News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by hobofan on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @04:40AM (#45885627)
In many ways OpenAI is transitioning towards an end-user facing product business. They have by far the strongest brand among consumers and are positioning themselves to take on Google/Meta in the ad business.

By proxy, having the strongest frontier model becomes less and less necessary for them and instead building a strong product by properly layering medium-strong models in a cost-efficient way is the priority.

Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by xnx on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @07:24AM (#45886495)
> They have by far the strongest brand

Just like Blackberry, but instead of having to buy an new device to switch to the competition, the customer just needs to click on a different website.

Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by keiferski on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @08:10AM (#45886878)
Not a great analogy. Blackberry was never really for mass consumers and was always business-first. They lost to Apple because Apple won the mass market, and the mass market overwhelmed the specific niche business use-case that was BB.

OpenAI is already the consumer-first AI platform. And, in my opinion, in the minds of the average consumer, the biggest one that is "an app" with memory and folders, vs. something like Gemini which is perceived as an extension of Google Search and thus doesn't have the same "knowledge database" UI.

Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by diamond559 on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @02:36PM (#45891773)
Yeah but consumers don't want to pay for these 7 second memes or "erotica", blackberries had actual value that companies paid for.
Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by jorvi on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @07:27AM (#45886517)
> They have by far the strongest brand

They don't really, because of Gemini and Grok.

If it was OpenAI vs Claude then yeah, ChatGPT is known whereas Claude you have to be an enthusiast to know.

But everyone using Google runs into Gemini and everyone using X runs into Grok, and people talk. Now even the laypeople know there is more than one AI, and they're from big brands that they trust. Which means that people will window shop for the AI with the best performance per cost. Bye bye brand power.

Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by ForHackernews on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @07:36AM (#45886584)
Does anyone trust Xitter? If so, they shouldn't.
Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by jpadkins on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @10:09AM (#45888120)
why?
Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by baal80spam on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @01:41PM (#45891121)
Probably because something something Nazi.
Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by diamond559 on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @02:38PM (#45891797)
Well the guy that owns it sieg heiled on stage twice so... Do you not have working eyes, or does something prevent you from acknowledging reality?
Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by array_key_first on Thursday November 13, 2025 @10:30PM (#45923538)
It's run by an insane person and insane people are generally very volatile and difficult to rely on.

I mean, even just the name - 'X'. You can tell that's some Elon Musk bullshit because it's the stupidest fucking name I've ever heard in my life and nobody with even a quarter of a brain would ever suggest that as a brand name.

When that's literally the brand of your company, naturally I question if everyone has the screws tightened up there, you know?

Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by JustExAWS on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @02:16PM (#45891533)
Twitter never had a meaningful customer base compared to Meta and it’s been declining since Musk took over.
Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by tarsinge on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @05:47AM (#45885961)
This argument regarding brand loyalty gets repeated but it’s really weak to me. The immense majority of people don’t tie their identity to the software services they are using. Without network effects or an ecosystem locking customers will switch as soon as there is a less expensive and/or better alternative, as the history of software has shown countless of times.
Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by Topfi on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @07:29AM (#45886534)
Keep in mind how severely the quality of Google search results or e.g. any consumer facing piece of Microsoft software (Windows, Office, OneDrive, etc.) have deteriorated to the point it has far transcended the more nerdy corners of the web, yet both continue to retain a strict grip, thanks to buy in/brand strength.
Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by ForHackernews on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @07:37AM (#45886597)
There's no viable alternative for either of those yet. Massive network effects around Microsoft office, and Google's only real competition is the equally-bad Bing.
Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by Topfi on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @07:56AM (#45886763)
Both DuckDuckGo and Kagi are, purely focused on result quality in 2025 far better than Google currently, but that does not matter if one has no need beyond the most basic results.

And much of the MS Office suite is actually a worse copy of another product, merely copied and forced via network effect. There are more than enough far better alternatives to e.g. Teams and OneDrive. The latter even makes Excel far less reliable to the point of unusability.

