News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. has the critical minerals it needs – but they're bei... by eptcyka on Friday September 19, 2025 @06:36AM (#45300078)
You don't get to do that with people's lives.
Re:U.S. has the critical minerals it needs – but they're bei... by selimnairb on Friday September 19, 2025 @07:07AM (#45300250)
In starting from scratch, you also run the risk of recreating, from first principles, the thing your are trying to replace.
Re:U.S. has the critical minerals it needs – but they're bei... by coldtea on Friday September 19, 2025 @08:00AM (#45300619)
And in trying to merely restructure you're also running the risk to carry over all pathologies, bad actors, "code debt", and general baggage, of the thing you're trying to restructure.

Choices...

Re:U.S. has the critical minerals it needs – but they're bei... by selimnairb on Friday September 19, 2025 @09:04AM (#45301238)
Yeah, I think this is why starting with a smaller part(s) of a big system that is more-or-less working and building on that is maybe the best we can do.
Re:U.S. has the critical minerals it needs – but they're bei... by CaptainOfCoit on Friday September 19, 2025 @07:19AM (#45300328)
If only someone thought of this 240 years ago when some peeps got frustrated enough with their government to fight their way through a separation from that government.
Re:U.S. has the critical minerals it needs – but they're bei... by paulryanrogers on Friday September 19, 2025 @08:13AM (#45300747)
Or 165 years ago when people tried to fight through separation, and arguably got most of what they wanted even after losing.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j4kI2h3iotA

Re:U.S. has the critical minerals it needs – but they're bei... by serf on Friday September 19, 2025 @08:09AM (#45300705)
it's a shame government itself has never been bound by that rule in the past.
Re:U.S. has the critical minerals it needs – but they're bei... by coldtea on Friday September 19, 2025 @07:53AM (#45300556)
How do you think policy that affects whole groups of people, or even a whole country, is made? Not talking about just Trump/DOGE, or even just US or just 2025. In general and globally.

Goverments and lawmakers do get to "do that with people's lives". And they do that, affecting them, all the time. Including affecting them negatively a lot of the time.

And it gets worse: ineffective bureucracies (or incompetend ones) also "get to do that with people's lives"

["that" being: affecting them negatively, destroying their livehood, even causing deaths, e.g. consider some country's organization similar to FEMA being incompetent when there's a crisis].

Re:U.S. has the critical minerals it needs – but they're bei... by eptcyka on Friday September 19, 2025 @08:36AM (#45300957)
But you just don't get to start over with someone's life. You can't unfuck a life.
Re:U.S. has the critical minerals it needs – but they're bei... by bpt3 on Friday September 19, 2025 @08:10AM (#45300714)
What does this mean, practically?

We can never reduce the size of the federal workforce because it means people will lose jobs?

We can never cut any federal benefit or subsidy regardless of the cost, importance, or overall value to society because someone, somewhere is benefiting from it?

Re:U.S. has the critical minerals it needs – but they're bei... by paulryanrogers on Friday September 19, 2025 @08:16AM (#45300784)
Democrats significantly cut the government and Al Gore led the effort. It had some issues though is widely considered a success in hindsight. That was a scapel, DOGE appears to be a drunken flamethrower.
Re:U.S. has the critical minerals it needs – but they're bei... by bpt3 on Friday September 19, 2025 @09:18AM (#45301374)
Yes, I understand that Democrats have cut government in the past.

I was young, but I remember cries of "you can't do this to people!" then as well, just like we hear from a select group of people every time any cut is contemplated, which is why I asked the parent poster what exactly they mean by their comment.

Re:U.S. has the critical minerals it needs – but they're bei... by cjbgkagh on Friday September 19, 2025 @10:02AM (#45301796)
Democrats cut the government because they were unable to resist Republican cuts, so if we’re drawing a causal link I think it would be fairer to say Republicans made the cuts during a time when a Democrat was president. Also the public blamed the Republicans for the shutdowns which reelected Clinton and is probably the reason the Republicans stoped caring so much about the deficit.
Re:U.S. has the critical minerals it needs – but they're bei... by mhalle on Friday September 19, 2025 @08:24AM (#45300857)
Here is a reference to the "Reinventing Government" effort that was implemented during the Clinton administration and considered highly successful (and legal):

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Partnership_for_Rei...

Re:U.S. has the critical minerals it needs – but they're bei... by bpt3 on Friday September 19, 2025 @09:20AM (#45301392)
Yes, I am questioning whether the parent poster would have supported those cuts or uttered the same cry, as some individuals and communities were absolutely worse off after those cuts.
Re:U.S. has the critical minerals it needs – but they're bei... by lazide on Friday September 19, 2025 @06:55AM (#45300178)
Clearly you’ve never dealt with a government before.
Re:U.S. has the critical minerals it needs – but they're bei... by philipallstar on Friday September 19, 2025 @08:23AM (#45300837)
You can do it with structures maintained by taxing other people's labour, though.