News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OpenAI researcher announced GPT-5 math breakthrough that ... by OtherShrezzing on Sunday October 19, 2025 @10:52AM (#45634589)
Am I correct in thinking this is the 2nd such fumble by a major lab? DeepMind released their “matrix multiplication better than SOTA” paper a few months back, which suggested Gemini had uncovered a new way to optimally multiply two matrices in fewer steps than previously known. Then immediately after their announcement, mathematicians pointed out that their newly discovered SOTA had been in the literature for 30-40 years, and was almost certainly in Gemini’s training set.
Re:OpenAI researcher announced GPT-5 math breakthrough that ... by card_zero on Sunday October 19, 2025 @11:15AM (#45634779)
Well, it is important that we have some technology to prevent us from going round in circles by reinventing things, such as search.
Re:OpenAI researcher announced GPT-5 math breakthrough that ... by glenstein on Sunday October 19, 2025 @11:11AM (#45634739)
It's an interesting type of fumble too, because it's easy to (mistakenly!) read it as "LLM tries and fails to solve problem but thinks it solved it" when really it's being credited with originality for discovering or reiterating solutions already out there in the literature.

It sounds like the content of the solutions themselves are perfectly fine, so it's unfortunate that the headline will leave the impression that these are just more hallucinations. They're not hallucinations, they're not wrong, they're just wrongly assigned credit for existing work. Which, you know, where have we heard that one before? It's like the stylistic "borrowing" from artists, but in research form.

Re:OpenAI researcher announced GPT-5 math breakthrough that ... by ummonk on Sunday October 19, 2025 @12:50PM (#45635672)
We also had the GPT-5 presentation which featured both incorrect bar charts (likely AI generated) and an incorrect explanation of lift.
Re:OpenAI researcher announced GPT-5 math breakthrough that ... by ogogmad on Sunday October 19, 2025 @01:05PM (#45635810)
No, your claim about matrix multiplication is false. Google's new algorithm can be applied recursively to 4x4 block matrices (over the field of complex numbers). This results in an asymptotically faster algorithm for nxn matrix multiplication than Strassen's. Earlier results on 4x4 matrices by Winograd and others did not extend to block matrices..

Google's result has more recently been generalised: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506.13242

Re:OpenAI researcher announced GPT-5 math breakthrough that ... by jsnell on Sunday October 19, 2025 @01:32PM (#45636057)
That doesn't match my recollection of the AlphaEvolve release.

Some people just read the "48 multiplications for a 4x4 matrix multiplications" part, and thought they found prior art at that performance or better. But they missed that the supposed prior art had tighter requirements on the contents of the matrix, which meant those algorithms were not usable for implementing a recursive divide and conquer algorithm for much larger matrix multiplications.

Here is a HN poster claiming to be one of the authors rebutting the claim of prior art: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43997136

Re:OpenAI researcher announced GPT-5 math breakthrough that ... by whimsicalism on Monday October 20, 2025 @11:11AM (#45644847)
no, you are incorrect