Not to mention Windows is easily replaced for the truly average person who spends their entire computer use inside a Chromium browser nowadays. Outside PC Gaming (which is far from the average if we are honest), the vast majority of people never touch software that isn’t already on mobile or more likely exclusively in the browser.

Familiarity and brand strength, not need or compatibility, keep the customer facing offerings of MSFT going. That isn’t inherently unreasonable either, for these people Windows is fine as Chrome works well enough on it and they do not have any needs beyond that, so why switch. Same with search, Google still finds flights, restaurants, Wikipedia, etc.

Being better is worth little if the vast majority are sufficiently well catered to by the incumbent.

Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by ForHackernews on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @01:05PM (#45890675)
DDG uses Bing's index. Kagi costs money. But you knew that already.
Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by Topfi on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @02:35PM (#45891769)
Kagi gives you free searches and you pay for Google with you data/advertisements so it costs something too, but you knew that already. And both provide more reliable results, so what are you trying to say?
Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by boredtofears on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @02:11PM (#45891451)
> Both DuckDuckGo and Kagi are, purely focused on result quality in 2025 far better than Google currently

I wish this was true

Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by Topfi on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @03:13PM (#45892204)
You don't have to take my word for it. Open the three next to each other, type in a search query. Only one will provide part of the results as a wildly inaccurate "overview" that somehow manages to link to sources telling you the opposite or contradicts itself inside the text box, which can also not be deactivated. Those are the results you get from Google and that alone makes quality worse, pure and simple.

More subjectively, but if you want to ignore the "AI overview" and consider that not results (then why are they on my results page?!), just look for a specific, slightly older video on Youtube, a site Alphabet themselves run. You can provide the exact title down to the letter and are in many instances going to struggle to find it with Youtube search or Googles Video Search, even when wrapping in ", etc. Kagi and DDGs video search tabs meanwhile yield the desired results. Again, this doesn't mean they are amazing or massively far ahead as Google was able to reliably provide such results in the past. It just means that Google Search has regressed, yet users stuck with it because, as I've been saying, quality (or lack thereof) has a hard time overcoming brand strength.

Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by boredtofears on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @07:24PM (#45894800)
I had DDG set as my default for years and found myself resorting back to google so often I had to finally admit to myself their results were inferior even to the diminished google result. I just didn’t seem to get the result you’re claiming on the everyday type of queries I make.
Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by tim333 on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @08:09PM (#45895216)
>Windows is easily replaced for the truly average person who spends their entire computer use inside a Chromium browser nowadays

Maybe I'm out of touch but I don't know anyone for whom that's true. They all use either games or Office or Photoshop type stuff.

I mean you can replace it but all the options - mac, linux or chromebooks have friction.

Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by Topfi on Wednesday November 12, 2025 @03:00AM (#45897479)
Gaming on PC or using Adobe software is very far removed from the average in 2025. Same if you use any Office application after work hours. Heck, even Canva is, the vast majority of users are not creating on their systems, solely consuming and would be served more than well enough with only their phones. In countries where most of the population has gotten access after modern multitouch smartphones became a thing, most do use these over notebooks/PCs as their primary device, like India.

And friction on MacOS, Linux, ChromeOS, Android or iOS, I don’t see that considering the vast majority still switched to 10 despite the departure from a decades long established environment and, lest we forget, quite a lot of XP/98 software also did not work well on more modern Windows, again, not really a problem for these either. There is no reason not to switch despite the brand, which I again must emphasize, is ok. They are fine enough with the status quo, even though alternatives would be more stable, secure, have better battery life, etc. I just dislike the idea that some in the space cling to that better alternatives are surely going to be adopted and the only reason they aren’t by the masses is compatibility, slight differences in UI, etc.

Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by tarsinge on Wednesday November 12, 2025 @03:43AM (#45897806)
I have been using DDG for years and even with Google quality having plunged it is neither better nor less expensive (nor the default when non technical users just type in the search bar of their browser). Yahoo has shown that even with immense brand recognition people will still switch if the alternative is really better. And if Google was 2x more expensive than DDG they’d switch too.

