News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by SamuelAdams on Sunday August 24, 2025 @11:34AM (#45005023)
I am speculating, but I think the real motive for cancelling renewables is to appeal to coal counties in the USA.

Coal is in a scary place right now in the US, see this as an example:

https://www.reddit.com/r/antiwork/comments/1mmqwd3/i_live_in...

Basically coal is less profitable and more expensive in places that have always been coal counties. The only thing to do in these areas is mine coal, so the concern is that entire regions will be rendered worthless if coal collapses.

Which means local residents cannot sell their homes without taking significant losses, and they probably lose their jobs in coal, which manifests into a poverty trap for the entire town.

And there are hundreds of these towns all through Appalachia.

So renewable energy will always be a political issue over the next 50 years, because entire towns and regions depend on its political outcome.

Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by alistairSH on Sunday August 24, 2025 @11:40AM (#45005072)
Anybody who didn’t see this coming hasn’t been paying attention. There’s been plenty of time to move, retrain, whatever. The government has probably failed these people in one way or another, but these tend to be areas the say they value self-sufficiency and minimal government interference , so…
Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by zahlman on Sunday August 24, 2025 @12:09PM (#45005349)
> move

To where, with what savings?

> retrain

To do what, in this area, with what existing infrastructure?

Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by ironman1478 on Sunday August 24, 2025 @12:14PM (#45005401)
I don't believe in retraining, but tons of immigrants move for better opportunities with very little savings. It's difficult and unfortunate, but it's necessary
Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by bluefirebrand on Sunday August 24, 2025 @12:42PM (#45005659)
People probably should not be forced to behave like desperate immigrants within the borders of their own country though
Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by 8note on Sunday August 24, 2025 @02:07PM (#45006317)
people also shouldnt be forced to bend over backwards to ensure these couple villages never have to change their coal mining ways.
Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by zahlman on Monday August 25, 2025 @07:47AM (#45012816)
From their perspective, this should require no effort; it is forcing them to change which requires effort.

Of course I want the use of coal to stop. But you need to reckon with these kinds of human factors if you want to effect change peacefully.

This is where Clinton failed. Having a documented plan to spend billions (somewhere on the order of 10 years of salary per miner, from numbers I could glean elsewhere in this discussion) doesn't make an impression when you have well-documented sound bites claiming that you intend to put them "out of business".

Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by ironman1478 on Sunday August 24, 2025 @01:23PM (#45005961)
Why not? It'll probably build character. Also, it's happened all the time? People have been doing it for all of America's history. Tons of famous media is about people moving to the city for a better life.
Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by alistairSH on Sunday August 24, 2025 @12:25PM (#45005497)
There are retrains programs dotted all over WV and Appalachia. They cover everything from construction and other trades to IT and more office-focused jobs.
Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by joquarky on Sunday August 24, 2025 @05:14PM (#45007851)
What office focused jobs?
Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by ModernMech on Sunday August 24, 2025 @12:27PM (#45005521)
> To do what, in this area, with what existing infrastructure?

Right! It's a real chicken and egg scenario. It would seem to me that without this infrastructure, it would be very hard to retrain and build new industries. It would really benefit the people of these regions to vote for people who, as a matter of policy, would bring training and infrastructure to them. Unfortunately, the people who most benefit from such policies vote against them [1], so the resources available are insufficient. So the conversation is about poverty reduction through social programs to support people working in a dying industry, rather than growing new industries. The solution, might be to vote for people proposing such resources, which I know is a radical idea, but it's at least something new to try.

https://medium.com/hillary-for-america/the-future-of-america...

Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by tzs on Sunday August 24, 2025 @12:58PM (#45005781)
Here's the plan she had specifically for coal communities [1].

[1] https://static.politico.com/b8/90/cbbc9c59413089d87e8d6340f1...

Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by bryanlarsen on Sunday August 24, 2025 @12:44PM (#45005680)
Clinton had promised a large pile of cash to do this. Voters preferred Trump's lie that he would save the jobs.
Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by Sharlin on Sunday August 24, 2025 @11:38AM (#45005053)
At the same time there are hundreds of towns in low-lying areas that are being rendered worthless by the climate change.
Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by deadeye on Sunday August 24, 2025 @12:10PM (#45005353)
Where can I find a list of these towns?
Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by burnout1540 on Sunday August 24, 2025 @11:40AM (#45005070)
There are only about 45,000 coal miners in the entire US. That's a tiny number.
Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by rtkwe on Sunday August 24, 2025 @12:00PM (#45005266)
They're also in geographically low population areas so counting them and the people employeed in their towns they have a significant sway on some states and the Senate skews things towards low population states through it's inequitable representation AND the outsized power Senate rules give individual Senators.

Plus it's made a few people EXTREMELY rich so they've made their opinions and interests everyone elses problem too.

Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by Yeul on Sunday August 24, 2025 @03:13PM (#45006830)
Every once in a while someone in the Netherlands argues for the district system and they are immediately shut down with "America".

One man one vote. And yes the regions that contribute more to the economy are a priority. They fund everything including the military without which we'd still be a part of Spain.

Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by rtkwe on Sunday August 24, 2025 @03:43PM (#45007090)
Yeah I get the idea originally, you had to appease the slave and smaller states to get them to join the plan originally at all, but there's a very, very good reason wherever the US has had the chance to design a new government we have never saddled them with our system. I don't think there's a reasonable hope that it'll get reformed in a clean way though.
Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by jeffbee on Sunday August 24, 2025 @11:50AM (#45005166)
More people drive buses in NYC than are coal miners in the whole America.
Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by HPsquared on Sunday August 24, 2025 @12:17PM (#45005422)
Probably though, like the buses, there's an order of magnitude more work done on the "back end". The machines, logistics, etc etc and everything else that depends on the industry. In the bus drivers example, it could be all the people in NYC who need to take a bus to get to work and would be affected by the sudden disappearance of buses. So it is with many industries.
Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by olddustytrail on Sunday August 24, 2025 @12:29PM (#45005539)
If people really cared about coal miners then they could be offered a $1 million redundancy package. It would amount to a tiny fraction of government spending and I'm pretty sure it would be welcomed.
Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by hamdingers on Sunday August 24, 2025 @12:49PM (#45005710)
There are approximately twice as many yoga instructors. It's unfortunate Big Yoga doesn't have the same political pull.
Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by cosmic_cheese on Sunday August 24, 2025 @11:40AM (#45005068)
The thing is, if you’re burning fossil fuels to generate power there’s not much reason to prefer coal over natural gas. The latter is cheaper and cleaner and once pipelines are in place, you don’t need to truck it around.

Coal is dead and it’s not coming back. Areas in which it served as the pillar of the economy need to figure something else out. I say this as someone hailing from one such area.

Speaking frankly, the way politicians keep selling the fantasy of it making a comeback is cruel.

Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by ModernMech on Sunday August 24, 2025 @12:10PM (#45005356)
> Areas in which it served as the pillar of the economy need to figure something else out. I say this as someone hailing from one such area.

Old steel towns had to do this, coal country might look to them for a model on how to leave a dying industry behind. But seeing how they vote, they might not like the answer for what it takes to survive:

Pittsburgh PA - famous former steel town, faced very uncertain economic future after the mills closed, now a booming metropolis with top industry leaders in education, healthcare, sports, finance. What did it take? A dedication to multiculturalism and diversity. Pittsburgh would have died without embracing the global economy and attracting doctors, professors, students, entertainers, and athletes from all over the world to visit, live, and grow a family.

Cleveland OH - once one of America's great manufacturing hubs, powered by steel mills, car parts, and shipping along Lake Erie. When industry collapsed, Cleveland faced deep decline, job losses, shrinking population, even bankruptcy in the 1970s. But today it's finding new strength as a center of healthcare, research, and culture.

Then you look at places like Youngstown OH. Unlike Pittsburgh or Cleveland, Youngstown struggled to reinvent itself. Population plummeted, tax bases collapsed, and poverty took hold. The city became a symbol of the Rust Belt's hardest struggles. What held it back? Overreliance on steel, limited diversification, and waves of outmigration left too few resources to rebuild. What are they doing today to fix things? Healthcare and education.

One more example is Bethlehem PA, another former steel town that now has top industries in healthcare, education, and also some manufacturing.

So that's the model. If you're a dying town with an industry that's shrivveling up due to changing economic conditions, the model to survive is to quickly pivot to healthcare, education, and entertainment, and to invite a bunch of outsiders into your community with open arms.

And that is the main problem these dying coal regions have, because looking at how they vote, embracing healthcare, education, entertainment, and diversity is the last thing they want to do. You look at what the people who they voted for are doing with their power its attacking healthcare, attacking education, and attacking diversity sometimes violently, but always unrelentingly. So the Pittsburgh model is off the table, and they'll have to find another way from the abyss.

Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by cosmic_cheese on Sunday August 24, 2025 @12:21PM (#45005462)
> And that is the main problem these dying coal regions have, because looking at how they vote, embracing healthcare, education, and diversity is the last thing they want to do. You look at what the people who they voted for are doing with their power its attacking healthcare, attacking education, and attacking diversity sometimes violently, but always unrelentingly. So the Pittsburgh model is off the table, and they'll have to find another way from the abyss.

Spot on, from what I’ve seen. Just keep doubling down on what hasn’t worked in hopes that one day it’ll magically manifest a Disney ending and the good old days will return.

Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by jimbob45 on Sunday August 24, 2025 @12:52PM (#45005737)
What did it take? A dedication to multiculturalism and diversity. Pittsburgh would have died without embracing the global economy and attracting doctors, professors, students, entertainers, and athletes from all over the world to visit, live, and grow a family.

Just cater to the rich folks! That’s the same playbook every city in world is running right now to rampant failure. Rich people don’t bring prosperity. Prosperity brings the rich. Building prosperity is a difficult ordeal that takes time, sacrifice, a lot of money, and a culture of safety and community.

Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by ModernMech on Sunday August 24, 2025 @01:05PM (#45005838)
Sure if you want increase your tax base, step one is to be attractive to people with money.

