News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by Cortex5936 on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @11:56AM (#47850587)
I love GrapheneOS and I use it daily for more than 2 years. However, and as Louis Rossmann pointed out in one of his videos, they really need to work on the "defensiveness" and "rants" of their communication. Even when they are 99% right most of the time, they sometimes don't come as mature and professional.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by Georgelemental on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @12:09PM (#47850796)
Personally, I like that they come across as a little paranoid. That's exactly the attitude I want in the people protecting my privacy and security. I hope the developers lie awake at night, unable to fall sleep because terrified that someone somewhere is plotting to attack and exploit them
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by busterarm on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @12:12PM (#47850833)
There's healthy paranoia and there's treating even casual commentary/criticism from anyone as an existential threat & coordinated attack...and responding to that with sustained, coordinated attack campaigns online. That's what Micay's history is.

That's not healthy for any project.

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by Cider9986 on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @12:42PM (#47851236)
Recently, the socials have been more moderate and level-headed, imo.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by TehCorwiz on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @01:04PM (#47851496)
Based on how discourse in the US has been perverted by inches and millions of mosquito bites they may not be wrong. Stamping out bad information fast and hard seems to be the only way to combat mass coordinated disinformation. Being polite just lets people play the "both sides have merit" game.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by user_7832 on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @01:13PM (#47851620)
Could you share a link or something about this?

> ...responding to that with sustained, coordinated attack campaigns online. That's what Micay's history is.

For the rest, in general, I'm tempted to give grapheneOS the benefit of the doubt. Running any FOSS project is hard, running it against the (implicit) wishes of OEMs/Google (who throw in things like Play Integrity) is even harder, and doing it when 3 letter agencies at the US govt actively hate you is harder still.

Being paranoid in responses to FUD campaigns isn't ideal, but save coordinated attacks, I'd say fairly understandable.

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by HybridStatAnim8 on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @03:13PM (#47853162)
No one on the GrapheneOS team is paranoid.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by microtonal on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @02:56PM (#47852943)
Well, they have had to deal with multiple swattings, constant misinformation from some competitors (e.g. Murena's CEO doing interviews with various media where they insinuate that security-hardened systems like GrapheneOS are only for criminals and secret agents, complete with 'think of the children'-style arguments), and some local/national governments boosting the narrative that GrapheneOS is for criminals.

So I can understand why they are as defensive as they are.

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by HybridStatAnim8 on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @03:12PM (#47853153)
This is false. Commentary and criticism is not treated as a coordinated attack. Coordinated attacks are treated as coordinated attacks. Criticism is often used as an excuse to try and hide attacks, and many people unfortunately cannot tell the difference. Kind of like this reply, which attacks Micay under the guise of criticism.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by singing_tartly on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @05:19PM (#47854628)
not true at all...

There's no coordinated attacks on anyone or projects by GrapheneOS. They respond to misinformation, that's about it.

There have been many attacks on privacy/security projects, not just GOS, recently. If you keep up with the GOS forum you can see posts saying GOS was hacked without evidence. Other claims that GOS is only used by criminals. Theyre not true. Misinformation that aims to destroy the reputation of the project should be responded to.

