News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Anthropic silently downgraded cache TTL from 1h → 5M on M... by cedws on Sunday April 12, 2026 @06:20AM (#47738041)
There’s the argument that Anthropic has built Claude Code to use the models efficiently, which the subscription pricing is based on.

Maybe there’s some truth to that, but then why haven’t OpenAI made the same move? I believe the main reason is platform control. Anthropic can’t survive as a pipeline for tokens, they need to build and control a platform, which means aggressively locking out everybody else building a platform.

Re:Anthropic silently downgraded cache TTL from 1h → 5M on M... by Zetaphor on Sunday April 12, 2026 @07:16AM (#47738373)
Alternatively products like openclaw have an outsized impact on Anthropic's infrastructure for essentially no benefit to them. Especially when you're taking advantage of the $200 plan.

OpenAI has never shyed away from burning mountains of cash to try and capture a little more market share. They paid a billion dollars for a vibe coded mess just for the opportunity to associate themselves with the hype.

Re:Anthropic silently downgraded cache TTL from 1h → 5M on M... by plusplusungood on Sunday April 12, 2026 @11:34AM (#47740939)
> Taking advantage of the $200 plan.

No, I'm paying $200 a month for a premium product that I expect premium service for. It's the single most expensive IT expense I have. Taking advantage my foot.

Re:Anthropic silently downgraded cache TTL from 1h → 5M on M... by charcircuit on Sunday April 12, 2026 @01:00PM (#47741937)
It's not a premium product. It's just expensive.
Re:Anthropic silently downgraded cache TTL from 1h → 5M on M... by infecto on Sunday April 12, 2026 @01:42PM (#47742364)
You are simply a bit too entitled. It's not a premium product and honestly not that expensive in my opinion either (though that is going to depend on your location).

You are more than able to pay for API rates.

Re:Anthropic silently downgraded cache TTL from 1h → 5M on M... by siva7 on Sunday April 12, 2026 @06:13PM (#47745119)
You may want to learn the difference between someone being able to pay API rates and someone willing to pay API rates. I'm sure many people on HN are able to pay API rates and almost all of them aren't willing to pay API rates. The providers know this hence why subscriptions exist. API is almost solely used by companies as almost no private person would be willing to pay that.
Re:Anthropic silently downgraded cache TTL from 1h → 5M on M... by infecto on Sunday April 12, 2026 @06:18PM (#47745152)
“You may want to learn” such choice way to introduce your position which is really not much of one.

If you are going to come and complain about a $200 subscription that gives you $400 worth of API tokens there is only so much room to complain. Only so many lemons can be squeezed. Hope that was a helpful for you.

Re:Anthropic silently downgraded cache TTL from 1h → 5M on M... by Dylan16807 on Sunday April 12, 2026 @07:11PM (#47745482)
A normal person pays $0-10 for an AI plan, maybe double that for a business.

$200 is premium.

Re:Anthropic silently downgraded cache TTL from 1h → 5M on M... by infecto on Sunday April 12, 2026 @09:01PM (#47746285)
It is not a premium service, it simply is buying you more tokens. Those $200 gives you at least $400 in API cost tokens.

Don't confused price with "premium service". It was not that long ago that folks would be spending $100-200 on their cable service bundle. You are buying a subsidized product when using the plan and the more you spend the more tokens you get, has nothing to do with being a premium service.

Re:Anthropic silently downgraded cache TTL from 1h → 5M on M... by Dylan16807 on Sunday April 12, 2026 @10:36PM (#47746927)
> It is not a premium service, it simply is buying you more tokens.

The cheap plans are usually semi-unlimited the same way but not as powerful. This isn't simply a matter of buying more tokens.

> It was not that long ago that folks would be spending $100-200 on their cable service bundle.

Compared to OTA that's premium, but more relevantly if most cable buyers are getting a hypothetical $10 bundle then the $100 one is a premium bundle.

Re:Anthropic silently downgraded cache TTL from 1h → 5M on M... by infecto on Sunday April 12, 2026 @11:42PM (#47747319)
Sorry still not sure what you’re going on about . The majority of LLM plans are simply a token purchase. The $200 account buys you nothing but tokens. It’s not a premium service, it’s simply more tokens. This is true for most of the companies out there.

The original comment was they are paying for a premium service. No they are paying for more tokens. You lot going on and on arguing over some small hill.

