News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by garbawarb on Thursday February 12, 2026 @12:15PM (#46991616)
I'm forever baffled that GM gave up on Cruise just as soon as Waymo was proving that autonomous driving is feasible.

(Disclaimer: former Cruise employee)

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by xnx on Thursday February 12, 2026 @12:28PM (#46991853)
As an outsider I assumed it took GM a substantial investment just to realize how far out of their depth they were. It made sense to cut their losses once they figured this out.

Having experience and capability to manufacturer cars has approximately zero benefit to create a self-driving software/sensor stack. It would make more sense for Adobe to create a self-driving car than GM.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by jessriedel on Thursday February 12, 2026 @01:17PM (#46992734)
Cruise was being operated as a separate company though. As a default, GM could have just not done anything and let Cruise operate as if it were independent. Any synergies (personnel, manufacturing expertise, etc) would have just been a bonus. And if they didn't want the financial exposure, they could have spun it out again.

Instead they chopped it up for spare parts, specifically, sending some Cruise personnel to work on deadend GM driver assistance tech and firing the rest. Baffling.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by xnx on Thursday February 12, 2026 @02:20PM (#46993668)
Reputational risk to GM from the cavalier/shameful way Cruise/Kyle Vogt operated. Tried to hide the fact they dragged a person.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by jessriedel on Sunday February 15, 2026 @11:05AM (#47024786)
If that were really the risk they would spin them out.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by helge9210 on Thursday February 12, 2026 @01:29PM (#46992934)
I remember GM cars in Herzliya, Israel with cables and cameras held by duct tape circa 2019 after Andrej Karpathy already presented end to end neural network training for Autopilot in Tesla. Looked like very late to the party.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by garbawarb on Thursday February 12, 2026 @11:10PM (#46998835)
Cruise was always run as a separate business from GM until they shut it down. I think they got too nervous about committing to the Silicon Valley investment style: high capital, high risk, long time horizon, high reward.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by Hawkenfall on Thursday February 12, 2026 @01:29PM (#46992932)
Cruise was actually just about to return to market after the October incident [1]. We had reached efficacy on all (much harder) internal safety benchmarks showing the car had significantly improved.

GM pulled the rug on us a day or two before announcing. The current Cruise CEO wasn't aware at all either. I have my own conspiracies of why GM did this, but GM also has a long history of fumbling the ball.

[1] https://www.cbsnews.com/sanfrancisco/news/nhtsa-robotaxi-cru...

[2] https://www.theautopian.com/here-are-five-times-gm-developed...!

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by ibejoeb on Thursday February 12, 2026 @01:32PM (#46992968)
Maybe I'm giving GM too much credit, but it seems to me that GM acquired the technology with the intention to bring it into their vehicles as driver assistance, not autonomous driving. They were pretty candid about not wanting to operate taxis. Cruise itself was embroiled in investigations and was prohibited from operating in SF and voluntarily ceased operations in other markets, which basically made it a target, and since GM had already dumped a few billion into it, it probably made sense to at least get unencumbered rights to the tech.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by kjkjadksj on Thursday February 12, 2026 @01:38PM (#46993073)
It seems the time car companies thought more than 4 years ahead was in 2007 and that culture was swiftly removed from the industry out of the economic shock that occurred shortly after.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by syntaxing on Thursday February 12, 2026 @02:12PM (#46993557)
Pushing Dan Ammann out was a bad idea. I personally like the original set up at the time. Kyle as the CTO and Dan as the CEO. Kyle was great as an internal CEO, he was calling most of the internal shots anyway. The accident would have played out very differently if Dan Ammann was the CEO IMO.

(Also former Cruise employee)

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by sja on Thursday February 12, 2026 @04:42PM (#46995663)
Was always unclear to me whether DanA was truly pushed out, or if the board (largely comprised of GM execs) wanted to take the company in a different direction than Dan wanted to go, and Dan decided to leave rather than stick around. Ie. IPO vs keep it a majority owned subsidiary.

(Another former employee)

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by AlotOfReading on Thursday February 12, 2026 @04:50PM (#46995755)
I got the impression that it was a conflict with Mary Barra specifically, not so much the board as a whole. They simply went along with her. The tone of the notice was indicative of being pushed out, not a mutual parting of ways.

(Another former).

