News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by shantanubala on Thursday November 08, 2012 @10:04AM (#4758009)
Although I agree with you, I get the impression that someone who doesn't think affirmative action should exist even after learning about the gang violence, intense poverty, substance abuse, neglect, and trauma that surrounds children growing up in housing projects and "bad neighborhoods" -- even after all of that, if someone still says no, then you could probably trace this back to the Big Bang and they'll still say no.
Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by jivatmanx on Thursday November 08, 2012 @11:11AM (#4758325)
Why can't we just try to remedy those ills directly? Why does there need to be an association with race?

I'm not denying that these are a result of the U.S's past action, and that we have a responsibility to fix them, but I have doubts that associating them with race is necessary or helpful in any way.

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by ajross on Thursday November 08, 2012 @11:28AM (#4758435)
OK, what's your solution? Affirmative action is a bandaid, and its effects are at best poorly distributed. But it actually works to reduce ethnic imbalance, and most people (I assume you too) agree that's a good thing.

You have an alternative to suggest that doesn't have equivalent problems?

Just recognize that (I'm going to go out on a limb here and assume) that, because you are a middle class white man, probably 90% of the reason you oppose "affirmative action" is because it negatively impacts your own demographic group. Well, sorry. We're in a priviledged group; get over it.

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by mtoddh on Thursday November 08, 2012 @11:50AM (#4758574)
Just recognize that (I'm going to go out on a limb here and assume) that, because you are a middle class white man, probably 90% of the reason you oppose "affirmative action" is because it negatively impacts your own demographic group.

Arguments for or against AA aside, this line of reasoning, where you invalidate somebody's argument based on what demographic group they belong to (white middle class males in this case), really seems like a simple ad hominem argument. You're no longer addressing what is said - only who is saying it.

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by ajross on Thursday November 08, 2012 @12:21PM (#4758742)
Sigh... First: that's not a logical argument, it's a message directly to the poster (and anyone like-minded, probably including you) intended to provoke introspection. Read it again, I don't claim anything in those words says anything about AA.

Second: you seriously think it's inappropriate to point out that people tend to have opinions which advantage their own station? Really? You're not simply saying that this is incorrect, you're actually saying that I'm not allowed to make the argument that white people might not like AA because it disadvantages white people. That's insane, sorry.

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by Locke1689 on Thursday November 08, 2012 @01:08PM (#4758988)
I agree that affirmative action is a good thing, but I thought it was a quite interesting discussion we were having.

Let's go back to the original topic at hand and refrain from derailing the discussion with personal messages directly to the poster and those like-minded.

A good argument is not solely made up of logical arguments, but it does not sacrifice logic for pathos. If your argument is sound you should be able to defend it both logically and emotionally.

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by jivatmanx on Thursday November 08, 2012 @11:34AM (#4758466)
As I have said, the alternative is affirmative action for the poor in general.

Medicaid, Food Stamps, and other social programs don't discriminate based on race, but certainly have that effect where there is larger poverty among African-Americans. What would be the advantage of basing them on race?

I'm questioning the best way to achieve the economic effect that we agree on, reducing racial inequality, in the same way that I question if Carbon credits are the best way to reduce emissions (simply taxing fossil fuels, I believe.

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by ajross on Thursday November 08, 2012 @11:42AM (#4758515)
It sounds like you simply don't understand what affirmative action is. It's not welfare. You're seriously saying we should give out slots on boards of directors to people on food stamps?

AA doesn't correct for immediate need, it corrects for the fact that people growing up in unpriviledged environments lack advantages. So they have to work a job instead of going to a test prep class. They go to schools with high teacher turnover and poor class selection. They live in social environments with high crime. So they don't get into the "right" colleges, and they don't get the great jobs.

At what spot on that chain would your "make AA like food stamps" idea actually work? You're not even addressing the problem.

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by MordinSolus on Thursday November 08, 2012 @11:53AM (#4758590)
> AA doesn't correct for immediate need, it corrects for the fact that people growing up in unpriviledged environments lack advantages.

So poor white folks never grow up in unpriviledged environments?

You're providing no justification for why AA is race based instead of socio-economic based.

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by ajross on Thursday November 08, 2012 @12:09PM (#4758671)
The first sentence is just bad statistics. Obviously all that's required is that "more" poor black kids grow up in unpriviledged environemnts (something that I assume you agree with) to have a problem worth correcting. You can't disprove a correlation with a single counterexample.