Re:Anthropic silently downgraded cache TTL from 1h → 5M on M... by Dylan16807 on Sunday April 12, 2026 @11:49PM (#47747363)
The lower tier openai and google plans don't have access to the same models. Where are you seeing popular plans that are simply token purchases?
Re:Anthropic silently downgraded cache TTL from 1h → 5M on M... by infecto on Monday April 13, 2026 @11:17AM (#47753250)
I guess if you want to go that deep sure they sometimes offer early access, access to new agents/models but ultimately it’s a function of tokens. The selling point for most/all providers is x times the usage. You are upgrading for the token access.

Claude was the topic at hand and higher tiers buy you more tokens. I know some like Gemini bundle a ton of junk alongside the tokens but you really are still buying yourself more tokens. There is nothing premium in a $200 Claude account. You are buying more tokens, $100 is the same as $200 except token count. Hope that helps. ;)

Re:Anthropic silently downgraded cache TTL from 1h → 5M on M... by Dylan16807 on Monday April 13, 2026 @05:22PM (#47757986)
> $100 is the same as $200 except token count

But I was making an argument about the $10 plans, not the $100 plans.

Claude doesn't even go that low. Except the free plan which has a very reduced feature list.

Claude's $20 and $100 are pretty similar except tokens, that part is true. So they're a bit higher priced and more of the "it's just tokens" model. But the market as a whole is mostly selling a limited feature set down at lower price points. On average, getting up to the point where you have full access and are paying per-token is itself a premium jump.

Re:Anthropic silently downgraded cache TTL from 1h → 5M on M... by infecto on Monday April 13, 2026 @06:21PM (#47758699)
You are standing on top of an ant hill and I still don’t fully understand your position. The original post was about the premium service Anthropic plans. There is no such thing, you are simply paying for more tokens. Hope that helps.
Re:Anthropic silently downgraded cache TTL from 1h → 5M on M... by Dylan16807 on Monday April 13, 2026 @06:45PM (#47758919)
Any $200/month AI plan is premium. Hope that helps.
Re:Anthropic silently downgraded cache TTL from 1h → 5M on M... by infecto on Monday April 13, 2026 @08:52PM (#47759887)
I know why I typically don’t respond to your posts. So much said and I am still not sure your point. You have ignored the original point and gone off on a tangent.

It is not a premium service that deserves special care which was what the original commenter stated. It is a $200 account that buys you $400+ on tokens.

Hope that helps recenter this weird path we are following. :)

Re:Anthropic silently downgraded cache TTL from 1h → 5M on M... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @01:32AM (#47761628)
> gone off on a tangent

What? What I just said was my one and only point from the very beginning. The price is so much higher than the median that that makes it premium and deserving of some special care.

I understand your point of view here, and it's fine if you disagree with mine but it's weird if you don't at least understand my point by now. You saying my last comment is a tangent suggests you don't understand me. But it's a simple point and I'm not sure how to make it clearer.

Does that help recenter?

Re:Anthropic silently downgraded cache TTL from 1h → 5M on M... by everforward on Monday April 13, 2026 @09:56AM (#47752041)
This is a messaging issue on their part, which I think is partially intentional.

It’s not unreasonable for people to expect the most expensive subscription plan to be “premium”. That’s how it works everywhere else. They typically have better margins on the premium plans, and the monthly payment gives them reliable cash flow at that higher margin.

You’re right that that’s not true at Anthropic (or really most AI providers). You’re not even really buying tokens because you get billed whether you use it or not, the tokens don’t carry over like buying API tokens, and they get to dictate what an acceptable way to use those tokens is. They are cheaper though, assuming you actually use them. Which Anthropic et al would really prefer you didn’t.

Re:Anthropic silently downgraded cache TTL from 1h → 5M on M... by 59nadir on Sunday April 12, 2026 @03:52PM (#47743726)
Can you imagine paying the actual cost of it, or a subscription cost that at least ballpark matched it? I don't think I have a single friend or acquaintance who realistically would.
Re:Anthropic silently downgraded cache TTL from 1h → 5M on M... by qeternity on Sunday April 12, 2026 @02:10PM (#47742586)
> They paid a billion dollars for a vibe coded mess just for the opportunity to associate themselves with the hype.

Lol no they didn't. It wasn't even an acquihire. They just hired Peter.

Maybe they are paying him incredibly well, but not a billion dollars well.

Re:Anthropic silently downgraded cache TTL from 1h → 5M on M... by snovv_crash on Sunday April 12, 2026 @04:20PM (#47744027)
I think it's a training data thing. They can only gather valid training data from real human interactions, so they don't want to subsidize tokens for purely automated interactions.