News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Project Gutenberg – keeps getting better by idoubtit on Saturday May 16, 2026 @05:10AM (#48158372)
Not the GP, but I also have mixed feelings about Standard Ebooks. They modernise texts for American readers. This means changing the punctuation, merging some words, altering the syntax, etc.

When I read an old novel, written two centuries ago in England, the little differences to modern English are part of the charm, and I certainly don't want any Americanism mixed in. For one of my favorite novels, The Forsyte saga, the author deliberately used some rare forms of words, which SE replaced with the mainstream forms.

Re:Project Gutenberg – keeps getting better by jcurtis on Saturday May 16, 2026 @06:37AM (#48158890)
You may already be aware, but SE marks all commits making those kinds of changes as '[Editorial]', so it is generally trivial to use their tooling to build your own high-quality ebook without any of the editorial changes.
Re:Project Gutenberg – keeps getting better by mrob on Saturday May 16, 2026 @06:42PM (#48164412)
When I tried this in the past, it was non-trivial because the editorial changes are mixed with the technical changes. Reverting the editorial changes broke the technical changes.
Re:Project Gutenberg – keeps getting better by AdamN on Saturday May 16, 2026 @05:15AM (#48158409)
SE sounds truly, truly awful. Thanks for making me aware of its existence so I can avoid it.
Re:Project Gutenberg – keeps getting better by phaedrix on Saturday May 16, 2026 @11:25AM (#48161025)
They're providing beautifully made ebooks for free...

The only thing they are is truly, truly wonderful.

Re:Project Gutenberg – keeps getting better by AdamN on Monday May 18, 2026 @07:20AM (#48178073)
But why not be true to the original author's text? What's the need to modify it?
Re:Project Gutenberg – keeps getting better by encrypted_bird on Friday May 22, 2026 @05:50PM (#48242141)
Not parent, but while I can appreciate your viewpoint, I would like to point out that many many many books have abridged, reworded, simplified, or disambiguated versions for different audiences.

The Bible is I daresay the most famous of these. Translations aside, even the English versions have had significant alterations done to wording, spelling, and meaning depending on the version.

There's also the Great Illustrated Classics imprint for certain classic novels like H.G. Wells's The Invisible Man. (I read that one like 10 times as a kid and it's what got me into sci-fi as a whole I'd argue. Haha.)

Whether these alternate versions are good or bad is obviously up for debate and depends on the person, but I'm just saying that what SE does is hardly new in the publishing world.

Re:Project Gutenberg – keeps getting better by condwanaland on Sunday May 17, 2026 @01:13AM (#48166203)
SE is an amazing and wonderful resource
Re:Project Gutenberg – keeps getting better by acabal on Saturday May 16, 2026 @10:07AM (#48160395)
SE editor in chief here. What you describe is incorrect. The only thing we do is very light sound-alike spelling modernization, like "to-night" -> "tonight". We do not do things like change from en-GB to en-US, replace old words with different modern words, or change text for "American readers", whatever that means. I have no idea where you got that impression.

I personally worked on the Forsyte saga. If you think something was done in error, please let us know and we'll be happy to fix it.

Re:Project Gutenberg – keeps getting better by natex on Saturday May 16, 2026 @11:52AM (#48161263)
> The only thing we do is very light sound-alike spelling modernization, like "to-night" -> "tonight".

Curious. Why even bother?

Re:Project Gutenberg – keeps getting better by bell-cot on Saturday May 16, 2026 @05:39PM (#48164053)
Guess: screen readers and such.
Re:Project Gutenberg – keeps getting better by tangledhelix on Saturday May 16, 2026 @03:41PM (#48163134)
One could argue that this falls into the previous poster's thought about "the little differences to modern English are part of the charm" ...
Re:Project Gutenberg – keeps getting better by mrob on Saturday May 16, 2026 @06:40PM (#48164391)
I commented on this kind of editing several years ago:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16957359

The edit is still in place, and I still maintain that changing 'phone to phone in dialogue changes the meaning.

Re:Project Gutenberg – keeps getting better by jeltz on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @06:34AM (#48191576)
Yeah, that edit clearly changes the meaning of the text.