News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by ekjhgkejhgk on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @04:12PM (#45972164)
Mastodon is great. It's just unfortunate that the number of people is on the low side.
Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by INTPenis on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @04:20PM (#45972253)
>The fediverse is an island within an increasingly dystopian capitalist hellscape.
Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by bovermyer on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @04:23PM (#45972311)
These two statements are not mutually exclusive.
Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by dsr_ on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @04:30PM (#45972404)
I think the fediverse is great but: the specific desire for "more people that you already know coming to the Fediverse" is good; the general desire "more people" is not such a useful goal.
Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by bigiain on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @06:31PM (#45973712)
Yeah. Everybody wants "more of the right kind of people", but there are as many interpretations of "the right kind of people" as there are people.

People and interactions between them are just messy. And that's not a thing there can be any tech solutions to.

For me, there are several clear step changes in groups based on size and there closeness of the relationships. A close circle of perhaps up to a dozen or two trustworthy friends is different to that same sized group of less trusted people. As the group size grows, it becomes less possible for the sort if "trusted" status of all group members to exist, and that fundamentally changes things. There's another step change when the group gets big enough that you can't personally know all the members. And another big step change when the group gets big enough that you can't even recognise all the members names (in my head, this is associated with a lot if the postulating about Dunbar's Number, however bad that research really was).

Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by verdverm on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @04:38PM (#45972509)
On boarding is too complicated for your average social user

https://atproto.com has more of the developer mindshare now

Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by lutoma on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @04:56PM (#45972746)
It's also effectively centralized. Of course that makes the experience easier.
Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by verdverm on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @05:30PM (#45973122)
If you cannot reach UX that normal people will use, you're building for the very few

tradeoffs are acceptable to help our social fabric to take a step in a better direction and away from corporate silos and the attention economy

Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by kstrauser on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @05:53PM (#45973374)
Except that usernames contain a domain name component, and the “bare” username likely isn’t globally unique, the UX is nearly the same as other microblogs. And as to that username bit, people are used to [email protected] and [email protected] being different people, and having to specify which one they’re trying to send an email to.

Everyone who’s both email and Twitter already understands all the basic concepts.

Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by verdverm on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @06:29PM (#45973695)
> And as to that username bit, people are used to [email protected] and [email protected] being different people, and having to specify which one they’re trying to send an email to.

User handles are unique in ATProto because of the domain, just like email. Not sure what the "except" part is about. Can you clarify? In ATProto, they are not "bare"

ActivityPub is the same, except they are tied to the server you join. In ATProto, they are decoupled from your data host so you can move your data and server without changing your handle. You can also change your handle without moving anything else, because handle points to a DID behind the scenes

Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by kstrauser on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @08:28PM (#45974765)
Ah, to be clear, I was thinking of ActivityPub.

How’s ATProto work for the 99.9% of people who don’t own domains?

Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by cmckn on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @10:29PM (#45975531)
You just get a *.bsky.social handle.
Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by Zak on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @05:22PM (#45973037)
The thing I really don't love about ATProto is its decision, or that of its dominant implementation to enforce a schema ("lexicon") on content, limiting interoperation between disparate software. This violates the Old Internet idea of software being liberal about what it accepts.

For a concrete example, I tagged a Lemmy community in a Mastodon post today. Lemmy is Reddit-like and Mastodon is Twitter-like, but it displays reasonable on Lemmy using the first line of the post as a title and expanding to the attached image when clicked in the default Lemmy UI. I can also post a long-form article on Wordpress (with a plugin) and have it show up in Mastodon even though it has a short character limit by default.

Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by verdverm on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @05:28PM (#45973097)
That's an incorrect assessment

Lexicon schema are not enforced, they are a tool for social coordination, and most implementations are very liberal in what they accept

https://www.pfrazee.com/blog/lexicon-guidance

> isTool: true; isRule: false; meaning: undefined

ActivityPub by contrast lacks such social coordination and many apps are reusing the same schema for very different concepts, leading to its own form of over-complexity

Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by tcfhgj on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @06:07PM (#45973512)
how do you measure "too complicted"?
Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by verdverm on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @06:40PM (#45973777)
Didn't measure what complicated means, these are the words people who churned use

Generally the first point is server selection. That's too complicated for most users

Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by tcfhgj on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @06:51PM (#45973878)
Somehow I doubt it is.

