Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made
by Cyberdogs7 on Friday June 05, 2026 @05:39PM
(#48418694)
Ok, what about a more direct take.
Hello games made a game called No Man's Sky which has VERY heavy use of procedural generation. Same as Minecraft.
If someone were to make the same games using genAi, would it be less impressive, even if the output was 'better'?
Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made
by happytoexplain on Friday June 05, 2026 @07:06PM
(#48419502)
Yes, of course.
But even if the answer was no, I don't see the relationship to what I said. I never commented on "impressiveness".
Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made
by baobabKoodaa on Friday June 05, 2026 @06:18PM
(#48419078)
Yes.
Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made
by throawayonthe on Friday June 05, 2026 @06:31PM
(#48419195)
yeah?
Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made
by em-bee on Friday June 05, 2026 @09:16PM
(#48420414)
i think you need to be more specific: if just the procedural generation was replaced or augmented with AI generation, would that be less acceptable? the procedural part is machine generated either way and everything else is done by hand as before.
the question here really depends on how much the procedural generator is an artwork in itself, and how much that would be lessened by using AI to generate the worlds instead.
Re:Let's celebrate work that is 100% human-made
by kbrkbr on Friday June 05, 2026 @04:58PM
(#48418182)
What is dishonest about asking for clarification of submission criteria that are utterly unclear?
> Help us to signify and share projects done by humans (not AI).
Here is nothing about GenAI specifically.
Who else could be asked if not the ones that set up this collection?
It's OK to use the term "human made" to mean "not the output of genAI". There's no "gotcha" to be scored here.