News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by kylecazar on Saturday September 20, 2025 @12:34PM (#45314843)
"Use minimalism to achieve clarity. While you are writing, ask yourself: is it possible to preserve my original message without that punctuation mark, that word, that sentence, that paragraph or that section?"

This echoes advice I first read in Strunk & White. It remains the most actionable tip for better writing I'm aware of, technical or otherwise.

Aside: I consider McCarthy's residency at SFI an ideal job

Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by nkrisc on Saturday September 20, 2025 @03:33PM (#45316556)
Reminds of this quote attributed to Dieter Rams:

> A designer knows that he has achieved perfection not when there is nothing to add, but when there is nothing to take away.

Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by shakow on Saturday September 20, 2025 @06:45PM (#45318278)
Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by amelius on Saturday September 20, 2025 @12:52PM (#45315002)
When I read papers I often think: if only the author had the space here to write two sentences instead of one, then perhaps I would immediately understand what they are trying to say.
Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by bbminner on Saturday September 20, 2025 @01:44PM (#45315482)
Oh, that's the only way to write a good paper - first you write 1.5x pages to figure out what you want to say, and then, with this knowledge, you replace entite confusing paragraphs with short sentences focused on exactly that. When i don't know how to express an idea, i ask myself "-so what idea are you trying to communicate? -well, that XYZ holds -if so, just go ahead write literally that!"
Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by raincole on Saturday September 20, 2025 @02:26PM (#45315911)
It's a great way to write fiction too. But only if you're not marrying to what you've written.
Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by Eugeleo on Saturday September 20, 2025 @06:32PM (#45318203)
FWIW I think this is exactly the opposite of what the OP was trying to say. I think the OP meant that they often wish authors had used more space to explain their ideas, because that would immediately make them more accessible.

And I must agree. I often feel papers are written with an extra 20% over the page budget, then condensed in the last minute to fit the constraints, which hurts the exposition.

Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by cyrillite on Saturday September 20, 2025 @01:19PM (#45315247)
Sometimes two sentences is the minimum necessary number of sentences, but everybody should be wary of that instinct
Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by tuatoru on Saturday September 20, 2025 @03:59PM (#45316830)
I routinely reduce my Readmes by 30% or more in the third draft.
Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by marcuskaz on Saturday September 20, 2025 @12:46PM (#45314949)
Sorry, but he takes it too far. McCarthy's omission of punctuation makes his books difficult to understand who is saying what, and a challenge to follow especially with dialogue. The Road and No Country for Old Men both do not contain quotation marks for speech, and he omits the common speech tags like "he said" or "she exclaimed" which makes it a challenge to know who is saying what. It is a choice and the art form he's choosing, but is far from writing for clarity.
Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by mariusor on Saturday September 20, 2025 @12:52PM (#45315007)
I would assume that his suggestions for clarity in "scientific papers" and his literary style don't overlap all that much to infer the former from the later.
Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by suuuuuuuu on Saturday September 20, 2025 @01:42PM (#45315466)
This is certainly the case, but it does make it all the more amusing that the myth

> Commas denote a pause in speaking.... Speak the sentence aloud to find pauses.

made its way into this article. Hard to imagine that this particular point, to which I might attribute many of the comma splices I see in scientific writing, actually came from a professional writer.

Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by jjmarr on Saturday September 20, 2025 @02:34PM (#45315998)
McCarthy's books involve unrelenting violence. If he viewed commas as pauses, it makes sense that he would never use them.
Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by oh_my_goodness on Saturday September 20, 2025 @06:48PM (#45318300)
It goes without saying that you're a better writer than Cormac McCarthy. Tell us something beyond that.
Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by suuuuuuuu on Saturday September 20, 2025 @08:11PM (#45318833)
The implication was that likely not all of the advice in this article, which was written by biologists, is actually attributable to McCarthy.
Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by greenie_beans on Saturday September 20, 2025 @01:38PM (#45315426)
> the former from the later

my writing advice:

never use the former and the latter

Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by mariusor on Saturday September 20, 2025 @02:16PM (#45315833)
Does it make me sound pretentious? That's fine, we're debating literary styles after all. :D
Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by greenie_beans on Saturday September 20, 2025 @03:59PM (#45316822)
no, it's just a stylistic pet peeve of mine. lacks specificity and always makes me have to think about which is the latter and which is the former, no matter how many times i look it up. scrambles my brain.
Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by jcul on Saturday September 20, 2025 @02:54PM (#45316196)
I recently read Blood Meridian, the only one of his books I've read. I agree this was a bit jarring and confusing at the start, but I got used to it by the end.