And why must I "justify" that it be "race based"? There's a problem. It's a solution. It works, if imperfectly. I'd like to see a better option too. (Not least because one of it's biggest problems is that it pisses off entitled white kids like you and starts pointless internet flames like this.)

So I repeat what I said earlier: if you have another solution that works better, then propose it and advocate for it. Right now all you're doing is whining.

(edit to avoid prolonging thread: both replies have ignored the issue mentioned upthread, namely that AA corrects for disadvantage in the past, not currently. You can't give executive jobs to unqualified poor people, you need to start farther upstream. So if that's your suggestion, come up with a new one -- you're essentially saying "eliminate poverty", which is dumb.)

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by MordinSolus on Thursday November 08, 2012 @03:33PM (#4759702)
> (Not least because one of it's biggest problems is that it pisses off entitled white kids like you and starts pointless internet flames like this.)

> Right now all you're doing is whining.

Stop the nonsense.

I'm going to specifically look at college admissions since it's a pretty interesting area. Specifically, I want to point out a passage from here (the article itself is worth reading): http://www.tnr.com/book/review/disadvantages

> Moreover, some universities have been successful in maintaining racial diversity despite a ban on using race in admissions. At UT Austin, which was forbidden by a lower court from considering race between 1997 and 2003, a class-based affirmative action plan, combined with a plan to automatically admit students in the top 10 percent of their high school class, resulted in a net increase in racial diversity. In 1996, prior to the ban on race, African Americans and Latinos made up 18.8 percent of the freshman class. In 2004, under the socioeconomic and top 10 percent plan, the combined representation had risen to 21.4 percent.

Not only is such policy less racist, but it is more effective!

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by ShawnBird on Thursday November 08, 2012 @12:51PM (#4758890)
If a policy benefits poor people in general and more black people are poor it would stand to reason that it would help more black people. I think that the problem with AA is that it attempts to treat the entire country. A better solution would be to concentrate efforts on the poorest communities with the largest percentage of black population. Once those cities start to succeed it would help turn around institutional bias. I don't thank that AA has helped reduce bias, it seems like it has served more as a cosmetic measure. I could be wrong.
Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by ta12121 on Thursday November 08, 2012 @12:56PM (#4758918)
You must justify it because you are advocating for race based discrimination.

We have already proposed an alternative: economics based discrimination. It is better because it captures the group of people that deserve help more accurately.

We are not whining, we are having a discussion.

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by mkr-hn on Thursday November 08, 2012 @12:01PM (#4758636)
It came about when the disparity was more substantial. That it's less obvious now is a sign that it's working. Institutional underrepresentation of poor white people is already dealt with separately by the lack of historical institutional discrimination against them.
Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by mkr-hn on Thursday November 08, 2012 @11:43AM (#4758527)
Affirmative action is about dealing with the discrimination in education that often leads to unequal opportunity. How do you deal with the opportunity gap without acknowledging the impacted groups?
Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by mkr-hn on Thursday November 08, 2012 @11:36AM (#4758480)
It seems like privilege is more transparent the more you have.
Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by rmc on Thursday November 08, 2012 @11:29AM (#4758445)
Why can't we just try to remedy those ills directly? Why does there need to be an association with race?

Because targeting based on race is a simple and effective way to target these ills. Race is often strongly correlated with these problems.

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by alexanderh on Thursday November 08, 2012 @11:37AM (#4758486)
Yes but not all African American's are disadvantaged. But all disadvantaged people are disadvantaged.

Why not make laws to simply help the disadvantaged? Why does race have to be the indicator, even if its a pretty good one? Why cant income be the indicator? It seems like it would be at least as accurate, if not more so... and no need to bring race into it.

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by rmc on Thursday November 08, 2012 @12:04PM (#4758649)
How do you define & measure disadvantage?

You suggest income, but then that ignores:

(a) debt

(b) medical costs (Joe & Jim have the same income, but Joe has cancer and has to pay $LOTS per month, has less energy etc. Who's more disadvantaged?)

(c) where one lives (Joe & Jim have same income, but Joe lives near where possible jobs are, Jim needs a 2 hour bus journey)

(d) existing assets (Jim has a new car and partner has a second hand car, Joe has a crappy car that could break, who is more advantaged)

(e) family support/obligations, both financial & emotional (Joe has to care for his mother, Jim's mother can pay for her own nursing home. Joe knows he can rely on his parents to bail him out, Joe can't). etc.