People are capable of selecting phones, phone network providers, e-mail providers, Internet providers, but selecting a server for mastodon is too complicated?

Don't buy it

Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by verdverm on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @07:27PM (#45974218)
> Don't buy it

Not listening to users is when learning stops

You are making bad analogies, instead compare AP to other social media networks and what users expect when signing up

Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by tcfhgj on Wednesday November 19, 2025 @05:00AM (#45977748)
> You are making bad analogies, instead compare AP to other social media networks and what users expect when signing up

I don't. I make these analogies, because they show that almost everyone is able to deal with the complexity of selecting a service provider.

I acknowledge that it is not their expected sign up flow, though, because they you can only expect what you already know.

Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by SoftTalker on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @07:46PM (#45974397)
That’s actually why I never tried it. Server selection. Choice paralysis. Gave up.
Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by tcfhgj on Wednesday November 19, 2025 @05:01AM (#45977752)
how did you get internet access?
Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by perryizgr8 on Wednesday November 19, 2025 @09:08AM (#45979678)
Usually there's a couple of options for internet access based on your address, not hundreds of servers.
Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by SoftTalker on Wednesday November 19, 2025 @11:07AM (#45981253)
Yeah one choice for me, the local cable company.

But for mastodon, even if it technically "doesn't matter" nobody stops there. You see things written like "The hardest part of getting started on Mastodon is the first step,"[1]

They talk about chosing a server based on region, language, topics of interest, or which ones your friends use. I've even some mention that your server choice can signal your political leanings.

I don't worry about any of those things when I choose an email provider or ISP.

[1] https://www.pcmag.com/how-to/how-to-pick-a-mastodon-server

Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by RobotToaster on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @05:11PM (#45972931)
It's another centralised service
Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by LastTrain on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @04:53PM (#45972711)
I wish it were better. I really want to move to it, but they’ve somehow managed to even make something as simple as liking a toot unintuitive. Boost and favorite don’t fit the bill.
Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by BeetleB on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @06:08PM (#45973522)
Honest question: Why is it important to like a toot? What benefit does liking one provide?
Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by abdullahkhalids on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @06:37PM (#45973754)
It indicates to the poster that someone (you) liked their post. Perhaps that encourages them to make other similar posts.
Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by BeetleB on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @06:44PM (#45973808)
In which case either favorite or bookmark will do the trick, correct? Why worry whether you're clicking the "wrong" one?

Boost will also do it, but it has more side effects.

Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by LastTrain on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @08:21PM (#45974702)
Because I don’t want to boost or add the toot to a perma-list, I just want to give the person that posted something I like some acknowledgement.
Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by abdullahkhalids on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @09:08PM (#45975046)
In real life, your friend tells you a moderately funny story that happened to him. You tell the friend, "nice story" (that's a like).

Another friend tells you a super funny story. You then go and tell other friends this same funny story. (that's a boost).

Different real life things, that are captured by digital tools.

What I have a problem with are quote tweets, which are like talking about someone in front of them, without including them in the conversation.

Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by krapp on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @08:30PM (#45974787)
That sounds like exactly the kind of addiction-reinforcing Skinner box nonsense that leads to influencers, parasocial relationships and a content economy, and all of the dark patterns of social media that the fediverse is designed to avoid.

People shouldn't be posting to get the endorphine rush from clicks or to satisfy metrics. They should post whatever they want, whenever they want. If you like what someone posts, you can follow their account, or better yet the hashtags they use. That should be sufficient.

Not having a like button seems like a good design choice TBH.

Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by LastTrain on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @08:35PM (#45974827)
The issue with social media isn’t with encouraging or content creators, it is with how consumers are conditioned.
Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by krapp on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @08:47PM (#45974916)
The incentives are related and create a feedback loop. Give someone a number and they'll do whatever it takes to make that number go up.
Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by lenkite on Wednesday November 19, 2025 @12:23AM (#45976155)
> That sounds like exactly the kind of addiction-reinforcing Skinner box nonsense that leads to influencers, parasocial relationships and a content economy,

No, this is the digital analogue of a non-verbal expression. Basic table stakes - unless you categorize human behavior as "addiction-reinforcing".

Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by krapp on Wednesday November 19, 2025 @06:29AM (#45978298)
>unless you categorize human behavior as "addiction-reinforcing".

In the context of social media most human behavior is addiction-reinforcing, because that is the behavior that those platforms are designed to reinforce. The medium is the message.

Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by LastTrain on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @08:18PM (#45974683)
It isn’t important, it’s just something I would like to do.
Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by tcfhgj on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @06:08PM (#45973523)
how is clicking a heart or a star - depending on the UI - unintuitive?
Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by criddell on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @05:00PM (#45972787)
At some point more users would probably make everything worse. Having a low user count is probably a good thing.
Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by pndy on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @05:25PM (#45973071)
I see bots that import from/link to other sources, bots that are clearly someone's attempts at automation. Then "classic" ad spam bots and countless porn/drawn lewd content profiles and even instances that contain nothing else.

Normal people are getting buried beneath all of this trash and if you actually want to have some conversations you need to either look up by particular tags or comment in trending posts.

Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by jeromegv on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @05:37PM (#45973194)
> Normal people are getting buried beneath all of this trash

This is the entire opposite of my experience on Mastodon. I get buried in trash on Twitter, any semi-popular tweet ends up with hundreds of bots and racial slurs. I see none of that on Mastodon

Really curious how you ended up in a situation like that.

Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by pndy on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @05:58PM (#45973423)
I tried two different instances and two different accounts, following people and really extensive post filtering and it still happen.

Also no matter if content was filtered or not, three different applications on iOS and Android were crashing after trying to scroll through streams - local and federated. I guess it was because of that trash overload.

It's not like I don't like mastodon, fediverse - on contrary, it's an amazing idea. I had really nice conversations there for a while - till people drop their masks.

Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by BeetleB on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @06:07PM (#45973517)
Curious: Are you looking at the local/federated timeline, or just the people you follow?

I strongly urge you to stick to the latter.

I get nothing like what you describe, but I ensure the local/federated timeline stays out of my feed.

Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by cthulha on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @08:03PM (#45974562)
I also just read the timeline of followed accounts, and even a list of 'must-reads' for the high-value people, but I'm also aware that this isn't the way other people liked to use Twitter/Mastodon.

Maybe that's why this discussion is so split between "I read my follows and love it" || "I read the open feeds and hate the stream of trash"

Not sure what can be done when there's such an adversarial environment for open social media - everything you need for a federated environment can be misused by bad actors or neglected by naive well-intentioned ones :/

Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by prmoustache on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @06:04PM (#45973475)
I view it as a good thing.
Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by BeetleB on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @06:08PM (#45973520)
> It's just unfortunate that the number of people is on the low side.

You mean like HN?

Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by protocolture on Tuesday November 18, 2025 @06:33PM (#45973728)
If i logged into my account, its probably just some german hackers, some weird people, and a bot that posts the current big ben chimes in an amusing way. I love it. Empty is good.
Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by jillesvangurp on Wednesday November 19, 2025 @02:26AM (#45976766)
Mastodon is alright; it could be much better. And I find that disappointing. Mastodon is where some of my techie friends live (the less sociable types generally, which is ironic IMHO). Bluesky seems to have a much broader appeal. They both aspire to federation. So why not federate them together? I'm sure there are technical challenges but those aren't the reason this is not happening.

The Mastodon community actively pushes back against federating with other networks, discoverability features (having content indexed for search), or sane security mechanisms (like signing your content). This is IMHO what is holding back Mastodon. It could be better but people push back against improving it and therefore it stays a bit niche and meh.

It's basically open source twitter but minus all the loud mouths using that to self promote, spam, troll, attack each other, etc. Twitter was really nice too before the masses showed up.

Bluesky basically adds content signing, discoverability, and a few other things a to the mix. It's similarly free from all the nasty things on Twitter.