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by uqers on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @12:44PM (#47851258)
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by Cider9986 on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @01:30PM (#47851849)
That's hilarious thanks for sharing.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by tokai on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @12:48PM (#47851303)
Realistically Stallman would start lecturing them on how his licenses are not open source.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by kibibu on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @02:23PM (#47852483)
Richard Stallman would most certainly not use the term open source to lecture somebody about free software.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by HybridStatAnim8 on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @03:09PM (#47853113)
Thats... a horrible thing to want for someone. No one on the GrapheneOS team is paranoid or mentally ill.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by finalst on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @04:05PM (#47853838)
While I understand you are trying to be positive about this, I don't think it's good to want our team portrayed like this, sorry. Paranoid people are people who'd easily be influenced into doing harmful behaviors because it believes it will stop their problems. Making a response to inaccuracies and bad journalism platforming an extremely malicious actor isn't a symptom of that. We don't have people with severe mental illness on the team. That would be irresponsible and mental illness is not something to romanticise in my opinion.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by Georgelemental on Wednesday April 22, 2026 @09:59AM (#47863770)
There is a very broad spectrum between "completely average and neurotypical" and "severe mental illness". E.g. "slightly atypical personality". The world would be a boring place if everyone was exactly the same
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by finalst on Wednesday April 22, 2026 @01:21PM (#47866496)
I agree for sure everyone should be different and have a diversity of how peoples brains work. The same type of think puts us into a bubble. We are definitely atypical because we are developing something quite atypical as well. Coming as a project member I just sometimes see comments that call us stuff like 'schizos' or 'paranoid' even when it is intending to be positive. I guess somehow they believe someone with a severe mental issue is more likely to an adversary of the government or whatever enemy they perceive? I don't know the justification behind it. I just find that odd, we're quite ordinary people actually. I don't think it does good for mental health awareness and for people who actually have these issues to backseat diagnose how people's minds supposedly work.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by neonstatic on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @12:15PM (#47850887)
It's a personality type / disorder (pick your poison). There's no hope for change. Programming seems to attract such people, because they are fixated on being right and proving that they are right. I know a few more examples. My common sense policy is - if the software these types produce works for me, I will be using it, but I will never allow myself to be dependent on it. That kind of person will gladly burn their own house to the ground, with everyone in it, if that's what's required to prove their truths or maintain some kind of intellectual purity.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by 1attice on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @01:05PM (#47851513)
One common personality disorder I see a lot is psychologizing your interlocutors to invalidate them, thus insulating you from having to think you're wrong about something

Classic OCPD behaviour

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by throw4847285 on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @01:12PM (#47851598)
One common personality disorder I see is being extremely defensive when encountering any discussion of human psychology. This comes from a deep psychological fragility.

Classic OAD (Obvious Asshole Disorder)

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by 1attice on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @01:20PM (#47851728)
You couldn't even bother to google an actual disorder! Bah, you insult me :)
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by u8080 on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @05:52PM (#47855028)
>being extremely defensive when encountering any discussion of human psychology

You just have paranoidal schizophrenia and attributing imaginable things to random people you don't like.

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by neonstatic on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @01:31PM (#47851861)
Ok, but what I'd be wrong about here? I'm not even claiming that the person in the article is that way. I don't know enough about them. I have noticed a certain trend, however, and that's what I was noting.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by HybridStatAnim8 on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @03:24PM (#47853337)
Nobody on the GrapheneOS team is mentally ill or unwell. There is no personality issue. Defending themselves is not an ubquenchable drive to be right, it is the right of anyone to be able to defend themselves.
[dead]
[dead]
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by balamatom on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @12:22PM (#47850974)
No.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by uberman on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @12:15PM (#47850873)
By extension should we not use Linux as Torvalds is essentially in the same boat?
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @12:40PM (#47851197)
> By extension should we not use Linux as Torvalds is essentially in the same boat?

Eh, Linus signs his personal name to rants. Having a blog post by GrapheneOS per se making non-factual personal attacks (nestled among, to be clear, factual attacks) does seem wanting for maturity, at least from a distance.

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by toaste_ on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @12:33PM (#47851107)
When Louis Rossmann thinks your communication has a problem with going on rants, it must be pretty out there.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by Cider9986 on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @12:43PM (#47851252)
Louis has a Kiwifarms[1] account.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kiwi_Farms

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by OsrsNeedsf2P on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @12:46PM (#47851275)
So do I. What's your point?
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by not_really on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @01:29PM (#47851826)
The point is, you are a terrible human if you subscribe to that trash. Wake the fuck up man, that shit is awful.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by kiwiscum on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @01:14PM (#47851629)
Anyone who participates in a website that exists to coordinate the doxxing and harassment of people into committing suicide is the absolute lowest kind of bottomfeeder in society, no better than a common murderer, and anything they say is completely worthless. The open source emulation community lost an unbelievably talented individual because of people like you. In a just society you should be completely ostracized for admitting this, if not outright put in a cage on conspiracy charges.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by akimbostrawman on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @04:06PM (#47853847)
>Anyone who participates in a website that exists to coordinate the doxxing and harassment of people into committing suicide is the absolute lowest kind of bottomfeeder in society

okay and? Do you have any proof Rossmann has done any of that. He made the account for the sole purpose of engaging with _his_own_thread_ on the site... Does defending yourself from "coordinate the doxxing and harassment" make you "the absolute lowest kind of bottomfeeder in society" too?

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by HybridStatAnim8 on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @04:19PM (#47854024)
Rossmann made a thread on Kiwi Farms because Kiwi Farms members support him, and they support harassing his targets.