Regarding Microsoft it’s not as easy to switch as going on another website, OpenAI doesn’t have that ecosystem lock in.

Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by Topfi on Wednesday November 12, 2025 @06:45AM (#45898975)
> Yahoo has shown that even with immense brand recognition people will still switch if the alternative is really better.

But it didn’t, Google users beyond a few initial super users who switched early on in the late nineties/early two thousands, track directly with the massive growth in new active web users. These new first time web users, far more than switching made up the growth between 2002-2006 that made Google dominant over Yahoo. It also should be kept in mind how much better Google was over Yahoo, whereas I am doubtful LLMs will have such deviations in quality, looks more like the opposite.

Point remains, OpenAI will, in my opinion, retain the strongest consumer share of LLMs, regardless of output quality, introduction of ads, etc.

This is not ecosystem lock in, it is solely branding. What do you think most have in mind when you mention search? What when it comes to online shopping? Now do the same for “AI”. Only one brand comes to mind for most.

Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by array_key_first on Thursday November 13, 2025 @10:26PM (#45923513)
It's due exclusively to network effects.

People use Google search because they have (or rather, need) a Google account. Also, there are no alternatives really, because search is very difficult.

Microsoft has alternatives, but it doesn't matter, because you're artificially restricted from using them. All your friends (MBAs who cut your check) are using Excel, so why don't you just use Excel too?

Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by stingraycharles on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @07:24AM (#45886496)
no but there’s the network effect that Google has / once had with search that OpenAI has with ChatGPT: user interactions. all that data and classification will help tremendously getting better datasets, which is equally important (or more important) than better algorithms.
Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by JustExAWS on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @02:08PM (#45891416)
And defaults matter - every browser that matters except for Edge defaults to Google as well as every mobile phone outside of China.

Both Google and Apple (ie any searches in Safari make money for Apple based on the Google deal) said there was no slowdown on Google searches and the “AI overview” by Google is “good enough”.

Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by chemmail on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @06:52AM (#45886294)
It’s going be pretty hard to dethrone Google when even Apple is going to Google for AI with another huge billion $ contract.
Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by Topfi on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @07:23AM (#45886486)
In fairness, that is for their model, not their brand. In this industry, the mind share and buy in OpenAI has is still second to none, even when Gemini 2.5 Pro served the vast majority of users far better than the OpenAI models, the latter MAU trounced all competitors.

We do not know for certain as of yet, but I’d be very surprised if Apple felt the need to loudly communicate to their user base that the upcoming Siri improvements aren’t Apple Intelligence. They won’t lie of course, but Googles brand in the space isn’t nearly as strong with the layperson, whereas they more than happily shouted their use of GPT from the rooftops initially.

Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by DANmode on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @11:28AM (#45889216)
This year.

Apple is in the business of contracting out new-hotness until their polish is done.

Then they put their name on the thing, pretend it’s new technology – and depending on the named feature, sometimes it is!

Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by nly on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @04:43AM (#45885649)
It's hard to see how they become profitable enough to justify current valuations.

The numbers are just mind boggling even in the optimistic scenario.

Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by hobofan on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @06:16AM (#45886108)
If they are able to actually successfully pivot into ads as a business model, it's very easy to justify the valuation: Just look at Google/Meta.

I'm personally skeptical that they are able to pull off ads, at least on the short timescale they likely need to. They more or less have to nurture/disrupt a whole SEO industry, and the way big corps allocate advertising budgets are very slow to shift (many are still struggling to find their footing in social media advertising).

Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by disgruntledphd2 on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @07:40AM (#45886625)
> If they are able to actually successfully pivot into ads as a business model, it's very easy to justify the valuation: Just look at Google/Meta.

Ads are not just a switch one can turn on. Firstly, you need to build a decent ad serving/targeting/pacing engine. Secondly (and more importantly) you need to hire a shed ton of sales people (in many, many geos) and then ramp them all up (difficult if you're building the product at the same time).

