News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by mbesto on Sunday September 21, 2025 @06:58PM (#45327428)
This is a very poorly researched article. A few things worth considering:

- 20,000 mAh is the rated capacity. Anyone who has tested 18650 batteries (which are the cells typically used in these battery packs) knows the rated capacity != tested capacity.

- Watthours is more important than amp hours

- Tested watt hours as typical loads is more important than amp hours

- It's very normal to see tested capacity to be roughly 70~80% of rated capacity.

- This commenter said they got "At 18W average, I pulled out 55.4Wh" on the Haribo [0]

- The generally considered "gold standard" for ultra light batteries in this range is the Nitecore NB20000 Gen 3, which regularly tests around 56 Wh.

So yes the conclusion is correct - you get roughly the same amount of capacity for a typical load (18W phone) for a cheaper price and slightly less weight. Very curious what battery cells the Haribo uses.

[0] - https://old.reddit.com/r/Ultralight/comments/1li5rxw/20000ma...

Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by coin on Sunday September 21, 2025 @08:12PM (#45327839)
> Watthours is more important than amp hours

I'd go a step further and say that amp hours is meaning less since voltage is not specified. The only valid battery capacity unit of measure is watt hours. While most battery packs use a single 3.7 lithium ion battery, Apple's first gen MagSafe battery pack used two internal batteries in series, throwing off everyone's amp hours only comparison.

The industry can a

Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by nwallin on Sunday September 21, 2025 @08:57PM (#45328092)
> The only valid battery capacity unit of measure is watt hours.

I would also accept Joules. But yes, the unit should be a unit of energy.

Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by macrocosmos on Sunday September 21, 2025 @09:07PM (#45328143)
We could also talk about lb•AU (pound Astronomical Units), but generally it's best to stick to what's standard so readers don't need to do conversions. Watt hours is great.
Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by fy20 on Monday September 22, 2025 @01:02AM (#45329241)
It's not terrible... The iPhone 17 has a battery capacity of 63 nano lb·AU. Around 16 million would equal 1 lb·AU.

Another fun one would be milli hundredweight leauge (mcwt·lg). Both hundredweight and league have multiple accepted definitions to make it more "fun". But the range maps quite nicely to everyday things:

AA battery - Around 5 mcwt·lg

Phone battery - Around 20 mcwt·lg

Laptop battery - Around 200 mcwt·lg

Car 12v battery - Around 1,000 mcwt·lg

EV battery - Around 100,000 mcwt·lg

Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by greesil on Sunday September 21, 2025 @09:37PM (#45328295)
I prefer to use British Thermal Units (BTU) for my battery capacity.
Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by SV_BubbleTime on Monday September 22, 2025 @12:40AM (#45329138)
I use calories… then I can plan my meals and electronics together.
Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by user_7832 on Monday September 22, 2025 @12:58AM (#45329224)
I know it's a matter of taste but personally I prefer to use the Calorie instead of the calorie ;)

(Context: 1 Calorie = 1 kilocalorie = 1000 (gram) calories; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calorie)

Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by vidarh on Monday September 22, 2025 @04:09AM (#45330449)
> 1000 (gram) calories

The "(gram)" make no sense here. We commonly use "kilo" as shorthand for kilogram", but kilo is just a prefix indicating 1000 and never indicates "kilogram" when given as a prefix to another unit, and so there's no implied/left out "gram" in 1 kilocalorie.

Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by spuz on Monday September 22, 2025 @04:15AM (#45330481)
1 kilogram Calorie is the amount of energy needed to raise the temperature of one kilogram of water by 1 degree. 1 gram calorie is the amount of energy needed to raise the temperature of 1 gram of water by 1 degree.
Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by vidarh on Monday September 22, 2025 @04:45AM (#45330683)
I see there's some use of it after having done some searches, so I'll concede it makes some minor sense as a means to disambiguate due to the Calorie/calorie confusion. Especially as "calorie" and "gram calorie" then means the same thing. This is actually the first time I can recall having seen anyone use it, though, and so for me at least it confused matters rather than clear it up...
Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by eesmith on Monday September 22, 2025 @03:49AM (#45330312)
Today I learned there are multiple BTU definitions. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_thermal_unit lists Thermochemical, 59 °F, 60 °F, 39 °F, and International Steam Table.

