News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mind-reading devices can now predict preconscious thoughts by jaapz on Monday November 24, 2025 @05:26PM (#46040138)
Can we? We can only see whatever we can measure with the tools we currently have, which are based on the knowledge we currently have. Who's to say there isn't something out there we haven't discovered yet? There's more than enough we still don't understand in many domains of science
Re:Mind-reading devices can now predict preconscious thoughts by smallnix on Monday November 24, 2025 @06:44PM (#46040760)
> Who's to say there isn't something out there we haven't discovered yet

Occam's razor? We should work with as few assumptions as possible to get a model with the largest scope. Otherwise we get stuck with a hard to falsify mess.

Re:Mind-reading devices can now predict preconscious thoughts by RHSeeger on Monday November 24, 2025 @10:27PM (#46042046)
Yeah, but "we've been discovering new things for all of history, so there's likely more to discover" seems to a pretty fair assumption.
Re:Mind-reading devices can now predict preconscious thoughts by PaulRobinson on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @05:59AM (#46044649)
The point I made a few comments up is that often we start to identify the need for a new science based on observations we can't explain with our current understanding. Hydro-dynamics and electricity are examples given in the comment I replied to - but we could see those and go "wait, we can't explain this well, yet". Quantum physics, X-rays, wave-particle duality of light, and so on - we observed something and could not explain it.

My point was I don't think that's happening with neuroscience yet. We might not have a complete map yet, but we know where thoughts come from in the organ, we can watch them. Or can we? It's an open question, if people think there is more science to be done to sort out fundamentals, and we're not just in the stage of iterating on our base assumptions more, I'm OK with that, but it's not my understanding today.

Re:Mind-reading devices can now predict preconscious thoughts by akomtu on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @12:45AM (#46042697)
Occam's razor is just a search heuristic when we try to find something in the woods at night blindfolded. It's a rule of thumb that says "when there is so many possibilities to explore, start with the simplest ones first, otherwise we'll surely get lost." But it's a mistake to use the Occam's razor as a law of nature and think that if we can't see anything in the dark over there, then there must be nothing there.
Re:Mind-reading devices can now predict preconscious thoughts by anthonypasq on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @11:36AM (#46047549)
considering our current physics can explain the vast majority of physical interactions in the universe, it just seems unlikely that there is some new fundamental force in the universe that helps explain how the brain works yet has no perceivable effect on the rest of the physical material of the universe.
Re:Mind-reading devices can now predict preconscious thoughts by bfuller on Thursday November 27, 2025 @04:53AM (#46067608)
Conceivably someone has said this at some point in every generation.