Rossmann has an account on Kiwi Farms for the purpose of engaging with his supporters on the site. He acts friendly with them and they choose to actively support him.

Rossmanns thread on the site is in support of him, not a harassment thread against him.

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by akimbostrawman on Wednesday April 22, 2026 @05:29AM (#47861136)
>Rossmann has an account on Kiwi Farms for the purpose of engaging with his supporters on the site. He acts friendly with them and they choose to actively support him

Once again. Okay and? Kiwifarms is a legal site in the us. He is engaging in no harassment or doxxing of anyone just talking to people that talk about him. Does micay talking on twitter with other people mean he supports musk or anything else anybody does on the platform?

If all your points are just "guilt by association" then just say that.

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by tranq_cassowary on Wednesday April 22, 2026 @05:47PM (#47869693)
KiwiFarms is a platform created for the purpose of cyber bullying, harassment and encouraging self-harm. This is very different from a general purpose social media platform that happens to have people signing up that misbehave. The whole point around KiwiFarms is that it's a place to be the most terrible version of yourself and the promise that it won't be moderated. It says a lot about Rossman that he believes it's worth engaging with such people there. Yes, reasonable and ethical people would indeed choose to not be associated with KiwiFarms.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by handedness on Wednesday April 22, 2026 @09:09PM (#47871243)
It's beyond guilt-by-platform-use. I just started looking into this today, but the primary dox thread thanks Rossman for information he provided, so I'm not entirely sure about your claim. When Rossman does weigh in on that site he seems fairly unbothered by the fact that people on there are posting every private detail they can unearth of Micay's and calling for Micay's violent murder, at least from what I've seen in my cursory glance.

He's also made highly-viewed videos theatrically (and ridiculously) expressing technically unfounded concerns about the project, laid the blame at Micay's feet, and went on to make verifiably false claims about the project, about himself, about his own relation to it (from everything I can find about it), and appears to have no problem stoking any of it.

I had long appreciated Rossman's work on right-to-repair, but when that video came out I found it pretty beneath his potential. He scored cheap points from his considerably bully pulpit for his own benefit.

Reducing that to mere guilt by association hardly captures it.

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by handedness on Wednesday April 22, 2026 @09:10PM (#47871247)
It's beyond guilt-by-platform-use. I just started looking into this today, but the primary dox thread thanks Rossman for information he provided, so I'm not entirely sure about your claim. When Rossman does weigh in on that site he seems fairly unbothered by the fact that people on there are posting every private detail they can unearth of Micay's and calling for Micay's violent murder, at least from what I've seen in my cursory glance.

He's also made highly-viewed videos theatrically (and ridiculously) expressing technically unfounded concerns about the project, laid the blame at Micay's feet, and went on to make verifiably false claims about the project, about himself, about his own relation to it (from everything I can find about it), and appears to have no problem stoking any of it.

I had long appreciated Rossman's work on right-to-repair, but when that video came out I found it pretty beneath his potential. He scored cheap points from his considerably bully pulpit for his own benefit.

Reducing that to mere guilt by association hardly captures it. I posted some more detail here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47868159

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by joyous_limes on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @02:32PM (#47852605)
Rossmann is a way bigger ranter than GrapheneOS people. Have you seen some of his videos lol.

Rossmann wanted to work with GOS and they didn't want him. So Rossmann made that video to make Daniel look bad for revenge probably. Saying he was leaving GOS was a lie, not that GOS can push malicious updates which was also a huge lie. Even after pointing that out that part wasn't corrected because Louis doesn't care about accuracy, he only cares about making Daniel/GOS look bad. He used his big following to punish Daniel. Now he works with Nick from Calyx after he got pushed out and are doing business together.

The more you learn about the story, the more you see the Copperhead stuff was just the beginning and those involved held grudges and pushed their grudges onto more people who bought their lies and it continued. Privacy-focused OSes that pretend to compete with GrapheneOS suck. GrapheneOS is led by someone with integrity, unlike some other projects.