All systems have flaws. This stuff is hard and complicated, and you'll have mistakes, false positives and false negatives with all methods (yes including race/ethnicity). There'll also be costs to each method: Cost for the applicant to have to find & submit paperwork, cost for staff to process and review it, opportunities for fraud (e.g. asset-based-measurement means you can fake it by moving assets to a family member/close friend for a year).

Race/ethnicity has several advantages as a "disadvantage metric":

(a) easy to apply (hard to fake), yes there are problems with people of many ethnicities

(b) cheap and quick to decide, no calculations or hours of staff time checking that the payslip from 2007 is legit, or try to figure out if the person really is a single parent or is the partner still living there, etc.

(c) applicants don't have to find old information & forms & letters

(d) strongly statistically correlated with disadvantage

However some people just react negatively about race being mentioned at all, thinking that "racism = any reference to race" and "racism = bad" ergo "any reference to race = bad". Sometimes conversations about this can be like talking about evolution to a creationist, ask yourself if there is any evidence you'd accept that would convince you that it's OK to have affirmative action, if not, you might be being dogmatic.

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by jivatmanx on Thursday November 08, 2012 @02:24PM (#4759398)
Assuming that poverty alleviation programs are consolidated, than using the shorthand of race for disadvantages on only the education portion does not actually reduce paperwork/costs.

The strong and convincing argument for affirmative action is that African Americans and Indians have been severely wronged in the past and should be recompensed.

But what about would Hispanics, more recently immigrants who never suffered from Genocide or Slavery.

Or what about Asian Americans, who actually suffer reverse AA (need higher scores than whites) for no reason other than being smart. They're aware of this and don't mark Asian on applications if it can be avoided.

Racial discrimination does cause problems. Personally, I really do feel that Blacks and Indians need to be compensated for past ills. I'm not sure how the best way to do that is, however.

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by rmc on Thursday November 08, 2012 @03:45PM (#4759733)
Assuming that poverty alleviation programs are consolidated, than using the shorthand of race for disadvantages on only the education portion does not actually reduce paperwork/costs.

Oh? Care to elaborate?

When I said "reduce paperwork", I mean it's less paperwork to evalulate and classify people based on race (since looking at a photo for 30 seconds will get you the answer 95% of the time (or some other high percentage)), vs. if you looked at income. To classify people based on income you have to look at lots of different forms and letters and statements etc.

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by johnrgrace on Saturday November 10, 2012 @12:37PM (#4767140)
We just had an election and almost 50% of the country said No we don't want "big goverment" which is what it takes to remedy those ills. If you want to solve the ills it's going to take years of hard work and a lot of money.

Also, a part of why we don't have the political will is latent racism.

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by wallawe on Thursday November 08, 2012 @10:41AM (#4758199)
If you really want to take this line, then you should take action. I am from one of these counties originally, and there is a much larger percentage of the black population working side by side with whites than anywhere you'll find in Silicon Valley. In fact, if this is the mentality that presides, then why aren't there more blacks working at startups in SV or anywhere for that matter?

Edit: It should also be noted that Alabama has no comprehensive fair employment law or specific affirmative action requirements covering public or private employers.

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by bdunbar on Thursday November 08, 2012 @10:37AM (#4758181)
The problems you mention were not problems until after affirmative action was implemented.
Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by _delirium on Thursday November 08, 2012 @10:48AM (#4758238)
I don't believe your chronology is correct: affirmative action was first implemented in the U.S. in 1961, with widespread implementation not until the late 1960s, but there were already many poverty-ridden black ghettoes in the 1950s.

(And the areas talked about in this article have been full of grinding poverty for their entire existence, with most of their inhabitants being slaves prior to the 1860s, and then desperately poor from the 1860s to today.)

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by AimHere on Thursday November 08, 2012 @11:18AM (#4758363)
Maybe I'm leaning too much on the 'benefit of the doubt' side, but I parsed the prior post to mean that all those things existed, but they weren't considered problems by, say, white people, or people in power, prior to the 1960s.

The alternative is that some (presumably intelligent) poster on HN stating something completely at odds with the facts, and perhaps even informally suggesting that affirmative action was likely to have caused black people to live in poor, squalid, crime-filled ghettoes.

