News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by boopity2025 on Sunday September 14, 2025 @02:32AM (#45237928)
JWST just found a 50‑million‑solar‑mass black hole 750 million years after the Big Bang, with no galaxy around it. That’s not supposed to happen under the standard “stars → galaxies → black holes” model.

It’s pure hydrogen, so it formed before nearby stars had time to seed heavier elements. That leaves a few options: primordial black hole from the Big Bang, direct collapse of a gas cloud, or a galaxy that formed and disappeared.

There are ~300 similar “little red dots” in JWST data. If most are black holes, the early universe was building them in parallel with — or before — galaxies. Either way, the neat timeline in textbooks is wrong.

Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by codethief on Sunday September 14, 2025 @03:17AM (#45238141)
> the early universe was building them in parallel with — or before — galaxies

Reminds me of the "blowtorch theory"[0] discussed here on HN a while ago.

[0]: https://theeggandtherock.com/p/the-blowtorch-theory-a-new-mo...

Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by gus_massa on Sunday September 14, 2025 @07:40AM (#45239100)
HN discussion https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44115973 (187 points | 3 months ago | 180 comments)

Note that in spite of the name it's not a "theory" that gives an clear and accurate prediction.

We mix results of many theories, like electromagnetism, general relativity dopler effect, atoms ionization and spectrum, centripetal force, ... to get an accurate prediction and error estimation of how much mass a galaxy must have. Different calculations disagree, so we are forced to try to fix the theory (MOND) or guess there is dome difficut to see mass (dark matter).

The "blowtorch theory" is only a few general ideas and handwaving, without clear and precice calculations. So it's impossible to know if it explains all the current data (without dark matter) or even if the predictions digree so much with the current data that we need even more weird stuff to natch it.

Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by zero_bias on Monday September 15, 2025 @01:33AM (#45246422)
> Note that in spite of the name it's not a "theory" that gives an clear and accurate prediction.

It does make verifiable predictions, and moreover, these predictions are much easier to test than those of string theory, which involves a lot of mathematics but is still not considered a scientific theory because it is impossible to verify

Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by farnsworth on Sunday September 14, 2025 @08:50PM (#45244910)
I absolutely don't know enough to know how legit or ridiculous that idea is, but it's been stuck in my head ever since I read about it here, and it's been fun to mull over.
Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by Cthulhu_ on Sunday September 14, 2025 @03:52AM (#45238260)
Was it wrong, or based on incomplete data?
Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by tempodox on Sunday September 14, 2025 @04:25AM (#45238396)
If you draw conclusions from incomplete data, they tend to be wrong. Even Prof. van Dusen and Sherlock Holmes knew that. So if there were any difference, it would be sheer luck.
Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by perching_aix on Sunday September 14, 2025 @06:23AM (#45238802)
Both at the same time? Weird question.
Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by HPsquared on Sunday September 14, 2025 @06:26AM (#45238816)
In most fields it's impossible to have complete data.
Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by uncircle on Sunday September 14, 2025 @06:31AM (#45238832)
Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by sandworm101 on Sunday September 14, 2025 @03:30AM (#45238177)
Well, the black hole isnt hydrogen. This is the gas around it. And being pure hydrogen seems sus as there should be some helium in there according to most models.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_Bang_nucleosynthesis

Not only that, but getting stars to form using pure hydrogen is tricky. That helium helped early stars collapse and ignite. Not seeing any helium in an early-universe object is a big deal, suggesting some sort of error.

Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by felbane on Sunday September 14, 2025 @07:42AM (#45239107)
Bug fixes:

- Corrected an infrequent issue with getResultingProtonCount that would cause it to always return 1 for certain origin bodies.

(In the merge request comments: "This why we don't let junior devs commit unreviewed code to critical branches, guys.")

Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by reactordev on Sunday September 14, 2025 @06:59AM (#45238922)
If the theory of abnormal galaxy formation hold up, then the Big Bang was spitting out both simultaneously. Maybe there’s a mathematical “tipping point” for mass where the weight of it crushes the atoms? Resulting in early black holes from abnormal matter… not from a collapse but just from mass being in close proximity. There still so much to learn…
Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by gus_massa on Sunday September 14, 2025 @08:39AM (#45239374)
> “tipping point” for mass where the weight of it crushes the atoms?

If you have a material of constant density like water, bananas or rocks, then if you have a ball that is big enough you get a neutron star where all the atoms collapsed in a huge-mega-super-nuclei. (I think the surface may have some normal atoms, and the center may be even more strange.) If the ball is even more big enough you get a black hole. If you use a gas like Hydrogen that has no constant density, the calculation is similar, but more complex.

