News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by lugao on Monday February 02, 2026 @08:28PM (#46865061)
Only people who never interacted with data center reliability think it's doable to maintain servers with no human intervention.
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by keepamovin on Monday February 02, 2026 @09:42PM (#46865759)
Whoa there, space-faring sysadmin. You really want that off-world contract tho?
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by lugao on Monday February 02, 2026 @09:58PM (#46865869)
Haha, hard pass on the job. I prefer my oxygen at 1 atm.

I'm not a data center technician myself, but I have deep respect for those folks and the complexity they manage. It's quite surprising the market still buys Musk's claims day after day.

Re:xAI joins SpaceX by SecretDreams on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @08:23AM (#46870664)
> It's quite surprising the market still buys Musk's claims day after day.

More disturbing than surprising.

Re:xAI joins SpaceX by andrewinardeer on Monday February 02, 2026 @11:18PM (#46866423)
This guy invented reusable rockets that land themselves. I'm sure xAI is not just one guy. Plenty of talented people work there.
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by jmyeet on Monday February 02, 2026 @09:23PM (#46865593)
There are a class of people who may seem smart until they start talking about a subject you know about. Hank Green is a great example of this.

For many on HN, Elon buying Twitter was a wake up call because he suddenly started talking about software and servers and data centers and reliability and a ton of people with experience with those things were like "oh... this guy's an idiot".

Data centers in space are exactly like this. Your comment (correctly) alludes to this.

Companies like Google, Meta, Amazon and Microsoft all have so many servers that parts are failing constantly. They fail so often on large scales that it's expected things like a hard drive will fail while a single job might be running.

So all of these companies build systems to detect failures, disable running on that node until it's fixed, alerting someone to what the problem is and then bringing the node back online once the problem it's addressed. Everything will fail. Hard drives, RAM, CPUs, GPUs, SSDs, power supplies, fans, NICs, cables, etc.

So all data centers will have a number of technicians who are constantly fixing problems. IIRC Google's ratio tended to be about 10,000 servers per technician. Good technicians could handle higher ratios. When a node goes offline it's not clear why. Techs would take known good parts and basically replacce all of them and then figure out what the problem is later, dispose of any bad parts and put tested good parts into the pool of known good parts for a later incident.

Data centers in space lose all of this ability. So if you have a large number of orbital servers, they're going to be failing constantly with no ability to fix them. You can really only deorbit them and replace them and that gets real expensive.

Electronics and chips on satellites also aren't consumer grade. They're not even enterprise grade. They're orders of magnitude more reliable than that because they have to deal with error correction terrestial components don't due to cosmic rays and the solar wind. That's why they're a fraction of the power of something you can buy from Amazon but they cost 1000x as much. Because they need to last years and not fail, something no home computer or data center server has to deal with.

Put it this way, a hardened satellite or probe CPU is like paying $1 million for a Raspberry Pi.

And anybody who has dealt with data centers knows this.

Re:xAI joins SpaceX by WalterBright on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @12:12AM (#46866786)
> but they cost 1000x as much

Compute power has increased more than 1000x while the cost came down.

I recall paying $3000 for my first IBM PC.

> they need to last years and not fail

Not if they are cheap enough to build and launch. Quantity has a quality all its own.

Re:xAI joins SpaceX by queenkjuul on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @12:39AM (#46866946)
Have you heard of cosmic radiation?
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by WalterBright on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @02:45AM (#46867826)
Cosmic rays take time to destroy them.
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by tecleandor on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @06:44AM (#46869748)
It's not only about destruction. It's also about reliability. Without proper shielding and error correction you're going to have lots and lots of reliability issues and data corruption. And if we're talking about AI and given the current reliability problems of the Nvidia hardware, plus the radiation, plus the difficulty for refrigerating all that stuff on space... That's a big problem. And we still haven't started to talk about the energy generation.

I think there's a very interesting use case on edge computing (edge of space, if you wanna make the joke) that in fact some satellites are already doing, were they preprocess data before sending back to Earth. But datacenter-power-level computing is not even near.

