News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by brudgers on Thursday September 13, 2012 @10:06PM (#4519648)
From word processing to servers to compilers, no tech company eats their own dog food like Microsoft. They even have their own search engine.

It's an under appreciated feature of their corporate culture that first hit me when I asked myself, "Why the hell does Microsoft sell project?" and realized that just about everything they have developed since DOS has been something they could use in house.

Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by InclinedPlane on Thursday September 13, 2012 @11:42PM (#4519949)
True, for the most part, but not a complete story.

One thing that MS never does is eat its own pricing or licensing dog food, which is a big part of the downside of using MS products. For example, an individual developer at MS never thinks for a second about the cost/benefit of various different OSes or servers, if they feel like installing Windows Server 2008 r2 data center edition with SQL Server on their desktop (which is around $10k in total cost to some schlub outside the company) or on an old machine they've converted into a server, they do so.

This can create a fairly substantial difference between the experience within MS and without. Also, there are tons of internal tools used throughout the development process which don't exist outside of MS or for which MS doesn't consider using the equivalent 3rd party tool which result in very different experiences. A lot of times this is justified as servicing workflows which are only relevant at MS's scale but often times this is a pretty bogus rationalization.

Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by cookingrobot on Friday September 14, 2012 @01:07AM (#4520163)
As a UI pm on a consumer facing product at MS, I wasn't allowed a license of photoshop. I was told to use paint. (this was before paint.net)
Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by ryanmolden on Friday September 14, 2012 @01:40AM (#4520248)
And our UX folks routinely use both Photoshop and Illustrator. It's almost like we can't make sweeping statements of "how it is" at a company with 90k or so employees.
Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by seanmcdirmid on Friday September 14, 2012 @01:58AM (#4520294)
Without a site license for Adobe CS, it makes sense that some orgs wouldn't have that in their budget (its like $1000 per seat!), while UX teams would definitely budget for that. The problem in essence is "design by PM," which I'm sure is not unique to Microsoft at all.
Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by justincormack on Friday September 14, 2012 @04:22AM (#4520727)
It is only about $20 a month on the subscription package.
Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by twinsnes on Friday September 14, 2012 @01:09AM (#4520168)
Not true, with a $1200 ($800 renewal) msdn subscription "Visual Studio Professional with MSDN" you should have access to 5 copies of every operating system and server software + professional versions of all Visual studio packages.
Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by martey on Friday September 14, 2012 @01:11AM (#4520171)
The EULA for MSDN subscriptions prohibits using them in a production environment: http://download.microsoft.com/documents/useterms/MSDN%20Subs...
Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by seanmcdirmid on Friday September 14, 2012 @02:01AM (#4520298)
Well, there is DreamSpark...

I'm not sure why anyone would think MS uses only their own OS for everything. Microsoft has been known to use other OS's in the past (the website used to run on Solaris right?), and we do have designers with macs (beyond just the team that does MacOffice, of course). Eat the dog food but don't drink the kool aid, anyways.

Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by bad_user on Friday September 14, 2012 @02:37AM (#4520373)

      Well, there is DreamSpark...
DreamSpark is again, for non-commercial use. You're probably referring to Bizspark / Webspark.

And it's far from ideal to go this route.

To get accepted into the program, you first have to start a company. As a lone developer that just wants to try stuff out and see what sticks, dealing with such bureaucracy is far from ideal - of course, in the US you can start a company probably in a couple of hours, but many in the rest of the world are not so lucky.

Then you need to apply by describing what you intend to do with it. If you have an idea for a project you have to describe it in detail, including the business plan, otherwise you can get rejected. And people have been rejected.

And then, assuming you did the above and got accepted, the *Spark programs are a ticking time bomb. When it's over, it's over. You can keep whatever software you have on your desktop already installed, but then you do have to license whatever software you're using in production (SQL Server, Windows Server).

Again, I'm mainly speaking from the point of view of someone that has a day job and that would like to try stuff out. Skipping over the fact that if you tell them you have a day job, you probably won't get accepted, it can take a lot of time to start earning money from what you're doing and thus afford those licenses at the end of the program. And it's not like successful businesses haven't been built this way.

So I just don't get why would somebody be willingly getting into this, when many companies and individuals succeeded by using the free and open-source alternatives, which personally I find technically superior.

Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by seanmcdirmid on Friday September 14, 2012 @02:51AM (#4520426)
Sorry, yes, I was thinking about BizSpark. And your point is very reasonable, which is why tools like Visual Studio Express are very important.
Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by InclinedPlane on Friday September 14, 2012 @03:41AM (#4520595)
This is an amusing digression but it doesn't change the point. At any other company the size of Microsoft the cost of installing a high-end Windows OS or a server runs into the many thousands of dollars and would normally be a very convoluted process to install. Within MS it takes all of a matter of seconds, everyone there is protected from one of the biggest pain points of using MS software, which I think is a pretty significant problem.
Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by brudgers on Friday September 14, 2012 @07:50AM (#4521151)
If this is really a problem, it applies to other companies commonly praised on HN, such as 37Signals. I suspect that the alternative of charging the street price of software off against internal budgets would be a more significant problem and garner pecks of criticism on HN.
Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by jere on Thursday September 13, 2012 @10:28PM (#4519703)
>no tech company eats their own dog food like Microsoft

See, I've always assumed the exact opposite based on how rough the user experience is on so many Microsoft products.

I've often wondered if it was possible for a web developer at MS to sit down with IE for 30 minutes and not think "I have to fix this.... now!" When I realized how awesome Chrome developer tools were I never wanted to go back. But of course, as a web developer, you have to go back.

Or maybe that is the problem. Maybe too much dogfooding blinds you to how great the competitor is.

Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by jrockway on Thursday September 13, 2012 @10:42PM (#4519757)
Just because something is used internally doesn't mean the product manager is going to prioritize fixes for internal bug reports. Testing internally does not magically add more programmers to the project.
Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by jere on Thursday September 13, 2012 @10:49PM (#4519787)
That's certainly true, but then dogfooding seems completely pointless if you're not going to use it to make your product better.
Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by jrockway on Thursday September 13, 2012 @11:38PM (#4519933)
It just means that software engineering is difficult even with many testers.
Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by xtdx on Thursday September 13, 2012 @11:42PM (#4519945)
Fixing some of the bugs you find internally doesn't mean you need to fix all of the bugs you find internally.
Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by sliverstorm on Friday September 14, 2012 @12:37AM (#4520098)
How about the part where you don't pay licensing to other companies? In other words, if you're developing the software anyway, may as well use it.
Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by jere on Friday September 14, 2012 @12:57AM (#4520135)
Sure. My first instinct is to say that's a small concern, but they do have 100k employees.

Sorry, I was introduced to "dogfooding" in Dreaming in Code. I believe there was even a chapter named after it and it was a pretty big deal about how you dogfood to maintain quality. So when I hear the term that's what I assume is implied.

Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by jmspring on Friday September 14, 2012 @01:26AM (#4520212)
While true, "the PM may not prioritize fixes", a big aspect you are missing is, someone internally with a problem has access to a direct communication line with said PM, his peers, superiors, etc.

For most day to day usage issues, dogfooding is a great way to hammer out issues. Will they find issues with every use case? No, but they will find some. Also, generally, the more diverse and large the organization, the more use cases will be dogfooded (assuming the bulk of the org is encouraged/required to do so).

When you are talking a company of 90k+, encouraged dogfooding will hit a lot of different use cases.

Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by at-fates-hands on Thursday September 13, 2012 @10:58PM (#4519815)
>"See, I've always assumed the exact opposite based on how rough the user experience is on so many Microsoft products."

And you are correct.

I remember back in the day (2005) reading about MS employees hiding their ipods when they were on campus:

http://www.wired.com/gadgets/mac/commentary/cultofmac/2005/0...

And then Steve killed everybody's buzz by banning Apple products entirely:

http://www.cultofmac.com/155131/microsoft-bans-employees-fro...

Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by InclinedPlane on Thursday September 13, 2012 @11:44PM (#4519959)
Apple products are not banned at MS, that's BS, in most parts of the company the most popular phone is the iPhone.
Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by ebf on Thursday September 13, 2012 @11:07PM (#4519846)
The article states that company money cannot be used to purchase Apple products, not that Apple products are banned entirely. I know plenty of people that use iPhones on campus.
Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by seanmcdirmid on Friday September 14, 2012 @02:04AM (#4520305)
Which is also bogus. There are plenty of exceptions (otherwise, how the heck does Microsoft develop Mac Office?).
Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by wingspan on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:44PM (#4525059)
In some orgs it is actually relatively easy for a PM to get a MacBook Air, for instance. You don't even need a bulletproof justification. Although with the new crop of ultrabooks, the MacBook Air is no longer so unique, so it may be more difficult.
Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by farnsworth on Friday September 14, 2012 @02:10AM (#4520316)
Definitely still bogus. They have to test webapps on iPads somehow.
Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by avree on Thursday September 13, 2012 @10:36PM (#4519738)
The new IE is actually pretty good. Microsoft knows that IE6 is an abomination and even made a website dedicated to its demise: http://www.ie6countdown.com/
Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by jere on Thursday September 13, 2012 @10:47PM (#4519779)
Are you referring to 9 or 10?

