News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by mmooss on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @04:10PM (#46050822)
How did the language end up with a Latin alphabet?
Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by itake on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @04:21PM (#46050945)
Same as Vietnam: No dominate written language at the time of European Colonialization.
Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by rafram on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @04:32PM (#46051052)
Sort of. Indonesian had Jawi, based on the Arabic script. People in today's Vietnam mostly wrote in Chinese AFAIK. Those methods of writing were dominant among the people who could write. But the populations were mostly illiterate, so it was easy for colonial administrators to supplant the existing writing systems with Latin as they introduced European-style schooling.
Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by LAC-Tech on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @05:37PM (#46051689)
How well do Chinese characters mesh with Vietnamese?

I mean I note that there are some Chinese languages, with millions of speakers, where the largest written text they have is a bible written in a Roman script. If those are a challenge surely Vietnamese must be as well.

Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by alephnerd on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @05:42PM (#46051744)
Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by wisty on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @09:27PM (#46053535)
Like Korean and Japanese it has a different grammar and vocabulary. Japanese added a bunch other characters and Korean just made up a new (phonetic) script.
Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by realusername on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @02:06AM (#46054896)
> How well do Chinese characters mesh with Vietnamese?

Not very well. The old vietnamese script with Chinese characters had a lot of custom additions not in Chinese to make it work. It clearly was ducktaped.

Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @11:41AM (#46059327)
There are non-Chinese languages in China that use Chinese characters phonetically for writing. Most of these are newer though, since the 1950s.
Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by realusername on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @03:18PM (#46061881)
That was kind of like that with vietnamese, a mix of phonetic-only characters, fully custom characters and standard ones all blend together, it's quite a mess. I doubt any Chinese speaker can understand that.

The colonial administration didn't have to push too hard to make people switch, the customized chinese script wasn't very popular.

Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @04:47PM (#46062724)
Chinese speakers won't understand Zhuang, Yi, or Bai as well. Latinization would probably be more effective, but China would lose some face. They even re-popularized an old form of Uighur script for Mongolian (while Mongolians in outer Mongolia/Russia use Cyrillic).
Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by eaksa on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @09:01PM (#46053349)
Despite its name, Jawi wasn’t used all that much in Java – it had always been more popular in the Malay peninsula. Java, as with many parts of Indonesia, used Brahmic abugidas descended from the Pallava script of Southern India (just like the Thai and Khmer scripts). Latin was chosen to write the Indonesian language for the same reason Malay was chosen as the language’s base: it was a politically neutral choice to unite a diverse archipelago.
Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by faizmokh on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @01:08AM (#46054627)
Jawi is also not popular nowadays among the malaysian malays.

Every now and then it will pop up in the news due to politicians using it as a tool to cause racial divide.

Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by mc32 on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @10:37PM (#46053944)
Vietnam adopted the Latin alphabet from a missionary of some sort a couple of centuries before they were colonized by France --at the time Vietnam was decolonizing from China. The French made some modifications to how the alphabet was used to represent their phonemes.
Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by dboreham on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @09:57AM (#46057965)
Btw, after a couple of days being super-confused in Thailand I reverse-engineered this history from signs in English I kept seeing that in no way matched the Thai pronunciation. Finally the penny dropped that whoever had come up with the "English" phonetic spelling of Thai words, was not an English speaker.
Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by alephnerd on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @05:30PM (#46051612)
> No dominate written language at the time of European Colonialization

Vietnamese used to be written using Chinese orthography just like Japanese.

The French forcibly cracked down on this form of orthography, and following independence, later modernists attempting to copy Ataturk along with latent Sinophobia due to the Chinese colonial era meant this for of orthography has largely been relegated to ceremonial usage.

A similar thing happened with Bahasa Indonesia, as Indonesia's founding leadership was more secular and socialist in mindset compared to neighboring Malaysia where Jawi remained prominent because of the Islamist movement's role in Malaysian independence.

Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by xvedejas on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @06:56PM (#46052367)
Another factor is that literacy rates were very low before colonization, in Vietnam to read or write using Chinese characters was never a broadly known skill (outside of the elite). This is a pretty big contrast to Japan, which had double-digit rates of literacy during the same era.
Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by throwaway2037 on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @06:40PM (#46052205)
One word: Colonization
Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by csomar on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @03:45AM (#46055452)
Malay culture adopted Arabic alphabet without colonization. I think colonization had less to do with it and more with the fact that the Alphabet is better and more practical. Same thing with modern numbers.
Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by boxed on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @05:16AM (#46055991)
> Malay culture adopted Arabic alphabet without colonization

Is that just because you define "colonization" as "by western countries"?

Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by csomar on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @06:57AM (#46056547)
No. But Arabs didn't colonize the Malay islands. They just adopted Islam from their internal politics. Not sure why this triggered you, pretty much everybody is a colonizer.
Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by defrost on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @05:31AM (#46056043)
Do you have evidence that Malaysia was "colonized" by Arabs?

There is evidence that Parameswara converted to Islam following his infatuation with and marriage to a girl from the Samudera Pasai Sultanate.

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parameswara_of_Malacca

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samudera_Pasai_Sultanate

Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by hearsathought on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @12:29PM (#46059984)
> There is evidence that Parameswara converted to Islam following his infatuation with and marriage to a girl from the Samudera Pasai Sultanate.

Doesn't that seem like the silliest thing you ever read? When the infatuation ended ( like all infatuations do ), did he convert back? The only thing royals are infatuated with is wealth and power. If anything, don't you think the guy converted to get preferable treatment from the arab traders or get special access to the arab trading network? There is more to the story for sure. But I'm not buying that fanciful story.

Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by defrost on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @07:50PM (#46064124)
> Doesn't that seem like the silliest thing you ever read?

Not even close to be frankly honest.

Leaving aside the delibrate silliness of Edward Lear, Roald Dahl, et al and focusing just on origin stories relating to the spread of various beliefs ...

* Have you heard the one about the Buddist Monk, the Monkey, Pig, Fish, Dragon, and Horse spirits ?

* the tale of a great snake that carved rivers ?

* maybe that fishing boat passenger that got out and walked across the water ?

> If anything, don't you think the guy converted to get preferable treatment from the arab traders

I suspect the marriage was political .. but he wasn't marrying into a family of arab traders, Sultan Malikussaleh (the progenitor of the Samudera Pasai Sultanate) was an Acehnese man from part of what is now called Sumatra, a part of Indonesia.

> special access to the arab trading network

Was pretty low key wrt volume between the modern middle east and Indonesia back in the time we are looking at - the trade advantages by volume (ie. that which mattered) was all local to the greater archipelago.

Moreover, returning to the original point upthread, there's no evidence of colonisation by arabs in the sense of colonisation by the British of India or various parts of Africa, colonisation by the Dutch in the East Indies, colonisation by the Germans in Africa and PNG, by the French in Vietnam, etc.

Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by hearsathought on Tuesday December 02, 2025 @12:37PM (#46123929)
> focusing just on origin stories relating to the spread of various beliefs ...

The difference being that nobody believes those silly things. Or are you saying you believe these nonsense also?

> I suspect the marriage was political ..

Why didn't you say so in the first place.

> but he wasn't marrying into a family of arab traders

Did I say he married into a family of arab traders? Stop with your bullshit already.

Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by csomar on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @03:44AM (#46055443)
The same way the latin world ended up with a Latin Alphabet. It's more practical and they never developed their own. Malaysia, for example, has Jawi which is the Arabic alphabet of the their language. The short answer: the language never developed an "alphabet" and thus adopted one.
Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by hearsathought on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @11:58AM (#46059553)
The dutch colonization of indonesia started in the 1600s and ended in 1949. So plenty of time for the locals, especially the elites, to learn dutch and the alphabet.