Though as the difference is at most 0.5%, it's probably won't affect your battery buying experience. :)

Measuring by TNT equivalent is more standardized. "This battery stores 50 grams of TNT."

Ummm, on second thought, maybe don't use that term at the airport, .. or in secure areas, ... or near the police, ... or in public, ... or on social media or anything else tapped by the NSA or other authorities.

Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by beAbU on Monday September 22, 2025 @02:43AM (#45329848)
You are probably making a joke, but just in case and for those that don't know, a joule _is_ a watt hour.

1 joule is 1 watt-second to be precise. So 1Wh is 3600 joules.

Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by numpad0 on Monday September 22, 2025 @05:37AM (#45331042)
So that's why it doesn't align with existing industry units and always requiring conversions...
Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by bregma on Monday September 22, 2025 @06:45AM (#45331599)
Thank goodness SI units are power-of-ten based so converting between watt hours and joules is just a matter of moving the decimal place. Oh, and throwing in an ancient Sumerian constant approximating the number of Earth rotations as it revolves around the sun once.
Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by numpad0 on Monday September 22, 2025 @07:15AM (#45331836)
No, Watt-second-hour = 3.6 kJ, so J to Wh is moving the decimal place couple steps AND dividing by 3.6. The actual units used in circuit designs is mAh, so the decimal has to be moved for another time then divided by 3.7[V] again. That's too much for a smooth-brained man like I am.
Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by lotsofpulp on Monday September 22, 2025 @07:07AM (#45331775)
Do seconds have anything to do with the Earth rotating around the sun? I thought a second just has to do with the Earth’s rotation on its axis.

Also, I wonder how usable a unit of time that was not based on a day would be, since so much of our life revolves around that cycle.

Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by tnlnbn on Monday September 22, 2025 @08:16AM (#45332352)
Yes, seconds are related to the Earth rotating around the sun. Simplifying slightly, the normal definition of a day relates to how long for Earth to rotate on its axis until the same spot on the Earth points at the sun again.

Compare Mean solar day vs Stellar day vs Sideral day - the difference is less than 5 minutes or so.

Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by lotsofpulp on Monday September 22, 2025 @08:58AM (#45332795)
Thanks, I see now from:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_time

I was thinking along the lines of the ancient Sumerians arbitrarily deciding to divide 1 day into 24 hours, and 24 hours into 60 minutes, and 60 minutes into 60 seconds, and how that doesn't have anything to do with how humans came up with the concept of 1 year (the Earth rotating around the sun).

Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by sixothree on Monday September 22, 2025 @12:56AM (#45329209)
The package says 3.85v so certainly this is a lipo.
Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by emilfihlman on Sunday September 21, 2025 @08:03PM (#45327767)
>18650 batteries (which are the cells typically used in these battery packs)

Absolutely not. Pouch cells are what most powerbanks have.

Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by mbesto on Sunday September 21, 2025 @10:18PM (#45328508)
"Power bank cells are mainly divided into 18650 cells and polymer cells. The most common one on the market is 18650 lithium-ion batteries, with a market share of 70%."

https://www.benzoenergy.com/blog/post/type-of-cells-used-for...

Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by saidinesh5 on Sunday September 21, 2025 @10:50PM (#45328657)
Looks like the article you've shared is from 2019 (at the bottom of their page?).

Things changed a lot since then. Most power banks these days use just lipo pouches.

Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by 1oooqooq on Sunday September 21, 2025 @08:01PM (#45327759)
you don't have to go that far. probably that demographic won't even carry a power bank to begin with.
Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by serf on Sunday September 21, 2025 @09:08PM (#45328153)
you're never going to construct a lightweight pack with cylindrical (18650/21700, whatever) cells.

a real light weight battery construction isn't going to have redundant casings and fuses; it'll be the bare minimum pouch/plate style construction, the bare minimum fuses at main junctions, and as light a protective shell as can be produced to house it all in. It probably won't have a BMS of any kind on board, with the functions handled up-stream from the battery.

here's something close, although with plenty of weight compromise for reliability and safeties' sake. : https://global.honda/en/tech/motorsports/Formula-1/Powertrai...

Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by lelandbatey on Sunday September 21, 2025 @09:56PM (#45328385)
While that's technically true for highly specialized applications such as an F1 car such as the one you listed, the parent article is discussing USB compatible consumer battery banks. Consumer battery banks are worth building with cutting edge-but-still-mass-produced cells, multiple layers of redundancies, and integrated BMS.
Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by mrheosuper on Sunday September 21, 2025 @10:15PM (#45328495)
typical li-po pouch, bet it's 2*10Ah pouch connected in parallel.
Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by tredre3 on Sunday September 21, 2025 @10:22PM (#45328531)
I don't think this power bank uses 18650. You could fit 3 18650 in it, but the highest capacity 18650 out there is less than 15Wh and this advertises 77Wh. Even the tested capacity of 55Wh is higher than the before-loss 18650 capacity you could fit in it.

> This is a very poorly researched article

So, yeah, pot, kettle, all that.

Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by mbesto on Sunday September 21, 2025 @10:44PM (#45328630)
I think you're right, however, 18650 batteries do carry, on average, more energy density per volume and weight.

> but the highest capacity 18650 out there is less than 15Wh and this advertises 77Wh.

10x 2000 mAh 18650 batteries in parallel gives you 20 Ah @ 3.7V.

> So, yeah, pot, kettle, all that.

Totally unnecessary comment but thanks.

Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by n2d4 on Monday September 22, 2025 @02:30AM (#45329755)
> Totally unnecessary comment but thanks.

It's not more unnecessary than your comment about the OP article being poorly researched. If the conclusions are true, even if they didn't do the measurements themselves, I find it quite excusable to skip past the detailed specs of the battery.

Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by shlant on Monday September 22, 2025 @04:08AM (#45330448)
yea considering they made 6 bullet points all just to say "rated and tested capacities are usually different" reeked of pedantry (although not surprising as we are on a tech site) and IMO did not warrant the label of "very poorly researched article"
Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by anigbrowl on Sunday September 21, 2025 @10:42PM (#45328623)
It's consumerist advertorial, which is why most of it is filler. 'Decent seeming new power bank happens to look cute' isn't that interesting of a sotry, so it has to be spun into a phenomenon that will allow the article to link out to 10 different products.
Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by masklinn on Monday September 22, 2025 @01:14AM (#45329297)
> Watthours is more important than amp hours

Although that is completely true, pretty much all discussion, speccing, and marketing of batteries and power banks is done in Ah. So the article working in that unit is logical and consistent.

Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by beAbU on Monday September 22, 2025 @02:46AM (#45329866)
The bit that annoys me always (and what makes Ah a meaningless measurement for power banks) is whether the amp-hours rating is just the internal batteries' spec summed together, or is it as measured at the 5V outlet? Huge difference!
Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by masklinn on Monday September 22, 2025 @04:26AM (#45330564)
I would assume it’s whichever gives the highest number which is usually going to be the internal voltage.

For instance I have a 20000mAh power bank which also has a 74Wh capacity printed on, a conversion factor of 3.7V matching li-ion chemistry.

Not to mention with PD neither the neither input not output voltages are limited to 5V.

Re:Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power... by harrall on Monday September 22, 2025 @01:46AM (#45329483)
A lot of battery packs do not use 18650s but rather pouches, which are a lot smaller at the cost of some stability.