No, Weil said he himself misunderstood Sellke's post[1].
Note Weil's wording (10 previously unsolved Erdos problems) vs. Sellke's wording (10 Erdos problems that were listed as open).
Previously unsolved. The context doesn't make that true, does it?
Don't get me wrong, effectively surfacing unappreciated research is great and extremely valuable. So there's a real thing here but with the wrong headline attached to it.
If I said that I solved a problem, but actually I took a solution for an old book, people would call me a liar. If I was prominent person, it would be academic fraud incident. No one would be saying that "I did extremely valuable thing" or "there was a real thing here".
Henrietta Leavitt's work on the relation between a stars period of pulsation and brightness was tucked away in a Harvard Journal, which had revolutionary potential not appreciated until Hubbel recalled and applied her work years later to demonstrate galactic redshift in Andromeda, understanding that it was an entirely separate galaxy, that it was receding away from us and contributing to the bedrock of modern cosmology.
The pathogenic basis for ulcers was proposed in the 1940s, which later became instrumental to explaining data in the 1980s and led to a Nobel prize in 2005.
It is and has always been fundamental to the progress of human knowledge to not just propose new ideas but to pull pertinent ones from the literature and apply them in new contexts, and depending on the field, the research landscape can be inconceivably vast, so efficiencies in combing through it can create the scaffolding for major advancements in understanding.
So there's more going on here than "lying".
Survivor bias.
I can assure you that GPT-5 fucks up even relatively easy searches. I need to have a very good idea how the results looks like and the ability to test it to be able to use any result from GPT-5.
If I throw the dice 1000 times and post about it each time that I got a double six. Am I the best dice thrower that there is?
It is pretty hard to fuck that up, since you aren't expected to find everything anyway. The idea of "testing" and "using any result from GPT" is just, like, reading the papers and seeing if they are tangentially related.
If I may speak to my own experience, literature search has been the most productive application I've personally used, more than coding, and I've found many interesting papers and research directions with it.
It sounds like the content of the solutions themselves are perfectly fine, so it's unfortunate that the headline will leave the impression that these are just more hallucinations. They're not hallucinations, they're not wrong, they're just wrongly assigned credit for existing work. Which, you know, where have we heard that one before? It's like the stylistic "borrowing" from artists, but in research form.
Google's result has more recently been generalised: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506.13242
Some people just read the "48 multiplications for a 4x4 matrix multiplications" part, and thought they found prior art at that performance or better. But they missed that the supposed prior art had tighter requirements on the contents of the matrix, which meant those algorithms were not usable for implementing a recursive divide and conquer algorithm for much larger matrix multiplications.
Here is a HN poster claiming to be one of the authors rebutting the claim of prior art: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43997136
The deleted tweet that the article is about said "GPT-5 just found solutions to 10 (!) previously unsolved Erdös problems, and made progress on 11 others. These have all been open for decades." If it had been posted stand-alone then I would certainly agree that it was misleading, but it was not.
It was a quote-tweet of this: https://x.com/MarkSellke/status/1979226538059931886?t=OigN6t..., where the author is saying he's "pushing further on this".
The "this" in question is what this second tweet is in turn quote-tweeting: https://x.com/SebastienBubeck/status/1977181716457701775?t=T... -- where the author says "gpt5-pro is superhuman at literature search: [...] it just solved Erdos Problem #339 (listed as open in the official database erdosproblems.com/forum/thread/3…) by realizing that it had actually been solved 20 years ago"
So, reading the thread in order, you get
I think the problem here is the way quote-tweets work -- you only see the quoted post and not anything that it in turn is quoting. Kevin Weil had the two previous quotes in his context when he did his post and didn't consider the fact that readers would only see the first level, so wouldn't have Sebastien Bubek's post in mind when they read his.That seems like an easy mistake to entirely honestly make, and I think the pile-on is a little unfair.