who might want to strike up a conversation. If I'm not in the mood, I'll just say so.

I feel entitled to personal isolation from schizophrenics, who have a good chance of assaulting me if I look at them wrong. (And did you think screaming and playing loud music was disruptive just to quiet, and not to the aforementioned conversation too?)

You are the problem, not the person you're replying to. When you say 'you must exhibit infinite tolerance of antisocial disruption', the easy response is 'or I could always just leave'.

Re:The AirPods Effect by DANmode on Saturday June 20, 2026 @12:47AM (#48606423)
My home is now a place where people are mortified by the homeless, and literally give them things off of themselves, or offer ways to existentially assist, on-sight.

Maybe it’s the crushing disproportionate volume and nature of the poverty that each effective individual is confronted with that’s to blame - I still believe people are inherently good, but they do give up pretty easily if you make it socially acceptable to ignore.

I will no longer choose to live in places it’s socially acceptable to ignore.