This is LEO, so it's everyone's orbits. And in any case the big worry about space junk is not so much that it takes out one or one thousand existing satellites - which China could replace - but that it makes the orbits unusable by future spacecraft.
The point is that having junk in your own orbits is an interesting self goal. It opens the window to hybrid war strikes, for example.
It takes a lot of energy to change orbital planes. Debris tend to stay in constrained orbits (usually their original ones). If the upper stages are in the birds’ orbits (which is a big if), the debris will all tend to stay there.
> they have the capabilities to do it in a more targeted manner
But not plausibly deniable. My point is China is leaving the front door open to shenanigans by leaving high-energy mass next to its birds. (If, again, it is.)
I don't see any plausibly deniable scenario involving apparent spent rocket stages suddenly reanimating in militarily useful way. c.f. routine electronic warfare jamming. Even a "malfunctioning satellite" would have more deniability, and certainly equal ability to threaten others' space assets.
"Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity."
A common way to do that is to perform an extra burn and tip the second stage's orbit into the atmosphere - so that it burns up in a controlled manner. That's what's done on Starlink launches - the most common type of US launch.
Other countries may choose not to do that, because the second stage has to be designed to allow for those extra burns, and the fuel used cuts straight into the performance margins.
> Are they in the same orbit as the satellites?
Not exactly. Most larger satellites nowadays carry their own fuel and engines, and perform orbital adjustments and station-keeping. Which has a way of putting distance between them and the second stages. They might end up in the same orbital plane, but not the same orbit.
For some satellite types, the second stage only gets the satellite to a transfer orbit - and the satellite itself gets to the deployment orbit from there under its own power.
The FCC individually licenses every launch, and explicitly cares about collision risk. I'm not sure if there's a specific rule about when second stages must be deorbitted, but I'm pretty sure that if a launch provider intended to leave a second stage in a crowded orbit the FCC would cause trouble for them.
Of course the above is a game of prisoners dilemma. You are risking others defecting first. In the current situation there doesn't seem to be much cost if you are last to defect (since regulations will come in just a few rounds). In other situations there can be great gain in defecting first.
Edit: I stand corrected!
The FCC does deal with disposal requirements for US satellites that are launched. In order to secure a license from the FCC you have to prove that your satellite will meet the latest guideline that it will be disposed of (either de-orbit for LEO, or moved to disposal orbit for higher orbits) within 5 years after mission complete [2]. Unfortunately this doesn't seem to apply to upper stages for some reason even though I would say that it is an orbit object that gets licensed and would "complete the mission" after deploying the satellites and have to abide by the 5 year rule.
[0] https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/faa-proposed-rule-would-reduce-...
[1] https://spacenews.com/faa-to-complete-orbital-debris-upper-s...
Edit: The FAA is also proposing orbital debris rules that were supposed to be finalized this year, but aren't released yet[2]. This whole area is a mess, and really needs congress to set clear responsibilities.
[1] https://www.fcc.gov/space/orbital-debris
[2] https://spacenews.com/faa-to-complete-orbital-debris-upper-s...
In 2022, the FCC adopted a “5-Year Rule” requiring that satellites in low Earth orbit (below ~2,000 km) be disposed of (deorbited or moved to a safe disposal orbit) “as soon as practicable but no later than five years after mission completion.”
It used to be 25 years but less stringent and more of a guideline. This is problematic for CubeSats that are already on tight budgets and some are requiring redesign like AMSAT’s
[1] https://www.n2yo.com/satellite/?s=61448
I know I read about another over the last year, but can't remember of the top of my head.
1. 2024-125H — Firefly Alpha FLTA005 Stage 2, launching demo cubesats for NASA
2. 2025-077C — Orbital Minotaur IV (8) Stage 4 (Orion 38), launching a few spy satellites
Fun fact: the first stage of the latter rocket was manufactured in 1966.
Was it? Minotaurs repurposed components of Peacekeeper missiles. Development of the SR118 first stage motor—reused as the first stage on Minotaur IV—didn’t start until 1978. [1, pg16]
[1]: https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20120016230/downloads/20...
[1]: https://spaceflightnow.com/2021/06/15/three-nro-satellites-l...
> China launched 21 of the 26 hazardous new rocket bodies over the last 21 months, each averaging more than 4 metric tons (8,800 pounds). Two more came from US launchers, one from Russia, one from India, and one from Iran
What are the American ones?
> most of the rockets used for Guowang and Thousand Sails launches have left their upper stages in orbit
Are they in the same orbit as the satellites? If so, China is effectively mining their own constellations.
(Side note: Ars is usually much better at citing its sources. This is terribly written by their standards.)