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by someonehere on Thursday February 12, 2026 @02:18PM (#46993630)
I liked my one and ride in Cruise however the problem I had was it took 10 minutes or so for my car to depart.

Car arrives. I get in. The car is sitting there getting ready to depart but not moving. After a few minutes I hit the button to call support. Someone tells me it's about ready to go. Ten minutes later it starts leaving.

I have no idea why it took so long to start but it wasn't a great experience.

If you (or anyone else from Cruise) can explain what was going on, that would settle the difference in experience to me.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by Rohansi on Thursday February 12, 2026 @02:51PM (#46994113)
Waiting for someone to be ready to (actively) monitor it?
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by RivieraKid on Thursday February 12, 2026 @02:49PM (#46994080)
This is a business with winner-take-all characteristics. Cruise was unlikely to leapfrog Waymo. So it makes the case for continuing to throw money at this very unconvincing.

Cruise was always destined to be "like Waymo, but worse". Tesla, on the other hand, is taking a very different path than Waymo, they have a chance at beating Waymo at their own game and even if they don't beat Waymo, they can be a winner in some specific niche. (For the record, I'm a fan of Waymo.)

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by soperj on Thursday February 12, 2026 @03:52PM (#46994987)
What path is that? Their self driving took a huge step back when they dropped Mobileye and honestly I don't think it's been the same since.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by RivieraKid on Thursday February 12, 2026 @07:06PM (#46997122)
1. Leveraging data collected from Tesla owners. In theory, they have the data to learn the driving behavior from almost everywhere in the world.

2. Going directly for vision-only, no geofence system. Waymo's strategy has been to start with a proof-of concept and gradually expand geography and capabilities.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by soperj on Friday February 13, 2026 @10:49AM (#47004066)
Tesla has already done a geofenced system in Austin (in the shape of a penis). It went poorly.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by ForHackernews on Thursday February 12, 2026 @05:08PM (#46995970)
What, why? There's no winner-take-all aspect to shuttling people around. Taxi service is a commodity and taxis-without-drivers will also be a commodity. The switching costs for users are essentially zero.

That's how we get Uber, Lyft, DiDi, Grab, Bolt, WeRide, BlackWolf...

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by anonymous908213 on Thursday February 12, 2026 @05:56PM (#46996461)
I don't know how you can write that list and come to the conclusion that it's not winner-take-all. In their home market (US), Uber is ~75%, Lyft is ~25%, and all other competitors are sub-1% combined. Didi is similarly dominant in China, and so on. "Completely different markets have different winners taking it all" does not counteract the claim of winner-takes-all in any way, nor does listing utterly insignificant players like BlackWolf. Do you think people saying "winner-takes-all" in business contexts mean one company with literally 100% marketshare globally?
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by bluGill on Thursday February 12, 2026 @08:22PM (#46997768)
People who drive their own cars are larger than all. You can find single markets where those people are more than all combined world wide.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by ghaff on Friday February 13, 2026 @08:12AM (#47002324)
I think there is probably a healthy subset of people on here who take Uber etc. all the time. I, on the other hand, maybe take it a half-dozen times a year (plus some private cars to the airport).

I'd love a really good driver assistive system for my car (ala FSD today) but I likely wouldn't actually get driven around a lot more unless the economics were more compelling than seem likely anytime soon.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by bluGill on Friday February 13, 2026 @08:53AM (#47002725)
For most people the economics won't every work out. Uber/Taxis make sense if you only need them a few times per year. However even if the driver is free, if you are using your car daily as most people do it won't work out.

People who yell "share" forget that most people are driving during rush hour, and so the car will be idle the rest of the day anyway. As such there isn't that much money to save by sharing a car.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by ghaff on Friday February 13, 2026 @12:36PM (#47005335)
In my observation, some cities that have "OK" public transit, people can make-do without cars if they Uber, Zipcar, traditional rentals, walk, and use transit. I also observe that it involves a lot of juggling and probably not regular well-outside-of-town trips.

Absent driving yourself at all, you're going to be very limited most places. Which may be OK for continuing a college lifestyle but mostly doesn't work unless you have a partner who handles the driving.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by ForHackernews on Friday February 13, 2026 @06:10AM (#47001430)
Try to raise prices and see how fast those regional "monopolies" evaporate. MoviePass was the winner in the "unlimited movie tickets" subscription space.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by RivieraKid on Friday February 13, 2026 @11:34AM (#47004595)
But Waymo or their competitors are not in the "shuttling people around" business. They're developing a driver. Robotaxi is one of the applications.