Though I haven't read any scientific papers, so can't comment on those.

Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by sacredSatan on Saturday September 20, 2025 @12:54PM (#45315021)
I agree about clarity, so this is just an aside but that's what makes it a fun experience for me. It's unlike reading anyone else (although I haven't read many authors). I'd say no country for old men was still pretty straightforward, but I had to re-read sentences and whole paragraphs with blood meridian.

The work makes it worth it, makes it that much more rewarding to me personally. It's like choosing to play a difficult videogame, because you know once you overcome it, it'll be great.

Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by marcuskaz on Saturday September 20, 2025 @01:01PM (#45315086)
I agree, his literary work is unique, and does take a bit more work to read, and with that it includes additional meaning behind it. For example, in The Road often times it doesn't even matter if its the boy or the man saying it.

However, I wouldn't take his advice on how to write for clarity. I too often found myself rereading paragraph, "wait is this description or dialogue", "who said that" - this is not what you want in scientific papers

Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by greenie_beans on Saturday September 20, 2025 @01:21PM (#45315261)
technical writing and fiction writing are two totally different forms of writing. the ability to modulate between those disciplines is the sign of a good writer.
Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by throwpoaster on Saturday September 20, 2025 @01:48PM (#45315531)
> The Road and No Country for Old Men both do not contain quotation marks for speech, and he omits the common speech tags like "he said" or "she exclaimed" which makes it a challenge to know who is saying what.

I am reading NC4OM right now and this is not, technically, the case. He does use those “speech tags”.

Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by paulpauper on Saturday September 20, 2025 @12:55PM (#45315030)
Aside: I consider McCarthy's residency at SFI an ideal job

This is a testament to just how multifaceted he was.

Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by sfpotter on Saturday September 20, 2025 @12:52PM (#45315005)
"A foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds."
Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by treetalker on Saturday September 20, 2025 @01:04PM (#45315127)
Yet behaving consistently according to well-chosen rules is a path to probable prosperity and, often, greatness.
Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by auggierose on Saturday September 20, 2025 @01:22PM (#45315278)
I guess that means that machines will be greater than man could ever hope for.
Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by sfpotter on Saturday September 20, 2025 @01:30PM (#45315345)
What kind of greatness? Or prosperity? Well-chosen according to whom?
Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by throwpoaster on Saturday September 20, 2025 @01:49PM (#45315543)
You’re using an absolute attachment to relativism to critique objectivism. This is a category error.
Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by sfpotter on Saturday September 20, 2025 @01:58PM (#45315643)
Strawman word salad.
Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by throwpoaster on Saturday September 20, 2025 @01:50PM (#45315548)
Big brain socialist “everything is a special case” quote.
Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by dsizzle on Saturday September 20, 2025 @01:56PM (#45315610)
Yes, I came here to say this sounds a lot like Strunk & White
Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by mhuffman on Saturday September 20, 2025 @07:42PM (#45318636)
"Use minimalism to achieve clarity. While you are writing, ask yourself: is it possible to preserve my original message without that punctuation mark, that word, that sentence, that paragraph or that section?"

This is rich, coming from the guy that spends multiple paragraphs describing an empty ditch in the desert.

Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by Eisenstein on Saturday September 20, 2025 @10:45PM (#45319580)
Apparently he thinks that is the minimum required. There is no metric included with the statement.
Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by chrisweekly on Saturday September 20, 2025 @10:51PM (#45319621)
"Perfection is achieved, not when there is nothing more to add, but when there is nothing left to take away."

- Antoine de St Exupery

Re:Novelist Cormac McCarthy's tips on how to write a great s... by riddley on Tuesday September 30, 2025 @09:49PM (#45433494)
"If I had more time, I would have written a shorter letter."