News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by w1ntermute on Sunday October 14, 2012 @11:43PM (#4653657)
> Militant Islam scares the crap out of the West, and we're willing to pass laws and endure a certain level of self-censorship to avoid provoking violence out of these people.

This is such a stupid strategy. The right thing to do is to look at the root cause of all this. After all, there are lots of angry people all across the world that hate the Western world and want to hurt it, but most can't. What sets the Arabs apart is their vast oil riches. Without that, they wouldn't have the money or power to do anything to the West.

If you want to fight militant Islam, the first thing to do is to limit immigration from those countries and spread the immigrants out to force assimilation. The second thing to do is to invest as much money as possible into developing domestic energy sources, as well as alternatives to crude oil. The minute that crude oil loses its relevance to the Western world, the Arabs will just go back to what they were before - a bunch of desert nomads with no real power.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by potatolicious on Monday October 15, 2012 @02:29AM (#4653993)
> "If you want to fight militant Islam, the first thing to do is to limit immigration from those countries and spread the immigrants out to force assimilation."

It would work, but is not very different from banning all white people in order to shut down the KKK.

The proportion of Arabs to radical Islamic fundamentalists is so small that it really, really wouldn't make sense. That's a lot of baby for very little bath water.

I'm not sure if your comment is meant to be hand-waving theorizing-out-loud or if you're actually serious - if you're serious, I'd hold your post up as one of the reasons why people despise America so much. You paint with a broad brush, advocate irrational fear-based decision making not supported by your own numbers, and demonstrate a tremendous amount of racial and cultural ignorance (desert nomads? seriously?)

[edit] I've noticed that all of the posts here pointing out the racism in w1ntermute's post are getting downvoted. Normally I don't point out downvotes, but this in particular seems especially cowardly. Would the responsible party please get out from under that rock and explain why you feel the need to, without justification, silence everyone who has expressed this?

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by w1ntermute on Monday October 15, 2012 @02:53AM (#4654023)
> It would work, but is not very different from banning all white people in order to shut down the KKK.

There's a big difference in that those white people are already in America, and getting rid of them would be impossible. Note that I'm talking about implementing stricter immigration policies going forward, not getting rid of people who are already here.

> The proportion of Arabs to radical Islamic fundamentalists is so small that it really, really wouldn't make sense. That's a lot of baby for very little bath water.

To be honest, this whole Muslim immigration issue is more applicable to Europe than it is to America. America has (fortunately) maintained much stricter immigration policies than much of Europe, and the latter has consequently suffered from large swathes of Arab/Muslim immigrants failing to properly integrate into mainstream society. I'd say America has done quite well in comparison when it comes to assimilating Arab immigrants (although it has failed quite miserably so far when it comes to Hispanic and African Americans).

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by potatolicious on Monday October 15, 2012 @03:08AM (#4654052)
> "(although it has failed quite miserably so far when it comes to Hispanic and African Americans)."

I wouldn't exactly describe African Americans as immigrants per se... It seems to imply a level of volunteerism that simply wasn't there.

Anyways, that's a nitpick.

> "Note that I'm talking about implementing stricter immigration policies going forward, not getting rid of people who are already here."

Right, but how do you know there aren't any bad apples in the people who are already here?

Also bear in mind that of all Muslim terrorists who have committed an act of terrorism on American soil, many were visitors to the US, not immigrants. Do you believe we should also restrict Muslim visitation of the USA?

How many more extremists do you think we will create within the existing Muslim population if we essentially had a big "Muslims go home" sign at every border checkpoint? What would it to do in terms of our desire to assimilate these immigrants?

Your idea is fun to think about, but IMO it's not realistic. There are too many moving pieces for "no more Muslims in the US" to be a realistic policy choice.

Not to mention the costs would be rather high. Go to any of the top US schools and look at both the grad student and professor rosters, count the people of Middle Eastern decent or of Muslim faith. These are all huge wins for American society - both in talent addition and talent denial to rival regimes. Do you really want all of these people to, say, go work for the Chinese? Or Iran?

US hegemony is ensured in large (and put large in big screaming rainbow marquee letters) part by talent acquisition. We took much of Europe's best scientific talent after WW2, and we continued mopping up all the smartest and most talented people from all over the globe - Japan, China, India, the whole Eastern Bloc, and beyond. The US's lead over everyone else is economic and technological - leaving a whole swathe of educated immigrants on the table seems to go very firmly against this model. Slamming the door shut on immigration would be like starving yourself so you don't have to poop - it would work, but why?

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by w1ntermute on Monday October 15, 2012 @09:43AM (#4654988)
> Right, but how do you know there aren't any bad apples in the people who are already here?

Part of ICE's job is to deport any foreign nationals who are a danger to the country, and I think this would be acceptable action. For example, ICE failed to detect and deport/imprison the 9/11 attackers before 9/11, even though they were in the US legally.

> Also bear in mind that of all Muslim terrorists who have committed an act of terrorism on American soil, many were visitors to the US, not immigrants. Do you believe we should also restrict Muslim visitation of the USA?

Restrictions should have nothing to do with religion. It's a matter of doing the proper legwork to ensure that those who are a danger to the country, Muslim or otherwise, are not allowed in.

> Your idea is fun to think about, but IMO it's not realistic. There are too many moving pieces for "no more Muslims in the US" to be a realistic policy choice.

You're attempting to use reductio ad absurdum. I never suggested that there shouldn't be any more Muslims in the US.

> Go to any of the top US schools and look at both the grad student and professor rosters, count the people of Middle Eastern decent or of Muslim faith. These are all huge wins for American society - both in talent addition and talent denial to rival regimes. Do you really want all of these people to, say, go work for the Chinese? Or Iran?

Strawman. I never suggested that educated people with a significant contribution to make to the country shouldn't be allowed in. My statement was mostly applicable to Europe actually, where they allowed in a lot of poor and uneducated Muslims who ended up living in Muslim ghettos and failing to assimilate into mainstream European society. They're now well known for killing their daughters for talking with a guy not related to them and keeping them from getting a higher education.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by white_devil on Monday October 15, 2012 @05:15AM (#4654300)
Europe certainly does have a problem with Muslim immigration.

We've been tolerating and understanding the fuck out of them too, but that doesn't seem to have helped at all. They're massively over-represented in crime statistics.

There are talented people everywhere, but you won't find all that many Western people who killed their own daughters for showing too much skin.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by _delirium on Monday October 15, 2012 @08:58AM (#4654838)
I moved to Europe somewhat recently, and I haven't seen any tolerance or understanding: people are incredibly racist towards anyone with non-white skin, and it's socially acceptable to make snide comments about race in polite society. The U.S. (where I come from) is not exactly a pinnacle of race relations, but I was shocked by how much worse it is in Europe. There was a professor in my department of Bangladeshi heritage, and she got all sorts of weird comments. And as a CS professor, she was obviously not going about committing crimes, but rather writing research papers, but this didn't seem to matter to people.

In Denmark, at least, there's also this inaccurate perception, like what you mention, that immigrants are causing all the violence. But here we have basically two main sources of violence: biker gangs, who are mostly white, and immigrant gangs, who are mostly not. The kinds of people who vote Danske Folkeparti and are really worried about crime never seem to mention the biker gangs. Same in the UK: a huge amount of crime in the UK is caused by lower-class whites, the group sometimes derogatorily termed "chavs", and overlapping with "hooligan" culture. But you don't see the BNP complaining about them. Why? Because that's where their own members come from.

Some of my family is Greek, and there is no real tolerance there either, except from a smallish segment of left-wing internationalists. There are 2nd-generation Chinese-origin Greeks who speak perfect Greek and are generally integrated, but are still called racist names and considered "foreigners" by the Greeks who have a very ethnic view of Greekness (the majority).

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by white_devil on Monday October 15, 2012 @12:45PM (#4655866)
I moved to Europe somewhat recently, and I haven't seen any tolerance or understanding: people are incredibly racist towards anyone with non-white skin, and it's socially acceptable to make snide comments about race in polite society.

Oh? At least in Finland, the situation is actually the exact opposite of that. As far as I know, the same applies all over Scandinavia and Central Europe.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by _delirium on Monday October 15, 2012 @01:23PM (#4656066)
Weirdly, I was just in Finland two weeks ago, and the first person who randomly approached me and my Finnish friend in a bar in Turku was some drunk guy ranting about immigrants, who wouldn't leave us alone! We thought pretending neither of us could speak Finnish would solve the problem, but it didn't. My friend enjoyed provoking him in English while pretending not to be Finnish, though. They had some kind of argument about "True Finns", and about Janne Holmén.