The winner-takes-all aspect comes from economies of scale for example. If Waymo is several years ahead and has better economics, how can Cruise catch up? They will have lower cost of capital. Top people will want to work at Waymo rather than Cruise. It will be hard to close the R&D gap. When Cruise is where Waymo is today, Waymo will already have a lightweight package that will be used by Ford, VW or Toyota and capable to drive everywhere in any weather conditions.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by nradov on Thursday February 12, 2026 @05:57PM (#46996478)
For national security reasons, several other countries won't allow Waymo (or Tesla or any other US company) to "win" in their territory. This will ensure that at least a couple other competitors remain worldwide regardless of whether it makes sense in purely economic terms.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by lacker on Thursday February 12, 2026 @04:53PM (#46995793)
It seems tough culturally.

If you look at it from an outside point of view, right now Tesla is worth $1.6T, Waymo is worth $130B, and GM is worth $72B. If Cruise were actually a third viable competitor in this race, it would probably be worth more than the rest of GM. Self-driving is just a far more valuable business than car-making.

So from that point of view it would make sense to say, don't worry about the rest of GM too much, you should be willing to sacrifice all of that to increase the changes of making Cruise work.

It's hard to change the culture at a place like GM though. Does the GM CEO really want to take a huge amount of risk? Would they be willing to take a 50-50 shot where they either 10x the company's value or lose it all? Or would they prefer to pay a few billion dollars to avoid that risk.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by Alive-in-2025 on Thursday February 12, 2026 @06:05PM (#46996546)
Using tesla valuation is not useful. It's a meme stock, has AI bs overvaluation over it. It's value is completely unconnected from reality. The car business is declining steadily. It's a good day when the famous CEO doesn't do something incredibly destructive to the brand name. It's just going down.

At the same time, if Musk went away, the stock would crash back to reality but a non-idiot leader could just do impossible, crazy, hard stuff, like ... working on obvious new models and basic steady improvements.

Tesla PE is 398 today (after a drop). Toyota's PE is 13. Toyota at the least is not hemoraging market share, sales, revenue, profits. Tesla is losing on all thoes things. Tesla would need a 30x price reduction to get down to much much more stable and profitable toyota. It's gets worse because Tesla's sales and profit keep going down each quarter.

There's no doubt value in self driving but the overall value is questionable. If there are many companies providing it, and at least waymo is doing great, plus there are many many other companies in China in good shape, the value multiple won't be there.

What's the market value of all taxi compannies combined in the us? It was about $230 billion in 2024 (https://www.skyquestt.com/report/taxi-market). Will tesla get 100% of the us self driving business in the future? No, waymo at least will be a serious market competitor, tesla's service doesn't really work.

Because there are going to be muiltiple competitors with working products (we'll see if/when tesla ever gets there), Tesla's huge valuation will never make sense. Robots are much farther behind than robotaxis (there's no brain, no prototype of a learning system, maybe one day).

This got way too long, I think GM just saw it as a money sink. I think that was a big mistake, though.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by lacker on Thursday February 12, 2026 @06:43PM (#46996925)
It's funny to use "the market value of all taxi companies combined" as a proxy for how valuable the self-driving market will be, because that's exactly the reasoning that led people to underestimate Uber. The market value of all taxi companies combined was pretty small when Uber started.

That said, you could be right! Maybe self-driving will never be worth more than that. It's really hard to tell what business models will be like in the future. But this is the cultural mismatch, it seemed like GM leadership did not want to be in a risky business where they were betting billions of dollars on the success of self-driving. Clearly, to some people, that seemed like a really good bet to make. Time will tell.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by gruez on Thursday February 12, 2026 @08:02PM (#46997593)
>The market value of all taxi companies combined was pretty small when Uber started.

Were there even reliable metrics for this? They only seem small like car dealerships seem small - not of consolidation.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by Alive-in-2025 on Saturday February 14, 2026 @01:18AM (#47012097)
Of course a new genre defining company can do what existing companies did and vastly increase the market if they make it better, more efficient, easier whatever. All taxi companies are not all transportation needs, not even on the road. Busses, planes, etc. There will be really new market niches, how about if your RV lets you sleep comfortably and drives all night, you never need to pay or stop (if you can sleep in a moving vehicle), gas or charge itself up.