And then you need to keep at it for 3-5 years minimum before you'll finally get the bigger/more conservative brands/agencies/etc to buy in properly.

At that point, you'll make decent money, after accounting for all of the costs. I'm not sure that you'll make enough money, but it would definitely stanch their bleeding a little.

tl;dr if they haven't already built this ad product, it's unlikely to make a material difference before 2030.

Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by mvdtnz on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @12:27PM (#45890187)
Why should they give a fuck about the SEO industry? You think Google "nurtures" the SEO industry? They're selling ads to businesses and displaying them to consumers. SEO folks are just parasites in the system.
Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by hobofan on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @02:09PM (#45891428)
Yes of course Google nurtures the SEO industry. The first hit I get when I google SEO is a best practice site from Google themselves.

The person/department/agency that is responsible for doing SEO is the same one that is responsible for spending ad money on Google. It's in their best interest to internally sell "search" (no matter if organic/inorganic) as a good advertising channel and that creates great stickiness for Google's ad business.

Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by NitpickLawyer on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @05:52AM (#45885999)
I can see a world where if everything they do pans out, on average 1B "entities" end up paying 20$/mo to openAI, via the myriad of integrations they end up supporting. Where entity can be a user, and one human can have many entities (i.e. a work account where the company pays, a personal account, etc). That'd be a quarter of a T$ revenue / year. Dunno, while the number is so large it's hard to compute, it somewhat seems plausible.
Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by iso1631 on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @07:24AM (#45886501)
And then they'll ruin it all by injecting adverts to get an extra $20b a year in revenue
Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by esafak on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @02:13PM (#45891480)
Their goal is obviously to take a fraction of the world's economy, proportional to the productivity lift they can attribute to themselves. That's in the trillions.
Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by rchaud on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @05:47PM (#45893948)
How does one take a fraction of the world economy?

Microsoft sells services pretty much everywhere on earth and has a near-monopoly on PC OSes, enterprise email, productivity suites plus a giant cloud computing service....and their annual revenue last year was just $245 billion.

OAI can't get anywhere close to that, not least because they have multiple competitors and several large corporations (MSFT, Google, Meta) would rather dogfood their own solutions than use a rival's.

Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by yesco on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @09:47AM (#45887830)
I'd argue their brand might be too strong, ChatGPT has already begun to enter the same semantic space as "Velcro". Everyone I know seems to have tried it yet quickly you begin to realize that for most people ChatGPT == LLM, it seems everyone is using "ChatGPT" on completely different platforms.

In the end, regardless of technical understanding, people will always shop around on price if the feature set is similar enough I suppose.

Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by JustExAWS on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @01:58PM (#45891321)
ChatGPT though isn’t where the profit id going to come from. Businesses using LLMs are and Amazon (AWS) is not selling access to Bedrock and neither is Google (GCP). Models are becoming a commodity. *Every* implementation I’ve done one of the requirements is to easily be able to switch between multiple models
Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by roncesvalles on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @06:47PM (#45894487)
The thing is, laypeople aren't using anything other than Google Search even for LLM answers.

If I want an LLM answer to "is erythritol bad for you", I'm not firing up ChatGPT. I'm just typing it into Google, and the LLM answer it spits out is pretty good.

ChatGPT needs to be significantly more compelling for most people to use it for one-shot LLM answers over Google Search. And the minute Google removes the one-shottedness of its search answers, it's over for ChatGPT.

Imo ChatGPT is just "a feature not a product", in the search engine space, as the adage goes.

Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by marcus_holmes on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @11:33PM (#45896401)
I have no idea on the data, but anecdotally I'd dispute this. Regular folks in my life (i.e. non-techies) routinely talk to an LLM and use it to answer questions that 5 years ago they'd have searched for.

The techies are the ones who are steering clear and sticking with search engines in my experience.

Re:SoftBank sells its entire stake in Nvidia for $5.83B by butlike on Wednesday November 12, 2025 @11:11AM (#45901923)
It's a Google without ads right now. Worth using until that day comes