News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by SilverElfin on Friday January 30, 2026 @05:20PM (#46830737)
Taxing bullion is absurd - it’s not a product but more like currency or a placeholder of money you already have. What other taxes are they passing when you say “frenzy”?
Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by jfengel on Friday January 30, 2026 @05:25PM (#46830799)
Why is it more like a currency than any other object? It's not negotiable currency or legal tender.

People buy it and sell it. I don't see any difference between bullion, iron ore, frozen concentrated orange juice, and Pokemon cards. You buy a thing, you pay the sales tax.

Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by its_ethan on Friday January 30, 2026 @05:46PM (#46831008)
Well it's more like a currency than any other object because it has been used historically to either a) be the currency, or b) back the currency. Sure that's not true today in the United States, but like, it's obviously different than frozen concentrated orange juice... can we not at least agree on that pretty tame assumption? Or is this just some semantics race to non-meaning?

Iron ore is similar physically, but it's really just a raw input material/ingredient used for heavy industrial manufacturing and production, it's never been intended to be an appreciating asset/hedge against inflation.

I'm unfamiliar with whatever tax is being referred to in this specific comment thread, but I'd be curious how something like $SIVR is handled, considering it's backed by actual silver in vaults. That could lead to some unintended consequences if the investment plans of a lot of money suddenly changes how it's being allocated.

Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by quickthrowman on Friday January 30, 2026 @06:42PM (#46831548)
> Iron ore is similar physically, but it's really just a raw input material/ingredient used for heavy industrial manufacturing and production, it's never been intended to be an appreciating asset/hedge against inflation, not any intrinsic property of gold itself.

Gold is not intended to be an asset/hedge against inflation either. Market participants believe that gold has value and that it can hedge against inflation. The belief is what gives life to gold being as a hedge against inflation.

Gold is not an asset, it’s a commodity, an industrial input, and material for jewelry, and for some reason I fail to understand, people buy and hold it because they believe it is an asset that will appreciate in value, but it’s just an elementary metal that is useful for being easy to work with (jewelry) and because it doesn’t oxidize. It does not generate income, you can’t eat it, and in a post-apocalyptic scenario, it’s useless. I suppose the density of gold would allow some very small, very high mass slingshot balls you could defend yourself against people with?

Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by jazzyjackson on Friday January 30, 2026 @07:14PM (#46831800)
A system is what it does, and gold is popular for jewelry because it’s a useful way to wear money.

Off topic and this might be apocryphal, but I heard on the internet a good reason to keep “money” in the form of gold chains and other jewelry, is that it counts as personal property, so if you’re arrested during a drug bust or trafficking women, your cash and bank accounts may be seized, but whatever you wear to prison gets put in a ziplock bag and returned to you when you leave :)

Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by robotresearcher on Friday January 30, 2026 @05:38PM (#46830936)
Gold hasn't been money since 1971.
Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by 15155 on Friday January 30, 2026 @05:32PM (#46830879)
Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by dmos62 on Friday January 30, 2026 @05:26PM (#46830805)
Is taxing investment absurd?
Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by pfannkuchen on Friday January 30, 2026 @05:46PM (#46831014)
This investment is now taxed more than other types of investment. Is sales tax charged when you buy stock? Should it be?
Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by kyboren on Friday January 30, 2026 @05:32PM (#46830873)
"Tax what you want less of."

Do you want less investment?

Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by ahtihn on Friday January 30, 2026 @05:48PM (#46831030)
Why would you want to encourage investment in gold?
Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by lostlogin on Friday January 30, 2026 @08:02PM (#46832178)
> Tax what you want less of.

How do you apply this to housing?

You want investment in housing. You don’t want slumlords ramping up prices for slums. Presumably somewhere has got the balance correct. I haven’t been to that place.

Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by lazylizard on Monday February 02, 2026 @09:39PM (#46865736)
u can not-tax the first property...
Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by roenxi on Saturday January 31, 2026 @04:36AM (#46834991)
Because we need a low risk system to track whether people are net-contributing or -draining society's resources, otherwise it isn't easy to tell who is creating more wealth so they can be supported. Gold remains the best option after centuries (if not millennia) of experimentation.
Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by mapontosevenths on Friday January 30, 2026 @05:43PM (#46830985)
Gold is not an investment. It takes otherwise productive capital out of the economy and produces nothing. It's functionally no different than stuffing your money in a mattress.
Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by kajecounterhack on Friday January 30, 2026 @05:49PM (#46831036)
It has utility though: unlike the dollars in your mattress, it can't be printed into oblivion by your central bank. It is relatively portable, and people have flocked to it as a store of value especially during periods of socioeconomic instability when assets are going down and gov't spending is going up. It's tradeable for fiat in any country, so it allows you to bring value along if you relocate.

Its price reflects that utility and like any modern asset, a lot of speculation. You can speculate on whether it's more or less useful given current events -- nothing wrong with speculating that it is only going to be increasingly useful.

Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by mapontosevenths on Friday January 30, 2026 @06:04PM (#46831186)
You're right that it has utility, but being fungible doesnt imply that it is automatically an investment.

Speculation is not the same as investment, and it is still completely non-productive.

Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by kajecounterhack on Friday January 30, 2026 @06:21PM (#46831359)
Agree it doesn't generate wealth. It's explicitly a store of wealth.

Investment is a weird term because most people would consider keeping cash or cash equivalents (gold) to be investments, even if they don't generate wealth. Cash is also an opinion, in terms of the market.

Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by michaelmrose on Friday January 30, 2026 @06:46PM (#46831585)
An investment creates a return
Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by fuzzfactor on Friday January 30, 2026 @09:59PM (#46832930)
Roger, sometimes positive, sometimes negative.
Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by its_ethan on Friday January 30, 2026 @06:05PM (#46831193)
What is it that you're arguing for then? That there be some entity that gets to decide what is and isn't a productive use of all of our excess money? Who gets to decide what's excess? Who gets to decide what is and isn't a productive use of the money?

How is this any different than buying a house? Buying a house that's already been built is pretty damn close to the same thing as buying gold. No new "work" is being done into the economy, you're just exchanging dollars for an asset that will likely appreciate a bit faster than inflation but less than $SPY.

The person you bought it from can do something else with that money, sure, but that's also true of the other person in your transaction to buy gold.

Maybe you'll say a house has more utility than bars of gold, but all of this at the end of the day, seems to come down to your specific views and judgements of what it means for capital to be used productively. So to circle back to the beginning, what is it you're advocating for here? That because you don't see gold as a low risk hedge against inflation as being "productive" it should face more taxes to incentivize it not happening?

Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by freedomben on Friday January 30, 2026 @06:46PM (#46831579)
> Buying a house that's already been built is pretty damn close to the same thing as buying gold. No new "work" is being done into the economy, you're just exchanging dollars for an asset that will likely appreciate a bit faster than inflation but less than $SPY.

I mostly agree with you, but I don't think the house comparison is good. Houses require lots of maintenance, and to hold their value (comparable to other houses) they often need remodeling every decade or so. If instead of houses we just said "land" then I think the comparison would hold up more.

Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by mapontosevenths on Friday January 30, 2026 @06:22PM (#46831365)
No, im not arguing that it should be illegal. Im just saying, as Warren Buffet before me did, that its not an investment.

It relies on the greater fool theory to produce excess returns. It is bad for the economy when money idles in non productive speculative assets.

Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by amanaplanacanal on Friday January 30, 2026 @06:35PM (#46831497)
The money didn't disappear, it just changed hands.
Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by mapontosevenths on Friday January 30, 2026 @07:29PM (#46831898)
You are forgetting the opportunity cost. The gold does not generate wealth it just stores value, like a mattress stuffed with bills. It has become a dead, stagnant, and unproductive thing and by doing that it has removed value from the overall economy that was previously there.
Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by amanaplanacanal on Friday January 30, 2026 @08:59PM (#46832573)
How? The money that was used to buy it is now in the hands of somebody else that can invest it. Nothing was lost. It just changed hands.
Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by mapontosevenths on Saturday January 31, 2026 @01:33AM (#46834054)
There are two sides to every transaction.

