But then again this time seems different, laws aren’t followed or upheld. Human rights are a fleeting staple.
I suspect Mexicans would view it as another Pancho Villa Expedition, which was also event where neither side declared war.
Not in the metaphorical "war on poverty" sort of way.
FWIW, examples in addition to Maduro are Aguinaldo (Philippines), Noriega (Panama), Hussein (Iraq), and Aristide (Haiti).
(Technically speaking, the US didn't recognize Philippine independence so didn't consider Aguinaldo to be its president, but instead a rightful cession from the Kingdom of Spain due to the Treaty of Paris, which ended the Spanish–American War, where the US had made a formal declaration of war.)
(Also, the US says Aristide's departure was voluntary.)
rather than arming the cartels to fight against the mexican government, thr US could just... not
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internment_of_Italian_American...
Let's not forget that a belligerent at war could round up all of their Americans as "enemy aliens" and intern them too.
Obviously, even before 1939, Italian-Americans were upstanding citizens, legitimate businessmen, and loving family guys who wouldn't hurt a flea. Italians had always been accepted as members of the White race and they got along with the Irish and the Chinese like peas in a pod. It would've been excessively cruel for American authorities to go into their communities, round them up and put them in camps. Those poor unarmed fellas would've suffered so much in the lockup. Terrible prison conditions in those days. Unthinkable. Many of us would've starved with nobody to serve us pizzas and pasta and cannoli!
/s
There will not be a hot war in Mexican territory. The problem with Americans is that they see this international border as a bright line and a defining point of jurisdictional change. Latinos do not see it that way. Chicano nationalism exists wherever there are Chicano communities. If Chicanos live in Los Angeles, they belong to família and la raza. Likewise if they live in Florida, or Minnesota or Seattle. They maintain their cultural ties and their allegiance is clear by the flags that they wave.Territory is only an accident of history. Presidente Sheinbaum said that thousands of Mexican soldiers were marching to the border, but the reality is that her soldiers have been crossing to El Norte for hundreds of years, and immigration laws won't stop them.
No, Latinos are not a monolithic people. There are Borriqueños and Cubanos and Peruanos and the mestizos vs. los Indios all remember where they came from. But can Americans tell them apart? Do you know what a gang member looks like? Is he different from a father/husband/restaurant manager?
The Gadsden Purchase, Southern California, and Texas are occupied territory, and the United States thinks we're occupying it, but who is really in control? The idea that a U.S. military force would "invade" south of our border is laughable with the US trying to mitigate the situation in Minnesota (for example), and non-Chicanos are defending on the side of the recolonizers.
The U.S. is trying to remind the Chicanos who has jurisdiction and who has territorial control, and the the Chicanos are tactfully trying to do the same to us.
Some Americans may, I don't know how many, but definitely not Americans as a collective.
Suffice it to say that the Chicano experience and perspectives on nationalism are different than that of typical Americans. And that Americans cannot understand the political relationships or the border states or the Chicano enclaves without accepting that our perspective is not shared by them, and their worldviews on race, ethnicity, culture, territory, nationalism and legal status has led us to this point in 2026.
Our national motto is "E PLURIBUS UNUM" and our structure is a republic with 50 states. But like the Internet is a network of networks, the United States is a nation of immigrants, where not everyone is playing by the same rules.
In what world is public opinion not universally against the cartels? It's hard to take you seriously after that.
In that case, the justification was a prerequisite to Congress authorizing a war without losing elections, and then selling it to the US's allies so we wouldn't have to send quite as many troops and thus lose elections. This administration demonstrably doesn't care about justification, authorization, alliances, or elections. So why bother? If they're going to stage an arbitrary Venezuela-like military operation in Mexico because of "cartels", they wouldn't wait for a civilian mass-death event, or for Congress, or regional allies, or public opinion. They didn't wait for any of that in Venezuela.
TBQH this just felt like a cheap and easy way for them to perpetuate the idea that we're always at war with terrorists. Now they're "narcoterrorists", but they're still "terrorists". And this administration might not like obstacles like authorization and due process, but it loves cheap, easy terrorists.
I think you’re getting tripped up by some specific wording and managing to miss the point the poster was making. The point should be taken seriously even if imprecisely articulated. While most folks are against the cartels, there’s a much wider range of belief on how much they warrant government or military intervention and to what degree we should be spending various resources on them. The historical state of play was(is?) that cartels are criminal organizations which are generally a policing matter that has escalated to specialized policing agencies and multinational networks of policing agencies. The marked escalation of the military into this is a more recent piece that is somewhat more controversial. One doesn’t have to be “in favor of the cartel” to ask questions about whether our military should be bombing boats or invading countries to ostensibly neutralize organizations that historically have been subject to policing operations.
To go back to the parallel… the public wasn’t in favor of Al Qaeda before 9/11 either, but there was a huge difference in the level of response the public was in favor of after. It turned from an intelligence monitoring level of response into an active military invasion of multiple countries.
If they were all drug runners, why weren't they put on trial? Why was so much effort made to sink all the evidence? Why did an admiral resign, when told to do this?
Everybody involved, starting from the people pulling the trigger, to the people giving the orders should be getting a fair trial and a swift punishment for that little stint of piracy and murder.
But these people all act like there is no such thing as consequences.
Are there?
They definitely care about not ratting the cage with the US - they don't harm US federal agents, or take US hostages, and the last incident of Americans being killed in Mexico by cartel-affiliated gunmen in a case of mistaken identity - it was the cartel who handed the perps over and apologised[0]
[0] https://edition.cnn.com/2023/03/09/us/mexico-matamoros-ameri...