IANAA, but I expect that the collapse into the black hole does not capture the 100% of the initial mass if the object is a rotating irregular blob, so in this huge cases near the big bang I expect the leftover to form something that looks like a galaxy. And the lack of leftover is what is surprising. (Again, IANAA.)

Except in neutron stars and black holes, atoms are very stable. There are many conservation laws, like the number of leptons (like the electron) and barions (like the proton/neutron) that make it hard to create weird stuff. You can create weird stuff for a very short time, but almost immediately it goes back to normal stuff. As always, there may be some surprise in particle physics, but I don't remember or expect something like this.

Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by reactordev on Sunday September 14, 2025 @11:45AM (#45240687)
Not to quote a 90s New Zealand pop hit but… how bizarre!
Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by IAmBroom on Sunday September 14, 2025 @09:52AM (#45239740)
> Except in neutron stars and black holes, atoms are very stable.

Radioactive elements excepted, of course.

And when they get struck by ionizing photons.

So I would rather say: non-radioactive atomic nuclei are stable.

Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by Workaccount2 on Sunday September 14, 2025 @10:10AM (#45239837)
Radioactive atoms are just unstable atoms shedding energy to until they fall into a stable atom state.

It's not really atoms falling apart into non-atoms.

Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday September 14, 2025 @10:52AM (#45240190)
To be fair, everything is stable if we restrict ourselves to their stable subsets.
Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by IAmBroom on Monday September 15, 2025 @09:04AM (#45249202)
Exactly. It's like saying baked goods are shelf-stable because they degrade into humus, which is shelf-stable.
Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by BugsJustFindMe on Sunday September 14, 2025 @08:30AM (#45239320)
> It’s pure hydrogen

The gas around it is pure hydrogen. We can't know what's inside. Could be stacks of little green men and ponies in there.

Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by catchclose on Sunday September 14, 2025 @09:43AM (#45239691)
Maybe, lazy or tired light, and everything shifts towards specific spectral lines or frequencies/wavelengths at distant observation. Attenuates? Asymptotes to the hydrogen line?
Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by jfengel on Sunday September 14, 2025 @11:09AM (#45240334)
If light got tired it would make ordinary chemistry impossible. You wouldn't see spectra because atoms themselves would work differently (and probably not at all).

The fact that we can tell that it's hydrogen makes it extremely unlikely that light behaved differently there.

Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by adgjlsfhk1 on Sunday September 14, 2025 @10:02AM (#45239796)
that doesn't work out. from the spectra we're seeing hydrogen spikes red shifted, so the lack of any other spikes is very strong evidence
Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by catchclose on Sunday September 14, 2025 @02:14PM (#45242006)
!
Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by ndsipa_pomu on Sunday September 14, 2025 @08:35AM (#45239338)
Arguably, it makes no difference at all as to what's inside (apart from the inference that the early universe had lots of singularity seeking ponies and little green men)
Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by api on Sunday September 14, 2025 @09:50AM (#45239729)
Primordial black holes seem likely since many models predict them. They’re not a fringe idea.

They are also a dark matter candidate, though this is more controversial. The ones we are seeing here would be huge ones but their masses could range the spectrum. Smaller ones would have evaporated already but there could be tons of asteroid, moon, and planetary mass ones around.

At least some dark matter may be black holes the size of a hydrogen atom with the mass of an asteroid, and similar objects. These would be incredibly hard to detect. The only way would be their gravitational effects on other bodies or weak anomalous radiation bursts when they rarely encounter matter.

They’re also awesome and weird. One could, for example, shoot right through the Earth. If it was small nothing might happen. Larger ones might cause seismic events or perhaps Tunguska type events due to induced fusion in the atmosphere. What was Tunguska anyway?

The most exciting thing is that if small mass PBHs exist and are common enough, we could find one someday in our solar system, maybe captured as a moon or in an asteroid belt. That would be close enough to send a probe to go look at it and do experiments with it. Being able to directly examine a black hole could be the thing that lets us “finish” physics. It would let us see conditions far beyond anything any imaginable terrestrial accelerator could ever produce.

Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by WaxProlix on Sunday September 14, 2025 @12:23PM (#45241075)
I encountered a theory that 'planet x' might be such a PBH, explaining its ability to gravitationally impact post Neptunian bodies and its elusiveness. Would be incredibly cool to have something so exotic (or commonplace?) so close to home.

Cool idea on Tunguska - would such an explanation make predictions that we could verify? Radioactivity or changes to carbon in stones or the rings of local trees... An interesting thought.

Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by api on Sunday September 14, 2025 @01:24PM (#45241552)
If planet X exists and is a planetary mass PBH it could unlock the universe in many ways. We could use it as a gravitational slingshot to fire probes at significant fractions of the speed of light out for flyby surveys of other solar systems.
Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by dwaltrip on Sunday September 14, 2025 @02:05PM (#45241931)
It would make a better slingshot than a planet of the same mass?
Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by adgjlsfhk1 on Sunday September 14, 2025 @02:30PM (#45242135)
yes. you can get a lot closer to it.
Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by positron26 on Sunday September 14, 2025 @08:16PM (#45244698)
And you can pick how strong you want the gravity to be up to the event horizon
Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by BriggyDwiggs42 on Sunday September 14, 2025 @01:47PM (#45241742)
Probably a dumb question but at those energies would we be risking de-orbiting the black hole with such a maneuver?
Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by dtech on Sunday September 14, 2025 @02:32PM (#45242148)
No, for the same reason slingshotting on a planetary body now has no significant effect on it. The mass difference is too enormous.
Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by api on Sunday September 14, 2025 @03:00PM (#45242354)
It’s hard to visualize how weird and extreme black holes are.

A black hole with the mass of the Moon would be smaller than a BB but would have the mass and inertia of the Moon. It would be basically immovable as far as we are concerned. Chuck stuff at it all day and its trajectory change would be so small we probably wouldn’t be able to measure it.

Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by BriggyDwiggs42 on Sunday September 14, 2025 @04:04PM (#45242790)
That makes sense, thanks!
Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by adgjlsfhk1 on Sunday September 14, 2025 @02:31PM (#45242142)
no. if it has the mass of a planet, it has the inertia of a planet
Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by perihelions on Sunday September 14, 2025 @04:49PM (#45243114)
What's a plausible mechanism for that? There's no net change in speed in a two-body interaction. The conventional slingshot mechanism is a three-body interaction that involves a massive planet's rotation around the sun, but that's a very low speed for Planet 9—much slower than i.e. Jupiter.
Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by api on Sunday September 14, 2025 @07:24PM (#45244332)
Oberth effect is one:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oberth_effect

Fire a super high thrust engine during flyby.

If the PBH were in orbit around the Sun I don’t see why a conventional gravity assist would not work, but an Oberth effect maneuver would be more powerful.

Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by perihelions on Monday September 15, 2025 @09:44AM (#45249686)
When you have a conventional gravity assist, the speed (magnitude) is unchanged in the coordinate frame of the planet that's providing the assist. All that happens is the velocity vector is rotated in that frame. Thus the usefulness hinges on arriving with a large relative velocity, to start with—a large vector to rotate, allows for a large velocity change.

There's no heliocentric velocity in a slow-moving outer planet.

Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by perihelions on Sunday September 14, 2025 @04:40PM (#45243054)
There's several large HN threads about that hypothetical,

https://hn.algolia.com/?query=planet%20black%20hole&type=sto... ("What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole?" (+ title variations))

Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by zero_bias on Monday September 15, 2025 @01:45AM (#45246474)
After the Chelyabinsk meteorite, we know that the Tunguska event has a mundane explanation: certain types of meteorites are prone to breaking up in the upper layers of the atmosphere, and Tunguska simply exploded the same way the Chelyabinsk meteorite did
Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by thehappypm on Sunday September 14, 2025 @08:52PM (#45244921)
It would be an incredible thing if you could build a device that emitted tiny black holes over and over and over again, just strip out horizontal lines of matter
Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by antognini on Sunday September 14, 2025 @11:26PM (#45245790)
Planetary and moon mass black holes are ruled out by gravitational microlensing surveys. Microlensing puts an upper bound on the mass of primordial black holes at ~1/5 the mass of Ceres.
Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by zero_bias on Monday September 15, 2025 @01:40AM (#45246450)
These surveys assume that primordial black holes are distributed uniformly across galaxies, but this may not be the case if they form small dark globular clusters in the outskirts of galaxies. By small, it is meant that with a total mass of 100–1000 M, they would produce no significant lensing, and by dark, that such clusters would consist entirely of black holes.
Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by PantaloonFlames on Sunday September 14, 2025 @12:26PM (#45241098)
Thanks , very helpful.
Re:A single, 'naked' black hole confounds theories of the yo... by tomhow on Sunday September 14, 2025 @03:30PM (#45242559)
A user emailed us to point out that this seems to be an LLM-generated summary of the article that contains inaccuracies. Please don't do this.

We've marked the comment off-topic and moved some of the replies to be root comments, where appropriate.