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by bdunbar on Thursday November 08, 2012 @12:16PM (#4758715)
"even informally suggesting that affirmative action was likely to have caused black people to live in poor, squalid, crime-filled ghettoes."

That is what I am suggesting.

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by tjic on Thursday November 08, 2012 @12:30PM (#4758788)
> completely at odds with the facts

Asserted without evidence.

The argument makes perfect sense to me. What part of it do you think is false?

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by _delirium on Thursday November 08, 2012 @12:40PM (#4758830)
Isn't the person making a very strong causal claim the one in need of evidence? If someone's claiming that affirmative action caused black poverty, then I would expect some good data to back up that claim. Merely asserting it is not an "argument".
Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by bdunbar on Thursday November 08, 2012 @12:46PM (#4758860)
Why not put it back on the poster who asserted without evidence that affirmative action will cure "gang violence, intense poverty, substance abuse, neglect, and trauma"?

I will allow that it could. But we've had this deal in place for fifty years.

If you've got a program running, and the problems keep getting worse .. maybe it's time to check one's assumptions.

At any rate - I'll go grubbing around for the facts. Later tonight. Now I've got lunch to eat and work to be done. I've got a tax bill to pay.

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by bdunbar on Thursday November 08, 2012 @12:36PM (#4758817)
"there were already many poverty-ridden black ghettoes in the 1950s."

There is poverty. And then there is

"gang violence, intense poverty, substance abuse, neglect, and trauma"

I am asserting that these became systematic problems after the introduction of affirmative action.

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by Synthetase on Friday November 09, 2012 @12:19AM (#4761468)
You're seriously suggesting affirmative action leads to social ills?

I'd also suggest you avoid hospitals because they cause cancer.

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by mkr-hn on Thursday November 08, 2012 @12:25PM (#4758768)
Was it the flight of money, mostly in the hands of white people, out of the cities and into the suburbs around the time institutional segregation started to crumble, or was it affirmative action? I'm not leaning toward the latter.
Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by bdunbar on Thursday November 08, 2012 @12:38PM (#4758825)
"I'm not leaning toward the latter."

Are you basing this leaning on study and contemplation of the facts, or because it makes you feel better?

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by mkr-hn on Thursday November 08, 2012 @12:44PM (#4758851)
What are you basing your assertion on? I indicated an inclination. It's inherently an opinion. You made an assertion of fact.
Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by bdunbar on Thursday November 08, 2012 @12:47PM (#4758863)
Data. And you?
Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by omni on Thursday November 08, 2012 @01:08PM (#4758986)
I believe it's common courtesy to actually provide some citations when you claim you have data.
Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by mkr-hn on Thursday November 08, 2012 @12:48PM (#4758869)
I made no assertion, so I have nothing to support.
Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by rmc on Thursday November 08, 2012 @11:28AM (#4758438)
You mean there was no extreme poverty amoung marginalized groups before affirmative action?
Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by bdunbar on Thursday November 08, 2012 @12:18PM (#4758726)
The poster I was replying to said

"gang violence, intense poverty, substance abuse, neglect, and trauma"

These, by and large, were not systemic problems before the introduction of affirmative action.

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by mkconor on Thursday November 08, 2012 @06:57PM (#4760561)
gang violence The gangs were white, but the contours of the violence would probably be familiar to contemporary observers.

intense poverty Sociocultural hurdles that limited property ownership, the inability to meaningfully advocate for fair wages, and the lack of the suffrage required to change this reality meant that intense poverty was the status quo.

substance abuse http://www.utexas.edu/utpress/books/jamdoi.html

"William Henry James and Stephen Lloyd Johnson document the role of alcohol and other drugs in traditional African cultures, among African slaves before the American Civil War, and in contemporary African American society, which has experienced the epidemics of marijuana, heroin, crack cocaine, and gangs since the beginning of this century. The authors zero in on the interplay of addiction and race to uncover the social and psychological factors that underlie addiction."

neglect see:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Redlining#History; see also: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:JimCrowCar2.jpg

trauma Subjective, based on who you ask, but I'd say yes.

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by gyardley on Thursday November 08, 2012 @12:26PM (#4758771)
Well, sure, since affirmative action doesn't help those people nearly as much as it helps upper-middle class kids from the suburbs.

That's the problem with it - whatever its intentions, it just doesn't help the people it truly needs to.