I have no idea and numbers to back it up, but I feel it would be even easier to set up a Moon datacenter than an orbital datacenter (when talking about that size of datacenter)

Re:xAI joins SpaceX by WalterBright on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @01:46PM (#46875350)
We'll see!

Keep in mind that the current state of space electronics is centered around one-off very expensive launches, where the electronics failure would be a fiscal disaster. (See JWST)

Being able to rapidly launch cheap electronics may very well change the whole outlook on this.

Re:xAI joins SpaceX by queenkjuul on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @02:58PM (#46876391)
People already do that (launch cheap, redundant, unshielded electronics) for LEO, but sounds like these data centers would pretty explicitly not be in LEO.

Also AI GPUs are the exact opposite of cheap electronics

Re:xAI joins SpaceX by fblp on Monday February 02, 2026 @10:08PM (#46865937)
Great comment on hardware and maintenance costs, and in comparison Elon wrote "My estimate is that within 2 to 3 years, the lowest cost way to generate AI compute will be in space." It's a pity this reads like the entire acquisition of xAi is based on "Elon's napkin math" (maybe he checked it with Grok)
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by SilverElfin on Monday February 02, 2026 @11:57PM (#46866704)
The deal they made values xAI at $230 Billion. It’s a made up number, with no trustworthy financial justification to back it up. It is set to provide a certain return to xAI’s investors (the valuation decides the amount you get per share), who in turn are bailing out the earlier acquisition of X (Twitter). All of this is basically a shell game where Elon is using one company to bail out another. It’s a way of reducing the risk of new ventures by spreading them out between his companies. It’s also really bad for SpaceX employees and investors, who are basically subsidizing other companies.

The thing is, everyone knows Elon is not a real CEO of any of these companies. There isn’t enough time to even be the CEO of one company and a parent. This guy has 10 companies and 10 children. He’s just holding the position and preventing others from being in that position, so he can enact changes like this. And his boards are all stacked with family members, close friends, and sycophants who won’t oppose his agenda.

Re:xAI joins SpaceX by miohtama on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @01:38AM (#46867342)
As both are private companies none of this matters if the investors of both companies are happy.
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by SilverElfin on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @02:34AM (#46867748)
Most of the investors don’t even have a choice. Nor do all the other shareholders like employees. And the boards of Musk companies are stacked with his yes men.
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by miohtama on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @11:06AM (#46887533)
This was well known before the investments were made. If the investors were not happy with this they would not have invested.
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by rf15 on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @03:11AM (#46868043)
Ah yes, my favourite kind of engineering: financial engineering
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by breakyerself on Monday February 02, 2026 @10:23PM (#46866054)
He's bailing out one of his failing ventures with one of his so far successful ones. The BS napkin math isn't the reason he's doing it. It's the excuse for doing it.
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by bigbuppo on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @03:31AM (#46868198)
Or he's having another mental break because he knocked up yet another woman and is going to have yet another kid he can't remember the name of.
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by titzer on Monday February 02, 2026 @10:19PM (#46866023)
Can you provide a link for that quote, because that quote is absolute stupidity.
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by spenczar5 on Monday February 02, 2026 @10:31PM (#46866109)
It's in the article that you're commenting on, https://www.spacex.com/updates#xai-joins-spacex.
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by titzer on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @12:21AM (#46866840)
Oh, ffs.
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by spikels on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @12:49AM (#46867014)
Haha. It's less than 1,000 words that would take less than 5 minutes to read.

I bet much less than half of the hundreds of HN commenters here bother to read it. Many are clearly unfamiliar with its content.

