News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by bdunbar on Thursday November 08, 2012 @10:37AM (#4758181)
The problems you mention were not problems until after affirmative action was implemented.
Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by _delirium on Thursday November 08, 2012 @10:48AM (#4758238)
I don't believe your chronology is correct: affirmative action was first implemented in the U.S. in 1961, with widespread implementation not until the late 1960s, but there were already many poverty-ridden black ghettoes in the 1950s.

(And the areas talked about in this article have been full of grinding poverty for their entire existence, with most of their inhabitants being slaves prior to the 1860s, and then desperately poor from the 1860s to today.)

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by AimHere on Thursday November 08, 2012 @11:18AM (#4758363)
Maybe I'm leaning too much on the 'benefit of the doubt' side, but I parsed the prior post to mean that all those things existed, but they weren't considered problems by, say, white people, or people in power, prior to the 1960s.

The alternative is that some (presumably intelligent) poster on HN stating something completely at odds with the facts, and perhaps even informally suggesting that affirmative action was likely to have caused black people to live in poor, squalid, crime-filled ghettoes.

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by bdunbar on Thursday November 08, 2012 @12:16PM (#4758715)
"even informally suggesting that affirmative action was likely to have caused black people to live in poor, squalid, crime-filled ghettoes."

That is what I am suggesting.

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by tjic on Thursday November 08, 2012 @12:30PM (#4758788)
> completely at odds with the facts

Asserted without evidence.

The argument makes perfect sense to me. What part of it do you think is false?

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by _delirium on Thursday November 08, 2012 @12:40PM (#4758830)
Isn't the person making a very strong causal claim the one in need of evidence? If someone's claiming that affirmative action caused black poverty, then I would expect some good data to back up that claim. Merely asserting it is not an "argument".
Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by bdunbar on Thursday November 08, 2012 @12:46PM (#4758860)
Why not put it back on the poster who asserted without evidence that affirmative action will cure "gang violence, intense poverty, substance abuse, neglect, and trauma"?

I will allow that it could. But we've had this deal in place for fifty years.

If you've got a program running, and the problems keep getting worse .. maybe it's time to check one's assumptions.

At any rate - I'll go grubbing around for the facts. Later tonight. Now I've got lunch to eat and work to be done. I've got a tax bill to pay.

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by bdunbar on Thursday November 08, 2012 @12:36PM (#4758817)
"there were already many poverty-ridden black ghettoes in the 1950s."

There is poverty. And then there is

"gang violence, intense poverty, substance abuse, neglect, and trauma"

I am asserting that these became systematic problems after the introduction of affirmative action.

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by Synthetase on Friday November 09, 2012 @12:19AM (#4761468)
You're seriously suggesting affirmative action leads to social ills?

I'd also suggest you avoid hospitals because they cause cancer.

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by mkr-hn on Thursday November 08, 2012 @12:25PM (#4758768)
Was it the flight of money, mostly in the hands of white people, out of the cities and into the suburbs around the time institutional segregation started to crumble, or was it affirmative action? I'm not leaning toward the latter.
Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by bdunbar on Thursday November 08, 2012 @12:38PM (#4758825)
"I'm not leaning toward the latter."

Are you basing this leaning on study and contemplation of the facts, or because it makes you feel better?

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by mkr-hn on Thursday November 08, 2012 @12:44PM (#4758851)
What are you basing your assertion on? I indicated an inclination. It's inherently an opinion. You made an assertion of fact.
Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by bdunbar on Thursday November 08, 2012 @12:47PM (#4758863)
Data. And you?
Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by omni on Thursday November 08, 2012 @01:08PM (#4758986)
I believe it's common courtesy to actually provide some citations when you claim you have data.
Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by mkr-hn on Thursday November 08, 2012 @12:48PM (#4758869)
I made no assertion, so I have nothing to support.
Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by rmc on Thursday November 08, 2012 @11:28AM (#4758438)
You mean there was no extreme poverty amoung marginalized groups before affirmative action?
Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by bdunbar on Thursday November 08, 2012 @12:18PM (#4758726)
The poster I was replying to said

"gang violence, intense poverty, substance abuse, neglect, and trauma"

These, by and large, were not systemic problems before the introduction of affirmative action.

Re:Obama's Secret Weapon In The South is 129 Million Years Old by mkconor on Thursday November 08, 2012 @06:57PM (#4760561)
gang violence The gangs were white, but the contours of the violence would probably be familiar to contemporary observers.

intense poverty Sociocultural hurdles that limited property ownership, the inability to meaningfully advocate for fair wages, and the lack of the suffrage required to change this reality meant that intense poverty was the status quo.

substance abuse http://www.utexas.edu/utpress/books/jamdoi.html

"William Henry James and Stephen Lloyd Johnson document the role of alcohol and other drugs in traditional African cultures, among African slaves before the American Civil War, and in contemporary African American society, which has experienced the epidemics of marijuana, heroin, crack cocaine, and gangs since the beginning of this century. The authors zero in on the interplay of addiction and race to uncover the social and psychological factors that underlie addiction."

neglect see:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Redlining#History; see also: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:JimCrowCar2.jpg

trauma Subjective, based on who you ask, but I'd say yes.