It's worth noting though that the actions of the "stereotypical man" are strongly culturally informed, and not neccessarily indicative of whatever evolutionary pressures would've wired males brains whatever way they're wired for fatherhood. I don't think we have much direct evidence of ancient female and male parent roles (apart from being able to infer the obvious, like that females would've breastfed).
PS: prediction power and testable.. could be science where it not for utopist airsuperiority
Tribes tend to have thin men. They dont have big bulky muscles. Agricultural subsistence cultures tend to have thin men.
They can be violent all the same. Just that bulky look is modern male aesthetic.
The point of the article is that nurturing babies is one of those things that stereotypical men already do. Probably not as much as women, but it is a research result we could have guessed. Turns out that men care about the success of their children too, who knew.
> And as a corollary the idea that a high-T man somehow is a worse caregiver, and that it needs to be reigned in by some adaptation.
You're reading things that the article did not write. The article did make some political calls around more parental leave and a call for fathers to be more involved with their children, but that isn't any sort of knock against all the other hormones that humans have.
Sure people might believe that; lots of people believe a lot of wildly stupid things. But it isn't in the article. There isn't anything judgemental in observing that people's lifestyles can cause hormonal shifts.
Then you'll enjoy all the contrarian opinions on both sides. Also here in HN comments.
But also not to infants.
I think he's saying that a manly man might not be soft and cuddly with a small child like a traditional mother would. But that is not necessarily detrimental. For instance, a guy might not want to coo and caw, or change the pitch of his voice, or giggle, things that some men find weak. But (perhaps - I don't know anything about children) the child may still respond positively to a male who used his normal voice and interacted with them however he naturally felt.
Do hunter gatherers split care of tiny children? Whatever they do is what we’re wired for, mostly.
Hadza men spend enough time with their children that their T levels drop: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2674347/
Aka men are doting fathers to the point of letting their children suck on their nipples: https://www.theguardian.com/society/2005/jun/15/childrensser...
This is a nice survey of the role of fatherhood in various cultures, with a focus on foragers: https://anthro.vancouver.wsu.edu/media/documents/fa_role_201...
Near the beginning, the paper states that humans are extremely unusual in the rates of paternal investment that fathers do. With most species, the male dips out. Men don't always spend a lot of time on children, but they do have the wiring for it. It seems to be one of the many traits that sets humans apart from other species.
Like the experiment where the monkeys wouldnt eat bananas for generations after the electric shocker attached to them was removed - they had internalised the idea that bananas gave shocks, we have also internalised these untrue ideas.
Also, they have very distinct spatio-temporal skills compared to men. And that experiment is nothing against millenia on behaviour encoding in your genes.
https://www.researchgate.net/scientific-contributions/Jorge-...
American Social Pseudosciences should shut up their Sokal-like mouth and learn the basics for once and all.
They did tests and trials on how human males and females do orient themselves on distinct environments. Females used points and clues from the environment creating some kind of a graph and men used geometry with distances as vectors and rotations.
That on average, of course, because there wil always be overlapping edges. Women using 'male' bound orientation schemes and vice-versa. And they also showed how females could find Waldo-finding like tasks much faster on average than males, while the males were better of focusing for long a single point against slighly moving surronding events without distracting themselves.
This is not pseudoscience nor male chauvinistic bullshit. It's the pure reality. Hormones drive us, either you like it or not.
Discrete math vs linear algebra. Distinct tools to solve the same problem. Which is better? It depends on the case.
Since you like to appeal the authority of some dude, let me give it to you straight from the "About Author" section from goodreads.com.
Are you ready?
> Allan Pease is an Australian author and motivational speaker. Despite having no education in psychology, neuroscience, or psychiatry, he has managed to establish himself as an "expert on relationships".
> Originally a musician, he became a successful life insurance salesman, he started a career as a speaker and trainer in sales and latterly in body language. This resulted in a popular sideline of audio tapes, many of which feature his irreverent wit.
Hahahahahaha, I literally couldn't make this shit up. Good luck out there, buddy!
It affects me as a man, too, be highly educated or not. As I said, one of my favourite recreational Math authors (like Conway or Gardner) it's a woman, and her favourite Math branch it's discrete Math. Now, please, understand that she was pefectly able to understand the rest, as Mathematician men are able to the same with subjects they don't like much, too.
PD: women on average have a more developed language area than men. They can process and send more complex information like men on a single sentence from subtones in every word. If men use more 'complex' language than women on average it's because women already told everything implicitly with every subtone in words driving subtle but different messages women are able to understand but men do not.
So, most of what men do it's to add syntactic sugar while women have a much superior context aware syntax.
I literally give you a link that points out that what you're basing your beliefs on, is from some motivational speaker, pop-science, borderline con-artist author.
And you reply with... more anecdotes. Do you not see the irony? Are you incapable of reflecting on this?