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by handedness on Wednesday April 22, 2026 @09:11PM (#47871264)
That video of Rossman's was cheap theatrical trash. Disappointingly beneath him.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by HybridStatAnim8 on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @03:15PM (#47853186)
Rossmann publicly blasted a private discussion, twisting what was going on, and then lied to his own viewers. Such a claim from an identity verified kiwifarms account holder holds no weight.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by akimbostrawman on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @04:08PM (#47853875)
repeating the same lie doesn't make it true. do better, GrapheneOS deserves that too.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47853847

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by mrbn100ful on Wednesday April 22, 2026 @12:06PM (#47865595)
HybridStatAnim8 is Micay

He loves using alias, he does the same thing on X btw.

It is super easy to tell, account last few months and only ever talk about GOS.

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by daemonspudguy on Wednesday April 22, 2026 @01:06PM (#47866314)
No. He is not. He's posted before at times that Micay cannot possibly be online at. He is a different person entirely. This is easily disproven by thinking about the logistics. Unless you think Daniel Micay is up 24/7.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by retrochameleon on Wednesday April 22, 2026 @02:52PM (#47867693)
Twisted what? Rossman showed lots of receipts in the video.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by tranq_cassowary on Wednesday April 22, 2026 @05:42PM (#47869655)
Rossman leaked private messages without properly giving background information about preceding private conversations that they had and about the circumstances that occured just before the conversation he leaked. It was very bad faith.
[dead]
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by balamatom on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @12:52PM (#47851352)
Signal obedience at all times or be destroyed.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by simianparrot on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @12:40PM (#47851202)
Agreeable people don't make it very far. But please do put your money where your mouth is and try for yourself, show us the way.

I'll keep being disagreeable. Because it works.

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by idle_zealot on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @01:20PM (#47851723)
Parent is obviously being sarcastic.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by simianparrot on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @02:00PM (#47852172)
Poe's law gets me again. It's getting really rough these days on HN, I have to admit... My bad. Seems the AI-Protectorate Flagging Brigade managed to parse the sarcasm though.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by mvkel on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @12:41PM (#47851209)
Being "right" shouldn't excuse bad behavior, especially if you depend entirely on a community to survive, which we all do.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by HybridStatAnim8 on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @03:20PM (#47853262)
There is no bad behaviour. Defending oneself isnt an unreasonable thing to do. GrapheneOS is entirely funded by donations and receives a lot of donations to this day. Them defending themselves is not an existential risk, the attacks against them are.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by balamatom on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @04:09PM (#47853885)
Why the scare quotes? Being right is the literal opposite of bad behavior.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by mvkel on Wednesday April 22, 2026 @10:22AM (#47864093)
If you have zero consideration for other people, sure.

"I can't believe you wrote this terrible code. You clearly don’t understand how concurrency works. Do it again."

Technically right, but when you run out of people who actually want to work with you, you'll be writing the code yourself.

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by balamatom on Wednesday April 22, 2026 @06:29PM (#47870144)
What's worse: good work that I get to do myself, or bad work that I'm forced to accept anyway?
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by aphorism on Wednesday April 22, 2026 @11:58AM (#47865499)
Which "bad behavior" are you talking about?
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by Matl on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @01:18PM (#47851693)
> However, and as Louis Rossmann pointed out in one of his videos, they really need to work on the "defensiveness" and "rants" of their communication

Not that I disagree but Louis Rossmann giving someone advice to tone down the rants is ironic.

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by busterarm on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @02:52PM (#47852885)
The difference is that Louis' rants are contained to his channel and largely only paid attention to by his fanbase.

Micay rants are most often on other peoples' platforms and he deliberately tries to draw as much public attention as he can muster.

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by HybridStatAnim8 on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @03:17PM (#47853231)
GrapheneOSs posts are made to combat misinformation. Drawing public attention from those who may be misled and put at risk is how one combats misinfo. Its not ranting and its not somehow unreasonable to defend oneself.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by busterarm on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @03:45PM (#47853594)
Your entire comment history on HN exists across two separate posts about GrapheneOS.

You're not a community member, you're an astroturfer.

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by HybridStatAnim8 on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @04:06PM (#47853846)
Yeah, that is my entire comment history. I wasnt hiding that. I made this account to help with the misinfo.

I dont know what astroturfer means though.

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by HybridStatAnim8 on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @04:45PM (#47854292)
I have been a GrapheneOS user for several years, and I choose to dedicate my time supporting the project. Supporting an open source project is not 'astroturfing'.

I am an active chatroom member, and many people see me there on a regular basis. I choose to volunteer my time, and am not paid or compensated in any form.