In this case 1/2 of the trade is a dead end. In another hypothetical transaction we might see that the money was instead used to pay for services, and that profit was then spent on food, and then it was spent on fertilizer, and then it was spent on chemicals, and then it was spent on mining, and then it was spent on energy, and then it was invested in.... You get the idea. You can follow a single dollar around the world for years. The money is exchanged, and then exchanged again and again generating profits and adding value to the economy with every exchange.

With the purchase of gold that half of the transaction is instead just... dead. The money is no longer in the economy, it's locked in some dudes junk drawer or a safe instead. Worse, it's not being used to generate excess returns like all of the items above are.

Gold is just... useless. Except of course as a store of value, but even then it's only good if you think the dollars value will decrease and don't care that it's not great for the world around you to extract money from the economy and render it effectively dead.

Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by amanaplanacanal on Saturday January 31, 2026 @10:21AM (#46837421)
So before, person A has the dead thing, and after, person B has the dead thing. The result for the economy is exactly the same as if the transaction didn't occur, except the people have switched places.
Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by mapontosevenths on Sunday February 01, 2026 @02:31PM (#46848641)
In economics this is often referred to as a "sterile asset". Buffet called it an "unprodcutive asset". The terms "Zero Coupon" or "Non Yielding Asset" might also apply. You should be able to google any of them to learn more about why they're not good for the economy or for the 'investor'.

The TLDR being that the money exchanged for that useless rock is now wasted. It could have been used to provide genuine economic value, instead it was used to participate in another silly, wasteful, "greater fool" game.

Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by michaelmrose on Friday January 30, 2026 @06:45PM (#46831572)
You either maintain the house for others use and extract rent or live in it. This is productive.

If you are hoarding an unused house we should heavily tax that to make it unreasonable to do so.

Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by quickthrowman on Friday January 30, 2026 @06:47PM (#46831589)
In physical metals that don’t generate income or induce further economic activity, I don’t believe so. What good does a hunk of gold sitting in a safe do for the economy?
Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by fuzzfactor on Friday January 30, 2026 @10:07PM (#46832960)
>What good does a hunk of gold sitting in a safe do for the economy?

Not a whole lot once legal tender certificates can no longer be redeemed for the same amount of metal year after year.

Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by loglog on Friday January 30, 2026 @06:17PM (#46831320)
Wealth tax is the best type of tax, because it incentivizes productive activities against speculation. It should be levied on a continuous basis rather than on transaction basis though, which is just basic numerical analysis.
Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by fuzzfactor on Friday January 30, 2026 @10:41PM (#46833187)
Not my downvote, but the least devastating tax is only on commerce, and it has to be at insignificant levels to keep from resuting in undue damage.

Taxing wealth, property, wage income, or just plain existence has always sapped productivity like few other things.

It's foolish to try and tax "wealth" when you should instead be taxing the creation of wealth as it's in progress and nothing else. When actual ongoing business operations are going forward is the only time anybody can truly afford to pay any significant tax at all. Even if they are billionaires, and I say this as someone at the complete opposite end of the spectrum.

Ordinary wage income doesn't even make sense to tax whatsoever when you want max productivity, unless income is excessive enough to reach so far above average that greater capitalist profits can be earned on the surplus. Then maybe more than just those gains should be taxed.

Re:Silver plunges 30% in worst day since 1980, gold tumbles by WalterBright on Friday January 30, 2026 @11:02PM (#46833311)
> What other taxes are they passing when you say “frenzy”?

https://www.ballardspahr.com/insights/alerts-and-articles/20...

It's incomplete, it doesn't list the gold tax.