There are of course some statistical biological (hormonal, physiological, whatever) differences between women and men. But there are also statistical biological differences between... men! And we are not grouping men like this, except in caste systems or believers in racism. So why should we do this for women?
Because it's extremely convenient for people like you, to have women classified as child-rearers and general house servants, and then retroactively explain that this is "natural" with anecdata and pseudoscience, and never having to make any real attempt at gender equality.
No hay más ciego que el que no quiere ver...
Le dijo la sarten al cazo.
Yes, there are differences, and this is not pseudoscience. Nor hints about castes about races.
https://www.uoc.edu/en/news/2023/286-gender-differences-in-v...
>why should we do this for women?
Should we ban men from poetry/arts too? That would be dumb. In my case, Discrete Math and combinatorics where hell compared to other Math branches. Yet I could approach them from overlapping subjects. Women do the same, they applied different strategies and then they bound them together. This requieres effort for both genders? OFC, but that's the 'winning' strategy; the most different skills you gather, the better.
Men prefer measure and rotate and women use nodes and graphs? How about using both by definning a lattice and placing easy nodes as helping points making orientation a breeze for both genders?
Also, if you negate any difference, how come men and women tend to lose different brain sections upon dementia/Alzheimer?
Exactly, so please stop with the "women are better at [whatever task you don't want to deal with]" stereotypes. It's all pseudoscience, trying to find some "natural" or biological basis for oppressing people, just like racism.
Hormones' influence it's pretty real.
In order to avoid oppresions, we have the law systems, thank you.
The left loves to focus on extremes and tries to cancel the whole graph, as it happened with the post from Google on women and men in STEM. The right would love to snip any edge (artsy men, even if they are nerdy/geeky), or technical women -there are several, even in rural places where often men died young, far earlier than women and thus they had to learn several skills in order to survive. Heck, with Bulma from Dragon Ball and Scully from The X-Files there are tons of them, more than the mentioned Bell curve's edges.
And yet here we are. Both the extreme left and extreme right hate Science, because it makes most of their arguments a total bullshit.
Said this:
- quotas on race, gender or sexuality are bullshit. Are you poor and/or disabled? Ok, set quotas for these, as they are in actual danger.
- It will never a 50/50 parity of men/women in STEM by design. Maybe in 50000 years, but for that you would need to have proper parental leaves and throw the 40h week to the trash. Since the 80's the productivy skyrocketed and by just working 20h/week (even by employing 1.5x more people) the producitivy would be equal if not superior, because of the lack of burnouts. Also, the economy would rise a lot too, as people would have more time to go outside and do the chores. Healthcare costs would plummet down too as stress and mental related illnesses would go near 0.
In Spanish (your browser will automatically translate it for you):
https://jorlab.blogspot.com/2002/10/hormonalmente-orientados...
Sorry, what? The framing of this sentence alone has a very creepy vibe. I can't speak for all of us, but most us have strong protective instincts towards kids of all ages, especially the youngest ones.
> This is why many men find it difficult, it is contrary to instinct.
Contrary to whose instinct? If I had a kid, I would want to ensure his/her safety and success. Men in general yearn for it. And there's nothing that suggests men are incapable of it. Research indicates good outcomes. And I know fathers who are the sole care givers for young kids when life makes it inconvenient for the mother.
> Do hunter gatherers split care of tiny children? Whatever they do is what we’re wired for, mostly.
Hunter gatherer culture is at least ten thousand years old - plenty of time for social behavior to evolve. Modern humans, including men are very heavily invested in kids because humans can't have a lot of kids. Ensuring each one's safety becomes important.
Heck! Humans, including males are very nurturing and protective towards even children of other men and other species. Plenty of evidence that your assertion doesn't hold at all.
Biology it's the same, hormones run much faster than social customs.
We tried with religion/law, which the 'original sin' it's just a metaphor on hormone drived behaviours VS the learned behaviours in order to create a successful civilization/trive/society without wars. Probably that happened after last big ice defrosting.
Geologically speaking, we are civilized beings since 'yesterday'.
We tried that by force: Stalinisms, religion based totalitarian states, nazism creating a demon scapegoat... they failed. You can't drive changes on decades. It's impossible. Humanities' people fail to understand this. You need an effort of millenia in order to get some visible results.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/403855473_Sex_diffe...
Now keep your Humanities away from actual facts, please.
BTW, my favourite pop-science Mathematician it's a woman and the subject she loves most it's DIscrete Math, something directly related to my beloved computers too. She has no issues with the rest of branches but as I said the one she feels more confortable with it's graphs, nodes and whatnot.
Said entirely with love, this is a worse look, a cliche even. https://www.quora.com/What-s-wrong-with-saying-some-of-my-be...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clara_Grima
Said this, most Mathematicians -no matter women or men- owe a lot to Gardner and Conway.