My point regarding 9 is that the developer tools are buggy and painful to use compared to chrome. As a web developer, you would want them fixed as soon as possible.

Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by tesseractive on Friday September 14, 2012 @12:38AM (#4520099)
MS has tons of development tools available internally that they don't release to the world. It's possible that what you're wishing you had is sitting out on Toolbox, invisible to anyone outside the firewall.

There's something of a culture of "our internal developers are smarter than our external developers" at Microsoft, so dev tools are often where the dogfooding has been the weakest. It comes from having internal developers who are hacking on things like OS kernels while the external developers have a massive population of coders churning out enterprise CRUD forms (along with a smaller population of more advanced developers), but this internal/external tool gap sometimes really bites them.

Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by WalterGR on Friday September 14, 2012 @01:12AM (#4520172)
There's something of a culture of "our internal developers are smarter than our external developers" at Microsoft...

Interesting. I didn't get that impression across 4 teams, either as a PM intern or a FTE dev.

Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by tesseractive on Friday September 14, 2012 @02:37AM (#4520372)
Perhaps I'm misinterpreting. But I got the impression that dev tools that qualify to be sent out into the world need to have a primary emphasis on friendliness, automation and autogeneration, and general polish. By contrast, internal tools need to be industrial grade workhorses, and if you can improve them by putting a better interface on them, that's merely nice. One of the clearest examples I can think of is the difference between their internal workhorse Source Depot and their public tool TFS (nevermind the horror that was VSS).

Like I said, I might be misreading things. And certainly the blogging community around their dev tools has improved the level of detail that goes out to developers committed enough to keep up with them.

Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by jmspring on Friday September 14, 2012 @01:00AM (#4520146)
There may be bugs, but being able to select compatibility modes from prior versions isn't something I've seen in Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.
Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by jongalloway2 on Friday September 14, 2012 @02:14AM (#4520326)
I use web dev tools pretty hard, and I end up using both Chrome and IE Web Dev tools. They both have their strengths when you get to know them.
Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by 8ig8 on Thursday September 13, 2012 @11:01PM (#4519821)
Actually IE6 was great when it was released.
Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by JacksonGariety on Thursday September 13, 2012 @10:42PM (#4519758)
DAMMIT CHINA!
Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by xradionut on Thursday September 13, 2012 @10:45PM (#4519770)
I just came from a .NET developer meeting hosted on the local Microsoft campus. The presenter was trying to hype development of new Office 360, Sharepoint and other "code less" applications. Made the mistake of telling a room full of experienced developers they could be replaced with HTML jockeys at 1/6 their price. I decided to spend the rest of the presentation working on some stored procedures.
Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by tluyben2 on Friday September 14, 2012 @01:49AM (#4520274)
I love it when a client says 'I made my blabla in Lightswitch in a few days without programming, why did you quote $50k for this app?'.
Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by eckyptang on Friday September 14, 2012 @02:55AM (#4520440)
That's because the tooling does well enough versus your $50k dev project.

I'm not a fan of LightSwitch myself, but this is the right step forward for business software and fits in with the Office VBA ecosystem well (i.e. customise it yourself).

It's business mecca.

Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by tluyben2 on Friday September 14, 2012 @04:16AM (#4520705)
Sure, that's not what they/I mean though. They made something to register hours for their employees (perfect case for Access/Lightswitch) and asked us for a quote for a complex public facing SAAS solution. And the 'case' they want to make is to ask why there is so much programming involved even EVEN HE can make 'a complete application' in a few days.

Lightswitch and other systems like it have their domains and work well in those domains, but less tech clients cannot see the difference between one domain and the other. A web project we did in another 'codeless' tool (which is just not true as you are coding, just in another way) was delivered and the client said; we saw on the tool vendor's site that you just press one button to make the web site into mobile apps for all devices. So why are you charging us for that? In short; people believe what vendors say on the golf course or on their sites. Even if those cases are completely out of context; people don't KNOW that they are.

If a CEO of tool-vendor X tells CEO Y on the golf course that their product 'fixes all IT problems because anyone can make solutions for web and mobile with it', then CEO Y will tell buy this product. Although neither CEO X or Y know actually what the product does. This is really normal. So then the product gets pushed down to the production managers and they get the 'command' to 'use it for everything, because we are shifting to this product as it will save us millions in IT costs'.

