News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by Jcampuzano2 on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @03:06PM (#47679901)
A jump that we will never be able to use since we're not part of the seemingly minimum 100 billion dollar company club as requirement to be allowed to use it.

I get the security aspect, but if we've hit that point any reasonably sophisticated model past this point will be able to do the damage they claim it can do. They might as well be telling us they're closing up shop for consumer models.

They should just say they'll never release a model of this caliber to the public at this point and say out loud we'll only get gimped versions.

Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by cedws on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @03:18PM (#47680056)
More than killer AI I'm afraid of Anthropic/OpenAI going into full rent-seeking mode so that everyone working in tech is forced to fork out loads of money just to stay competitive on the market. These companies can also choose to give exclusive access to hand picked individuals and cut everyone else off and there would be nothing to stop them.

This is already happening to some degree, GPT 5.3 Codex's security capabilities were given exclusively to those who were approved for a "Trusted Access" programme.

Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by TypesWillSaveUs on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @04:01PM (#47680628)
Describing providing a highly valuable service for money as `rent seeking` is pretty wild.
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by 1attice on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @04:07PM (#47680686)
My housing is pretty valuable. I pay rent. Which timeline are you in?
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by kaashif on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @04:43PM (#47681122)
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by 1attice on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @06:00PM (#47681874)
Yes I know that, read your sibling post
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by bonsai_spool on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @04:46PM (#47681155)
Actually you're saying similar things:

Rent-seeking of old was a ground rent, monies paid for the land without considering the building that was on it.

Residential rents today often have implied warrants because of modern law, so your landlord is essentially selling you a service at a particular location.

Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by 1attice on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @05:59PM (#47681871)
thanks!
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by mhluongo on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @05:12PM (#47681439)
Two different "rent"s.
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by 1attice on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @05:59PM (#47681867)
Not really see your sibling post
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by bertil on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @04:27PM (#47680927)
It could be, formally, if they have a monopoly.

However, I’m tempted to compare to GitHub: if I join a new company, I will ask to be included to their GitHub account without hesitation. I couldn’t possibly imagine they wouldn’t have one. What makes the cost of that subscription reasonable is not just GitHub’s fear a crowd with pitchforks showing to their office, by also the fact that a possible answer to my non-question might be “Oh, we actually use GitLab.”

If Anthropic is as good as they say, it seems fairly doable to use the service to build something comparable: poach a few disgruntled employees, leverage the promise to undercut a many-trillion-dollar company to be a many-billion dollar company to get investors excited.

I’m sure the founders of Anthropic will have more money than they could possibly spend in ten lifetimes, but I can’t imagine there wouldn’t be some competition. Maybe this time it’s different, but I can’t see how.

Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by johnsimer on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @05:14PM (#47681456)
> It could be, formally, if they have a monopoly.

you have 2 labs at the forefront (Anthropic/OpenAI), Google closely behind, xAI/Meta/half a dozen chinese companies all within 6-12 months. There is plenty of competition and price of equally intelligent tokens rapidly drop whenever a new intelligence level is achieved.

Unless the leading company uses a model to nefariously take over or neutralize another company, I don't really see a monopoly happening in the next 3 years.

Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by bertil on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @06:01PM (#47681902)
Precisely.

I was focusing on a theoretical dynamic analysis of competition (Would a monopoly make having a competitor easier or harder?) but you are right: practically, there are many players, and they are diverse enough in their values and interest to allow collusion.

We could be wrong: each of those could give birth to as many Basilisks (not sure I have a better name for those conscious, invisible, omni-present, self-serving monsters that so many people imagine will emerge) that coordinate and maintain collusion somehow, but classic economics (complementarity, competition, etc.) points at disruption and lowering costs.

Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by eru on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @12:22AM (#47685196)
> practically, there are many players, and they are diverse enough in their values and interest to allow collusion.

Not only that, but open-weight and fully open-source models are also a thing, and not that far behind.

Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by coldtea on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @06:03AM (#47687958)
Why, you thought rented homes aren't valuable?

Rent seeking isn't about whether the product has value or not, but about what's extracted in exchage for that value, and whether competition, lack of monopoly, lack of lock in, etc. keeps it realistic.

Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by aspenmartin on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @03:26PM (#47680164)
Well don’t forget we still have competition. Were anthropic to rent seek OpenAI would undercut them. Were OpenAI and anthropic to collude that would be illegal. For anthropic to capture the entire coding agent market and THEN rent seek, these days it’s never been easier to raise $1B and start a competing lab
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by cedws on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @03:31PM (#47680231)
In practice this doesn't work though, the Mastercard-Visa duopoly is an example, two competing forces doesn't create aggressive enough competition to benefit the consumer. The only hope we have is the Chinese models, but it will always be too expensive to run the full models for yourself.
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by brokencode on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @04:01PM (#47680614)
New companies can enter this space. Google’s competing, though behind. Maybe Microsoft, Meta, Amazon, or Apple will come out with top notch models at some point.