It's less federated than it could be (it was designed as a federated protocol but effectively is centralized) because big company reflexes seem to be taking over there. That's an interesting dynamic. But there's enough open source stuff there that a mastodon bridge would be feasible. And IMHO stronger crypto would be good for Mastodon. I don't see the logic of defaulting to publishing content unsigned. How is that a thing in 2025?

Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by Tepix on Wednesday November 19, 2025 @05:57AM (#45978117)
Yes, it's disappointing frankly to see how many smart people still are on X.

Then again it's disappointing to see how many people with fuck you money don't say "fuck you".

Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by berkes on Wednesday November 19, 2025 @12:51PM (#45982510)
I think one is the result of the other. It is a nice place because there are few people there.

Or, more cynical, reversed: I am convinced Mastodon will be a horrible platform if it grows to a size of e.g. twitter, reddit, and far, far worse if it grows to sizes of insta, tiktok, facebook etc.

The reason I am convinced the low number of people makes the place overall nice is that its a niche, like HN is a niche. That its not an interesting target for phishers, spammers, scammers or attackers: the ROI is too low. And that the low number of people keeps influencers and other commercial entities, like brands or news-agencies away: not much to make money off.

Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by krapp on Wednesday November 19, 2025 @01:00PM (#45982624)
>Or, more cynical, reversed: I am convinced Mastodon will be a horrible platform if it grows to a size of e.g. twitter, reddit, and far, far worse if it grows to sizes of insta, tiktok, facebook etc.

The thing is Mastodon isn't a platform like twitter, reddit, etc, it's a decentralized network of platforms. A few instances might become popular (like mastodon.social) and become a default for newcomers but there will always be smaller instances doing their own thing.

Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by berkes on Thursday November 20, 2025 @06:15AM (#45991439)
But these instances are part of the platform. Or, a better term, part of the system.

So "doing their own thing" is very limited. Do "too much of it" and you'll be fediblocked. Too little of your own thing and you're essentially getting what the large instances dictate. Sure, your instance can e.g. block meta instances because it dislikes Facebook. But that doesn't isolate you from meta content completely - or even at all - it depends. If your instance wants that, it'll have to also block all instances that don't block meta. Basically defederating almost entirely.

And this doesn't even consider the numerous malicious practices that one can do, but aren't interesting currently due to the limited reach of this fediverse. Like scooping up expired domains of previous instances and using that to spam. Or like impersonating famous people and scamming users that way. Or like taking over accounts and spamming or scamming that way. Or even taking over entire instances by hacking the server or social engineering access. Etc. etc.

The fediverse has nothing technical that protects it against the real and expensive threats that "common social media platforms" face on a daily basis. Federation doesn't suddenly make any of these attacks more difficult. If anything, it makes it easier, because the instances themselves are ran by volunteers who in many cases will not have security budgets to protect against such attacks. The only thing that the fediverse has going for it, in this regard, is that the blast radius is smaller. The attack easier, the result contained. But it's not unthinkable that malware, fake news, or other malicious content can easily be spread this way.

Re:I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon by krapp on Thursday November 20, 2025 @07:35AM (#45991945)
You can do your own thing as much as you want, and choose with whom you federate, and others can do the same. That's just freedom of speech and freedom of association. Large instances aren't "dictating" anything to other instances. The point is you can't do that with Twitter or Facebook or even Reddit to the same degree. The fediverse will never have an Elon Musk trying to purge it of the "woke mind virus."

>And this doesn't even consider the numerous malicious practices that one can do (...)

Your argument here seems to be that because most instances are small, that makes them more prone to security issues. And that's true, but nothing you mention here is unique to the fediverse, and all of those risks are still greater with mainstream platforms even with their bigger security budgets and resources. People hack Facebook and Twitter all the time, and millions of people get their data stolen, and misinformation spreads like wildfire. In this regard being decentralized, smaller and able to defederate from malicious instances are features rather than flaws.

It is definitely a flaw in the fediverse that identity is tied to a url and so there's no way to validate an identity across instances, and it is trivial to impersonate someone by simply using their username elsewhere. I think Nostr got it more correct in this regard, and I don't know what could be done to mitigate this at a technical level.

But even then I think that at least the fediverse is a necessary step in the right direction.