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by microtonal on Wednesday April 22, 2026 @05:04AM (#47860969)
Ehm,

Astroturfing is the deceptive practice of hiding the sponsors of an orchestrated message or organization to make it appear as though it originates from, and is supported by, unsolicited grassroots participants.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Astroturfing

They are pretty much the opposite of an astroturfer, they mentioned several times in the comments that they are an active supporter/community member of GrapheneOS. So, they are not hiding and they are grassroots participants.

Please avoid personal attacks on HN, even more so when they are incorrect.

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by neilv on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @01:23PM (#47851767)
My gut feel is that Micay is genuine, and obviously also very defensive.

At least some of the defensiveness is warranted. Maybe most of it. Regardless, it comes across in most GrapheneOS communications, and it's sometimes counterproductive.

A related issue, which I'm sure Micay can appreciate, is that users of GrapheneOS tend to be cautious, and increasingly will want to know why the project should be trusted, now that it is popular and on a lot of radars of adversaries.

(For example, hypothetical scenario that's plausible, given the incentives: State actor (e.g., RU, US, CN) or organized crime group long-con starts with a public harassment campaign of Micay. Followed by sleeper volunteers taking more control of the project, initially under the pretext of helping insulate Micay from harassment, and taking some of the load off. Later maybe even impersonating Micay. Now the threat actor has backdoors to a large number of especially privacy/security-conscious parties, including communications, 2FA, location, cryptocurrency wallets, internal networks where those people work, etc.)

I think it probably hasn't been compromised like that, but it's an obvious real possibility, and IMHO, until GrapheneOS is more transparent, some natural users of GrapheneOS are going to consider iPhone relatively "the devil you know".

Again, I think Micay is genuine, and I'm a fan of the project and appreciate it. And I hope the project understands that's compatible with critical thinking about infosec, and doesn't take personal offense at that.

(Source: Am long-time GrapheneOS user, and have donated.)

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by microtonal on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @02:51PM (#47852870)
I agree that this is an issue, but it is impossible to prove a negative. The same could be said for Apple's or other manufacturer's signing keys. Who guarantees that the US government hasn't required access to the iOS signing keys? Or China in exchange for access to the Chinese market? They probably wouldn't even want to reveal that the signing keys were leaked if they were allowed to, since it would undermine their security story.

With a non-profit project of highly principled security experts, there is at least a high probability that they'd rather blow up the project than compromise. People elsewhere in the thread criticize Micay because he deleted the CopperheadOS keys, but to me it increases trust in the GrapheneOS project, since he clearly puts the security of his users over money, fear, and whatnot.

In the end trust arises from running a project or company long-term without evidence that you somehow compromised security.

I wonder in general how this situation could be improved. Second or third independent reproducible build + confirmation signing?

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by HybridStatAnim8 on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @03:08PM (#47853094)
All of the defensiveness is warranted. They speak neutrally and objectively.

The project is not going to relinquish control to any 3rd party. Not even the Motorola partnership is given control over the GOS project. The hypothetical you describe is not possible by design.

The GOS project takes no issue with critical thinking, and encourages it. But that is often used as an excuse to handwave attacks. There is a very big difference between criticism/critical thinking and attacking them.

Note that there are more individuals in the project than Micay. Multiple people handle multiple responsibilities, its not one person.

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by ryandrake on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @04:41PM (#47854263)
> The GOS project takes no issue with critical thinking, and encourages it. But that is often used as an excuse to handwave attacks. There is a very big difference between criticism/critical thinking and attacking them.

Responding to attacks so defensively is almost alway a bad look for organizations. They could really use a PR person with a more measured voice that corrects facts and projects confidence, and does not convey victimhood, insecurity or defensiveness. Take a look at the tone of press releases issued by companies when some tech press bozo writes a hit piece on them, for good examples of dealing with people attacking you.

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by HybridStatAnim8 on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @08:09PM (#47856701)
I would not use those words to describe the approach they take. They make the effort to speak neutrally and objectively, but the issues they are making light of are often exactly as extreme and common as they describe. Many people have voiced appreciation that they decide against a "corporate-speak" approach. The GrapheneOS accounts are meant to be accounts that let project members speak to users, rather than take on a corporate appearance.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by neilv on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @05:03PM (#47854476)
I'm sure you realize that confident assurances of a random new pseudonymous account on a Web site isn't sufficient for anything of importance.