In Copenhagen I would say things aren't too bad, but I wouldn't call it a great degree of tolerance or understanding, more "tolerance" in the sense of "will grit my teeth and tolerate you". Outside Copenhagen, things get progressively worse. And the government doesn't treat the religions equally: the Church of Scientology, of all things, got permission to build a church in Copenhagen, but the government is still holding up construction of a mosque.

And Central Europe? It's no fun at all, and possibly physically unsafe, to be Pakistani or black in Poland...

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by white_devil on Tuesday October 16, 2012 @04:21AM (#4658861)
You know, the word "immigrant" (="maahanmuuttaja" in Finnish) has basically become code for "Somali immigrant". If someone is complaining about immigrants, he means Somalis, and yes, he has good reason to complain.
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by _delirium on Thursday October 18, 2012 @09:27PM (#4671887)
From what I can find, there are very few Somali immigrants in Finland. Approximately 10,000, so about 0.2% of the population. How is this a problem?

In addition, the statistics indicate that Somalis are crime victims much more often than they're perpetrators, mostly due to the high prevalence of hate crimes perpetrated by young white men. See: http://www.poliisiammattikorkeakoulu.fi/poliisi/poliisioppil...

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by white_devil on Saturday October 20, 2012 @08:05AM (#4676882)
Without reading too far into that, it looks like total bullshit. The central theme seems to be "hate crimes".. What the fuck is a "hate crime", exactly? Why are Finnish policemen lectured about "hate crime" in English?

This looks like government propaganda, basically. Sure, some Finns are genuinely racist, but the overwhelming majority of people here are very tolerant and sensitive about "offending" any immigrant group (as long as they're black, of course).

Before you shout at me for being racist, take a look at my conversation with potatolicious: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4654794

Quite frankly, the article you linked to looks disgusting to me. Like some "perception shaping campaign" with the aim of sensitivizing the police force to "hate crime".

All this hysteria about "racism", defined roughly as: "pointing out any facets of reality that reflect negatively on any non-white (preferably black) people", could well be meant to stifle freedom of speech. It's working too, because most sheeple in Finland are very strict about not saying anything negative about Somalis, for example, even though there's good reason to.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by randomchars on Monday October 15, 2012 @08:45AM (#4654794)

    > They're massively over-represented in crime statistics.
Can you show data?
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by white_devil on Monday October 15, 2012 @11:28AM (#4655459)
Sure.

First, note that there are roughly three times as many Russians in Finland as there are Somalis:

http://www.stat.fi/til/vaerak/2011/vaerak_2011_2012-03-16_ku...

Then, look at this: http://www.stat.fi/til/polrik/2011/polrik_2011_2012-04-02_ta...

Unfortunately that's only in Finnish, but here are some key words:

  - "Suomen kansalaiset" = "Finnish citizens".
  - "Venäjä, entinen Neuvostoliitto" = "Russia, former Soviet  Union"
  - "Raiskausrikokset" = "Rape (-crimes)"
Then, take the year 2011 for example.

2011

  - Total number of rapes: 644
  - Total number of rapes committed by Finns: 474	
  - Total number of rapes committed by all foreigners: 170
  - Total number of rapes committed by Estonians: 15
  - Total number of rapes committed by *Russians*: 3
  - Total number of rapes committed by Swedes: 3
  - Total number of rapes committed by *Other Foreigners: 149*
Other than Estonians and Russians, there were 13 other language groups listed.

Let's be "generous" and assume they account for 3 rapes each, much like Russians and Swedes, even though they're much smaller minorities so the numbers are probably much lower.

That leaves us with 110 rapes committed by Somalis. Now I'm no statistician, and not very good at math either. But when Somalis outnumber a much larger minority in rape statistics 110 to 3, it seems that they're pretty fucking Rapey.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by potatolicious on Monday October 15, 2012 @05:32PM (#4657261)
Woah woah woah. Slow down there, you're trying to take a flying leap across a giant statistical chasm.

The logic here is so bad I'm not sure where to start.

There's a very bad assumption here, which is that the "other foreigners" category contains only the 13 groups listed, and that membership in none of the others implies membership in the Somalis group.

In other words, what you're saying is, in government statistics re: rape, everyone in the "other nationality" category is Somali unless they can be attributed to 12 other ethnic groups. This seems specious at best, horrifying twisting of fact at worst.

Do you have any evidence that this is what the data says? Or are you reading this out of the data due to your own preexisting prejudices? I'm starting to see what _delirium is describing re: European racism.

In other news, there are 100 cars in the parking lot outside. There are 2 Toyotas, 3 Hondas, and 95 "other" cars. Clearly these 95 cars are Fords.

[edit] Also need to address this:

> "Let's be "generous" and assume they account for 3 rapes each, much like Russians and Swedes, even though they're much smaller minorities so the numbers are probably much lower."

You can't do this with stats and still claim to remain impartial, or correct. You're trying to use numbers to give legitimacy to your claims, yet right in the middle of the argument you inject huge assumptions with no attempt at even making an educated guess.

The moment the words "probably" and "let's be generous" come out of your mouth re: statistics, your numbers have lost almost all meaning. When you're trying to justify incredibly racist views, back of the napkin calculations do not cut it.

Let me be frank: GP was skeptical of your claims and asked for substantiation, you have provided numbers that in no way substantiates your claims, and are incredibly vague and full of bad assumptions made in bad faith.

I rarely accuse people directly on these forums. You sir, are racist. For the sake of all of us, please re-evaluate your views.

Understanding and tolerating them my ass.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by white_devil on Tuesday October 16, 2012 @04:14AM (#4658852)
Well, this is certainly an uphill battle..

As I said, I'm no statistician. I can't do science, and I can't do statistics. But that doesn't matter with regard to what I was pointing out.

There's a very bad assumption here, which is that the "other foreigners" category contains only the 13 groups listed, and that membership in none of the others implies membership in the Somalis group.

Assuming I'm not even pretending to "do statistics" (as a science), and that I'm not even trying to be "rigorous" about it, why is that a bad assumption?

Why would it not be reasonable to assume that if a minority is not on that list, it's an insignificant one?

Why would membership in none of the others not imply membership in the Somalis group?

Again, there's no need to be rigorous here. It's actually common knowledge here in Finland that Somalis rape a lot of women, but I felt like I should point to some statistics instead of just making that claim right away. Otherwise a cold reception like this would have been guaranteed.

It's common knowledge in Sweden too, by the way. In Germany, it's the Turks, and in the Netherlands, it's Moroccans.

There are people who are aware of reality, and then there are Sheeple, and for whatever reason, the media here (and afaik, all over the countries affected by Muslim immigration) has been systematically covering up the fact that the perpetrators of lots of crimes are, in fact Somalis, and not Finns.

Whenever there's news of a gang-rape, they always say it's was a bunch of "younglings" (="nuorukaiset" in Finnish, "ungdomar" in Swedish, "youth" in English news). Without any mention of the ethnicity, the reader will just assume it was locals who did it. Actually, I'm surprised they even publish statistics like those I pointed to.

Seriously. How rare is gang-rape among Western men? It's pretty fucking rare. But there have been lots of incidents in Finland in the past years. Does it make sense to assume that Finns have suddenly gotten all gang-rapey?

In other news, there are 100 cars in the parking lot outside. There are 2 Toyotas, 3 Hondas, and 95 "other" cars. Clearly these 95 cars are Fords.

Well, if we know that those 100 cars consist of Toyotas, Hondas, and Fords, and that 2 are Toyotas and 3 are Hondas, what does that leave us with for the 95 "Others"?

You can't do this with stats and still claim to remain impartial, or correct.

Again, I never claimed to be rigorous with my stats. That's just an assumption by you.

The moment the words "probably" and "let's be generous" come out of your mouth re: statistics, your numbers have lost almost all meaning. When you're trying to justify incredibly racist views, back of the napkin calculations do not cut it.

Again, not rigorous. Besides, there was no need to be rigorous. The conclusion is very clear even with a large error margin. Even 110 to 3 is a massive difference, but as I pointed out, it's reasonable to assume that the smallest minorities don't actually count for 3 rapes each, but less.

I rarely accuse people directly on these forums. You sir, are racist. For the sake of all of us, please re-evaluate your views.