But healthcare, education, and entertainment are not exclusive to rich people, they're industries that everyone enjoys and can take part in. The doctors, actors, professors, students, athletes, researchers, who come from around the world to live and work in Pittsburgh are not "the rich". They have money, but they're still just regular people.

For example the students who come to Pittsburgh for an education are not wealthy, but they are flush with cash from the government and lenders. They are attracted to Pittsburgh not because it's a good place for the rich, but because it's a good place for students.

Incidentally, good places for students are also good places for the rich. So I agree, rich people don’t bring prosperity. Prosperity brings the rich.

> That’s the same playbook every city in world is running right now to rampant failure.

Did you miss the part where Pittsburgh is thriving? Cleveland is doing okay. Bethlehem is booming. Youngstown... not great but moving in a good direction.

Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by wat10000 on Sunday August 24, 2025 @11:55AM (#45005223)
Coal counties are insignificant. Nobody is winning national elections by appealing to them.

The actual motive is to appeal to people who have made coal part of their identity. These are people who have never been anywhere near a coal mine, but have internalized coal as Important and American, and as a way to stick it to those stupid environmentalists.

Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by notahacker on Sunday August 24, 2025 @01:00PM (#45005801)
Yeah. Think this was epitomised by the DoE tweeting pictures of coal to own the libs. Or as one wag put it the right in 2005: "we shouldn't overregulate energy markets"; the right in 2025: "I'm actually attracted to coal"

In Trump's case you can throw in a personal obsession with hating wind power because you can see it from one of his golf courses.

Generally pathetic that people are trying to retcon this reflexive lib-owning vice-signalling from incredibly stupid people as actual industrial policy.

Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by wat10000 on Sunday August 24, 2025 @03:47PM (#45007127)
I think it’s hard for people who aren’t steeped in that world to understand it, because it sounds so ridiculous. The idea of loving pro-coal policies because it upsets environmentalists is hard to accept. It’s natural to think it must really be about economic realities, people's livelihoods, etc.

I have the questionable advantage of having listened to Rush Limbaugh almost every day in the 90s, reading lots of National Review, and taking in various other conservative media. I know the basis for these things, straight from the people pushing them. None of what’s happening is a surprise to me.

Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday August 24, 2025 @11:42AM (#45005092)
> the real motive for cancelling renewables is to appeal to coal counties in the USA

Wyoming here. Coal country. Everyone thinks this is dumb. Including the folks in Campbell county, our top-producing coal region that has been trying to build a wind farm [1].

Trump’s social media fans in Florida and Texas like this because it feels like owning the libs. (To the extent there may be pecuniary interest, it would be in power producers. Like housing, stopping new power raises prices and profits incumbents.)

Also, that Reddit thread is about coking coal. Not the thermal coal power plants burn. It’s about American steel production shutting down in the face of our trade war. Not this new economic miracle these idiots have spun up.

[1] https://billingsgazette.com/news/state-and-regional/wyoming/...

Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by CamperBob2 on Sunday August 24, 2025 @11:48AM (#45005157)
Everyone thinks this is dumb.

Dumb enough to make them reconsider voting Republican in the future? I doubt it.

Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by groby_b on Sunday August 24, 2025 @11:47AM (#45005150)
This would make sense if it were a single issue. (And then, limited sense - even quite red places like Texas invest in solar because they need it. Coal is a regional issue, not a national one)

If you see it in light of all the other actions taken across the spectrum, you land at best at "desperate dice roll to re-tool the US into a manufacturing power from the 80s", and at worst at "deliberate dismantling of a first-rate world power into a second tier paradise for oligarchs".

Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by rtkwe on Sunday August 24, 2025 @12:09PM (#45005346)
It's made a national issue by 1) Senators from coal mining heavy states and the ridiculous setup of the Senate and the outsized power it gives individual Senators unless one party has 60 seats and 2) the amount of wealth it's given a few people (like the Koch brothers) who've used that wealth to buy influence in the GOP.
Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by ModernMech on Sunday August 24, 2025 @11:44AM (#45005109)
This message seems to come from a timeline where the people cutting the renewable projects care about electoral outcomes.

But in this timeline, they tried to violently overturn the 2020 election, and they are currently trying to rig the 2026 election by gerrymandering states they control as much as possible.

This isn't about earning the political support of people in coal country who vote GOP. If they ever face negative electoral outcomes in the future, their plan is to overturn the election using either force or legal chicanery.

Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by dalyons on Sunday August 24, 2025 @12:22PM (#45005476)
At the speed at which coal has been declining, and will continue to decline now due to economics, it’s not going to take 50 years. Maybe 10 at most.
Re:US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that sp... by hollerith on Sunday August 24, 2025 @12:32PM (#45005563)
>So renewable energy will always be a political issue over the next 50 years, because entire towns and regions depend on its political outcome.

I heard that before the first Trump administration, there was bipartisan support in Congress for phasing out the use coal in the US, so it seems quite possible that that bipartisan support will reassemble itself after Trump is gone (because the next President is unlikely to be as populist and as uncaring about climate change as Trump).