Non recreational math from Clara:
In very much more serious, but perhaps less kind thoughts, do you not get halfway through writing things like that without considering how fundamentally broken that thinking is? My heart seriously goes out to you, unless it’s not ok given I am pretty tall and you might be 12 or something so it may still be a few years before we can talk, but I may be dead by then and it feels like you could use a pal, lil buddy.
It’s not difficult at all. Minutes after birth, naked baby was on my naked chest, and bonding started. This never felt contrary to my instinct.
I agree that it’s the most natural thing, and I consider most of my time spent elsewhere to be a waste, but our youngest is very active and worrying about her wellbeing for extended periods is definitely exhausting!
And what's society without kids? Whether you're a parent or not, we need kids to do well. It makes no sense at all not to learn to be good with kids, to care about them, to invest in them, etc. They're firmly a core component of human society, certainly not going anywhere.
And I can't imagine not spending a lot of time with my kids. It's one of the things I think about most. I like to do a lot of things, but they're one of the few things I can always say yes to. I want to take care of them, teach them, learn from them, listen to them, see them grow, whatever. It just feels good to be in their lives. There's nothing unnatural about it.
I don't have kids and it still sounds nonsensical. As a man, my instinct isn't to run away from my child if I had one. If life keeps men and their children apart, that's a different matter altogether. But I have seen other men yearn to be with their little kids. My father did the same when I was young. Some of them are their kids' sole caregiver for the majority of the time because life keeps the mother away from the child. And in all instances, I see strong paternal affection and instincts at play. I'm baffled by an assertion otherwise.
Note also that a lot of what we consider "fatherhood" is a Western construct of the last 150 years, with falling birth rates and diffused wealth. Things were very different when families were poor and sprawling: fathers simply did not have significant time to spend with all their kids, when they had a dozen of them and were out of the house most of the day for work. Significant bonds would be developed only while working together, later in life.
That said, a lot of people don't bond for the sake of bonding, but bond over a shared task (one that really needs doing, not an invented game that mimicks a task..)
The bond I have with my children is profound and primal. The idea that it’s “unnatural” for me to spend much time with them is so ridiculous as to be instantly dismissed.
GP clearly doesn’t have kids or have close male friends who are involved with their kids.
for every helicopter dad there are ten guys who don't care about their offspring.
It would be unnatural for us to not do the things that would help our offspring survive.
Edit: removed a negative.
You could do it differently, but that only works if you swap one, not share half half.
Both have been eroded. Kids are raised by strangers, our food is crap, you can't warn each other about dangers cause that's somehow an insult and a single income doesn't pay the bills.
The goal seems to be to set men and women against each other.
> You could do it differently, but that only works if you swap one, not share half half.
I disagree. But I started nurturing early by planning and orchestrating all our births (home, birth center, birth center, twins/hospital) and her prenatal care.
Much later, my wife developed psych issues and in the end I was performing all roles to our 5 sons. But well before then I was deeply into nurturing our sons as infants, toddlers, PreK and grade schoolers. I changed most of the diapers (cloth! for sons 1 & 2.). I packed lunches, did cub scout leadership, cleaned up the wounds and encouraged them to go get more.
Compared to competent moms and dads, I wasn't substandard, insufficient or compromised in any way.
Wife starts doing X. Boom, clarity lost.
I know, I know, shades of grey and all that. But on average, divide it clearly and you know who is responsible for what.
You did all of it, while your wife was sick. Kudos man, tough job done well.
My point wasn't about the heaviness of the task, or about how well each could do it, but about clarity and role division.
It just seems odd that anyone would see "nurturing" as assigned to one or the other parent.
> Wife starts doing X. Boom, clarity lost.
These seems to reflect a strong division of labor. And it has me wondering if that work might be ever divided on ideological grounds. Either of those would be the opposite of what works for me.
They're also the opposite of what I want. Which is a more seamless integration, one where we are fairly interchangeable - where either of us can do what reasonably needs doing.
Single income doesn’t pay the bills. Period. Everything else is downstream.
One could argue that your talking about the dangers of these downstream effects is insulting and classist. Who is gonna pay these bills? Do you think we prefer that strangers raise our kids?
If we had a trust fund, we would raise our kids ourselves, and backhand brag on forums about how it is the right way. Sadly, we don’t.
You're pulling your reply straight from the offended-rack
Is that not easy to disregard? I certainly feel like my wife and I disregarded it raising our kids.
But I've seen numerous examples, and in my own marriage we also had to figure this stuff out because as kids we had bought into a lot of (never quite spoken out loud but loudly hinted at) unhealthy messages...
First there’s the idea that “nurturing” is somehow what kids need and better for them automatically, that whatever a stereotypical man does with kids is bad for them, and we need to be rewired by pheromones or whatever to be more sensitive. And as a corollary the idea that a high-T man somehow is a worse caregiver, and that it needs to be reigned in by some adaptation. The whole thing is definitely framed for a certain world view, it’s definitely not the only interpretation.