I can see how you'd reach that conclusion, especially since it was what you wanted to conclude all along. But really, Europe does have a Muslim immigration problem. There's no problem with Chinese immigrants, or Western ones, or anyone who comes in and adapts and doesn't cause trouble.

But there sure as hell is a problem with Somalis, in both Finland and Sweden. We're all brainwashed by our Western cultures in to viewing the world through rose-colored glasses, but that's not what reality is like.

There are differences between races and cultures.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by potatolicious on Tuesday October 16, 2012 @10:08AM (#4659872)
> "As I said, I'm no statistician. I can't do science, and I can't do statistics. But that doesn't matter with regard to what I was pointing out."

It absolutely does. If you do not have the (sound, defensible) numbers to point it out, what you have are personal anecdotes, not evidence.

So in other words, you believe Somalis rape 34x more than the general population, but you don't actually have proof of it. The fact that you would readily believe that one group rapes a whole 34x more than another group, without skepticism or wanting to verify the facts, reveals a great deal about what you wish to believe.

I highly recommend reading up on statistics, and looking at more stats in general (and not just in relation to crime). When you see a stat like "group A commits crime THIRTY FOUR TIMES more than group B", your skepticism alarm needs to go off. It isn't impossible, but it's also so unlikely demographics-wise that it bears extreme skepticism and checking.

For example, if you look at the very worst neighborhoods in the very worst cities of the US and compare their crime rates to the very best urban areas, the crime rate difference is usually not more than 4-5x. THIRTY FOUR times is such an extreme outlier that frankly I'm shocked you were not skeptical about it.

> "Why would it not be reasonable to assume that if a minority is not on that list, it's an insignificant one?"

Because insignificant numbers accumulate. How many "other" nationalities do you think there exists in your country? There are 130+ countries in existence right now - even if they each contribute very little to your rape statistics, that's a lot of accumulated crime.

You cannot ignore variables unless you have very good reason to. No group can be claimed "insignificant" without reason, not if you want to be anywhere close to impartial and correct.

What you need is the real breakdown of the "others" category, not an inferred one subject to your own biases.

And here's a little riddle for you: if the stats here are organized by significance (see how significant contributing nationalities are separated out?), why aren't the Somalis separated out? You would think that a rate over 34x more than the general population, contributing to a huge portion of rapes in the country, would bear its own column, no?

Your reasoning is specious.

> "Why would membership in none of the others not imply membership in the Somalis group?"

Okay. I've tried to remain civil, but your ignorance and lack of knowledge is so poisonous, and supports a view so vicious, that I cannot.

NO. FOR THE LOVE OF FUCKING GOD READ A BOOK. Educate yourself before making stupid statements up like this.

Do you really believe that in the entire country of Finland there are only thirteen non-Finnish nationalities represented?

Here's a simpler example. There's a parking lot outside with 100 cars. 3 of them are Toyota, 2 of them are Honda, and 95 are "other". In the "other" category there are 5 Chryslers and 5 Fiats.

What you are saying is that this means we have 85 Fords - even though nothing in the data suggests that my breakdown of the "others" is even remotely close to comprehensive - you've assumed that, and conveniently forget that there are more car brands in the world than Toyota, Honda, Chrysler, Fiat, and Ford.

Do you start to understand?

> "It's actually common knowledge here in Finland that Somalis rape a lot of women"

Yet where is your proof? You have offered ZERO evidence. You would think that if Somalis really raped women at a rate OVER THIRTY TIMES the national average, that you can find some iota of evidence? You would think that this would appear as a distinct column in your stats - after all, it points out much smaller national groups!

This is nothing more than your own prejudice and the prejudice of people who share your "common knowledge".

> "It's common knowledge in Sweden too, by the way. In Germany, it's the Turks, and in the Netherlands, it's Moroccans."

This is depressing. You are so blatantly racist but somehow you don't see it for yourself.

What's next. It's common knowledge in Germany too, it's actually the Jews?

This sort of "common knowledge" that can't seem to be backed up by fact (and what you offered is so far from fact I'm not sure what to say) is the most blatant, vicious form of racism. This casual belief that "well of COURSE group A rapes 34x more than everyone else, everyone knows that", yet with no evidence of it. The willingness to believe shocking, mind-boggling things without seeking the slightest shred of proof!

This whole conversation is sickening.

> "There are people who are aware of reality, and then there are Sheeple"

Ahh, I see how this works now. You've chosen to believe something so outrageous that it staggers belief, with no proof whatsoever. The only way you can defend this position is if you convince yourself anyone who disagrees is controlled by the government/media and are "sheeple".

You sir, are the worst kind of racist.

> "Without any mention of the ethnicity, the reader will just assume it was locals who did it."

And you will assume it's Somalis, right? Do you see what you just did yourself?

> "Again, I never claimed to be rigorous with my stats. That's just an assumption by you."

THEN YOU HAVE NO PROOF OR EVIDENCE WHATSOEVER.

What you are saying: "I'm completely making up these numbers to support my world view, I've never claimed these numbers are correct. BUT LOOK AT THEM, THEY REVEAL THE TRUTH ABOUT THE SOMALIS"

So here's what you really must own up to: your beliefs are your own but they are not supported by evidence or reason. You are entitled to your beliefs, however wrong and racist they may be, but do not claim to have evidence for it unless you actually do.

I came into this reply thinking maybe I had you wrong, maybe this is just a gross miscommunication and exercise in statistical awfulness. But no, you are far more racist than I even suspected. For the love of God I hope we never meet.

Sweet merciful [insert all deities here]... You've just completely ruined my morning. You are by far the most racist person I've ever conversed with, and I've seen some racist shit on this side of the ocean. The fact that people like you exist makes me depressed.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by white_devil on Wednesday October 17, 2012 @09:54AM (#4664390)
You, sir, are an ENRAGED SHEEP, and as such, it's difficult to discuss reality with you when you're hell-bent on rejecting it.

> If you do not have the (sound, defensible) numbers to point it out, what you have are personal anecdotes, not evidence.

You're still stuck on the numbers, and the lack of "statistical rigor" in the way I used them. Fine, let's just forget about the numbers.

As I already mentioned, the fact of the matter is that every non-sheep Finn KNOWS that Somalis rape women. It's just the way it is. We KNOW that the media tries to cover up the fact that Somalis are most often the perpetrators in cases of rape. We KNOW that whenever a bunch of "Younglings" gang-raped a woman, it was Somalis.

What would you expect from a culture that considers women men's property? They believe that if a woman is showing too much skin, she's asking to get raped. I heard this first-hand from a Pakistani colleague I befriended back when I was still a sheep too. Not only that, but if she wants anyone to get convicted, she needs four pious Muslim MEN as witnesses for the rape, and if she goes to the police station to complain about getting raped, the police may just decide to rape her too, just for funzies (or because she's "filthy" or whatever the official, Islam-sanctioned excuse was). Yeah. Not every single goddamn time, but it does happen.

It's just obvious that Muslims are more rapey than your average white Westerner (or any other non-Muslim).

Now, at this point, feel free to howl about "painting with a broad brush" or how Not All Of Them (tm) rape women, and so on. Not ALL of them bury their daughters alive for showing too much skin. No, but it constitutes a noteworthy phenomenon, and the observation can be made that Muslims are a group of people who do that (to whatever relatively-small-but-nevertheless-fucking-insane extent it happens).

So in other words, you believe Somalis rape 34x more than the general population, but you don't actually have proof of it. The fact that you would readily believe that one group rapes a whole 34x more than another group, without skepticism or wanting to verify the facts, reveals a great deal about what you wish to believe.

Yes, I'm willing to believe a factor of 34. But even if my "estimate" is wrong by half, it's still a massive factor of 17. Would you believe I was off by half? Even if we discounted a huge mistake like being off by 50%, it would still leave a massive factor of over-representation.

Again, it's just a fact that they are more rapey than non-Muslims. I can't just whip out proof for that claim, because rapes by Somalis specifically are not listed (even though they are for those handful of other groups) in those statistics. Not only that, but the media censorship of Somali rapes kind of gets in the way of proving anything.

And here's a little riddle for you: if the stats here are organized by significance (see how significant contributing nationalities are separated out?), why aren't the Somalis separated out? You would think that a rate over 34x more than the general population, contributing to a huge portion of rapes in the country, would bear its own column, no?

Here's another right back at you: If our government instructs our media to cover up Somalis' crimes, do you think they'd just give us the statistics that would make them blindingly obvious?