I was thinking it won't be just one company with this tech, so they'll compete and reduce the value of driverless cars down, by attacking the profit of each other. That would be healthier than having pseudo monopoly power because there are only 2 of them - like say ios and android are basically the world of cell phones, with a few very tiny other companies.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by refulgentis on Friday February 13, 2026 @01:25AM (#46999557)
Cosign, there's a reason it took forever and a day for Waymo to actually scale. It's great stuff, changed the way I live, but they gotta wince at the economics.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by FarmerPotato on Friday February 13, 2026 @03:18AM (#47000268)
Anecdote: living in an area where Waymo is becoming mainstream, but we've been seeing their mapping cars drive around streets for five years prior.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by Eridrus on Friday February 13, 2026 @12:46PM (#47005449)
Waymo has been attracting outside capital just fine.

I think the bigger issue is that Cruise was not succeeding at building the driver.

Cruise was shutdown after a safety incident, same as Uber.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by mkozlows on Friday February 13, 2026 @02:26PM (#47006662)
I feel like the bigger issue is that Cruise evidently had an unsafe company culture (like Uber): It wasn't just that they had an incident, it's that they lied about the incident and tried to cover things up.

This has been a pretty consistent pattern -- Cruise was always less transparent about its safety data than Waymo, and its claims tended to be opaque and non-measurable, whereas Waymo was partnering with insurance companies to get hard data.

Waymo is going to have incidents, too, but I think they have made the (correct) decision that being open and transparent about safety stuff is the way they move past those; Cruise made a decision in the opposite direction, and it killed them.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by KenSF on Thursday February 12, 2026 @05:48PM (#46996377)
We should not forget this is the same company that had an amazing lead on everyone in the electric car market 3 decades ago with the EV1. See "Who Killed the Electric Car [0]

[0] https://www.whokilledtheelectriccar.com/

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by UltraSane on Friday February 13, 2026 @01:00AM (#46999404)
replacing a gas engine with an electric motor and installing a battery pack is not hard. The EV1 was a pretty bad car. The real secret sauce of modern electric cars is cheap Lithium Ion battery packs.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by SoftTalker on Friday February 13, 2026 @01:06PM (#47005695)
That and making them look like normal cars not futuristic golf carts.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by KenSF on Saturday February 14, 2026 @01:12PM (#47016811)
The EV1 predated the Roadster by a decade. Had GM been improving the EV1 for those 10 years, including Lithium Ion batteries, GM would have been far ahead of everyone . . . had they just kept going with a technology that was inevitable. Where would Cruse be today had they continued with this new technology that is inevitable?
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by cortesoft on Thursday February 12, 2026 @06:32PM (#46996805)
One of my good friends was a driver for Cruise (he sit in the cars while they drove and made tons of notes about the behavior)

He said they were pretty awful and would constantly mess up.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by torton on Thursday February 12, 2026 @09:31PM (#46998255)
That is true for all algorithmic iterative learning. I'm sure early models from Tesla, Waymo, Zoox, etc. were also driving a few hundred feet before the operators had to take over at first as well.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by red75prime on Friday February 13, 2026 @03:22AM (#47000300)
Yep. Participants of Waymo's early rider program are under NDA.
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by cortesoft on Friday February 13, 2026 @01:48PM (#47006215)
Sure, but he test drove with them until they shut down, and they never improved (according to him)
Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by rangestransform on Thursday February 12, 2026 @09:12PM (#46998096)
“Cruise” is still churning out good tech, they gave a talk recently about using a lightweight [1] type of planner to train an end to end VLA style planner

[1] https://arxiv.org/abs/2502.03349

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by hypercube33 on Friday February 13, 2026 @07:07AM (#47001792)
Isolated I get why you're baffled, but given GM being GM this is par for the course.

Check out their history of EV or hybrid vehicles or even the history of Saturn - they stumble onto something awesome that people love and it's the company mission to destroy it.

Re:Beginning autonomous operations with the 6th-generation W... by Eridrus on Friday February 13, 2026 @12:47PM (#47005469)
Cruise seemed to have a significantly inferior product based on observed safety and what Cruise employees have said on HN.