Re:xAI joins SpaceX by titzer on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @12:58AM (#46867080)
I can't, I don't want it in my head :/
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by rkagerer on Monday February 02, 2026 @10:47PM (#46866214)
Thanks for putting words to that; the paragraph which most stuck out to me as outlandish is (emphasis mine):

    The basic math is that launching a million tons per year of satellites generating 100 kW of compute power per ton would add 100 gigawatts of AI compute capacity annually, *with no ongoing operational or maintenance needs*.
I'm deeply disillusioned to arrive at this conclusion but the Occam's Razor in me feels this whole acquisition is more likely a play to increase the perceptual value of SpaceX before a planned IPO.
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by rf15 on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @03:23AM (#46868132)
"what if we move all our data center needs into my imagination, things are running so much smoother there"
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by everfrustrated on Monday February 02, 2026 @09:39PM (#46865729)
Might be why he's also investing in building their own fabs - if he can keep the silicon costs low then that flips a lot of the math here.
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by Sparyjerry on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @12:39AM (#46866945)
First of all Twitter had basically no downtime since he bought it, so all the 'internet experts' posting their thoughts were completely dead wrong. If anything Twitter was far more reliable than Microsoft has been these past few years.

You are assuming things need to run the same way in space, for instance you mentioned fans, you won't have any in space. You also won't have any air, dust, static, or any moving parts.

You are assuming the costs to launch to orbit are high, when the entire point of Spacex's latest ship is to bring the cost to launch so low that it is cheaper per ton than an airplane flight.

Maintenance would be nice but you are saying this like Elon Musk's company doesn't already manage the most powerful datacenters on the planet.

You have no clue what you are talking about regarding cosmic rays and solar wind, these will literally be solar powered and behind panels and shielding 100% of the time.

Re:xAI joins SpaceX by jmyeet on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @01:29AM (#46867288)
I went looking through your comments. 75% of them (and probably 90% in the lasst 2 years) were Elon related. Tesla, SpaceX, Grok, Twitter, DOGE, etc. Quite a lot of comments for 101 karma if I'm being real.

Why do you feel this kneejerk reaction to defend Elon and his companies? You'll never be him. He doesn't care about you. He'd use you for reactor shielding for an uptick in Tesla share price without a second's hesitation. This is cultish behavior.

Do you have any idea who you're defending? I'll give you just one example. A right-wing influencer named Dom Lucre uploaded CSAM to Twitter, a video. But he didn't just upload it. He watermarked it first so had it on his computer and then postporcessed it. It was I believe up for days. This was apparently a video so bad that mere possession should land you in prison. And the fact that the FBI didn't arrest him basically tells you he'd an FBI asset. After taking days to ban him, Elon personally intervened to unban him. Why? Because reasons.

And this is the same man who it's becoming clear was deeply linked with Jeffrey Epstein, as was his brother [1].

Bringing this back to the original point: this is why Twitter lost 80% of its value after Elon acquired it. Advertisers fled because it became a shithole for CSAM and Nazis.

As for "basically no downtime" that's hilarious. I even found you commenting the classic anecdote "it was fine for me" (paraphrased) on one such incident when Twitter DDOSed itself [2].

Your cultish devotion here is pretty obvious eg [3]. I'm genuinely asking: what do you get out of all this?

[1]: https://www.axios.com/local/boulder/2026/02/02/kimbal-musk-j...

[2]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36555897

[3]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42836560

Re:xAI joins SpaceX by NlightNFotis on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @07:13AM (#46870011)
Lol, did you spot one of his alts?

But yeah, otherwise agree that his conduct, within a corporate context and otherwise, do not merit the kind of public adulation he's getting.

I also remember (vividly at that) his comments on distributed systems when he bought twitter back in the day and was starting to take it over. I remember thinking to myself, if he's just spewing so much bullshit on this, and I can understand this because it's closer to my body of knowledge, what other such stuff is he pronouncing authoritatively on other domains I don't know so much about?

Re:xAI joins SpaceX by Sparyjerry on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @12:18AM (#46881786)
I've never once seen any CSAM or nazi things except the highly publicized Ye postings on Twitter, who also did a super bowl commercial that linked to a nazi tshirt by the way, so go ahead and boycott the NFL too if you like. You simply don't use the service if you think these things. Also, I recall that day that the internet was all a buzz with how twitter is down, obviously only because Elon haters wanted so badly to be right, but I used it all day uninterrupted and wouldn't have even noticed if I didn't read an article about it. You are seriously being brainwashed to hate Elon by mostly democrat mouthpieces who make hit piece articles about how he waved while saying thank you wrong. I defend innoent and wrongly accused people like Elon because so many people clearly making this up out of no where, you literally linked to an article here claiming he has ties to Epstein, like seriously if you ever decide to exit your bubble you'll find out how many people are lying to you.
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by queenkjuul on Thursday February 05, 2026 @08:33AM (#46899468)
You may not have seen it, but everyone else did, including the French government, who has summoned musk to court.