Can I personally prove the censorship to you right now? No, not really. But I KNOW it happens. You can't hinge everything on proof that is - or would be - provided by a government. All governments lie to their little tax cows. You want proof of that? Well, you can't have it.

You know, I used to be an innocent, well-meaning sheep like you. I used to be quite enthusiastic about the idea that we're all equal and we're all "the same" and that we should all just live together in peace and harmony, but then, gradually, I was faced with Reality, and had to adjust my views on things. That's the thing. You need to be capable of adjusting your views on things whenever the need arises.

But it's in our nature as human beings to reject any changes, cling to our preconceived notions and dislike/resent anything that represents Otherness. Because of that, different races just aren't destined to get along. Saying that doesn't mean I hate black people just for being black, it means I'm aware of this particular aspect of reality.

> Do you really believe that in the entire country of Finland there are only thirteen non-Finnish nationalities represented?

How well do you know Finland? -Not particularly, obviously. Do you have any idea how homogenous our population still is? Before 1990, there weren't any Somalis here.

Even in 2011, the people who speak something other than Finnish or Swedish (or Lappish) comprised only 4.5% of the population: http://www.stat.fi/til/vaerak/2011/vaerak_2011_2012-03-16_ta...

So when the chart I originally posted says: "The largest groups by native language 2001 and 2011", there's no reason to interpret it as: "The largest groups by native language 2001 and 2011 (EXCEPT FOR LOTS OF OTHER PEOPLE WE LEFT OUT)"

Yet where is your proof? You have offered ZERO evidence. You would think that if Somalis really raped women at a rate OVER THIRTY TIMES the national average, that you can find some iota of evidence? You would think that this would appear as a distinct column in your stats - after all, it points out much smaller national groups!

You just keep yammering on and on about evidence.

Here's an idea: You should vote for Obama because he's The Good Guy, and Romney is The Bad Guy. You want The Good Guy to win, right?

Here's another: Your country's real, actual unemployment rate is 7.9%. (Do you think you can prove this by pointing to BLS statistics? --> http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EbfttPAj66k )

The massive bank bailouts and "stimulus" ever since 2008 have helped, and your economy is now on the path to prosperity!

Spain doesn't need a bailout! After all, Mr. Rajoy told us so!

You're free to believe all of that, but if you do, you are a clueless sheep. Most people in the world are, of course, and it's not your fault - you've been brainwashed into it, after all. But it is your mission, should you choose to accept it, to start seeing and accepting Reality for what it is.

Or, you could just keep on raging and bleating angrily at anyone who says anything that goes against your Rainbows & Unicorns view of the world.

By the way, here's another racial group in Finland that's a bit too active in the crime department: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Finnish_Kale#Perceived_violence... ..

> in 2005, persons of Romani background (who make up less than 0.2% of the total population of Finland[1]) perpetrated 18% of solved street robbery crimes in Finland

So a group of people that represents 0.2% of the population perpetrated 18% of the street robberies in Finland. Want proof of that? I haven't got any, but having lived all my life in Finland, it's very easy for me to believe it. This is a group of people that performs the vast majority of shoplifting too. I can't cite any statistics for that either, but I've personally seen them wander around a department store, just picking stuff up and putting it into their pockets. Want proof of that? Sorry, I don't have the security camera footage. But this is yet another thing that's common knowledge in Finland, and this time even Sheeple would agree, with a sheepish grin on their faces.

Now, here's something you should think about really fucking hard: Is it RACIST to point this stuff out? Or is it, you know, just.. describing Reality? But whenever someone describes a part of reality you're not comfortable with, you label them racist or whatever-ist and then proceed to rage at them.

> - by way of comparison, Somalis were responsible for 12%, while ethnic Finns were close to 51%.

Well well well, who do we have here? So Somalis commit 12% of all street robberies in Finland? But.. but.. they're such a lovely and upstanding group of model citizens! That simply CAN'T be true!

But no, you are far more racist than I even suspected. For the love of God I hope we never meet.

Ah, because then you'd just HAVE to beat me into a bloody pulp in the name of Justice! Right?

That's sweet. I hope we never meet too. Who knows, maybe I'm a filthy misogynist too, so beating me into a pulp just wouldn't suffice - you'd have to straight up kill me.

All in the name of Righteousness and Justice, of course. Killing me would be your civic duty as a Good Person.

You are by far the most racist person I've ever conversed with, and I've seen some racist shit on this side of the ocean. The fact that people like you exist makes me depressed.

Well, Mr. White Knight, you just might be the most enraged sheep I've ever conversed with. I guess that makes us even. You know, there are actually people on Hacker News that live in reality. Sometimes you even see them speak about it, and somehow miraculously not get downvoted into oblivion by a herd of enraged sheeple, so I thought some of that might have rubbed off on you. Apparently I was wrong.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by javajosh on Tuesday October 16, 2012 @02:46AM (#4658682)
Worst. Statistics. Interpretation. Ever.

You can't assume that other foreigners are somalis. It wouldn't make sense if they were either, because why would they single out estonians and russians, but not somalis?

This is a gross error that might fly on another board, but you are totally wrong, and a racist to boot! Downvoted.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by white_devil on Tuesday October 16, 2012 @04:42AM (#4658898)
Please refer to my lengthy reply to potatolicious.
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by simonh on Monday October 15, 2012 @03:44AM (#4654133)
Our current government here in the UK is doing this at the moment. They even revoked a university's license to accept foreign students on a technicality. We make a fortune out of foreign students and with our demographics need them far more than the US, but according to the Daily Mail reading grey brigade if we packed them all off home, all our troubles would be over. Because simplistic, sweeping, poorly thought out solutions to deep rooted cultural and economic issues always work out so well.
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by lmm on Monday October 15, 2012 @05:47AM (#4654350)
It wasn't a technicality. While the response may have been disproportionate, we're talking about brazen corruption from LMU; I have very little sympathy for them.
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by whyhellothere on Monday October 15, 2012 @06:02AM (#4654380)
That 'technicality'(1) was the universities lack of effective checks on students right to be in the UK, which they had 6 months to fix.

I don't disagree that foreign students bring a lot to this country, and that the handling of this thing by the government was extremely poor (2), but you're conflating two different issues in order to make a point about the Daily Mail.

It seems like you're guilty of the same simplistic arguments.

(1) http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-19419395

(2) http://www.guardian.co.uk/education/2012/aug/30/london-metro...

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by winter_blue on Monday October 15, 2012 @06:37AM (#4654466)
Wow, you're so incredibly racist and bigoted that it's sickening. I didn't expect the likes of you to be on HN.
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by anon1385 on Monday October 15, 2012 @07:50AM (#4654664)
Ha, do you actually regularly read HN? If you think the comments on this submission are bad I advise you don't go read the ones here from the other week http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4603611
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by guylhem on Monday October 15, 2012 @09:38AM (#4654974)
Sometimes it's not about racism but being practical - here, slowing down the progress of a dangerous ideology.

Take a parallel with communism and the Rosenberg execution. Many declared that as just plain barbary, antisemitism, etc. "Between the trial and the executions there were widespread protests and claims of antisemitism; the charges of antisemitism were widely believed abroad" (wikipedia)

But they were spies, and they gave secrets to help an enemy build atomic weapons.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Julius_and_Ethel_Rosenberg

Was this racism?

Sometimes big problems require hash actions. It might look like a bad move morally, but tactically it might be justifiable.

Example in hand - Quebec in Canada is selecting its own french speaking immigrants. After noticing on studies that immigrants from a specific part of the world were much more likely to be jobless or receiving public help, they discussed reducing the ratio of immigrants from this part of the world. The part of the world was north-Africa.

Is this racist? (while they keep welcoming immigrants from the rest of the world and north-Africa - but just adding a ratio)

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by justsee on Monday October 15, 2012 @01:28AM (#4653898)
Replace 'Western' and 'Arabs' with Superpower X and Subjugated peoples Y and it's immediately clear how defective your root cause analysis is.

It's an intentionally defective 'root cause analysis' from the perspective of Superpower X, where all wars waged by X on Y have no part in discussion of cause and effect.

The rules seem to be:

1. Y is always irrational, savage, subhuman.

2. X is always civilised, noble, well-meaning.

3. Aggression by X is always unfortunately necessary for some greater geopolitical good.

4. Aggression by Y must always be explained in terms of 1., and never as a result of 3.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by w1ntermute on Monday October 15, 2012 @01:56AM (#4653948)
I'm not looking at this from an impartial point of view, I'm looking at this as an American citizen who greatly enjoys the benefits of having been born in a developed nation with global hegemony.

