Re:Malus – Clean Room as a Service
by ameliaquining on Thursday March 12, 2026 @10:37AM
(#47351178)
Note for people who just briefly skimmed the site: This is satire.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Malus – Clean Room as a Service
by TimTheTinker on Thursday March 12, 2026 @12:17PM
(#47353127)
I don't know - if you upload a package.json with any dependencies that map to real npmjs.com packages, it does lead you to a Stripe payment page which appears to be real... and it appears you'd be sending real money.
Maybe that's part of the joke, though :)
At least you think that this is satire, until the author receives a DMCA from one of the big corps saying that he leaked the transcript of their last meeting
Re:Malus – Clean Room as a Service
by chilipepperhott on Thursday March 12, 2026 @11:13AM
(#47351858)
Yeah, thank you. I was starting to get a little heated.
Re:Malus – Clean Room as a Service
by embedding-shape on Thursday March 12, 2026 @11:29AM
(#47352184)
Same, I got as far as "Finally, liberation from open source license obligations." until I went back to the comments.
haha did the same. that being said I’m convinced some people do think AI reimplementation actually mean cleanroom…
Too late. Someone's senior executive management has probably already seen it and spinning up a new project to implement it.
Luckily LLM’s are nowhere near capable enough to pull this off for anything other than the likes of isEven()
It legit got me. An actual "whaaaaaatttt?" out loud and then I had to figure out why it was the top of HN haha.
The situation is a bit too Torment Nexus-y for my comfort, thank you very much
Re:Malus – Clean Room as a Service
by lo_zamoyski on Thursday March 12, 2026 @12:07PM
(#47352910)
W.r.t. intent, yes. But w.r.t. content, we are long past a situation where it is unrealistic enough to function as satire.
While such tactics would render certain OSS software licenses absurd, the tactic itself, as a means to get around them, is entirely sound. It just reveals the flawed presupposition of such licenses. And I'm not sure there is really any way to patch them up now.
It would also entirely obviate the need for those very same OSS licenses, if LLMs can simply do a clean-room reimplementation of any copywritten software whatsoever.
Re:Malus – Clean Room as a Service
by donkeybeer on Friday March 13, 2026 @05:07AM
(#47362119)
Thats a bit more difficult as you have to somehow leak or hack the proprietary code first to train the initial llm.
It will be like Galaxy Quest - they saw the historical records, copied them and then ... still needed humans to help them :)
For now
Re:Malus – Clean Room as a Service
by schmeichel on Thursday March 12, 2026 @11:02AM
(#47351643)
Thank you for pointing that out, I genuinely was scratching my head and questioning if this site was serious.
Re:Malus – Clean Room as a Service
by dcchambers on Thursday March 12, 2026 @11:27AM
(#47352143)
For now...
The best satire is that which becomes reality.
I would posit that the best satire is that which holds a clear enough mirror to society that people choose for it to not come to pass.
Re:Malus – Clean Room as a Service
by intrasight on Thursday March 12, 2026 @12:44PM
(#47353606)
Best comment here!
I was wondering. I had heard chardet story and wouldn't be surprised to see others moving into that same space.
Re:Malus – Clean Room as a Service
by andriy_koval on Thursday March 12, 2026 @01:27PM
(#47354301)
its partial satire. I kinda believe Claude/Codex spill lots of OSS code without license attribution for many millions of devs already.
Re:Malus – Clean Room as a Service
by tonyedgecombe on Thursday March 12, 2026 @01:46PM
(#47354578)
It wouldn't be funny if it wasn't close to the truth.
I know this is satire, but I would wish to see something like this for liberating proprietary & closed-source hardware drivers.
Re:Malus – Clean Room as a Service
by bananzamba on Thursday March 12, 2026 @02:51PM
(#47355394)
Malus Corporation = EvilCorp