So your claim is that the Trump FBI fabricated evidence linking Musk to Epstein? Why do you think they'd do that?

Re:xAI joins SpaceX by Sparyjerry on Wednesday February 11, 2026 @01:01AM (#46971412)
It's not that the FBI fabricated evidence, its that the article misrepresents evidence entirely. Just having your name mentioned in an e-mail means absolutely nothing, what matters is the content of the e-mails. The ring wing, including Elon, has always wanted Epstein files released for years, while the left wing has only wanted it for the last couple months since they realized they can just write lies to convince people that some how Trump being an informant on Epstein and helping the FBI somehow is a strong enough connection to also 'connect' him for being in it? That's like you calling the police on a robber and democrats saying you were 'connected' to the robbery.
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by Sparyjerry on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @12:23AM (#46881813)
If people stop posting completely wrong things, I'll stop correcting them.
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by nkozyra on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @07:43AM (#46870322)
> Twitter had basically no downtime since he bought it

I'm sorry, but what? Not only has it had multiple half days of downtime, two full days+, but just two weeks ago had significant downtime.

https://www.thebiglead.com/is-x-down-twitter-suffers-major-o...

Re:xAI joins SpaceX by Sparyjerry on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @12:11AM (#46881746)
Significant downtime being like an hour, maybe, per year? Please.
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by nkozyra on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @09:53AM (#46886519)
No, as I mentioned, full days in several cases, multiple 8+ hour outages.

Keep in mind this is in response to "basically no downtime"

If you told me Microsoft had "basically no downtime" I'd have the same reaction.

Re:xAI joins SpaceX by edm0nd on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @09:35AM (#46871474)
The sock puppet account is angry!
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by mosquitobiten on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @06:01AM (#46869380)
for me trying to apply some liquid TIM on a CPU in a space station in a big ass suit would be a total nightmare, maybe robots could make it bearable but the racks would get greassy fast from many failed attempts
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by skartik on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @09:20AM (#46871297)
Excellent comment.
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by e4325f on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @11:14AM (#46872891)
I'm pretty sure they don't harden compute in space anymore, that's one thing SpaceX pioneered with their cost-cutting approach early on.
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by angled on Monday February 02, 2026 @08:33PM (#46865106)
But … but what if we had solar-powered AI SREs to fix the solar-powered AI satellites… /in space/?
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by lugao on Monday February 02, 2026 @09:03PM (#46865409)
Maintaining modern accelerators requires frequent hands-on intervention -- replacing hardware, reseating chips, and checking cable integrity.

Because these platforms are experimental and rapidly evolving, they aren't 'space-ready.' Space-grade hardware must be 'rad-hardened' and proven over years of testing.

By the time an accelerator is reliable enough for orbit, it’s several generations obsolete, making it nearly impossible to compete or turn a profit against ground-based clusters.

Re:xAI joins SpaceX by trothamel on Monday February 02, 2026 @09:22PM (#46865581)
On the other hand, Tesla vehicles have similar hardware built into them, and don't require such hands-on intervention. (And that's the hardware that will be going up.)
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by lugao on Monday February 02, 2026 @09:50PM (#46865818)
Car-grade inference hardware is fundamentally different from data center-grade inference hardware, let alone the specialized, interconnected hardware used for training (like NVLink or complex optical fabrics). These are different beasts in terms of power density, thermal stress, and signaling sensitivity.

Beyond that, we don't actually know the failure rate of the Tesla fleet. I’ve never had a personal computer fail from use in my life, but that’s just anecdotal and holds no weight against the law of large numbers. When you operate at the scale of a massive cluster, "one-in-a-million" failures become a daily statistical certainty.