I have no illusions about the various immoral and unethical acts committed by the US government over the last 50-75 (and probably more) years in various 3rd world countries in the name of American interests, nor do I think they are defensible from a moral/ethical perspective. I'm merely stating the simplest and most effective method of ensuring that the US's global hegemony remains as it is now.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by justsee on Monday October 15, 2012 @03:57AM (#4654153)
But failing to undertake a proper root cause analysis is harmful to your stated aims.

You appear to believe that a resurgent radical Islam is primarily due to the rise of wealthy Arab states, and yet these states are aligned to the West, armed by the West, and also suppress the same radical elements you wish to neutralize domestically.

A proper root cause analysis would reveal that violent military intervention coupled with Western political soundbites (which have a modern crusades theme to them) are the real factors responsible for radicalizing elements of Middle Eastern society.

Western and Middle Eastern political organizations with a religious base, radical pastors and imams, and military contractors seem to be the main beneficiaries in this culture war, and domestic citizens in the Middle East and the West seem to be the main losers.

Civil liberties are eroded domestically, a constant state of fear is generated domestically, and travel options internationally are limited. This applies to both Middle Eastern and Western domestic populations.

The simplest and most effective solution is, you say, to limit immigration and assimilate existing immigrants? Historically maybe it's been the 'simplest' approach, in terms of isolating and subjugating 'foreigners' (apart from slavery), but I wouldn't agree that it's been effective in neutralizing resistance to whatever was the hegemony of the age.

Instead I would look at the success of Western countries in cultivating an apathetic population as the counter-intuitive solution for a continued hegemony. Rising living standards, opportunity, and entertainment as distraction.

Look at how China invests in significant infrastructure in Africa to buy stability and access to natural resources. The idea of foreign aid is certainly not new, and the world is littered with US-funded roads and hospitals, but the ratio of destructive / constructive actions is completely the wrong way around.

Why not wage peace, allocate more of the loot to local populations so they see a significant rise in living standards, and cultivate a widening middle class that has less reasons to be sympathetic to radicals?

That seems to me a far more sophisticated approach to exerting and maintaining influence than the traditional "wage war" approach.

Your position seems to be a result of artful misdirection which paints militant Islam as the cause when in fact it is simply the effect of the militant West. It's the bitterest of ironies that the global Defence industry is in fact one of the greatest enemies of continued goodwill and peace for Western populations.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by iSnow on Monday October 15, 2012 @05:32AM (#4654324)
>A proper root cause analysis would reveal that violent military intervention coupled with Western political soundbites (which have a modern crusades theme to them) are the real factors responsible for radicalizing elements of Middle Eastern society.

Oh please. A proper root cause analysis is different from blaming everything on the West. It would have to include the idea that the current cultural clash is with an extremely violent religion as can be shown by its teachings. It would further investigate the influence of the division of church and state on the moderation of Christian beliefs and (in most countries) lack thereof in the Muslim world.

>Why not wage peace, allocate more of the loot to local populations so they see a significant rise in living standards, and cultivate a widening middle class that has less reasons to be sympathetic to radicals?

9/11 as the showcase of the clash between the West and radical Muslims was planned by a descendant of a rich Saudi family. There were not many poor and underprivileged amongst those plane hijackers.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by justsee on Monday October 15, 2012 @06:48AM (#4654486)
> Oh please. A proper root cause analysis is different from blaming everything on the West.

That's another rule I forgot to mention:

5. Anyone pointing out the clear history of repeated violent actions by X against Y shall be labelled a: Y sympathiser, "blame-the-X" bleeding-heart liberal, anti-X, etc

> It would have to include the idea that the current cultural clash is with an extremely violent religion as can be shown by its teachings.

You seem to hold a Western stereotype of Islam[1]. How can you accept this stereotype and at the same time bristle with indignation when someone points out that the West is a collection of extremely violent superpowers, as shown by the West's history of constant war and invasion?

What metrics do we use to calculate which 'side' is more violent? Number of people killed, and number of countries invaded? On that basis the West is clearly far more violent, isn't it?

> 9/11 as the showcase of the clash between the West and radical Muslims was planned by a descendant of a rich Saudi family. There were not many poor and underprivileged amongst those plane hijackers.

Injustice is oxygen for radicals at every strata of society, so my point is that if you serve your subjugated people more justice and less injustice, you are getting increased stability and security in return. It's a good trade for people like w1ntermute who are satisfied with their global status and not troubled by questions involving morality and ethics.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islam_and_violence#Western_ster...

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by iSnow on Monday October 15, 2012 @08:24AM (#4654737)
> Anyone pointing out the clear history of repeated violent actions by X against Y shall be labelled You are constructing a straw man here. YOU specifically stated that "that violent military intervention coupled with Western political soundbites [...] are the real factors responsible for radicalizing elements", so you ARE knocking the West for everything that happens. I did specifically not label you as anything of the above.

>What metrics do we use to calculate which 'side' is more violent? Number of people killed, and number of countries invaded? On that basis the West is clearly far more violent, isn't it? I don't think so. How many wars between democratic Western countries vs. between Muslim countries? I do recall Iraqis and Iranians happily gassing each other as late as the 1980s.

>Injustice is oxygen for radicals at every strata of society, so my point is that if you serve your subjugated people more justice and less injustice, you are getting increased stability and security in return. Sure, that's why Western secular countries win this contest hands down. Saudi Arabia is not a US colony, they have a home-grown Muslim theocracy. They are subjugated by their own sheiks and their religion.

The West does deserve blame for destroying traditional societies during the 19th century. BUT, those societies were far from peaceful - and contrary to a lot of Asian states, a big part of Africa and the Muslim world never changed their violent ways post-colonialism. The West deserves blame for nurturing dictators like Hussein and Ghaddafi, but it's the Muslim population that - even in more or less free election - votes Islamic radicals into office.

I for one are getting irritated and tired of proponents of a peaceful Islam blissfully ignorant of the realities of violence in Muslim societies and Muslim migrant culture. I don't get it why it is so hard to take at least some responsibility and try to improve things instead of always blaming the West. This is a loser's attitude.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by mercurial on Monday October 15, 2012 @09:27AM (#4654927)
> Oh please. A proper root cause analysis is different from blaming everything on the West. It would have to include the idea that the current cultural clash is with an extremely violent religion as can be shown by its teachings.

Christianity can be an extremely violent religion, as shown by its history, from the Crusades to the Thirty Years war. Not to mention the various non-religious genocides committed for the most part by "good christians". Most religions have enough internal contradiction that widely different interpretations arise. You have a world of difference between Salafists and Sufis, for instance.

Denying that at least a century of Western interference in the Middle East does not play a very significant role in this "culture war" is naive. Not to deny very different cultural standards between the West and the Middle East, but it's certainly not black and white.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by w1ntermute on Monday October 15, 2012 @09:33AM (#4654946)
You go on and on about Western intervention in the Middle East. My solution would eliminate Western intervention in the Middle East. Once we don't need crude oil, why would we even bother going there? There would be nothing of value. Wouldn't the Arabs be happy with that too?
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by mseebach2 on Monday October 15, 2012 @06:35AM (#4654459)
> You appear to believe that a resurgent radical Islam is primarily due to the rise of wealthy Arab states, and yet these states are aligned to the West, armed by the West, and also suppress the same radical elements you wish to neutralize domestically.

To add a touch of concreteness, according to "The Looming Tower: Al-Qaeda and the Road to 9/11" by Lawrence Wright (which I cannot recommend enough if you're interested in that bit of modern history), an explicit motivation of Osama bin Laden was the US's continued presence in Saudi Arabia (at the regime's express invitation). The book also contains an account of Hosni Mubarak's rather heavy handed suppression of radicals in Egypt, and how that motivated resistance (although focused on Egypt, they were co-opted by bin Laden).

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by justsee on Monday October 15, 2012 @07:07AM (#4654529)
In relation to recently-enriched Arab states, w1ntermute stated that: "Without that, they wouldn't have the money or power to do anything to the West". He appears to think that well-funded Arab states are directly supporting radical Islam - my response was directed at that wrong notion, because as you note those states are actively involved in suppression of radicals.

US backing of oppressive regimes in the region is certainly an injustice that fuels radicalization of citizens in those countries.

