This incentivises the rich to split up their fortune, and allows the poor to keep control of objects with emotional luggage.
That said, if the value of your house has grown tenfold, it is most likely because the community added that value. And so I don't think it is necessarily wrong if that same community sees some of that value back.
Someone who wants to spend an inheritance is going to do it, whether it’s liquid (cash) or marginally less so (real property)
Once you sell it you pay more taxes. Do you think any of the money you got will go to your kids, or even grandkids? Id say in 80% of all cases it will be long gone before that time comes.
You are not "earning" something you are continuing to "own" something that was already yours, shared with people who were here and are no longer here.
I only spent about twenty two years in my parent's house (well less, because we moved), but you're making an emotive argument while I was arguing more from a data-driven point of view.
The Irish inheritance tax is more generous to children (325k euro per child is tax free), but even in the UK, my three siblings and I would have paid zero tax. And our inheritance is quite large, lots of people in the UK & Ireland inherit much less.
Like, the ONS data[0] (which covers 2014-16) suggests that most inheritences go to the top quintile in terms of income (which anecdotally matches my experience) so this is a tiny, tiny problem in societal terms.
I get that inheritance tax is very emotive (particularly around family homes), but given that the vast majority of wealth is in property (except for that of the 0.1%), then I think inheritance tax is a pretty good one, and am happy that it's something that my kids will have to worry about, assuming we're lucky enough to leave them anything.
For context, I regard inherited wealth as mostly unfair, as the children of successful people have often had lots of advantages afforded to them already, so I'm not sure why those advantages should compound over generations.
[0]: https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/personal...
Note: the ONS statistics are weird, talking about inheritances and gifts interchangeably and the numbers seem far too low. Figure 7 shows the unfairness clearly, IMO.
we all make our own way in the modern world and i feel as a society we try to not just leave it to fate and how gilded the vagina you crawled out of was
What you do with your life is up to you, but having a guardrail can make life just that more pleasant. Life should not be about counting cents and going from pay-check to pay-check.
The inheritance tax has to go somewhere. It could go into science and infrastructure and then everyone gets richer. Or it could be paid out as a dividend, then everyone below the average gets richer. There are many options here. Just saying "inheritance tax bad" without talking about the output side of such a tax is by definition going to be... well.. weird.
So we shouldn't really argue for raising or lower taxes, we should argue for spending it better.
Ridiculous straw man, because this is like saying income tax should be abolished because minimum wage people can't afford it. Yeah no shit that's why it's progressive. In the case of inheritance, even a 0% bracket until ~1M$ will mean the tax leaves the middle class entirely unaffected while ensuring massive feudal-levels of generational wealth are at least curbed, and turned over to the commons.
This means your 800K asset maybe gives you 650K, and from that sum you still pay the inheritance tax + sales tax (thats usually in the 20% range).
You will likely get somewhere in the 450-500K for an asset that was worth 800K.
This is how to poor will remain poor.
The whole property market in UK is a pyramid scheme, time to realize that.
The whole system is FUBARed.
Right now (where i live) you pay a big tax on inheritance, this is ok if you only inherit cash. In 99% of inheritances this is not the case. You inherit family home, a cottage etc. Then you must sell because you cant afford to pay for it. Now the asset is gone forever and the next generation will most likely inherit nothing.
Its really hard to keep anything of value in the family because of this, that one house that was purchased for 60K is now somehow worth 600K (even it has all kinds of problems) and you need to take a loan just to keep it.
By taxing inheritance its sure that decendants that work basic jobs will forever be poor.