News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by lateforwork on Monday April 13, 2026 @08:28PM (#47759726)
Because if we didn't we wouldn't have a tech industry?

The main problem with immigrant talent in computer field is that legislators don't understand the difference between IT and Tech product development jobs. IT jobs don't need immigrant talent, so companies like Accenture, Infosys etc. should not be given H-1B visas. But tech companies like Google, Meta, Apple, OpenAI etc. absolutely need immigrant talent, or they will lose to Chinese competitors.

Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by Hawkenfall on Monday April 13, 2026 @08:42PM (#47759824)
Not sure how you came to draw this conclusion, as there's lots of data out there showing droves of Computer Science graduates here in the states unable to land jobs.
Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by duped on Monday April 13, 2026 @08:57PM (#47759926)
I think that data captures the fact that there are more people being handed degrees without an education than there are jobs. Especially when there are thousands of mid career people on the market right now.
Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by woeirua on Monday April 13, 2026 @08:56PM (#47759919)
That is absolutely not true. There are plenty of Americans who can do these jobs.
Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by lateforwork on Monday April 13, 2026 @09:23PM (#47760114)
> There are plenty of Americans who can do these jobs.

This thinking is wrong. For IT jobs, the work is pre-defined and you go find people who can do the job. For product development this is sometimes the case, but for truly innovative products, such as AI models, this is not the case. You have to hire the best in the world and give them the resources they need, as opposed to defining the project upfront and hiring people "who can do the job".

Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by yabutlivnWoods on Monday April 13, 2026 @10:08PM (#47760433)
"Truly innovative".

I wrote my first neural net in the late 90s. Based on nothing but an old geocities post some rando put up about training a model to only unlock a pet door for their cat.

I implemented the same and it worked.

Where you see true innovation I see run of the mill. OpenAI, Google, etc are propping up data center rental business they came to rely on to titillate biology with whatever spaghetti that sticks. That's it.

The interesting science isn't happening anywhere close to big tech.

The mathematics of LLMs exists in textbooks from 1950s. Your entire comment chain here is little more than reciting propaganda.

Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by lateforwork on Monday April 13, 2026 @10:54PM (#47760696)
> I wrote my first neural net in the late 90s

Why aren't we using it, if that's all the world needs?

Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by yabutlivnWoods on Monday April 13, 2026 @11:38PM (#47760975)
Oh this game, huh?

If your powers of analysis were worth anything you would be running the world not copy-pasting hype straight from CNBC and Big Tech PR

As you are not running the world your analysis is worthless. As such I say; good day, sir.

Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by abenga on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @06:23AM (#47763684)
Why is it important that Google (or any of these large companies) only hire Americans for their jobs in the first place? They are global companies now, they make money from everywhere. Why is the insular "Americans only" idea worthy of consideration at all?
Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by joquarky on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @10:14AM (#47765950)
By this logic, Google should relocate to some abstract "global" location.
Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by pandaman on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @12:40PM (#47767932)
The law forces American corporations to hire Americans, various work visas are exceptions from the law given under certain conditions. It appears the companies are abusing these exceptions and violate these conditions. There is no such thing as a "global company" in the law, with the exception of foreign consulates all the entities that hire people in the US are American corporations.
Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by yabutlivnWoods on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @12:52PM (#47768099)
Humans were motivated to discover physical truth, invent technology before Google existed.

"Why is it important Google exists?" is a more interesting question.

Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by woeirua on Monday April 13, 2026 @11:43PM (#47760993)
I'm not opposed to hiring the cream of the crop using H1Bs, but that would only be a few thousand people a year. The vast majority of H1Bs though are people taking jobs that Americans can definitely do.
Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by acdha on Monday April 13, 2026 @09:27PM (#47760148)
How many “best in the world” people are we talking about, though? Based on what I’ve seen that’s a very small percentage (maybe 5%) while the rest were being hired by companies who valued having workers with limited negotiating power.

(I’m not opposed to immigration at all but it was transparent how for decades the industry resisted any change which would make it easier for a skilled H1-B worker to take a better job)

Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by lateforwork on Monday April 13, 2026 @09:39PM (#47760239)
> having workers with limited negotiating power

Sorry, this is 100% false. Companies like Google, Microsoft, Apple, Meta etc. do not hire H-1Bs in order to depress wages. That does happen, but not at these companies. It typically happens when hiring IT workers.

Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by newfriend on Monday April 13, 2026 @10:24PM (#47760527)
The mere presence of H1-B workers depresses wages systemically.
Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by lateforwork on Monday April 13, 2026 @11:01PM (#47760733)
In the early 1990s a good software engineer was paid $40K starting salary, and good companies like Sun Microsystems paid $45K. If you adjust that for inflation it is around $100K. But good companies in silicon valley today pay $120K plus stock grants (so around $170K or so), and Meta and Google pay much more.

So software engineer salaries have gone up dramatically in the last 35 years H-1B visa has been around. In fact, the H-1B visa is the reason the salaries have gone up. Without it the industry would be stagnant, just like non-tech S&P 500 companies and most companies in Europe in the same time period.

Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by newfriend on Monday April 13, 2026 @11:39PM (#47760979)
Are you trying to argue that increased supply of labor is responsible for increasing wages?

As others have said, H1-B has been good for companies, and bad for American workers. The same companies who were found to be colluding to keep wages down.

Europe is stagnant because of regulation, not because of immigration.

Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by lateforwork on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @12:24AM (#47761228)
> Are you trying to argue that increased supply of labor is responsible for increasing wages?

I am saying the reason silicon valley exists is because of the immigration of the smartest people from around the world. High Tech needs the best in the world, not the best in the US.

Consider the seminal research paper that kicked off the AI revolution (titled "Attention is all you need"). It was written by 2 Indians, 1 German, 1 British Canadian, 1 Pole, 1 Ukrainian, and 2 US born people. These people came to America, worked together and changed the world as we know it. Why would we want to stop it? Has this immigration been bad for American workers? Far from it. These immigrants are the lifeblood of the tech industry, without them the center of tech would be Beijing.

Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by ethanwillis on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @11:15AM (#47766752)
Why not "2 Indian born people, 1 German born person, 1 Canadian born person, 1 Polish born person, 1 Ukrainian born person, and 2 US born people?"
Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by intended on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @05:37AM (#47763321)
I think they are making a meta argument?

That H1B labour allowed other firms to build tech, which kept those firms competitive, creating a deeper economy and experienced bench.

That depth then enabled more advanced tech firms to be born.

At least thats what I think they are saying.

The analogy would be that China took over low tech manufacturing, and then because of that were able to develop expertise to move up the value chain.

At the same time, supply demand curves are real. If you have more workers, it should result in competition that drives down wages. (ALL THINGS BEING EQUAL)

There was a distinction being made between Tech and IT, which I am not too sure about.

Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by munksbeer on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @09:04AM (#47765150)
> If you have more workers, it should result in competition that drives down wages. (ALL THINGS BEING EQUAL)

Sort of a meaningless statement when all things are definitely not equal.

If there are 5 million people in a country, or 200 million, the theory of too many workers means the 5 million people country should be paying everyone vastly more.

But that is trivially untrue.

Economies grow and shrink and adapt around the number people.

Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by intended on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @11:40AM (#47767115)
> ALL THINGS BEING EQUAL

> Sort of a meaningless statement when all things are definitely not equal.

Hey, don’t look to me for a defense of the weaknesses of economic models.

At the same time you can’t really discuss complex systems like economies where one part affects another, without holding some of the factors in stasis.

Centris paribus does extreme amounts of heavy lifting.

Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by thatfrenchguy on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @08:58PM (#47773394)
You essentially have no data to back this up though, especially given the filed H1B/L-1 labor data for big tech is first year of employement with only base salary, which bears no ressemblance to what their wages will be even just 3 years in.
Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by bradlys on Monday April 13, 2026 @09:45PM (#47760275)
These companies were all guilty of wage collusion years ago. Their culture has not gotten any better about this since.
Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by mikert89 on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @01:16AM (#47761518)
you fundamentally dont understand economics
Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by acdha on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @07:39AM (#47764280)
If it’s “100% false”, I’d think you could have addressed the point. Do you think that H1-Bs have had the same negotiating power as permanent residents and citizens? Do you think that companies-especially the huge contractors and enterprise vendors who hired so many of them—did not exploit them?

I’m not saying that there aren’t people who really lived up to the idea that the best in the world were coming here—I’ve known a few of them myself—but that there were a much greater number of people who were not in that class and it wasn’t exactly a secret that their managers knew they could be imposed on more than their equivalently-skilled colleagues.

Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by shimman on Monday April 13, 2026 @08:34PM (#47759762)
We had a tech industry prior to H1Bs before the 90s. What we didn't have was Silicon Valley corporatism that doesn't value American labor nor American education. It's why SV is so gun-ho on charter schools and devaluing American labor.

Let's not act like we need to import 80k "high tech" workers that amount to writing react components and spring endpoints.

Hardly anything hard that we couldn't force companies to train workers to do, but they don't want to ever help people they just want to suck up all the money in the room while decimating entire populations.zzzzzzz

Also, as an American I don't really benefit if US corporations are doing "better." How does that help the person that can't pay for healthcare or afford to go to school, but they sure can get their serving of Zuckerberg slop? I'm supposed to care about these companies success? Really? I hope they go down in flames.

The problem is that the rich and elite have captured and dictated American tech policy for far too long.

Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by thesmtsolver2 on Monday April 13, 2026 @08:44PM (#47759839)
Do you share the same thoughts for blue collar immigrants?
Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by shimman on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @08:57AM (#47765069)
No, because blue collar immigrants aren't working for cartels that hold deeply undemocratic views.
Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by munksbeer on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @09:08AM (#47765186)
It is interesting to see the different views on immigration. Here in the UK, leading up to the brexit vote, everyone said blue collar workers were the problem, because they depressed wages for the poor and made the middle class richer because they could build cheaper houses, pick cheaper crops, etc.

In Singapore, the rage is mostly against higher earner immigrants, because they take all the good jobs, making the middle class in Singapore poorer.

I'm sensing a bit of a mix in your US centric argument.

All in all, a lot of people just hate immigration, always have, always will. It is a topic as old as time.

Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by lateforwork on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @01:04PM (#47768282)
> people just hate immigration, always have, always will

"We have always been a nation of immigrants who hate the newer immigrants." -- Jon Stewart, The Daily Show

Really it is not immigration people hate, it is having to compete for food.

Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by lateforwork on Monday April 13, 2026 @09:46PM (#47760282)
> How does that help the person that can't pay for healthcare or afford to go to school

How would you like to make t-shirts for rich Chinese, for $5 an hour? There is a reason Americans are not doing that. It is because we are smarter than the rest of the world. How do you think that happened? Were all the smart people born here? Nope. It is because smart people born around the world immigrated here. The prosperity they bring doesn't only help high tech workers, it feeds the economy, so everyone benefits.

Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by shimman on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @08:56AM (#47765061)
I mean we aren't doing it because capitalists decided they would rather move the factories outside of the country because they don't care about workers.

Americans are absolutely willing to work in factors, but capitalists want chattel slave workers instead.

Your view of history is farcical, acting as if American workers had any real say in their countries industrial capacity rather than a few thousand people decided to inflict mass poverty to tens of millions of Americans.

Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by thinkingtoilet on Monday April 13, 2026 @08:53PM (#47759893)
We would absolutely have a tech industry. The richest people on the planet, however, would make slightly less money. It is not an exaggeration to say this is what the entirety of American society is based on right now.
Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by yabutlivnWoods on Monday April 13, 2026 @10:03PM (#47760393)
> But tech companies like Google, Meta, Apple, OpenAI etc. absolutely need immigrant talent, or they will lose to Chinese competitors.

Let them lose.

Google and the rest do not prop up humanity. They prop up a financial engineering Ponzi scheme.

You're just parroting media and social tropes you grew up with.

We could assert in our children social truth about other forms of economics; for example, healthcare as a tent pole rather than stock valuations; still requires technology and jobs and we don't remain the last modern economy on the planet without universal healthcare. We're losing to Russia and China in healthcare.

But thankfully we win when the metric phallic rockets to nowhere and Google search uptime?

You should consider your economic benchmarks and their provenance; a bunch of self selecting biological organisms that we socially describe as billionaires have convinced you via their fear mongering that if we don't give them all the power giant foot will step on us

Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by Madmallard on Monday April 13, 2026 @08:46PM (#47759850)
Doesn't sound accurate. Please list some sources here that are credible that explain your point. Just sounds like dismissive bias.
Re:The tech jobs bust is real. Don't blame AI (yet) by Yizahi on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @06:10PM (#47772124)
Outside of the Default country what you call product development is a part of IT, along with QAs, SDETs, Devops and others. All of that is IT globally. And what USA calls IT is called system administration or something similar.