Thanks for the book recommendation, I'll have a look at it.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by olalonde on Monday October 15, 2012 @02:18AM (#4653986)
I would use some more empathy and adopt a bit more diplomatic attitude if I were you. There will be suicide bombers well after Arabs go back to being desert nomads. It's not all that expensive to blow yourself up.
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by _delirium on Monday October 15, 2012 @09:13AM (#4654872)
Heck, militia groups in the U.S. manage to mount occasional terrorist attacks, and they're generally quite poor. I don't think Timothy McVeigh raised too much funding.
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by w1ntermute on Monday October 15, 2012 @02:59AM (#4654033)
> It's not all that expensive to blow yourself up.

9/11 was estimated to have required ~$400-500k. And I'd say it'd be quite a bit more expensive to repeat that feat these days.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by natep on Monday October 15, 2012 @03:47AM (#4654139)
More than a few people have blown themselves up since 9/11.
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by smutticus on Monday October 15, 2012 @02:30AM (#4653997)
I don't know why you were downvoted. I found your explanation very rational.
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by mcantelon on Monday October 15, 2012 @01:55AM (#4653945)
>The second thing to do is to invest as much money as possible into developing domestic energy sources, as well as alternatives to crude oil

Folks in the West with stakes in maintaining the monopoly on oil as an energy source have a lot of power. They won't give up without a fight. The same Neocons that make a big show of decrying Islam to their base also chum around with Saudi Arabia, sucking up the royals.

>Arabs will just go back to what they were before - a bunch of desert nomads with no real power

Here's a nice summary of arab contributions to mathematics.

http://www.math.tamu.edu/~dallen/history/arab/arab.html

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by w1ntermute on Monday October 15, 2012 @01:58AM (#4653954)
> Folks in the West with stakes in maintaining the monopoly on oil as an energy source have a lot of power.

There are certainly people at home who have just as much of a vested interest in preserving the status quo, which is precisely why things haven't changed much at all despite the rise of militant Islam. It's upstarts like Elon Musk that are going to force the hand of Big Oil on this matter. But it will be a long & hard battle, one that may not be won for quite a while.

> Here's a nice summary of arab contributions to mathematics.

I don't see how mathematical contributions hundreds of years ago have any relevance to the modern world. We're talking about a time when the US as a country didn't even exist.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by mcantelon on Monday October 15, 2012 @02:16AM (#4653984)
>There are certainly people at home who have just as much of a vested interest in preserving the status quo, which is precisely why things haven't changed much at all despite the rise of militant Islam. It's upstarts like Elon Musk that are going to force the hand of Big Oil on this matter. But it will be a long & hard battle, one that may not be won for quite a while.

I'm guessing/hoping that Big Oil will be killed by grassroots innovation, open hardware designs that don't have companies behind them that can be bought out and their patented tech buried. If it's simply a matter of spending money or killing a few people to keep the gravy train going, they'll do it.

>I don't see how mathematical contributions hundreds of years ago have any relevance to the modern world. We're talking about a time when the US as a country didn't even exist.

True.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by patrickk on Monday October 15, 2012 @12:11PM (#4655690)
> I don't see how mathematical contributions hundreds of years ago have any relevance to the modern world.

Math is timeless unless it's mistaken.

...there’s an alternative math metaphor we might use: calculus. The calculus metaphor asks whether and how we can figure out exactly what’s going to happen. Take NASA and the Apollo missions, for instance. You have to figure out where the moon is going to be, exactly. You have to plan whether a rocket has enough fuel to reach it. And so on. The point is that no one would want to ride in a statistically, probabilistically-informed spaceship.

http://blakemasters.tumblr.com/post/20400301508/cs183class1

The origins of calculus can be traced to ancient times. Moon rockets. Let that sink in.

Elon Musk and anyone else who pushes that envelope must stand on the shoulders of the giants who came before him, including Arabic mathematicians (indirectly).

What about mathematics that are thousands of years old, i.e. geometry from the ancient Greeks? Buildings with architecture based on the golden ratio[1] are aesthetically very pleasing, e.g. Georgian architecture[2]. Far nicer and better proportioned than most of the shit that's hastily thrown up all over the world today.

Every time you fire up your computer, you're taking advantage of boolean algebra[3], first laid down in the 1850s by George Boole, which is critical to modern computer science.

Mathematical contributions from hundreds of years ago has an incredible amount of relevance to the modern world, in countless different ways.

I wish I knew more about the history of mathematics to counter you more forcefully.

I would also urge you to read this book: http://www.amazon.co.uk/Civilization-Killer-Apps-Western-Pow...

It shows how that in the 15th century, Europe was a shithole backwater, plagued by diseases and wars, and other civilisations like the Chinese and Arabic ones were far more advanced. By various accidents of history, the western world dominated the rest over the next 500 years. Some would argue that the wests' power is currently on the wane, and China is rising again.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_ratio

[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgian_architecture

[3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boolean_algebra

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by Volpe on Monday October 15, 2012 @09:24AM (#4654917)
I'm amazed at the hubris shown towards a civilisation that has existed far longer than your own.

Please reflect more on this. Your "solution" to this problem is just to oversimplify everything and solve these simple problems. A clear flag, that you lack the education to actually contribute something meaningful to the discussion.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by w1ntermute on Monday October 15, 2012 @09:38AM (#4654971)
> I'm amazed at the hubris shown towards a civilisation that has existed far longer than your own.

I don't understand why the age of a civilization should be a matter of pride. This is an entirely arbitrary point of distinction and has no real relevance to the conversation at hand.

> Your "solution" to this problem is just to oversimplify everything and solve these simple problems. A clear flag, that you lack the education to actually contribute something meaningful to the discussion.

And your inability to literal make any meaningful statements other than ad hominem attacks against me suggests that you need to go back to high school and study logic and debate.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by Volpe on Monday October 15, 2012 @09:49AM (#4655007)
> I don't understand why the age of a civilization should be a matter of pride. This is an entirely arbitrary point of distinction and has no real relevance to the conversation at hand.

> And your inability to literal make any meaningful statements other than ad hominem attacks against me suggests that you need to go back to high school and study logic and debate.

It is arrogant to assume a single countries path is correct vs a much older civilisation, given that single country has not stood the same test of time.

It was not intended as an ad hominem. Only that a meaningful debate could only be made with you, were you open to learning the full history and reasons behind the current problems. After reading your comments so far it is apparent you aren't open to learning these things. I'm sorry if you took offense.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by w1ntermute on Monday October 15, 2012 @11:07AM (#4655356)
> It is arrogant to assume a single countries path is correct vs a much older civilisation, given that single country has not stood the same test of time.

Once again, the point flew over your head. This has nothing to do with correctness, it has to do with maintaining America's global hegemony.

And Arab "civilization" is a tenuous concept. Many modern Arab countries didn't exist until less than a century ago. Given the horrific exploitation the Arab peoples suffered at the hands of Europeans, I'd say that their countries haven't withstood the test of time very well.

> Only that a meaningful debate could only be made with you, were you open to learning the full history and reasons behind the current problems. After reading your comments so far it is apparent you aren't open to learning these things.

The only thing that's apparent is that you're completely misunderstanding the purpose of my initial comment. It wasn't intended as a normative dismissal of Arab or Muslim culture, it was intended to be a suggested improvement of America's geopolitical current strategy.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by ucee054 on Monday October 15, 2012 @07:28PM (#4657645)
No, the point flew over your head.

The point is that America's global hegemony shouldn't be maintained.

Quite apart from the jackass immorality of it, maintaining hegemony implies indebting America to the point of economic collapse while generating more and more enemies.

The objective instead should be to maintain the quality of life of American citizens.

And there are all kinds of countries, from Japan to Switzerland to Norway to Slovenia, none of which attempt world domination, where citizens can live fine.

(Oh yeah, and as a result of not attempting world domination they also tend not to get attacked by terrorists.)

Many across the spectrum, from Dennis Kucinich to Stephen Walt to Ron Paul, have explained this better than I can here; if you are interested in the geopolitics I suggest you look them up.

Your points about history are equally preposterous. Just because modern middle eastern states are young it does not mean that middle eastern civilisation is young. By that logic, China and Greece are both younger than the USA.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by w1ntermute on Monday October 15, 2012 @08:55PM (#4657897)
> The point is that America's global hegemony shouldn't be maintained.