Claiming that because you don't personally see cars failing on the side of the road means they require zero intervention actually proves my original point: people who haven't managed data center reliability underestimate the sheer volume of "rare" failures that occur at scale.

Re:xAI joins SpaceX by trothamel on Monday February 02, 2026 @10:05PM (#46865908)
https://x.com/elonmusk/status/2017792776415682639

For what it's worth, this project plans to use Tesla AI5/AI6 hardware for the first launches.

Re:xAI joins SpaceX by jonah on Monday February 02, 2026 @09:56PM (#46865855)
Not only the sibling comments points, but cars aren't exposed to the radiation of space...
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by cloudfudge on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @02:26PM (#46875968)
Well, one car is... and it's a Tesla!
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by boutell on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @07:11AM (#46869991)
Thank you. The waste heat problem is so bad but no one gets around to mentioning the fact that you can't have AI grade chips and space at the same time.
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by elihu on Monday February 02, 2026 @08:40PM (#46865170)
Do they need to be maintained? If one compute node breaks, you just turn it off and don't worry about it. You just assume you'll have some amount of unrecoverable errors and build that into the cost/benefit analysis. As long as failures are in line with projections, it's baked in as a cost of doing business.

The idea itself may be sound, though that's unrelated to the question of whether Elon Musk can be relied on to be honest with investors about what their real failure projections and cost estimates are and whether it actually makes financial sense to do this now or in the near future.

Re:xAI joins SpaceX by lugao on Monday February 02, 2026 @08:55PM (#46865311)
AI clusters are heavily interconnected, the blast radius for single component failure is much larger than running single nodes -- you would fragment it beyond recovery to be able to use it meaningfully.

I can't get in detail about real numbers but it's not doable with current hardware by a large margin.

Re:xAI joins SpaceX by FeepingCreature on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @07:00AM (#46869898)
eh? They're not gonna lay cable in space. The laser links will be retargetable.
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by lugao on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @09:54AM (#46871728)
How are you doing pci express x16 with lasers without fiber optics? Have you touched data center hardware in your life?
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by youarentrightjr on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @11:15AM (#46872906)
Lasers, space, super geniuses, and most importantly money. You're worrying too much about the details and not enough about the awesomeness.

But seriously, why are all the stans in these comments as unknowledgeable as Elon himself? Is that just what is required to stan for this type of garbage?

Re:xAI joins SpaceX by cloudfudge on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @02:30PM (#46876019)
What if every installed twitter app just acted as a proxy for grok to post as millions of different elon stans? Diabolical.
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by mrweasel on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @03:27AM (#46868158)
Microsoft did do the experiment (Project Natick) where they had "datacenters" in pods under the sea with really good results. The idea was simply to ship enough extra capacity, but due to the environment, the failure rates where 1/8th of normal.

Still, dropping a pod into the sea makes more sense than launching it into space. At least cooling, power, connectivity and eventual maintenance is simpler.

The whole thing makes no sense and is seems like it's just Musk doing financial manipulation again.

https://news.microsoft.com/source/features/sustainability/pr...

Re:xAI joins SpaceX by zarzavat on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @03:46AM (#46868324)
> The whole thing makes no sense and is seems like it's just Musk doing financial manipulation again.

It's a fig leaf for getting two IPOs in one. There's no sense in analyzing it any further.

Re:xAI joins SpaceX by ryandvm on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @08:41AM (#46870850)
Exactly. He can croon about DOGE all day, but the reality is his entire fortune was built on feeding at the trough of government largess. That's why he talks about Mars all the time. He's not stupid enough to think we could actually live there, but damn if he couldn't make a couple trillion skimming off the top of the world's most expensive space program.
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by alextingle on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @10:57AM (#46872645)
No, I think he is that stupid.
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by alexc05 on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @10:03AM (#46871834)
Right, let's not forget that he's selling it to himself in an all stock deal. He could have priced it at eleventy kajillion dollars and it would have had the same meaning.

He's basically trading two cypto coins with himself and sending out a press release.

