It was interesting that aside from having the scrappy image, many of the athletes used in the analogy(Ichiro, Nash, and Dirk) happens to be foreign. The post is an attempt to differentiate from a leading competitor for talent on multiple fronts(Home Run vs Singles/Globalization vs Valley/Hackers vs Marketers).
Another point about the scrappy image: one of the points of PGs essay was to state that sometime the non-obvious guy/gal wins the biggest the end. 500 is saying they are that non-obvious accelerator.
Essentially he is saying YC is Hertz and 500 is Avis.
"Their corporate motto is "We Try Harder" It was adopted in 1962[4] (during the tenure of Robert Townsend as its CEO) to make a more positive reference of Avis' status as the second largest car rental company in the US, at the expense of its larger competitor The Hertz Corporation. "
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avis_Rent_a_Car_System
A well intentioned strategy of "attacking" (if you want to call it that) the market leader in the category. Doesn't even matter if they are really Avis by the way. Why? There is fresh kill on the internet every day. And those "fresh kill" are reading things like that and believing it.
anyway, i'm sure most folks at YC feel like they try harder too. probably we're more similar there than different.
but yeah, i don't mind being the underdog.
It's great to be the underdog it makes everything fun as you are trying to get somewhere. Once you get there you have something to lose. So you either becomes paranoid or you can become lazy and complacent.
You might remember the Dirk Diggler character in "Boogie Nights". First time he won the award he gave a big speech and thanked everyone. Next time a little less, next even less. After he had won so many awards he would just go up on the stage and say "thank you" as if it didn't even matter anymore. Later, he couldn't even "get it up" he became impotent. That's what you have to guard against. Your strategy is great.
It's not about being an underdog or a black swan. Both 500 and YC must differentiate. It's the only way for the founder to grasp the accelerators' pitch.
Everyone wants to put out their expressive character. Michael Jackson can be recognized from the silhouette, so can you do with your company.
So it's fine that Paul Graham played out the analytical card and Dave McClure counterplayed the same card as Apple played against Microsoft - we are the hippies, not the science guys.
i prefer band geeks vs. chess nerds, as stated in the piece.
in any case, didn't mean to mis-characterize your post... just thought it would be useful to identify some of the differences in YC & 500 re: style, philosophy, practice.
(regardless, happy hunting / farming :)
He seems to be trying to give the impression that 500 Startups is for plucky underdogs, and YC isn't. It would certainly be in his interest to have founders believe that. But the fact is that when the black swans show up on our doorstep, they don't seem like they're going to be black swans. That was the whole point of my essay; that's why I refer to them as black swans, and why I say that "we're in a business where we need to pick unpromising-looking outliers."