That's purely a matter of opinion, so there's no point in arguing about it. As a non-American, it's pretty obvious why/that you don't want America to be dominant. As an American, it's pretty obvious why I do.

> Quite apart from the jackass immorality of it, maintaining hegemony implies indebting America to the point of economic collapse while generating more and more enemies.

I don't think that's true at all. You don't need to spend billions of dollars on costly wars in order to keep yourself in control. You just have to render other people irrelevant, which is exactly what would happen to the Arabs if the world's dependence on crude oil were to vanish.

> The objective instead should be to maintain the quality of life of American citizens.

Which America's global power contributes to.

> And there are all kinds of countries, from Japan to Switzerland to Norway to Slovenia, none of which attempt world domination, where citizens can live fine.

And they pay the price for it - literally. Energy costs are much higher in Japan, for example. If I were living in Japan, I wouldn't be able to cool my entire house during the summer (or heat it during the winter). I've experienced it in Tokyo myself, and it's a significant degradation of quality of life.

> Many across the spectrum, from Dennis Kucinich to Stephen Walt to Ron Paul, have explained this better than I can here; if you are interested in the geopolitics I suggest you look them up.

I know exactly what they've expressed, and I agree with a lot of it. You're still missing my point, which is that you can achieve global hegemony and domination much more effectively through technological innovation that you can through military might.

> Your points about history are equally preposterous. Just because modern middle eastern states are young it does not mean that middle eastern civilisation is young. By that logic, China and Greece are both younger than the USA.

Once again, the age of the "civilization" is entirely irrelevant to modern geopolitical concerns. The age of the state, on the other hand, can at times demonstrate political stability/power.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by ucee054 on Tuesday October 16, 2012 @02:39AM (#4658676)
You would not render the middle east irrelevant by erasing the dependence on crude oil.

I personally think you could in fact be doing the middle east the biggest favour if you could make the global oil price drop to zero. At least to the people, if not the current rulers.

That's not what maintaining Hegemony means. Hegemony means Kicking other people around.

Did you mean something else, like Energy Independence? Or perhaps Being a world leader in science and technology?

And that's not the thrust of what you were referring to in your original post. You were talking about the INS screening people who look like me and not letting us into America.

Why that's a bad idea is a whole different can of worms, but basically Nazism is not an efficient security policy.

You have to put in place a whole lot of Nazism to get small gains in security.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by randomchars on Monday October 15, 2012 @09:04AM (#4654856)
> I don't see how mathematical contributions hundreds of years ago have any relevance to the modern world. We're talking about a time when the US as a country didn't even exist.

No math = No modern world. Got it?

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by w1ntermute on Monday October 15, 2012 @09:25AM (#4654922)
No, you're the one that still doesn't get it. Who invented algebra 1000 years ago is entirely irrelevant to modern geopolitics.
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by randomchars on Monday October 15, 2012 @09:47AM (#4655003)
It's not irrelevant. Without math we wouldn't have a modern society.

But if you insist that it's irrelevant than Arabs being desert nomads is irrelevant to modern geopolitics too.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by w1ntermute on Monday October 15, 2012 @11:11AM (#4655372)
Once again, my point flies right over your head.

> It's not irrelevant. Without math we wouldn't have a modern society.

Correct, but who made those discoveries has no relevance to modern geopolitical strategy.

> But if you insist that it's irrelevant than Arabs being desert nomads is irrelevant to modern geopolitics too.

I already stated how that fact is relevant, but you chose to ignore it. If the Arabs weren't desert nomads, they might be a credible threat to the US even without oil.

It seems that everyone here is taking offense at the fact that I called Arabs "desert nomads". The point I was trying to make is that without oil, the Arabs don't pose a threat to America.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by snambi on Monday October 15, 2012 @02:12AM (#4653973)
while talking about mathematics, please include this as well. Islamic conquest of India bloodiest in the history http://www.danielpipes.org/comments/32812

History may paint a different picture, but essentially its terrorism in its true form.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by mcantelon on Monday October 15, 2012 @02:20AM (#4653988)
Does Muslim violence negate arab achievement in mathematics? If so, does the US killing of native Americans negate US scientific achievement?
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by snambi on Monday October 15, 2012 @10:46AM (#4655260)
btw, many of the arab mathematics "innovation" is simply copied from India. Since, Europe found those through arabs, they were named as "arab" innovation. If they were so advanced 1000s of years ago, how come there is no one coming out of it now?
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by mcantelon on Monday October 15, 2012 @11:52AM (#4655593)
Adopting your line of thinking: if India, as you claim, is the originator of all this knowledge why is it not the current global leader of science and tech?
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by anon2012_786 on Sunday October 21, 2012 @03:22AM (#4679215)
That is good question. While indians are excelling in science and tech, India itself is not a leader in science and tech. India was never industrialized, So, even if innovation occurs, it never becomes part of the industrial-government machinery. That is the reason, I believe, indians who are interested in innovation, leave india.

India as a nation is very young. Even, the concept of india is very young. The only connecting fabric underlying india is its spiritually, beliefs and traditions ( Hindu/Vedic traditions ). Their lifestyle is very different from industrialized west or terror based middle east. India itself has two major kinds of people, city folks who are westernized and rural folks who are relatively non-westernized. depending on who you talk, you may get a different answer.

Anyway, this is great question. You should visit india to find it by yourself. It will be a journey worth taken. :)

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by intended on Monday October 15, 2012 @04:27AM (#4654221)
No it's not. Firstly you are talking about WAR. That's when armies of men, logistics and materiel are fired at each other.

Terrorism is assymmetric psychological warfare. It's done by forces who are extremely and utterly outclassed in strength.

You essentially are stretching the definition of terrorism so that you can use the hotter buzzword to demonize them and that period of Indian history.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by anon198263 on Monday October 15, 2012 @10:51AM (#4655287)
when 100s of barbarians surround a village populated with unarmed, un-prepared people and kill them all, do you call them war? No, It is not war. And it is not "terrorism" as well. Its worse than that, may be "genocide" is a better word. Today, the rest of the world is caught up with these barbarians, so their only option is "terrorism".
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by mcantelon on Wednesday October 17, 2012 @01:21PM (#4665499)
The word is "massacre".
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by paganel on Monday October 15, 2012 @04:37AM (#4654242)
> The minute that crude oil loses its relevance to the Western world, the Arabs will just go back to what they were before - a bunch of desert nomads with no real power.

Just as a general rule of thumb: not all Arabs are Muslims and not all Muslims are Arabs.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by JonnieCache on Monday October 15, 2012 @04:38AM (#4654245)
The minute that crude oil loses its relevance to the Western world, the Arabs will just go back to what they were before - a bunch of desert nomads with no real power.

You forgot the thousand years when they were inventing mathematics while your ancestors were living in mud huts covered in their own shit. Europe wasn't even capable of syllogism until they stole the knowledge back from the arabs.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by guard-of-terra on Monday October 15, 2012 @06:40AM (#4654474)
Why respect them for something they did a thousand years ago and then ceased to?
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by Ygg2 on Monday October 15, 2012 @08:37AM (#4654774)
Because it never ceased. If you ever used an algorithm or algebra you owe it to "those nomadic" Arabs.
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by guard-of-terra on Monday October 15, 2012 @08:38AM (#4654778)
How long do you think Gagarin will last?
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by Ygg2 on Monday October 15, 2012 @08:42AM (#4654785)
I hope longer than this fad with Christ lasts.
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by Evbn on Wednesday October 17, 2012 @04:19AM (#4663580)
Yuri?
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by guard-of-terra on Wednesday October 17, 2012 @03:53PM (#4666119)
Yes.
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by nodemaker on Monday October 15, 2012 @01:58AM (#4653955)
Wow this is a surprisingly hateful and ignorant comment for Hacker News and its not even getting downvoted.
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by intended on Monday October 15, 2012 @04:08AM (#4654178)
Well technically it should be getting downvoted for being wrong.

Here he is stating that he is taking an extremely America centric stance, and focused on the shortest path solution.

Its the obvious answer most people come up with, and its dissection and discovery of weak spots is valuable for those who would usually come up with a similar shortest path answer.

At the same time, he has accepted that he doesn't hold the moral high ground.

That should be repeated very clearly - this is a solution which doesn't hold to any high moral values.

So its NOT a good answer - anyone who wants to eschew morality and discuss pragmatism as the greater morality will do well to see its edge and failure cases.