Is there an authoritative source of information about how a takeover like that isn't possible by design, which people can verify, analyze, hold parties accountable for the pieces that require it, etc.?

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by HybridStatAnim8 on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @06:10PM (#47855248)
I am a GrapheneOS user and community member, and I am active in the chat rooms. I made this account to assist with misinformation.

As for how such a thing would not be possible;

-GrapheneOS updates do not trust the network, so any compromise of update servers for OS and app updates would not be able to push malicious updates. Only those who hold the signing keys are capable of pushing updates that will be accepted.

-Multiple people review the code that gets included in the OS. There is not one point of failure when it comes to social engineering.

-GOS supports reproducible builds, so the code that is published can be verified to be the code that is built for the official builds.

So in other words, you would need to convince multiple people who are consciously protecting against this, and who have a proven track record of burning the keys if the privacy and security of their users are in jeopardy. On top of that, you need to conceal this from every developer, moderator, and community member who would raise the alarm at the slightest indication of compromise.

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by ForHackernews on Wednesday April 22, 2026 @07:21AM (#47861983)
They are not neutral and objective, they're extremely hostile, especially (and ironically) to other projects that share similar goals. Key developers quit CalyxOS after harassment from GrapheneOS/McCay.

https://recapio.com/digest/grapheneos-documenting-numerous-a...

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by aphorism on Wednesday April 22, 2026 @11:55AM (#47865463)
Calyx Institute and GrapheneOS are both really great projects. I support them both. I rely on products from both.

You're not doing either project any favors by pretending that hastily generalizing nerd dramas and autism over-corrections is somehow a broad statement on the neutrality and objectivity of GrapheneOS's team or the high-quality product it produces.

This kind of bad faith posting is bad for the whole FOSS/libre community, and it's both dumb and rude, in contradiction of HN's site guidelines.

[dead]
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by spring-onion on Wednesday April 22, 2026 @06:52PM (#47870330)
The author of that blog got mad we didn't want to implement a feature they wished for. Their duplicate issue was closed and later deleted and they made a public drama out of it for... what reason?

Let me tell you something. I personally reached out to them just a few weeks ago. I didn't argue, I didn't blame them. That was not my intention and I communicated that clearly. Those were not empty words, I went into it with a genuine open mind and with the goal of finding a solution. After all they consider themselves an open source enthusiast.

It didn't go anywhere. They did not seem willing to discuss anything at all really. You see, even if we assume they are 100% in the right, i.e. they did nothing wrong, why would they oppose our attempt at resolving the conflict? I've come to the conclusion there is no good faith argument to be made here. They spread their post all over the internet, heck they even linked it on Facebook.

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by aphorism on Wednesday April 22, 2026 @05:31PM (#47869552)
Not a sock, just finally annoyed enough to actually login and say something.

I can see you can't engage about this without hurling wild accusations, so peace out.

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by wyldfire on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @01:39PM (#47851940)
It would be interesting if there were a state sponsored effort to discredit a project that helps some people keep their communications private.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by Cider9986 on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @01:53PM (#47852103)
There might be one, in France.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by dooglius on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @02:10PM (#47852301)
Have you considered that the smooth-talking "mature" and "professional" people are more likely to sell your data to advertisers at the first opportunity?
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by HybridStatAnim8 on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @03:03PM (#47853032)
Louis Rossmann caused a lot of harm to GOS and blasted them publicly for trying to raise issues privately. That is disgusting behaviour. He then lied to his own viewers about no longer using GrapheneOS, lied about fears of a targeted update despite that not being possible, among a lot of other things. Note he also has an identity verified kiwifarms account.

GOS only defends themselves from attacks. Its not that they are misinterpreting what is an attack, there are really just that many attacks. It leaves little room for much else than defense. Nobody should have to deal with the inhumane level of attacks.

Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by jasonvorhe on Wednesday April 22, 2026 @05:23AM (#47861096)
I don't care about messaging or professionalism in marketing. I'm perfectly happy with the way GrapheneOS is being managed right now, including their lengthy technical rebuttals to any attempts of attacking the project to dilute its quality or reach.
Re:Original GrapheneOS responses to WIRED fact checker by aphorism on Wednesday April 22, 2026 @12:21PM (#47865769)
So what if they're defensive and cringe in their rants? Are you so indoctrinated into believing performative aloofness is "professional" that you can't see clearly?