Re:xAI joins SpaceX by moontear on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @06:52AM (#46869828)
The experiment may have been successful, but if it was why don't we see underwater datacenters everywhere? It probably is a similar reason why we won't see space datacenters in the near future either.

Space has solar energy going for itself. With underwater you don't need to lug a 1420 ton rocket with a datacenter payload to space.

Re:xAI joins SpaceX by dubcanada on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @07:20AM (#46870084)
Salt water absolutely murders things, combined with constant movement almost anything will be torn apart in very little time. It's an extremely harsh environment compared to space, which is not anything. If you can get past the solar extremes without earths shield, it's almost perfect for computers. A vacuum, energy source available 24/7 at unlimited capacity, no dust, etc.
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by h3half on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @07:43AM (#46870316)
The vacuum is the problem. It might be cold but has terrible heat transfer properties. The area of radiators it would take to dissipate a data center dwarfs absolutely anything we’ve ever sent to orbit
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by kakacik on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @08:08AM (#46870521)
Also solar wind, cosmic rays etc. We don't have perfect shielding for that yet. Cooling would be tricky and has to be completely radiative which is very slow in space. Vacuum is a perfect insulator after all, look how thermos work.
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by tim333 on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @10:25AM (#46872128)
I can't see any reason to put them underwater rather than in a field somewhere. I think the space rationale is you may run out of fields.
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by droopyEyelids on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @11:12AM (#46872868)
Placing them underwater means you get free, unlimited cooling.

Exactly the opposite of space, where all cooling must happen through radiation, which is expensive/inefficient

Re:xAI joins SpaceX by queenkjuul on Thursday February 05, 2026 @08:26AM (#46899392)
It's not free cooling underwater, you still have to circulate the water and seal the components.

Makes far more sense to build on the beach than underwater, if all you want is unlimited sea water to pump around.

Re:xAI joins SpaceX by yencabulator on Friday February 06, 2026 @12:23PM (#46915569)
I understood that part of Microsoft's experiment was to see how being hermetically sealed would affect hardware durability. Submerging is a good way to demonstrate the seal, but that part might have been just showmanship.
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by yencabulator on Friday February 06, 2026 @12:21PM (#46915538)
Dropping a pod into the sea makes more sense than launching it into space, and Microsoft decided it wasn't worth doing.
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by donny2018 on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @09:46AM (#46871613)
I'd assume datacenters built for space would have different reliability standards. I mean, if a communication satellite (which already has a lot of electronic and computing components) can work unattended, then a satellite working as a server could too.
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by vagab0nd on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @10:10AM (#46871928)
You are right. But in the future we'll be refueling the satellites anyway. Might as well maintain the servers using robots all in one go.
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by SilverElfin on Tuesday February 03, 2026 @02:54PM (#46876335)
Right now that’s not the case. Satellites just store whatever fuel they need for orbital adjustments and by default, they fall back to earth and burn up at the end of their life. All the Starlink satellites are configured to fall back to earth within 5 years (the fuel is used to re-raise their orbit). The new proposed datacenters would sit in a higher orbit to avoid debris, allegedly, but that means it is even more expensive to get to them and refuel them, and the potential for future debris is far worse (since it wouldn’t fall back to earth and burn up for centuries or millennia).
Re:xAI joins SpaceX by lugao on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @07:41AM (#46885149)
I did some more reading and want to walk back my skepticism a bit. There is actually serious effort going into this, such as Google’s research on space-based AI infrastructure: https://research.google/blog/exploring-a-space-based-scalabl...

They highlight the exact reliability constraint I was thinking of: that replacing failed TPUs is trivial on Earth but impossible in space. Their solution is redundant provisioning, which moves the problem from "operationally impossible" to "extremely expensive."

You would effectively need custom, super-redundant motherboards designed to bypass dead chips rather than replace them. The paper also tackles the interconnect problem using specialized optics to sustain high bitrates, which is fascinating but seems incredibly difficult to pull off given that the constellation topology changes constantly. It might be possible, but the resulting hardware would look nothing like a regular datacenter.

Also this would require lots of satelites to rival a regular DC which is also very hard to justify. Let's see what the promised 2027 tests will reveal.