News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My Experience as a Rice Farmer by aledevv on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @04:56AM (#47672430)
> Doing a day of manual labour, chatting shit, then going for the onsen and some BBQ and beers is far better than grinding away at some enterprise SaaS that will probably disappear in a few years.

I particularly agree with this statement.

I don't know why manual work has been so denigrated over the last century. We believed that office labor was more important and healthier than manual labor. I don't think so.

As a developer, sitting all day typing in a stuffy office, without natural light, without sun, without air, is certainly no healthier than being outdoors, connecting with nature and other people. We come from nature and are made to be active, outdoors, and in the sunlight.

Today, with AI, many white-collar jobs are being called into question, and perhaps we can go back to loving certain traditional jobs.

Re:My Experience as a Rice Farmer by throwaway27448 on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @08:17AM (#47674093)
I don't think it's that deep: Obligatory manual labor destroys the body (and, often, the mind) and what time you have you spend exhausted. Being entirely sedentary remains a choice for us office workers—this is why people exercise and spend time outside.

Of course, I would like more flexibility in choosing how much I and where I do my sedentary labor, so I might devote time to, say, gardening. But it's easy to forget that humans have spent most of human history trying to escape subsistence farming.

I have worked subsistence farming for a small portion of my life, and I cannot tell you how hard it is, physically and psychologically. That was by choice, as part of essentially joining my wife's culture and family. If I were to do that for the remainder of my life it would destroy me.

Anyway, I'm going to go happily work from my desk 30 ft from my bedroom while drinking coffee likely farmed for about ~$0.30/hour while I make a few hundred times that.

Re:My Experience as a Rice Farmer by stunseed on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @09:41AM (#47675251)
> But it's easy to forget that humans have spent most of human history trying to escape subsistence farming.

Do you define human history as the last ~10k years or last ~100k-500k years?

But yes, certainly at least the last 3000 years for most humans have been spent farming to a large degree. But if we are even moderate in estimations of human origins, farming is very recent.

Re:My Experience as a Rice Farmer by throwaway27448 on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @10:27AM (#47675943)
History certainly does not predate sedentary farming. It seems reasonable to put at around ~8kya.

Certainly, some people still live as hunter gatherers. I presume people can deduce I do not refer to them.

Re:My Experience as a Rice Farmer by Noumenon72 on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @10:37AM (#47676112)
I think specifying "recorded history" would remove the confusion. Human history could refer to the history of anatomically modern humans, including before farming.
Re:My Experience as a Rice Farmer by throwaway27448 on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @10:42AM (#47676204)
History is a bit of a confusing word that way; I suppose I can see it can be used in an informal sense to refer to any timeline outside of just historiography, which does tend to refer to a distinct study from archaeology and anthropology. Noted.
Re:My Experience as a Rice Farmer by satvikpendem on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @02:01PM (#47679020)
You used the word correctly don't worry. Seems like the initial replyer meant prehistory.
Re:My Experience as a Rice Farmer by satvikpendem on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @01:59PM (#47678988)
History is recorded, that's the definition of the word. Prehistory is not recorded which is what the 500 kya to 10 kya refers to.
Re:My Experience as a Rice Farmer by Noumenon72 on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @10:01PM (#47683948)
The wikipedia for "Recorded history"[1] draws the distinction this way:

- Before writing: prehistory

- After writing: recorded history

- Both together: human history[2]

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recorded_history

2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_history

Re:My Experience as a Rice Farmer by satvikpendem on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @02:00PM (#47679008)
History means the time of recorded events, the 10 kya to present day, they used the word correctly. Anatomically modern humans are prehistory.
Re:My Experience as a Rice Farmer by aaarrm on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @01:38PM (#47678742)
It truly is not a choice, as I cannot sustain my family / lifestyle with manual labor. Opting into working out for the sake of my health is not nearly the same.
Re:My Experience as a Rice Farmer by evanjrowley on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @04:20PM (#47680844)
>It truly is not a choice, as I cannot sustain my family / lifestyle

Success and failure are choices. Accepting this allows us to take responsibility for the worlds we've created. Ignoring this is self-destructive act of cognitive dissonance and we pay for it years later.

Re:My Experience as a Rice Farmer by troupo on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @03:50AM (#47686806)
> Success and failure are choices.

Tell that to crop failures of sustinance farmers. "Oh you just chose the weather to be bad/a fast soreading disease/a severe drought. Live with your choices".

