News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by tiffanyh on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @03:35PM (#46369188)
Or it disincentivizes creating those features, if you must give it to your competitors.
Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by avianlyric on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @03:54PM (#46369352)
That’s a rather silly view to take. We have a phenomenon called “the first mover advantage” for a reason.

Plenty of other markets and businesses operate just fine while operating in an environment that makes protecting individual innovation functionally impossible. Just look at any related to fast fashion (not that I think the fast fashion market is a healthy phenomenon) or any commodities market. Or for that matter, most of the software industry.

The incentive for creating features should be to remain relevant and competitive. It shouldn’t be to build moats and war chests.

Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by websiteapi on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @04:23PM (#46369637)
"plenty of other markets" have way smaller margins and are not nearly as robust an industry as software.
Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by avianlyric on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @06:14PM (#46370615)
Are you trying suggest that Apple’s margins are so small that they need state protection? Or that Apple can’t compete if they’re not able to tightly lock down every aspect of their ecosystem?
Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by stefan_ on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @07:24PM (#46371096)
I don't understand. Robust markets don't have large margins. Why would a regulator even want markets with enormous margin? That's usually market failure.
Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by tekknik on Friday December 26, 2025 @03:59PM (#46396186)
Pharmaceuticals have very large margins.
Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by avianlyric on Tuesday December 30, 2025 @06:59PM (#46439729)
Most people also complain about how pharmaceuticals are greedy corporations that seek to exploit monopoly status for profits above human health. Hardly a good example of a well functioning market.
Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by tekknik on Saturday January 03, 2026 @10:34PM (#46484619)
Complaining doesn’t mean action. To affect prices people need to vote with their wallet, and they won’t do that when their life is on the line.

Or to put it another way, find an alternative.

Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by illiac786 on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @03:56PM (#46369367)
I would agree in general, but in this specific case it’s still an advantage for the iOS platform in general. It just removes a buying incentive for the AirPods.

The general problem is that there must be a line.

Vendors don’t create lock-ins because they are malicious, they create it because it makes them money.

Now, if we limit these lock-ins, it will reduce their ability to make money and yes, it will impact some features - short term.

But looking at it long terms, vendor lock-ins are actually a reason to stop innovating: your customers are locked in anyway.

So, overall, I would say this is good for innovation in general.

Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by websap on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @03:59PM (#46369391)
I actually have a problem with this. I want AirPods to be undeniably the best experience for me because I am fully locked into the Apple ecosystem, and I know many folks have complaints against that. I find it to be rather pleasurable to use compared to all the other alternatives out there. So if I have to start sacrificing my experience in favor of universal support, that really sucks.
Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by reorder9695 on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @04:07PM (#46369466)
But this isn't sacrificing your experience, you're free to keep using your Apple AirPods with the quality and reliability you'd expect from Apple. This just means other brands can create products with similar features to AirPods, and if they're not as good or reliable, well that's why you're paying Apple for theirs.
Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by DANmode on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @07:42PM (#46371210)
I see their point.

If Apple knew they would need to expand this feature past their gear, possible they’d never have implemented.

We may never know what stays unimplemented due to this.

(This is a neutral take - note I do not have a personal opinion formed in this “debate”.)

Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by supermatt on Wednesday December 24, 2025 @02:26AM (#46373298)
> If Apple knew they would need to expand this feature past their gear, possible they’d never have implemented.

And this is EXACTLY why they need to open up more core access to their devices. So someone else can innovate.

Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by DANmode on Wednesday December 24, 2025 @02:52AM (#46373429)
Why they need to be forced to, you mean?

I'm not seeing an incentive structure for them to change being the only source of good workflows for their users - it's their whole thing "It just works" - regardless of if it's true in practice or not.

Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by supermatt on Wednesday December 24, 2025 @02:56AM (#46373449)
Indeed. They have shown (and keep showing via blatant malicious compliance) that they can’t be trusted to play fairly.
Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by reorder9695 on Wednesday December 24, 2025 @05:06AM (#46374197)
If you want the "it just works" experience, you can still buy the Apple products though, that's not changing. You just also have the option to not do so.
Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by tekknik on Friday December 26, 2025 @04:06PM (#46396265)
which other company spends as much investing in UX? there is not a single other company on the planet with as polished of a user experience as apple, so who would develop a better workflow?
Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by websap on Friday December 26, 2025 @12:18AM (#46389409)
The best code is no code. Every line of extra code added, and every extra platform supported is potential for more bugs, which has the potential to affect my user experience.
Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by tekknik on Friday December 26, 2025 @04:04PM (#46396242)
It removes incentives to differentiate a platform because the EU will just come in and make every company exactly the same by forcing others to allow other companies access to their R&D budgets. Why bother? It’s easier to just avoid the EU market
Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by illiac786 on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @04:10PM (#46369500)
the long term innovation outlooks are still better, so you benefit long term as well.

It’s just less obvious / measurable that immediate benefits.

And also, short term, isn’t it that other EarPods are getting better, rather than AirPods getting worse?

Medium term, I don’t think that Apple will stop innovating on AirPods just because of the EU market and this one feature not being exclusive to AirPods anymore. But it’s a possibility, I agree.

Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by nutjob2 on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @04:39PM (#46369779)
Your tortured argument tests credulity and is pretty much opposite of how actual markets work.

In this case, stopping Apple from degrading competitor products means they can compete on a level playing field and Apple will need to create better products to maintain a lead. Their ability to degrade competitor products has nothing to do with the features or quality of their headphones but rather that they control a closed platform. Thus the EU's action in maintaining fair competition.

Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by wiseowise on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @04:53PM (#46369913)
Is there anything that makes you believe they'll sacrifice quality to have universal support?
Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by phatfish on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @08:18PM (#46371410)
Spite? It's standard practice for corporations to take the ball home when they are forced to play fair.
Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by ruszki on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @06:40PM (#46370815)
They won’t, but Apple previously lied similarly against PWAs.
Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by jessecurry on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @08:27PM (#46371464)
They did their initial AirPod implementation in a pretty insecure manner because it was securely locked to their hardware and they could trust themselves to not be malicious. If they have to build a feature, plus all the security around it, plus documentation, etc… it makes it much harder to bring to market. They may opt to skip it in favor of something else.
Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by wiseowise on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @04:52PM (#46369902)
Bro, market is there to benefit consumer first, not to make money for shareholders.
Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by phatfish on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @08:16PM (#46371401)
That is what the "free market" was supposed to do, if you believe capitalist lore. Shareholders getting a cut was the side hustle.
Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by morshu9001 on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @07:12PM (#46371028)
I disagree with this, but it shouldn't get downvoted. That's not how it works here.
Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by dangus on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @11:21PM (#46372426)
Isn't Apple currently disincentivized to make features because they don't even allow competing smartwatches to access a basic feature set on iPhone?

You're basically saying Apple would be disincentivized to innovate on the Apple Watch because Apple would need to release the underlying APIs that make those work with the phone to competing solutions. But the status quo is that competing solutions that are already better than the Apple Watch straight up aren't allowed on the platform, and the Apple Watch generally costs more than its competitors.

You are unintentionally saying that if Apple had to allow third parties to use their private APIs, that the Apple Watch would have to cost less and/or innovate more in order to convince us all to buy it instead of buying a watch from Samsung or Google.

What you are describing is a more competitive and open market where consumers benefit from lower prices and more of an incentive to innovate and justify high prices.

I would also dispute the notion that merely releasing these APIs would somehow give away all your secret sauce. Competitors still have to build the experience on top of that.

Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by djtango on Wednesday December 24, 2025 @12:28AM (#46372750)
I thought the first thing they teach you about capitalism is that competition is good, and monopolies are anti-competitive...
Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by beeflet on Wednesday December 24, 2025 @02:02AM (#46373180)
competition is for losers
Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by alextingle on Wednesday December 24, 2025 @01:58AM (#46373165)
Apple giving themselves an advantage in the markets for headphones and watches, because they have a dominant position in the market for phones is a textbook case of monopoly abuse.

They've done extra work to cripple competing devices. It's obnoxious.

Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by miohtama on Wednesday December 24, 2025 @02:02AM (#46373186)
Apple market share is 10% in the EU. Hardly a monopoly.
Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by tordrt on Wednesday December 24, 2025 @03:39AM (#46373690)
Where do you get 10% from? Its close to 40%, and the company with the biggest market share in Europe.

https://gs.statcounter.com/vendor-market-share/mobile/europe

Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by supermatt on Wednesday December 24, 2025 @02:18AM (#46373258)
That depends on the interpretation of a market, which is why laws like the DMA establish a market based on its size. In the iOS market, apple have a monopoly.

EDIT: Downvotes for what? That’s literally what the DMA is for. If you don’t like it, take it up with your representatives - it’s nothing to do with me.

Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by tekknik on Friday December 26, 2025 @04:02PM (#46396218)
> In the iOS market, apple have a monopoly.

So if a company creates a widget and sells that widget, thereby creating a market, they are automatically a monopoly? how is anything invented without creating a monopoly?

Also why is it an iOS market and not a mobile phone market? if we compare features of devices then there’s not a lot of difference between modern phones, so segregating them by what OS they run seems odd.

Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by supermatt on Saturday December 27, 2025 @06:33PM (#46406627)
Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by layer8 on Wednesday December 24, 2025 @09:02AM (#46375658)
Abusing one’s market position doesn’t require a monopoly, being a major player is enough.
Re:iOS 26.3 Brings AirPods-Like Pairing to Third-Party Devic... by Teever on Wednesday December 24, 2025 @04:06AM (#46373872)
Laws that mandate interoperability between devices are a net win for individual consumers and the market as a whole. They simplify people's lives, make society more efficient, prevent opportunities for blatant rent seeking and ultimately foster market productivity.

A government mandating standards in electricity transmission or gasoline composition may disincentivize the development of features that make some people's devices incompatible with charging at certain locations or cars that can only use gas from certain gas stations but that is the opposite of a bad thing.

We live in a much better world because people in the past decided that all telephones should be able to make calls to each other and that people don't really have to think about messing up putting fuel in their car because the size of the nozzles at pumps are standardized.

There are absolutely more opportunities for governments to make small but objectively measurable improvements in society with well placed regulations on interoperability.