I have seen this many times (in big and small companies) and I see it with LightSwitch as well; with Sharepoint too; I know a few companies who make everything with SP, much to the dismay of the IT dep.

Edit: and I don't really know if it's the right way for businesses to go. I remember Access well; I remember institutions, for instance the main Dutch court, creating MONSTERS in that themselves because it's easy and (almost) no programming. Then when the guy/girl who did this leaves, someone needs to take it over. We are talking about a complete mess which is business critical. So I believe it has it's place, but only for small departmental apps; if they grow they should be replaced by something solid and this should be considered the prototype. IMHO.

Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by eckyptang on Friday September 14, 2012 @05:00AM (#4520815)
Actually, I think your reasoning is flawed here.

1. They should just use something like replicon ( http://www.replicon.com/ ) for that. Don't build if something already exists.

2. Lightswitch solutions are not designed to be sold by consultancies of external developers. They are designed to be in house built and maintained as per VBA apps.

Access is still doing fine for a number of cases. I still have to maintain an Access 7.0 database for inventory tracking/management on NT4 which I built in 1997. It still does the job so there is no reason to replace it. I will be early next year moving it to Access 2010 on Windows 7 as their hardware is now dying miserably and that is the only motivation to upgrade it. Note: this is running on SQL6.5 with 50 users.

Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by tluyben2 on Friday September 14, 2012 @05:15AM (#4520853)
Why is my reasoning flawed? Which part exactly?

The part where people internally write horrible software on these 'code less' platforms? Company critical software which then somehow needs to be maintained by some poor programmer?

I just tell what I see in real life and that's not pretty.

Maybe your Access db wasn't such a mess. If you have over 50.000 lines of VBA written by people who never programmed but learned it organically by changing the application, then i'm not sure if it shouldn't be replaced. Any change to that system is a huge danger.

Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by tluyben2 on Friday September 14, 2012 @01:46AM (#4520269)
I never worked at MS and know no-one who does, so I don't know this for a fact, but I read they don't use Sourcesafe internally. I have used it and hated every second of it, so I can imagine, however, it is, literally, their dog food.
Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by aaronbrethorst on Friday September 14, 2012 @01:54AM (#4520287)
SourceSafe has been dead for years. It was never used for revision control on any shipped MS product. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Visual_SourceSafe#Mic...
Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by snogglethorpe on Thursday September 13, 2012 @11:56PM (#4519988)
Er, "kinda."

The last time I had a close friend at microsoft (and so heard the scuttlebutt) was a year or so ago, and at least from that perspective, it sounded like everybody there had an iphone -- and used google to search for stuff...

In other words, having a product, and actually getting your employees to use it when it isn't strictly necessary (e.g., they are gonna use MS compilers to compile stuff because it's pretty much necessary), aren't the same thing.

[... and a significant amount of MS dev work was done on iphone projects (e.g. in bing)!]

Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by wingspan on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:48PM (#4525065)
Like others have already pointed out, the experience of one person in a 100k+ employee company is not broadly applicable. Many employees have iPhones, yes, but many also have Windows Phones as well. I agree with you that since there is really no mandate to use MS products, it is a good sign if employees do use them, since it can signal that they truly are better than the competition.
Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by wdr1 on Friday September 14, 2012 @01:27AM (#4520216)
> just about everything they have developed since DOS has been something they could use in house.

Not to rain on the parade, but most Microsoft employees I know use Google.

Not a lot of them used Microsoft Bob.

Or Zune.

Or the Kin.

Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by bztzt on Friday September 14, 2012 @02:24AM (#4520341)
The Zune desktop app is actually (still!) pretty popular with employees.
Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by eckyptang on Friday September 14, 2012 @02:55AM (#4520443)
Zune is actually quite nice from experience. I use Zune for my Windows Phone.
Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by vvhn on Friday September 14, 2012 @12:29AM (#4520076)
>From word processing to servers to compilers, no tech company eats their own dog food like Microsoft. They even have their own search engine.

Wouldn't Apple be in the same position ? (except for the search engine) They have the Hardware, the OS, the compiler, their own office suite, mail program, calendar and server versions etc. the phone hardware, the phone OS.

Re:Microsoft employees getting free Surface tablets, new wor... by chj on Friday September 14, 2012 @05:03AM (#4520825)
The downside is that they get used to the pain, and then feel nothing about it, and then user has to eat it too.