News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by feverishaaron on Monday October 29, 2012 @05:19PM (#4714511)
Interesting that Jony will be overseeing UI. I expect a more minimalistic polish to upcoming interfaces. In other words, this is the beginning of the end for the skeuomorphism trend at Apple.
Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by bengl3rt on Monday October 29, 2012 @05:20PM (#4714519)
Yes, it's widely known that Ive was one of the most strongly opposed to skeuomorphism whereas Forstall was one of its biggest proponents within the company.
Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by dclusin on Monday October 29, 2012 @05:40PM (#4714626)
You're the second person that mentioned skeuomorphism. Could you please explain what it is and why it's a big todo? Most of my cursory google searches don't provide any particularly insightful definition of what it is. The blogs/rants usually just dive into why it's good or bad.
Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by feverishaaron on Monday October 29, 2012 @06:02PM (#4714746)
Skeuomorphism has been interpreted two ways - as decorative elements (leather stitching), and in functionality that attempts to emulate a real world object (page flipping in an e-book).

The former is just a matter of aesthetic preference. Where skeuomorphism gets dangerous is in the latter case.

A perfect example is the horrible address book in OS X. It looks like a book, and therefore the user expects it to function like a book. Yet, it doesn't. It's this area of interaction design that has run afoul at Apple.

Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by eridius on Monday October 29, 2012 @07:00PM (#4715011)
You give "page flipping in an e-book" as an example of dangerous skeuomorphism, but then cite Address Book as why it's bad. I'm a bit confused. I get why you don't like Address Book, but do you really think page flipping in an e-reader is bad too? If so, why do you think that?
Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by MetricMike on Monday October 29, 2012 @07:17PM (#4715080)
The dichotomy is what's dangerous. Address Book looks like an book, so I'll try to interact with it like that. When that doesn't work, I get confused, angry, and it's generally a "failure" from a UX point of view.

Neither form of skeuomorphism is inherently bad, but it's easier to shoot yourself in the foot and ruin the UX when you move from decorative to functional.

Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by eridius on Monday October 29, 2012 @07:23PM (#4715114)
Yes, I get the complaints about Address Book. But "page flipping in an e-book" is either really poorly written, or was not referring to Address Book to begin with, since Address Book is not an e-book. Hence my question.
Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by feverishaaron on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @01:49PM (#4718498)
Indeed, they were intended to be separate examples.
Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by panacea on Monday October 29, 2012 @07:22PM (#4715111)
Because pages in an e-reader are not physical sheets bound together that require flipping over before you can see the page below.

If you can render the next page faster, then why fake a 'page turn' that takes time to animate.

It's the very definition of skeuomorphism.

Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by eridius on Monday October 29, 2012 @08:15PM (#4715298)
The speed at which you can present text to the reader is not the end-all, be-all of the reading experience. In fact, the logical conclusion, of having zero transition whatsoever, is actually a pretty terrible experience. Why do you think people use smooth scrolling on their OS? Transitions are very valuable in producing a good user experience, whether it's a simple horizontal slide as the Kindle iOS app uses by default, or a page turn animation as iBooks uses by default. And if your argument is purely about the speed of the animation, there is nothing about a page turn that inherently requires it be slower than a horizontal slide.

Speaking personally, the iBooks page curl is one of my favorite features of any iOS app, period.

Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by RShiki on Monday October 29, 2012 @08:33PM (#4715379)
I don't know when it has been introduced, or even if it was always there and I didn't notice, but iBooks also supports continuous vertical scrolling and it IS much faster than looking at an animation that shows a page turn or a slide. The default mode, "page turn" doesn't make any sense. When I scroll through an ebook through the continuous scrolling, the text appears INSTANTLY, without a perceptible delay and since it's continuous scrolling, you don't go from a page to another, but you're always "in between". The concept of a "page" 1, "page 2", "page" 3 itself is no more. It's not a physical book, it doesn't need pages.
Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by sirmarksalot on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @04:32AM (#4716596)
This is a case where I recognize the absurdity of pages in e-books, and yet I still like to have them. Pages give you a sense of progress through the book, and act as a proxy for time spent. They're not necessary as part of the presentation of information, or even telling a story, but I do like having them there.

Maybe this is one example of skueomorphism done right, at least from my point of view. An anachronism that helps to make the user feel comfortable with the application, even though it isn't strictly necessary.

Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by panacea on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @09:01AM (#4717157)
I think a better animation would be the page 'lifting' and swiping away quickly to reveal the page underneath. You still get the affordance of turning a page, but with a new and improved SwiftTurn digital method, and without the ponderous neccessity of fake flipping a page.

Ala swipe to unlock, or elastic scroll-ending. Use affordances, rather than limiting real world analogies.

Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by vineel on Monday October 29, 2012 @10:46PM (#4715784)
It's a matter of personal preference. A seemingly endless expanse of text seems daunting. I like the idea of pages, they break down the text into more manageable pieces.
Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by eridius on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @03:10AM (#4716435)
Scroll mode was introduced in the just-released iBooks 3.0. And I personally think think a never-ending scroll of text is not a good way to read a book. Pagination is very helpful. I realize other people like scroll mode, but that's a personal preference.
Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by bad_user on Monday October 29, 2012 @07:21PM (#4715103)
Problem with Adress Book is that it doesn't do page flipping, although it looks like a regular book.
Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by eridius on Monday October 29, 2012 @07:22PM (#4715110)
Yes, I get why people don't like Address Book. But it's not an e-book or e-reader, so "page flipping in an e-book" is referring to something else (presumably, iBooks).
Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by Firehed on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @01:43AM (#4716267)
The point was that iBooks looks and behaves like a book, so it works even if you consider it distasteful; Address Book looks like one but behaves completely differently, leaving the user confused why this "object" doesn't work.
Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by snowwrestler on Monday October 29, 2012 @07:03PM (#4715022)
By your latter definition, inertial scrolling with snap-back is skeuomorphic, and that is universally praised (and copied).
Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by ricardobeat on Monday October 29, 2012 @05:43PM (#4714645)

    Skeuomorphism is when a product imitates design elements
    functionally necessary in the original product design, but that
    becomes ornamental in the new product design
Examples: leather/paper/textile textures, hyper-realistic shading, analog controls/displays.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skeuomorph

Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by sergiotapia on Monday October 29, 2012 @05:45PM (#4714657)
It's a design technique where the artist creates user interfaces that tries to mimick the real life object as much as possible.

Take for instance some of the apps on iOS. The have book bindings, rings, shadows, etc.

Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by harrywincup on Monday October 29, 2012 @05:51PM (#4714688)
Skeuomorphism is a design approach where digital interfaces retain certain elements from their real-world counterparts. For example, the notes app on iOS looks like a real-world notepad, with its leather binding and yellow lined pages, including a torn paper effect along the top where previous pages have been pulled out of the pad. (Obviously these pages do not exist in the digital world, and therefore this design choice is an attempt to insert "realism" into the UI for the purposes of familiarity == skeuomorphism)
Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by garretruh on Monday October 29, 2012 @05:46PM (#4714658)
Essentially, trying to mimic real world (as in the physical world) applications and appearances. See Calendar and Contacts on iOS for a perfect example of skeuomorphism to the extreme.
Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by rglover on Monday October 29, 2012 @05:48PM (#4714672)
Skeumorphism is when a user interface is stylized to look like real world materials (e.g. the Calendar.app on OSX is made to look like a leather desk calendar). The big argument toward it is that it either looks tacky or ruins usability.
Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by jitl on Monday October 29, 2012 @05:27PM (#4714556)
I'm very excited about this. I left the Apple ecosystem over thier poorly-designed skeuomorphic interfaces (iCal and Address Book in Lion being very frustrating). I love the hardware, though, and I'm excited for a return to UX on par with that hardware.
Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by emehrkay on Monday October 29, 2012 @05:30PM (#4714575)
I just hope that they can keep the contrast and the explicit visual of what a component does. Case in point: fire up letterpress on the ipad, get a gamecenter popover with its felt and wood finish, you can clearly identify what is supposed to happen (aside from copy[if you've used gamecenter before]).
Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by moe on Monday October 29, 2012 @11:46PM (#4715929)
Do you really like the gamecenter popover?

To me it's one of the worst designs on the iPad. The buttons are way too tiny, they are arranged differently for every game, and each game seems to compete for the least intuitive layout and labeling.

Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by emehrkay on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @12:29PM (#4718063)
Yeah why not? The metaphor works/I cant think of a better one. One thing that I like about some of Apple's approach to things is that the user explicitly enters a mode or changes frame of action. There is a mode the user enters when moving around ios icons/making folders, there is a mode when editing content that appeared to be static at one point. The faux leather/fake realism helps make that switch. If the Xbox os looks just like Metro, how does the user know when things are different?
Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by moe on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @11:23PM (#4721003)
Yes, well, I'm all for having a popup and for having it stand out in terms of design. I just say that the GameCenter-Popups is a very poor design, especially by apple standards.

In other words: The metaphor is fine but the execution is lacking.

Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by pooriaazimi on Monday October 29, 2012 @05:28PM (#4714563)
No. It's not UI, it's HI (Human Interface) now!

It's best we all get used to it. It'll be repeated again and again from now on :)

Edit: This is what I mean: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_Interface

> Wikipedia does not have an article with this exact name. Please search for _Human Interface_ in Wikipedia to check for alternative titles or spellings.

It's still a non-word, but will be an (oft-used) word soon enough (like that damn skeumorphism thing).

Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by michaelhoffman on Monday October 29, 2012 @05:37PM (#4714611)
Apple has been using the "Human Interface" terminology since the 1970s.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bruce_Tognazzini

Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by GuiA on Monday October 29, 2012 @05:40PM (#4714627)
The academic field behind UI design is HCI (Human Computer Interaction), so HI makes more sense :)
Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by mmahemoff on Monday October 29, 2012 @06:43PM (#4714935)
And before HCI it was MMI (Man-Machine)...so the term evolves.
Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by GuiA on Monday October 29, 2012 @07:42PM (#4715179)
Do you have any references for that? HCI has been in use since the late 70s (I believe it originated at Xerox PARC, since the earliest literature I can find using it is from there), and is now the de-facto standard term for all major conferences/publications. On the other hand, searching "MMI" on the ACM digital library only returns it as an acronym for various more-or-less related things.

Maybe MMI is a mistranslation from other languages? This Danish site [1] uses it, and I know the used French term is "Interaction Homme Machine", which I can easily imagine being translated to Man-Machine Interaction

[1]: http://www.eit.ihk-edu.dk/subjects/mmi/intro.php#0

Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by mmahemoff on Monday October 29, 2012 @07:47PM (#4715204)
It's mentioned here for instance http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User_interface. I always got the impression it was a term emerging from the military in the 1940s-50s, when they began to study the ergonomics of cockpits, flight control systems, etc.
Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by crs on Monday October 29, 2012 @08:00PM (#4715246)
When working with engineers from Israel, I still hear the term "MMI" used frequently. They use it the same way I would use "HMI" here in the states.
Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by defap on Monday October 29, 2012 @05:35PM (#4714596)
Apple has used the term HI for a long, long time.
Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by pooriaazimi on Monday October 29, 2012 @05:37PM (#4714612)
I remember HIG, surely (having read it many times, first for pleasure and now as a developer), but it was always H+I+G, never H+I+something else. But I can be mistaken...

Edit: It doesn't matter if you're an iOS/OS X developer or not. Even if you're a web designer, you should really read Apple's HIGs carefully and thoroughly. They're (by any definition of the word), "great".

http://developer.apple.com/library/ios/#DOCUMENTATION/UserEx...

https://developer.apple.com/documentation/userexperience/Con...

Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by panacea on Monday October 29, 2012 @05:46PM (#4714665)
Well a Director of Human Interfaces would be responsible for defining the Human Interface Guidelines.
Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by DanBC on Monday October 29, 2012 @06:56PM (#4714995)
Human Interface (as in Human Interface Device) was even used by MS during drafting of the USB standard. Admittedly that's hardware, not software, but Human Interface isn't a new thing.
Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by mikesun on Monday October 29, 2012 @05:26PM (#4714546)
happy for this move. i was actually starting to envy microsoft's metro design aesthetic and loathe the changes that came in every new os x release.
Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by xer0x on Monday October 29, 2012 @05:42PM (#4714638)
It will be interesting to see how Apple approaches a minimalistic Jony style. Will it they make similar choices to Microsoft's Metro interface?
Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by ricardobeat on Monday October 29, 2012 @05:46PM (#4714663)
Probably not, considering their long history in "candy" UI. OSX's chrome style already strikes a good balance, I think they will keep it that way and just phase out the hyper-realistic apps.
Re:Scott Forstall leaves Apple by sigzero on Monday October 29, 2012 @07:34PM (#4715156)
That and I see Ives pushing for consistency.