News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by TypesWillSaveUs on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @04:01PM (#47680628)
Describing providing a highly valuable service for money as `rent seeking` is pretty wild.
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by 1attice on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @04:07PM (#47680686)
My housing is pretty valuable. I pay rent. Which timeline are you in?
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by kaashif on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @04:43PM (#47681122)
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by 1attice on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @06:00PM (#47681874)
Yes I know that, read your sibling post
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by bonsai_spool on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @04:46PM (#47681155)
Actually you're saying similar things:

Rent-seeking of old was a ground rent, monies paid for the land without considering the building that was on it.

Residential rents today often have implied warrants because of modern law, so your landlord is essentially selling you a service at a particular location.

Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by 1attice on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @05:59PM (#47681871)
thanks!
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by mhluongo on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @05:12PM (#47681439)
Two different "rent"s.
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by 1attice on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @05:59PM (#47681867)
Not really see your sibling post
Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by bertil on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @04:27PM (#47680927)
It could be, formally, if they have a monopoly.

However, I’m tempted to compare to GitHub: if I join a new company, I will ask to be included to their GitHub account without hesitation. I couldn’t possibly imagine they wouldn’t have one. What makes the cost of that subscription reasonable is not just GitHub’s fear a crowd with pitchforks showing to their office, by also the fact that a possible answer to my non-question might be “Oh, we actually use GitLab.”

If Anthropic is as good as they say, it seems fairly doable to use the service to build something comparable: poach a few disgruntled employees, leverage the promise to undercut a many-trillion-dollar company to be a many-billion dollar company to get investors excited.

I’m sure the founders of Anthropic will have more money than they could possibly spend in ten lifetimes, but I can’t imagine there wouldn’t be some competition. Maybe this time it’s different, but I can’t see how.

Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by johnsimer on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @05:14PM (#47681456)
> It could be, formally, if they have a monopoly.

you have 2 labs at the forefront (Anthropic/OpenAI), Google closely behind, xAI/Meta/half a dozen chinese companies all within 6-12 months. There is plenty of competition and price of equally intelligent tokens rapidly drop whenever a new intelligence level is achieved.

Unless the leading company uses a model to nefariously take over or neutralize another company, I don't really see a monopoly happening in the next 3 years.

Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by bertil on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @06:01PM (#47681902)
Precisely.

I was focusing on a theoretical dynamic analysis of competition (Would a monopoly make having a competitor easier or harder?) but you are right: practically, there are many players, and they are diverse enough in their values and interest to allow collusion.

We could be wrong: each of those could give birth to as many Basilisks (not sure I have a better name for those conscious, invisible, omni-present, self-serving monsters that so many people imagine will emerge) that coordinate and maintain collusion somehow, but classic economics (complementarity, competition, etc.) points at disruption and lowering costs.

Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by eru on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @12:22AM (#47685196)
> practically, there are many players, and they are diverse enough in their values and interest to allow collusion.

Not only that, but open-weight and fully open-source models are also a thing, and not that far behind.

Re:System Card: Claude Mythos Preview [pdf] by coldtea on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @06:03AM (#47687958)
Why, you thought rented homes aren't valuable?

Rent seeking isn't about whether the product has value or not, but about what's extracted in exchage for that value, and whether competition, lack of monopoly, lack of lock in, etc. keeps it realistic.