Re:My Experience as a Rice Farmer by PowerElectronix on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @06:22AM (#47672984)
The push to increase production and leave nothing on the table is insidious and will turn every work environment, be it manual labor, design, programming or excel factory into shit.

You'll end up burn out and hating the job (no matter the job) if the company you work for doesn't give a considerable weight to the wellbeing of employees (at the percieved cost of productivity and raw revenue).

Re:My Experience as a Rice Farmer by sdevonoes on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @05:25AM (#47672619)
I’d love to do manual labor as long as: I have a decent house, decent health insurance, can afford decent food/stuff, can afford taking sabbaticals, can afford getting sick and not losing my income, can afford decent education for kids, etc.

Unfortunately, many of us are chained to the modern way of life.

Re:My Experience as a Rice Farmer by teruakohatu on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @07:27AM (#47673530)
Don’t forget doing only enough manual labour not to get hurt, killed or develop a chronic condition.

You can make a lot of money doing many skilled manual jobs in my country. Trades are highly paid and there is not enough supply. Better money than software development.

They often wreck their backs, or develop other chronic conditions. The successful ones stop doing manual work by the time they are in their 40s and move to running their own businesses employing 20 year olds.

A friend of mine just lost a family member a few weeks ago. He slipped on a roof.

Re:My Experience as a Rice Farmer by aledevv on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @09:55AM (#47675442)
@teruakohatu Some example of manual labor well payed in your country? In Italy, sometime manual labors are more safe than others not manual jobs.

This is because often the rules and laws protects still human instead the profits.

Re:My Experience as a Rice Farmer by satvikpendem on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @02:02PM (#47679040)
You don't have to @ their name here on HN, it doesn't work like Twitter. When you reply to them they'll see it already.
Re:My Experience as a Rice Farmer by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @02:09PM (#47679126)
Only if they go back through their threads.
Re:My Experience as a Rice Farmer by satvikpendem on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @02:13PM (#47679180)
Or they use something like https://www.hnreplies.com/ which many do. In any case the @ doesn't work regardless, it does not ping anyone.
Re:My Experience as a Rice Farmer by teruakohatu on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @01:53AM (#47685886)
Forestry is well paid in NZ, the average forester is probably better paid than the average developer. Although the ceiling for software devs is much higher.

But Forestry also has the highest number of industrial accidents.

We have a strong health and safety regime and culture. Most primary industries are heavily automated. Yet it only takes a simple mistake to cause injury.

Re:My Experience as a Rice Farmer by selimthegrim on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @02:05PM (#47679074)
Is this New Zealand? Don't all the software people migrate to Australia for better wages?
Re:My Experience as a Rice Farmer by teruakohatu on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @01:54AM (#47685898)
Many do go overseas. They would definitely get paid more in Australia. But New Zealand is a pleasant place to live.
Re:My Experience as a Rice Farmer by aledevv on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @06:05AM (#47672872)
@sdevonoes What do you do for work?

ps: Unfortunately I agree with you.

Re:My Experience as a Rice Farmer by troupo on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @03:52AM (#47686821)
You don't want manual labor that you unfortunately cannot do due to being "chained to the modern life".

You want a modern life with some light manual labor on the side as a hobby.

Re:My Experience as a Rice Farmer by RataNova on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @08:41AM (#47674409)
AI might shake things up, but I wonder if instead of "going back," it'll just blur the lines
Re:My Experience as a Rice Farmer by 9rx on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @02:43PM (#47679589)
> I don't know why manual work has been so denigrated over the last century.

As a farmer, it is funny to see how people react to you based on the current profitability winds. When farming is a money maker, everyone acts envious and treats you like a king. When times are tough, they think you're a slack-jawed yokel.

I expect in that lies the answer to your question: We denigrate anything that isn't, as a rule, making a lot of money. Manual jobs generally haven't made much money in the last century, and humorously the exceptions, like professional athlete, get exempted from being considered manual work.

Re:My Experience as a Rice Farmer by Pay08 on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @05:35PM (#47681652)
> When farming is a money maker, everyone acts envious and treats you like a king.

While I'm not a farmer, from my experience they still call you a yokel when it's profitable.

Re:My Experience as a Rice Farmer by 9rx on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @06:14PM (#47682038)
Well, yeah, they'd call me a yokel. They'd also call me that when I'm at my tech job. But not the farmers they see getting rich and wish they were.