That is mcp for coding agents is dumb. For gui apps installed at non-cli using non-permissive endpoints it makes a lot of sense.
I agree mcp is bad as a protocol and likely not what solves the problem long term. But clearly the cli focus is an artifact of coding agents being the tip of the iceberg that we are seeing for llm agent use cases.
Have you tried to use a random API before? It’s a process of trial and error.
With the MCP tools I use, it works the first time and every time. There is no “figuring out.”
My company is currently trying to rollout shared MCPs and skills throughout the company. The engineers who have been using AI tools for the past 1-2 years have few, if any, issues. The designers, product managers, and others have numerous issues.
Having a single MCP gateway with very clear instructions for connecting to Claude Desktop and authenticating with Google eliminates numerous problems that would arise from installing and authenticating a CLI.
The MCP is also available on mobile devices. I can jot down ideas and interact with real data with Claude iOS and the remote MCP. Can’t do that with a CLI.
This actually isn't true. I've written bespoke CLI tools for my small business and non-technical people run them without issue. They get intimidated at first but within a day or so they're completely used to it - it's basically just magic incantations on a black box.
I’ve used that approach to get non-technical near-retirees as early adopters of command line tooling (version control and internal apps). A semantic layer to the effect of ‘make-docs, share-docs, get-newest-app, announce-new-app-version’.
The users saw a desktop folder with big buttons to double click. Errors opened up an email to devs/support with full details (minimizing error communication errors and time to fix). A few minutes of training, expanded and refined to meet individual needs, and our accountants & SME’s loved SVN/Git. And the discussion was all about process and needs, not about tooling or associated mental models.
CLI works for both agents and technical people. REST API works for both agents and technical people. MCP works only for agents (unless I can curl to it, there are some HTTP based ones)
Back to the MCP debate, in a world where most web apis have a schema endpoint, their own authentication and authorization mechanisms, and in many instances easy to install clients in the form of CLIs … why do we need a new protocol, a new server, a new whatever. KISS
> OP never mentioned letting the agent run as him or use his secrets
That is implicit with a CLI because it is being invoked in the user session unless the session itself has been sandboxed first. Then for the CLI to access a protected resource, it would of course need API keys or access tokens. Sure, a user could set up a sandbox and could provision agent-specific keys, but everyone could always enable 2FA, pick strong passwords, use authenticators, etc . and every org would have perfect security.That's not reality.
CLI sandboxing is a solved problem compared to whatever MCP is.
When your agent calls a CLI or curls an API, it uses credentials stored on the developer's machine.
For one person that's fine. But for 50 agents across a department, each needing keys for Slack, Jira, GitHub, your CRM, and a dozen internal APIs? You've recreated the pre-SSO world, except access is autonomous and at machine speed.
Remote MCP servers (streamable HTTP, not stdio) change that. The agent authenticates via OAuth/SSO, the server holds the downstream keys, and the user never sees them. Disable the SSO account and every agent loses access.
This is the same pattern as centralizing database credentials instead of baking them into every microservice config, just on a different layer.
Longer version: https://dev.to/dennistraub/missing-from-the-mcp-debate-who-h...
The auth story is heavily overlooked by most folks that are solo-vibing and then think that advice, the tools, and the practices that work for 1 works for a team or org.
It tries to standardize the auth, messaging, feedback loop where API can't do alone. A CLI app can do for sure but we are talking about a standard maybe the way is something like mcpcli that you can install your phone but still would you really prefer installing bunch of application to your personal device?
Some points that MCP is still not good as of today:
- It does not have a standard to manage context in a good way. You have to find your hack. The mostly accepted one search, add/rm tool. Another one is cataloging the tools.
- lack of client tooling to support elicitation on many clients (it really hurts productivity but this is not solved with cli too)
- lack of mcp-ui adoption (mcp-ui vs openai mcp app)
I would suggest keep building to help you and your users. I am not sponsor of MCP, just sharing my personal opinion. I am also creator HasCLI but kindly biased for MCP then CLI in terms of coverage and standardization.
If it tried to do that, you wouldn't have the pain point list.
It's a vibe coded protocol that keeps using one-directional protocols for bi-directional communication, invents its own terms for existing stuff (elicitation lol), didn't even have any auth at the beginnig etc.
It's a slow sad way of calling APIs with JSON-RPC
Namely, two very useful features resources and prompts have varying levels of support across clients (Codex being one of the worst).
These two are possibly the most powerful ones since they allow consistent, org-level remote delivery of context and I would like to see all major clients support these two and eventually catch up on the other features like elicitation, progress, tasks, etc.
If you can tell ahead of time what external connectors you need and you're already sandboxing then by all means go with CLIs, if you can't then MCP is literally the only economical and ergonomic solution as it stands today.
> ...people assume the way they are using AI is universal
This is what led me back to MCP. Our team is using Claude CLI, Claude VSCX, Codex, OpenCode, GCHP, and we need to support GH Agents in GH Actions.We wanted telemetry and observability to see how agents are using tool and docs.
There's no sane way to do this as an org without MCP unless we standardize and enforce a specific toolset/harness that we wrap with telemetry. And no one wants that.
For any sufficiently complex set of AI tasks, you will eventually need to invent MCP. The article posted here talks about those cases and reasons. However, there are cases when you should not use MCP, and the article points those out too.
Considering many popular MCPs have done auth incorrectly, this made me lol
The security is so chief that they had no security at all until several versions later when they hastily bolted on OAuth.
MCP is a vibe-codef protocol that rode one of the many AI hype waves where all "design documents" are post-hoc justifications.
If they had made the security spec without waiting for user information they would most certainly have chosen a suboptimal solution.
That sounds like a hack to get around the lack of MCP. If your goal is to expose your tools through an interface that a coding agent can easily parse and use, what compels you to believe throwing amorphous structured text is a better fit than exposing it through a protocol specially designed to provide context to a model?
> The reason we have MCP is because early agent designs couldn't run arbitrary CLIs. Once you can run commands, MCP becomes silly.
I think you got it backwards. Early agents couldn't handle, and the problem was solved with the introduction of an interface that models can easily handle. It became a solved problem. Now you only argue that if today's models work hard enough, they can be willed into doing something with tools without requiring a MCP. That's neat, but a silly way to reinvent the wheel - poorly.
The reason we have MCP is because early agent designs couldn't run arbitrary CLIs. Once you can run commands, MCP becomes silly.
There is a clear problem that you'd like an "automatic" solution for, but it's not "we don't have a standard protocol that captures every possible API shape", it's "we need a good way to simulate what a CLI does for agents that can't run bash".