There is no real barrier to a customer of Anthropic adopting a competing model in the future. All it takes is a big tech company deciding it’s worth it to train one.

On the other hand, Visa/Mastercard have a lot of lock-in due to consumers only wanting to get a card that’s accepted everywhere, and merchants not bothering to support a new type of card that no consumer has. There’s a major chicken and egg problem to overcome there.

Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by sghiassy on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @03:46PM (#47680438)
Chinese competition can always be banned. Example: Chinese electric car competition
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by sho_hn on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @03:48PM (#47680456)
That's what OP was saying, I think, noting that running them locally won't be a solution.
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by oblio on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @04:35PM (#47681016)
Also Chinese smartphones. Huawei was about 12-18 months from becoming the biggest smartphone manufacturer in the world a few years ago. If it would have been allowed to sell its phones freely in the US I'm fairly sure Apple would have been closer to Nokia than to current day Apple.
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by aurareturn on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @05:04PM (#47681356)
If Huawei was never banned from using TSMC, they'd likely have a real Nvidia competitor and may have surpassed Apple in mobile chip designs.

They actually beat Apple A series to become the first phone to use the TSMC N7 node.

Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by realusername on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @07:39AM (#47688800)
I don't think it will matter too much in the long run, 8 of the top 10 smartphone manufacturers are Chinese, there's nothing the US government can really do.
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by dmantis on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @07:18AM (#47688651)
Just in one particular country. That hurts their labs, but there are ~190 other countries in the world for Chinese to sell their products to, just like they do with their cars.

And businesses from these other countries would happily switch to Chinese. From security perspective both Chinese and US espionage is equally bad, so why care if it all comes down to money and performance.

Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by lelanthran on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @03:26AM (#47686573)
> In practice this doesn't work though, the Mastercard-Visa duopoly is an example,

MC/Visa duopoly is an example of lock-in via network effects. Not sure that that applies to a product that isn't affected by how many other people are running it.

Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by MattRix on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @04:56PM (#47681276)
The thing is that the current models can ALREADY replicate most software-based products and services on the market. The open source models are not far behind. At a certain point I'm not sure it matters if the frontier models can do faster and better. I see how they're useful for really complex and cutting edge use cases, but that's not what most people are using them for.
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by therealdeal2020 on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @05:02PM (#47681328)
but you are assuming that the magical wizards are the only ones who can create powerful AIs... mind you these people have been born just few decades ago. Their knowledge will be transferred and it will only take a few more decades until anyone can train powerful AIs ... you can only sit on tech for so long before everyone knows how to do it
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by cedws on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @05:10PM (#47681413)
It's not a matter of knowledge, it's a matter of resources. It takes billions of dollars of hardware to train a SOTA LLM and it's increasing all the time. You cannot possibly hope to compete as an independent or small startup.
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by selcuka on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @07:25PM (#47682632)
> It takes billions of dollars of hardware to train a SOTA LLM and it's increasing all the time.

True, but it's also true that the returns from throwing money to the problem are diminishing. Unless one of those big players invents a new, propriatery paradigm, the gap between a SOTA model and an open model that runs on consumer hardware will narrow in the next 5 years.

Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by block_dagger on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @05:46PM (#47681752)
Presumably, the hardware to run this level of model will be democratized within the timeframe of the parent comment.
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by walterbell on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @06:28PM (#47682154)
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by wincy on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @01:26AM (#47685681)
Eventually these super expensive SXM data center GPUs will cost pennies on the dollar, and we’ll be able to snatch up H200s for our homelabs. Give it a decade.

Also eventually these WEIGHTS will leak. You can’t have the world’s most valuable data that can just be copied to a hard drive stay in the bottle forever, even if it’s worth a billion dollars. Somehow, some way, that genie’s going to get out, be it by some spiteful employee with nothing to lose, some state actor, or just a fuck up of epic proportions.

Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by WorldPeas on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @02:04PM (#47693969)
at the point where those gpus cost pennies, they likely won't even be worth the electricity that goes into them, better models would run on laptops.
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by marcus_holmes on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @08:57PM (#47683364)
Unless, of course, the powerful manage to scare everyone about how the machines will kill us all and so AI technology needs to be properly controlled by the relevant authorities, and anyone making/using an unlicensed AI is arrested and jailed.
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by robwwilliams on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @06:12PM (#47682019)
With Gemma-4 open and running on laptops and phones I see the flip side. How many non-HN users or researchers even need Opus 4.6e level performance? OpenAI, Anthropric and Google may be “rent seeking” from large corporations — like the Oracles and IBMs.
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by baq on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @08:29AM (#47689265)
Everyone, once AI diffuses enough. You’ll be unhireable if you don’t use AI in a year or two.
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by eru on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @12:20AM (#47685187)
You know, they have competitors?
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by alwillis on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @03:51AM (#47686819)
> More than killer AI I'm afraid of Anthropic/OpenAI going into full rent-seeking mode so that everyone working in tech is forced to fork out loads of money just to stay competitive on the market.

You should be more concerned about killer AI than rent seeking by OpenAI and Anthropic. AI evolving to the point of losing control is what scientists and researchers have predicted for years; they didn’t think it would happen this quickly but here we are.

This market is hyper competitive; the models from China and other labs are just a level or two below the frontier labs.

Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by quotemstr on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @03:16PM (#47680033)
This is why the EAs, and their almost comic-book-villain projects like "control AI dot com" cannot be allowed to win. One private company gatekeeping access to revolutionary technology is riskier than any consequence of the technology itself.
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by FeepingCreature on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @03:53PM (#47680522)
No it isn't lol. The consequence of the technology literally includes human extinction. I prefer 0 companies, but I'll take 1 over 5.
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by frozenseven on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @03:42PM (#47680387)
Couldn't agree more. The "safest" AI company is actually the biggest liability. I hope other companies make a move soon.
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by scrawl on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @04:23PM (#47680881)
Having done a quick search of "control AI dot com", it seems their intent is educate lawmakers & government in order to aid development of a strong regulatory framework around frontier AI development.

Not sure how this is consistent with "One private company gatekeeping access to revolutionary technology"?

Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by quotemstr on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @05:04PM (#47681352)
> strong regulatory framework around frontier AI development

You have to decode feel-good words into the concrete policy. The EAs believe that the state should prohibit entities not aligned with their philosophy to develop AIs beyond a certain power level.

Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by arw0n on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @05:16AM (#47687499)
And what is malicious about that ideology? I think EAs tend to like the smell of their farts way too much, but their views on AI safety don't seem so bad. I think their thoughts on hypothetical super intelligence or AGI are too focused on control (alignment) and should also focus on AI welfare, but that's more a point of disagreement that I doubt they'd try to forbid.
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by guzfip on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @03:18PM (#47680063)
> A jump that we will never be able to use since we're not part of the seemingly minimum 100 billion dollar company club as requirement to be allowed to use it.

> They should just say they'll never release a model of this caliber to the public at this point and say out loud we'll only get gimped

Duh, this was fucking obvious from the start. The only people saying otherwise were zealots who needed a quick line to dismiss legitimate concerns.

Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by marcus_holmes on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @08:55PM (#47683350)
This is my nightmare about AI; not that the machines will kill all the humans, but that access is preferentially granted to the powerful and it's used to maintain the current power structure in blatant disregard of our democratic and meritocratic ideals, probably using "security" as the justification (as usual).
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by ben_w on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @03:33AM (#47686646)
> I get the security aspect, but if we've hit that point any reasonably sophisticated model past this point will be able to do the damage they claim it can do. They might as well be telling us they're closing up shop for consumer models.

I read it like I always read the GPT-2 announcement no matter what others say: It's *not* being called "too dangerous to ever release", but rather "we need to be mindful, knowing perfectly well that other AI companies can replicate this imminently".

The important corps (so presumably including the Linux Foundation, bigger banks and power stations, and quite possibly excluding x.com) will get access now, and some other LLM which is just as capable will give it to everyone in 3 months time at which point there's no benefit to Anthropic keeping it off-limits.

Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by alwillis on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @03:36AM (#47686671)
> They should just say they'll never release a model of this caliber to the public at this point and say out loud we'll only get gimped versions.

That’s not going to happen. If you recall, OpenAI didn’t release a model a few years ago because they felt it was too dangerous.

Anthropic is giving the industry a heads up and time to patch their software.

They said there are exploitable vulnerabilities in every major operating system.

But in 6 months every frontier model will be able to do the same things. So Anthropic doesn’t have the luxury of not shipping their best models. But they also have to be responsible as well.

Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by mike_hearn on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @09:23AM (#47689898)
I think they already said somewhere that they can't release Mythos because it requires absurdly large amounts of compute. The economics of releasing it just don't work.
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by yencabulator on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @04:57PM (#47696161)
Yet they quote a $20,000 cost for one of the exploits.