News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by paxys on Monday November 03, 2025 @05:41PM (#45805349)
Why would companies sell you the golden goose when they can instead sell you an egg every day?
Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by codegeek on Monday November 03, 2025 @06:02PM (#45805520)
You could say the same thing about Computers when they were mostly mainframe. I am sure someone will figure out how to make it commoditized just like personal computers and internet.
Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by fph on Monday November 03, 2025 @06:22PM (#45805697)
An interesting remark: in the 1950s-1970s, mainframes were typically rented rather than sold.
Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by vjvjvjvjghv on Monday November 03, 2025 @06:45PM (#45805872)
It looks to me like the personal computer area is over. Everything is in the cloud and accessed through terminals like phones and tablets.
Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by freedomben on Monday November 03, 2025 @08:23PM (#45806537)
And notably, those phones and tablets are intentionally hobbled by the device owners (Apple, Google) who do everything they can to ensure they can't be treated like personal computing devices. Short of regulatory intervention, I don't see this trend changing anytime soon. We're going full on in the direction of more locked down now that Google is tightening the screws on Android.
Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by DevKoala on Monday November 03, 2025 @06:55PM (#45805949)
Because someone else will sell it to you if they dont.
Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by worldsayshi on Monday November 03, 2025 @06:05PM (#45805547)
Well if there's at least one competitor selling golden geese to consumers the rest have to adapt.

Assuming consumers even bother to set up a coop in their living room...

Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by kakapo5672 on Monday November 03, 2025 @06:06PM (#45805553)
Because companies are not some monolith, all doing identical things forever. If someone sees a new angle to make money, they'll start doing it.

Data General and Unisys did not create PCs - small disrupters did that. These startups were happy to sell eggs.

Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by otterley on Monday November 03, 2025 @06:15PM (#45805640)
They didn't create them, but PC startups like Apple and Commodore only made inroads into the home -- a relatively narrow market compared to business. It took IBM to legitimize PCs as business tools.
Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by saltysalt on Monday November 03, 2025 @05:43PM (#45805364)
Exactly! It's a rent-seeking model.
Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by echelon on Monday November 03, 2025 @05:48PM (#45805404)
> I look forward to the "personal computing" period, with small models distributed everywhere...

Like the web, which worked out great?

Our Internet is largely centralized platforms. Built on technology controlled by trillion dollar titans.

Google somehow got the lion share of browser usage and is now dictating the direction of web tech, including the removal of adblock. The URL bar defaults to Google search, where the top results are paid ads.

Your typical everyday person uses their default, locked down iPhone or Android to consume Google or Apple platform products. They then communicate with their friends over Meta platforms, Reddit, or Discord.

The decentralized web could never outrun money. It's difficult to out-engineer hundreds of thousands of the most talented, most highly paid engineers that are working to create these silos.

Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by NemoNobody on Monday November 03, 2025 @07:31PM (#45806220)
Ok, so Brave Browser exists - if you download, you will see 0 ads on the internet, I've never really seen ads on the internet - even in the before brave times.

Fr tho, no ads - I'm not making money off them, I've got no invite code for you, I'm a human - I just don't get it. I've probably told 500 people about Brave, I don't know any that ever tried it.

I don't ever know what to say. You're not wrong, as long as you never try to do something else.

Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by echelon on Monday November 03, 2025 @07:46PM (#45806321)
If everyone used Brave, Google wouldn't be a multi-trillion dollar company pulling revenues that dwarf many countries.

Or rather, they'd block Brave.

Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by acheron on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @01:19AM (#45807881)
Brave is just a rebranded Chrome. By using it you’re still endorsing Google’s control of the web.
Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by makingstuffs on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @04:44AM (#45809101)
I was gonna say this. If Google decides to stop developing chromium then Brave is left with very few choices.

As someone who has been using brace since it was first announced and very tightly coupled to the BAT crypto token I must say it is much less effective nowadays.

I often still see a load of ads and also regularly have to turn off the shields for some sites.

Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by NemoNobody on Friday November 07, 2025 @01:01PM (#45849060)
How?? I watch Hulu ad supported without ads, YouTube no ads ever, screen never goes black, Viki ad supported free package - never seen an ad, Paramount ad package - never seen an ad.

I never have to turn off shields - on one hand the number of times I've had to do that.

Maybe I have something additional installed I don't know.

Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by saltysalt on Monday November 03, 2025 @05:51PM (#45805430)
I agree man, it's depressing.
Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by mulmen on Monday November 03, 2025 @05:57PM (#45805489)
Your margin is my opportunity. The more expensive centralized models get the easier it is for distributed models to compete.
Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by JumpCrisscross on Monday November 03, 2025 @08:19PM (#45806514)
> Why would companies sell you the golden goose when they can instead sell you an egg every day?

Because someone else can sell the goose and take your market.

Apple is best aligned to be the disruptor. But I wouldn’t underestimate the Chinese government dumping top-tier open-source models on the internet to take our tech companies down a notch or ten.

Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by paxys on Monday November 03, 2025 @08:57PM (#45806717)
By that logic none of us should be paying monthly subscriptions for anything because obviously someone would disrupt that pricing model and take business away from all the tech companies who are charging it? Especially since personal computers and mobile devices get more and more powerful and capable with every passing year. Yet subscriptions also get more prevalent every year.

If Apple does finally come up with a fully on-device AI model that is actually useful, what makes you think they won't gate it behind a $20/mo subscription like they do for everything else?

Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by JumpCrisscross on Monday November 03, 2025 @11:28PM (#45807419)
> By that logic none of us should be paying monthly subscriptions for anything because obviously someone would disrupt that pricing model and take business away from all the tech companies who are charging it?

Non sequitur.

If a market is being ripped off by subscription, there is opportunity in selling the asset. Vice versa: if the asset sellers are ripping off the market, there is opportunity to turn it into a subscription. Business models tend to oscillate between these two for a variety of reasons. Nothing there suggets one mode is infinitely yielding.

> If Apple does finally come up with a fully on-device AI model that is actually useful, what makes you think they won't gate it behind a $20/mo subscription like they do for everything else?

If they can, someone else can, too. They can make plenty of money selling it straight.

Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by Draiken on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @11:12AM (#45812604)
> If a market is being ripped off by subscription, there is opportunity in selling the asset.

Only in theory. Nothing beats getting paid forever.

> Business models tend to oscillate between these two for a variety of reasons

They do? AFAICT everything devolves into subscriptions/rent since it maximizes profit. It's the only logical outcome.

> If they can, someone else can, too.

And that's why companies love those monopolies. So, no... other's can't straight up compete against a monopoly.

Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by phinnaeus on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @08:01AM (#45810522)
What on-device app does Apple charge a subscription for?
Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by cloverich on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @11:46AM (#45813018)
Because they need to displace open AI users, or open AI will steer their trajectory towards Apple at some point.
Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by likium on Monday November 03, 2025 @09:55PM (#45806995)
Unfortunately, most people just want eggs, not the burden of actually owning the goose.
Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by gizajob on Monday November 03, 2025 @08:40PM (#45806630)
Putting a few boots in Taiwan would also make for a profitable short. Profitable to the tune of several trillion dollars. Xi must be getting tempted.
Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by CuriouslyC on Monday November 03, 2025 @10:39PM (#45807209)
It's a lot more complicated than that. They need to be able to take the island very quickly with a decapitation strike, while also keeping TSMC from being sabotaged or destroyed, then they need to be able to weather a long western economic embargo until they can "break the siege" with demand for what they control along with minor good faith concessions.

It's very risky play, and if it doesn't work it leaves China in a much worse place than before, so ideally you don't make the play unless you're already facing some big downside, sort of as a "hail Mary" move. At this point I'm sure they're assuming Trump is glad handing them while preparing for military action, they might even view invasion of Taiwan as defensive if they think military action could be imminent anyhow.

Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by JumpCrisscross on Monday November 03, 2025 @11:29PM (#45807429)
> then they need to be able to weather a long western economic embargo until they can "break the siege" with demand for what they control along with minor good faith concessions

And you know we'd be potting their transport ships, et cetera, from a distance the whole time, all to terrific fanfare. The Taiwan Strait would become the new training ground for naval drones, with the targets being almost exclusively Chinese.

Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by CuriouslyC on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @06:52AM (#45809902)
I worked with the Taiwanese Military, that's their dream scenario but the reality is they're scared shitless that the Chinese will decapitate them with massive air superiority. Drones don't mean shit without C2.
Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @06:58AM (#45809947)
> they're scared shitless that the Chinese will decapitate them with massive air superiority

Taiwan fields strong air defenses backed up by American long-range fortifications.

The threat is covert decapitation. A series of terrorist attacks carried out to sow confusion while the attack launches.

Nevertheless, unless China pulls off a Kabul, they’d still be subject to constant cross-Strait harassment.

Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by CuriouslyC on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @07:18AM (#45810051)
China has between 5:1 and 10:1 advantage depending on asset class. If not already on standby, US interdiction is ~48 hours. For sure China is going to blast on all fronts, so cyber and grid interruptions combined with shock and awe are definitely gonna be a thing. It's not a great setup for Taiwan.
Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by gizajob on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @08:09AM (#45810612)
Destroying TSMC or knowing it would be sabotaged would pretty much be the point of the operation. Would take 48 hours and they could be out of there again and say “ooops sorry” at the UN.
Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by CuriouslyC on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @10:05AM (#45811803)
Hard disagree. They need chips bad, and it's the US defense position that TSMC be destroyed if possible in the event of successful Chinese invasion. They also care about reunification on principle, and an attack like that without letting them force "One China" on the Taiwanese in the aftermath would just move them farther from that goal.
Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by troupo on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @02:12AM (#45808217)
> Apple is best aligned to be the disruptor.

It's this disruptor Apple in the room with us now?

Apple's second biggest money source is services. You know, subscriptions. And that source keeps growing: https://sixcolors.com/post/2025/10/charts-apple-caps-off-bes...

It's also that same Apple that fights tooth and nail every single attempt to let people have the goose or even the promise of a goose. E.g. by saying that it's entitled to a cut even if a transaction didn't happen through Apple.

Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by eloisant on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @05:16AM (#45809304)
Sure, the company that launched iTunes and killed physical media, then released a phone where you can't install apps ("the web is the apps") will be the disruptor to bring back local computing to users...
Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by positron26 on Monday November 03, 2025 @09:04PM (#45806749)
When the consumer decides to discover my site and fund federated and P2P infrastructure, they can have a seat at the table.
Re:AI's Dial-Up Era by anjel on Monday November 03, 2025 @09:58PM (#45807012)
Selling fertile geese was a winning and proven business biz model for a very long time.

Selling eggs is better how?