News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by janaagaard on Friday June 05, 2026 @03:06PM (#48416820)
What are the rules? Is it okay to use autocomplete? Are spell checkers accepted? What if I used an AI chatbot to figure out something instead of a traditional search engine?
Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by jrflo on Friday June 05, 2026 @04:17PM (#48417611)
Is it ok if I used a compiler and didn't write the assembly code by hand?
Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by happytoexplain on Friday June 05, 2026 @05:01PM (#48418226)
It's hard to tell if you're mocking the parent's fallacy or contributing to it.
Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by pan69 on Friday June 05, 2026 @09:28PM (#48420469)
I suppose the argument being made is more about the meaning of human made rather than GenAI.
Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by baobabKoodaa on Friday June 05, 2026 @06:17PM (#48419060)
You're implying compilers now utilize generative AI somehow? I doubt that very much.
Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by vjvjvjvjghv on Friday June 05, 2026 @05:01PM (#48418222)
Nope. You also can't use a CPU made by big ASML machines. If you decide to go with a mechanical computer I am not sure if a lathe is ok.
Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by baobabKoodaa on Friday June 05, 2026 @06:17PM (#48419067)
You start from a rock and build your own CPU.
Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by happytoexplain on Friday June 05, 2026 @04:48PM (#48418053)
This is dishonest (and very common). You may certainly argue that genAI content should count as human-made, but it's pointless to just gesture at pre-genAI tools like autocomplete and insist that other people do the work of comparing/contrasting.

It's OK to use the term "human made" to mean "not the output of genAI". There's no "gotcha" to be scored here.

Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by Cyberdogs7 on Friday June 05, 2026 @05:39PM (#48418694)
Ok, what about a more direct take.

Hello games made a game called No Man's Sky which has VERY heavy use of procedural generation. Same as Minecraft.

If someone were to make the same games using genAi, would it be less impressive, even if the output was 'better'?

Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by happytoexplain on Friday June 05, 2026 @07:06PM (#48419502)
Yes, of course.

But even if the answer was no, I don't see the relationship to what I said. I never commented on "impressiveness".

Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by baobabKoodaa on Friday June 05, 2026 @06:18PM (#48419078)
Yes.
Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by throawayonthe on Friday June 05, 2026 @06:31PM (#48419195)
yeah?
Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by em-bee on Friday June 05, 2026 @09:16PM (#48420414)
i think you need to be more specific: if just the procedural generation was replaced or augmented with AI generation, would that be less acceptable? the procedural part is machine generated either way and everything else is done by hand as before.

the question here really depends on how much the procedural generator is an artwork in itself, and how much that would be lessened by using AI to generate the worlds instead.

Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by kbrkbr on Friday June 05, 2026 @04:58PM (#48418182)
What is dishonest about asking for clarification of submission criteria that are utterly unclear?

> Help us to signify and share projects done by humans (not AI).

Here is nothing about GenAI specifically.

Who else could be asked if not the ones that set up this collection?

Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by mrkeen on Friday June 05, 2026 @05:15PM (#48418432)
I dunno what version of the site you saw, but it probably hasn't changed in the last 17 minutes since your post.

  There's only one rule: generative AI cannot be used in the creation of the project.
Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by F3nd0 on Friday June 05, 2026 @04:55PM (#48418157)
None of these amount to AI making something. Before AI, it’s been humans who put the words on the paper, who put the strokes on the canvas, who put the notes on the sheet. Spell-checking and auto-completion have existed before AI and do not fundamentally change the process.

Since this project singles out AI (likely generative AI using machine learning), it seems evident to me that it rules out any involvement which does fundamentally change the process, i.e. what people otherwise do when creating.

(Yes, one could argue that e.g. word processing or printing have also fundamentally changed the process, and that is absolutely true, but each of those has changed the process differently than machine learning has, and clearly this website considers the changes made by AI undesirable in some ways, not the changes made by word processing or printing.)

Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by d3Xt3r on Friday June 05, 2026 @07:44PM (#48419847)
The question remains. Where do you draw the line? What are the rules?

The site only states "There's only one rule: generative AI cannot be used in the creation of the project.", without defining any further rules, nor does it clarify the exact definition of "creation of the project".

Like, what if you included a library in your project that was vibe-coded (but your main code wasn't), would your project be considered as "human-made"?

Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by F3nd0 on Friday June 05, 2026 @08:09PM (#48419996)
> The question remains. Where do you draw the line? What are the rules?

These questions absolutely remain, but their scope is not nearly as wide as some people here make it out to be. Of course, narrowing it down further might be nice.

Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by g-b-r on Friday June 05, 2026 @08:44PM (#48420218)
> Like, what if you included a library in your project that was vibe-coded (but your main code wasn't), would your project be considered as "human-made"?

Of course not.

Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by d3Xt3r on Friday June 05, 2026 @08:47PM (#48420240)
What if the library was human-made, but that library included a library that was vibe-coded?

If that's not okay, what if the library included a library which included a library that was vibe-coded?

Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by g-b-r on Friday June 05, 2026 @09:15PM (#48420411)
I think you know the answer :rolleyes:

Hopefully things are not so bad yet that it's an unlikely situation

Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by d3Xt3r on Friday June 05, 2026 @09:18PM (#48420422)
I don't know the answer, so please do enlighten.
Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by g-b-r on Friday June 05, 2026 @10:16PM (#48420755)
Any dependency on a vibe-coded library, however indirect, makes an application not 100% human made (since the application relies on the library for some of its featutes).
Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by d3Xt3r on Friday June 05, 2026 @10:42PM (#48420892)
If that's going to be your definition, then it's going to be extremely difficult, if not impossible to have a 100% human made program, unless you've personally hand-coded the entire OS, or you've verified beyond doubt that no vibe-coded dependency exist in the entire dependency chain - both build and runtime, direct and indirect.

I'm not sure how feasible verification of that would be, unless we have some "certified 100% human" certification program of some sort, with an external auditing agency or something - because you can't trust humans, they will 100% lie.

Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by g-b-r on Friday June 05, 2026 @11:12PM (#48421027)
If "verifying the entire dependency chain" is that difficult for your project, you have a problem in any case (and you're probably using npm).

You don't need to have personally hand-coded the OS, of course, you just need a OS that's not vibe-coded, and hopefully that just means avoiding Windows.

Even if you actually consider the OS a dependency, which is a stretch

And hopefully vibe coding doesn't get as widespread to become hard to avoid it.

Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by d3Xt3r on Friday June 05, 2026 @11:29PM (#48421102)
> If "verifying the entire dependency chain" is that difficult for your project, you have a problem in any case (and you're probably using npm).

That's a problem for anyone coding a modern app these days, not just npm users.

> You don't need to have personally hand-coded the OS, of course, you just need a OS that's not vibe-coded, and hopefully that just means avoiding Windows.

That's a problem too, because Linux is already accepting gen-AI code, and you can bet your arse that Google and Apple are too. So that just leaves the niche OSes, and although I don't know of their individual stances, the trust problem still remains - how do you know they're not using gen-AI in some shape or form, without some sort of formal certification and auditing system?

Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by g-b-r on Friday June 05, 2026 @11:49PM (#48421209)
> That's a problem for anyone coding a modern app these days, not just npm users

I wouldn't really say that

> That's a problem too, because Linux is already accepting gen-AI code

If it's accurately reviewed it's fine for me, although yeah, it wouldn't fit the 100% human definition.

Just as you can make GPL software for closed-source operating systems, though, I think you could ignore the OS in a definition of 100% human-made software.

Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by d3Xt3r on Saturday June 06, 2026 @04:07AM (#48422580)
> I wouldn't really say that

We can agree to disagree, but pretty much every modern app uses dependencies at some level, and that's a problem for everyone. Sure, npm is probably the worst of them all, but even the so called "safe" Rust is very heavy on dependencies - just look at any popular Rust project these days. It's only a matter of time until a malicious or poor quality code makes its way in a popular Rust project... or any other project for that matter. Just see the state all the popular FOSS projects are in, they're all getting swamped by LLM-driven PRs, so much so that some projects (like Ladybird) have decided to stop accepting PRs completely.

The problem isn't just about whether or not the code is accurately reviewed, because under pressure, humans are bound to slip up - just take a look at what happened with the XZ project, it has now become a textbook example of how projects can be compromised. LLMs have made the situation worse, it's only a matter of time until we see a second or third Jia Tan due to the pressure maintainers are in - or we see more FOSS projects stop accepting PRs altogether.

In such a scenario, every dependency is a liability.

And if you ignore the OS, that means you're drawing an arbitrary line in the sand - because how would you define what consists of an "OS"?

Going back to our example app, what if the app's dependency is Qt, and if Qt has vibe-coded components - by your original definition a few comments ago, that would make your app not human-made. But many distros also include Qt components OOTB due to some dependency or other (eg for KDE), so that would mean the OS is also not 100% human-made right?

Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by happytoexplain on Friday June 05, 2026 @08:55PM (#48420295)
"You must nail down every single detail in objective terms" is a dishonest requirement we, as engineers, reach for when we don't like something subjectively. It's petty. It's not honest.
Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by d3Xt3r on Friday June 05, 2026 @09:05PM (#48420361)
If you're an engineer, you'll understand why it's not petty. You do not want ambiguity in engineering. If you cannot even define what it is that you're campaigning for, then it's just random ramblings with no substance. No one's going to take you seriously if you can't even define what you're asking of others.
Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by selfhoster1312 on Saturday June 06, 2026 @03:39AM (#48422434)
You don't want ambiguity in a proper engineering project. In a simple webpage denouncing the slop machine and their prevalent sloperators, I've got more than enough to know i appreciate the initiative. I'm personally considering an actual boycott of anything remotely involving AI.
Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by d3Xt3r on Saturday June 06, 2026 @04:42AM (#48422789)
That's fine, but again, you need to be clear on where you're drawing the line. Because boycotting "anything remotely involving AI" means boycotting all mainstream operating systems (Linux, Windows, Android, macOS, iOS) - which means ditching smartphones completely and maybe even mobile phones completely (because I'm not sure if you can find a 4G-capable phone that doesn't use some sort of Linux-based OS).

But this also means you won't be able to work most white-collared jobs, as almost every such job these days involves operating a computer running a mainstream OS. But I guess there are still some jobs out there where you could be operating a legacy OS, such as as some banks and other financial institutions, maybe you could learn COBOL and work on mainframes or something.

And naturally your boycott would also include most of the modern web, because most web browsers these days have some sort of AI involvement or the other, not to mention most mainstream websites as well. So there's a good chance that even though you're working on old-school mainframes, you may still need to do your timesheets or taxes or whatever on a modern website. Or send emails at the very least. So most modern jobs would be a no-go.

So I hope you've got your line well defined, because "anything remotely involving AI" is a pretty loaded phrase that could completely cut you off modern technology and workplaces, and you could end up living the life of a hermit, or a medieval-era farmer or something. Which, I'm not saying is a bad or impossible thing - I know at least a couple of people who quit IT completely, took up farming and have gone off-grid - its certainly doable, so the question is, how badly you hate AI, and how far are you willing to go?

Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by leephillips on Friday June 05, 2026 @06:21PM (#48419102)
I made some rules: https://lee-phillips.org/humanmade/

I think I draw the line at a place that makes sense. (And mine was first, but I don’t care, as long as the movement takes off.)

Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by throawayonthe on Friday June 05, 2026 @06:23PM (#48419119)
what are the rules for hand-made? is it okay to use blades? are tables accepted? what if i used a digitized text to learn my craft

come on

Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made by keernan on Saturday June 06, 2026 @08:37PM (#48430630)
What if I use a hammer.