His words should be heard because we can learn from others discussing it. The essence of free speech.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by nodemaker on Monday October 15, 2012 @01:46PM (#4656181)
Of course his right to say hateful things must be protected. But as a member of a community that values insightful comments, I feel obliged to point out that his opinion is based mostly on his personal hate and ignorance.

Asking for a limit on immigration from islamic countries to or developing alternative energy sources still is pretty objective to me. But adding the " the Arabs will just go back to what they were before - a bunch of desert nomads with no real power" makes it obvious where he is coming from.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by intended on Monday October 15, 2012 @02:02PM (#4656269)
Your missing the point here.

Look at the thread, the responses and the clarifications. The least useful answers in terms of education value are the ones which focus on whether he was or isn't a bad person for saying it.

As I also point out, your concerns are handled when he gives up the moral ground. you don't have to follow something you know is wrong.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by mylittlepony on Monday October 15, 2012 @08:54AM (#4654829)
Yes the ignorance and hate on that comment exceeded my daily quota and ruined my day. By the way, how do you downvote on HN? Do I need more score?
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by randomchars on Monday October 15, 2012 @09:48AM (#4655004)
Yeah there's threshold for downvoting. Maybe 500? Not sure.
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by nodemaker on Monday October 15, 2012 @01:39PM (#4656140)
Yes 500 it is.
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by chad_oliver on Monday October 15, 2012 @01:27AM (#4653895)
It's been 1300 years since Arabs were "a bunch of desert nomads with no real power".
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by killwhitey on Sunday October 14, 2012 @11:57PM (#4653690)
This would be a good strategy to stop state sponsored attacks, but what about the rest? What about the World Trade Center attacks? The 2002 Bali bombings? The 2005 London bombings?
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by tsotha on Monday October 15, 2012 @12:50AM (#4653822)
The WTC attacks were committed by people who were in the country legally, either at the time or they had overstayed a visa. Those attacks would not have happened if the individuals involved weren't granted visas.
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by mansoor-s on Monday October 15, 2012 @01:22AM (#4653880)
Are you telling me I should not be allowed in the USA of which I am a law abiding citizen because of my ethnicity?

Its okay, be strait with me. You won't hurt my feelings.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by mcantelon on Monday October 15, 2012 @01:32AM (#4653903)
Perhaps the user is referring to the allegations that US intelligence agencies, using the State Department as a proxy, let people into the US who otherwise would have been denied.

http://www.globalresearch.ca/articles/SPR302A.html

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by tsotha on Monday October 15, 2012 @03:12PM (#4656652)
The US is under no obligation to accept immigrants from anywhere. We're under no obligation to be "fair". And yes, I'm telling you we should be keeping a list of countries with significant anti-US terrorist movements and not allowing immigration from those countries. If you're from KSA or Yemen or Pakistan I would not have allowed you to immigrate.
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by dmorgan on Monday October 15, 2012 @07:00AM (#4654507)
>This is such a stupid strategy. The right thing to do is to look at the root cause of all this. After all, there are lots of angry people all across the world that hate the Western world and want to hurt it, but most can't.

Put this way, it's even more stupid. It's as if people go about "hating the west" for no reason (or because their "religion tells them so", which is a Glenn Beck level argument).

A thing called colonialism did exist. Some hundred million people were killed in invasions and wars and while fighting for their freedom, and some 2 billion people were living under foreign occupation.

And then you had a thing called post-colonialism, that does exist. With hundreds of interventions and resource-grubbing all over the world. With so called "banana republics" set up. And with countries thousands of miles away of some areas, have the audacity to believe they have "strategic interests" in those areas, and that it gives them the right to intervene, get their resources for cheap, place puppet governments, etc. You know, like some country in the American continent controlling Philippines or killing people in Vietnam.

What sets the Arabs apart is their vast oil riches. Without that, they wouldn't have the money or power to do anything to the West.

Arabs, as in "arab states" could not care less about "doing anything to the west". What sets those people apart is indeed their vast oil riches, that had provoked unprecedented resource-grubbing, puppet government establishment and invasions western powers.

Does anyone imagine what a foreign power invading the US would mean to the US people, and under some BS pretext at that? But invading Iraq under the BS pretext of WMDs, wrecking the country in the process, killing hundreds of thousands, taking control of the oil and leaving them in a state of civil war by playing into the competing tribal and religious interests, is somehow "normal", because they are "arabs".

So, the people there have a lot of reasons to "blame the west". It's not like they have any spectacular resources, either. WWII era guns and ammo, and cheaply made stuff, while the "west" kills them with drones and 21st century military technology.

>The minute that crude oil loses its relevance to the Western world, the Arabs will just go back to what they were before - a bunch of desert nomads with no real power.

Actually they had a huge empire, including parts of Europe, even before the crude oil gained relevance.

The west managed to turn them to "a bunch of desert nomads with no real power" precisely when it wanted to get ahold of cheap labour and later the crude oil.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by w1ntermute on Monday October 15, 2012 @09:30AM (#4654938)
> A thing called colonialism did exist....

All that is true, but it doesn't change what America needs to do now to ensure it remains in control in the most efficient manner. Moreover, with domestic and renewable sources of energy, we wouldn't need to get involved in the Middle East, so they would benefit too.

> The west managed to turn them to "a bunch of desert nomads with no real power" precisely when it wanted to get ahold of cheap labour and later the crude oil.

Great civilizations rise and fill. Regardless of how they got there, that's where they'll be when the US leaves. My point is that their ability to attack the US will be neutralized the minute their cash flow stops.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by ucee054 on Monday October 15, 2012 @07:29AM (#4654593)
The right thing to do is to look at the root cause of all this.

The root cause would be the West arming and training militant Islam.

Back in the day, there was the Caliphate, which was the government of Turkey and Egypt, and the Salafis, Wahhabis and Saudis, who were the militants.

The Caliphate sent a huge army to wipe out the extremists and chase the survivors into the desert.

Later, the West thought it would be clever to bring the extremists back to take over Pakistan (google for "Deobandi") and Arabia (which is why it is called Saudi Arabia now).

Then, they thought it would be really clever to give them Stinger missiles to piss off the Russians (see "Rambo 3"). Saudis + help from Ronald Reagan = AlQaeda.

The West are still arming the extremists (google for "Jundullah"). They think it's a really clever way to piss off the governments in Syria and Iran.

Apparently nothing has been learned from 911.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by marshallp on Monday October 15, 2012 @05:34AM (#4654327)
You would like to limit immigration. What would companies like google like look after that? Would you advocate sending the head of youtube back to Iran? What about much of Detroit or New York?

You're conflating some poverty-stricken residents of impoverished parts of the world riled up by political rhetoric with a credible enemy (like a cold war style superpower).

You're arguments make as much sense as labeling all white people everywhere as Nazis because Hitler was a white guy.

Go to Liberia or the Congo or India. You'll see that people aren't civilized, they will eat each other if out of ritual. That was the case everywhere over a 100 years ago. You miss that it's not some kind of inherent badness, they are simply living in a different time, like 1800s europe for example. If children commit crimes they are not convicted in the same manner as adults, that's the correct analogy to take.

As civilized people and members of the global species that is humanity, it's a responsibility to take care of the weak. The problems you've outlined are (global) law enforcement problems. And they are disappearing, as time passes everyone on earth will become modern. Watch some Steven Pinker and see how today is the most peaceful time in human history.

Watch Carl Sagan's blue dot and realize it's not Us vs Them. That's the thinking of pre-space age man.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WibmcsEGLKo (Charlie Chaplin)

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by w1ntermute on Monday October 15, 2012 @09:27AM (#4654929)
> You would like to limit immigration. What would companies like google like look after that? Would you advocate sending the head of youtube back to Iran? What about much of Detroit or New York?

I'm not talking about educated people, and like I said above, this issue is not particularly applicable to America, it's more relevant to Europe. In Europe, there is a serious issue with Muslim immigrants not integrating into mainstream society, and this is because many European nations accepted large numbers of Muslim immigrants in an indiscriminate fashion.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by marshallp on Monday October 15, 2012 @09:51AM (#4655019)
You've completely missed the point. There are not Us vs Them. There are simply people. If you would like to label people as uneducated or muslims or whatever else, then you have engaged in that fallacy that pre-space age humankind engaged. You should really watch that link I gave as well as the Pale Blue Dot and let it really sink in.
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by Evbn on Wednesday October 17, 2012 @04:37AM (#4663625)
Holy cow, I would not have guessed that this thread would be where you least trollish post of the week would be.