News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by OkayPhysicist on Thursday August 14, 2025 @12:15PM (#44902260)
It's really easy to avoid your employees being "poached": treat them well, and pay them better.
Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by gibolt on Thursday August 14, 2025 @12:21PM (#44902332)
I generally agree, but the company likely doesn't have those funds. Considering the largest player (Apple) stands to make way more from it than you and just works around your patent.

Not arguing Apple shouldn't poach, just that your suggestion doesn't work.

Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by OkayPhysicist on Thursday August 14, 2025 @01:37PM (#44903309)
The company made a billion dollars in profit last year. I doubt Apple was willing to pay anywhere near that amount to hire an employee.
Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by lotsofpulp on Thursday August 14, 2025 @01:54PM (#44903498)
Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by runako on Thursday August 14, 2025 @02:38PM (#44904005)
Check the ratio of SG&A to R&D spend at MASI. They have money, they just choose not to spend it on engineering.
Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by boringg on Thursday August 14, 2025 @12:21PM (#44902339)
Wow you must work for a company with incredibly deep pockets. No way can massimo compete on salary with apple. Only people in the game who can do that are google facebook apple chatgpt etc.
Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by OkayPhysicist on Thursday August 14, 2025 @01:35PM (#44903284)
As long as a company is turning a profit, they by definition can afford to be paying their employees better. As a company you can choose not to, but it also means you get to suffer the consequences, and lose the right to complain that your employees were "poached" when in reality it was simply a matter of you not paying them enough to stay.
Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by ryandrake on Thursday August 14, 2025 @03:01PM (#44904266)
Yea, these employees are not being "poached." They're not zero-agency deer owned by Masimo, grazing on their land, that Apple came in and stole away. They can decide for themselves that someone else is offering a better business arrangement.

There is a market rate for talent, and if you can't afford the market rate, then you don't get the talent.

Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by adrianN on Thursday August 14, 2025 @02:01PM (#44903605)
If you compete with someone who can afford to lose money longer than you, for example because they have some departments with very high margins and can cross-subsidize, you can win.
Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by Workaccount2 on Thursday August 14, 2025 @02:17PM (#44903790)
Profit distribution only makes sense to owners of the company.

A better way to give employees a share of the profits is to give them shares of the company. But then that also comes at the expense of compensation in dollars. You cannot pay for groceries with company shares.

People really like the idea of "When you win, I get money, when you lose, you lose money". Explained like that they agree it's bad, but explained like "Companies should be distributing profits to workers" they fall over themselves about how good of an idea it is.

Running a business is a gamble and like gambling, you need to put skin in the game to get a share of winnings (and lose your skin in the losses). People are just hyper-focused on the winners.

Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by Dylan16807 on Thursday August 14, 2025 @03:46PM (#44904784)
> People really like the idea of "When you win, I get money, when you lose, you lose money". Explained like that they agree it's bad,

It's not bad, it's a cost.

You obviously wouldn't make a deal like that in isolation. You also wouldn't give someone a salary for nothing. But a cost like that can be worth paying just like a salary is worth paying. (Obviously you'd have limits on the numbers, just like salary is limited.)

Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by Workaccount2 on Thursday August 14, 2025 @06:09PM (#44906280)
The salary is the cost.

People think that profits should be distributed on top of salary. And frankly it already happens to a degree with bonuses. But there is this pervasive idea that any leftover profit is just money that should have gone to workers.

Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by Dylan16807 on Thursday August 14, 2025 @07:08PM (#44906794)
Most jobs have benefits on top of salary.

Distributing part of the profits would be a reasonable benefit.

There are hundreds of millions of profits here. Distributing even 10% of that to employees would be a tremendous amount of money. Even a lot less would have a big effect.

A 10% profit share makes plenty of sense. Yes, even while insulating employees from losses, it still makes sense. Owners need to be able to reap profit but they don't need to get all of it forever. Employees owning stock is not the only way profit sharing can work.

Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by lovich on Thursday August 14, 2025 @02:41PM (#44904035)
This has nothing to do with their point.

If company X is making a profit and losing employees to a competitor paying more, then company X has effectively chosen to let that happen. They don’t get to complain that they ate their cake and don’t have it anymore.

Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by wahnfrieden on Thursday August 14, 2025 @02:40PM (#44904029)
Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by HumblyTossed on Thursday August 14, 2025 @02:47PM (#44904104)
There's no way Massimo could have competed in a salary race with Apple. Apple could have paid those employees MILLIONS if they wanted to.
Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by dmitrygr on Thursday August 14, 2025 @05:02PM (#44905665)
Yes, this is capitalism. Apple get 1st rate engineers, Massimo gets 3rd. If they want 2nd, they pay more
Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by HumblyTossed on Tuesday August 19, 2025 @09:17AM (#44951168)
Oh just stop. There's a point at which they simply can't compete on salary with a multi trillion dollar company.
Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by missingcolours on Thursday August 14, 2025 @03:50PM (#44904837)
I mean, this doesn't tell us whether they can pay them twice as much or $5 more per year. Some companies make no profit, or very little, or very little per employee.
Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by runako on Thursday August 14, 2025 @01:28PM (#44903214)
Masimo was worth ~$16B when this was going down. They are worth $8B today. This is roughly the size of American Airlines. Masimo is not the biggest company, but they are a large publicly-traded company.

The company does $2B in revenue and spends close to $800 million annually in sales, general and admin. This is over 3x their R&D budget. (For reference, Apple's R&D spend is higher than its SG&A spend.)

Per levels.fyi, Masimo is paying senior SDEs in HCOL $150k. They could 10x the comp to these critical employees without it being more than a rounding error in their numbers. (I don't think they would have had to go to 10x. Most people would practically tattoo a brand on themselves for a one-time bonus of $1m.)

Long story short: Masimo does indeed have the money to compete on salary with Apple for this set of employees. They chose to spend the money on attorneys instead.

Some companies don't value engineers. That often works, until they end up in an engineering competition against companies that do value engineers.

Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by eitally on Thursday August 14, 2025 @01:52PM (#44903474)
I disagree with your assertion that Masimo has the money to compete. Apple's upside to employing these folks to build the tech into the Apple Watch is FAR, FAR greater than Masimo's potential sales growth for existing pulse ox devices (or patent licenses). With Apple Watches being licensed as medical devices for ECG & pulse ox, this gives clinicians even more reason to leverage them with patients for convenient 24/7 home monitoring. It's not the same market Masimo is serving, at all.
Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by runako on Thursday August 14, 2025 @02:33PM (#44903952)
I specifically did not address any of the corporate competitive dynamics, although it is worth noting that this is more of an existential issue for Masimo than Apple.

My core point is is that Masimo has far more than enough money to pay strategic employees enough money to keep them. Again, I doubt they would have to go as high as $5m/year for each of the relevant engineers. Masimo could spend that without making a major dent in their finances.

Could Apple up the ante and make offers of $5B/yr to each engineer? Sure, but we are likely talking about the difference between Masimo offering $150k and Apple offering $500k. These are numbers any public company can afford.

Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by richiebful1 on Thursday August 14, 2025 @02:54PM (#44904185)
Masimo sells a health monitoring watch. [1] There is direct competition here.

[1]. https://www.masimo.com/products/monitors/masimo-w1-medical-w...

Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by FireBeyond on Thursday August 14, 2025 @04:38PM (#44905428)
This product WAS generally marketed to the healthcare field, not to people directly.

It was literally described in the page you referenced: "Arm your patients with continuous measurements in a comfortable, lifestyle-friendly wearable—helping you deliver a true telemonitoring experience."

> automates the collection of clinically accurate measurements to help support: -Post-surgical recovery -Chronic care -Patient management

I say "was" because it was possible to buy it as a consumer, but there's still no direct competition, as:

"Please note that all Masimo consumer products have been discontinued. These include:

MightySat® Masimo W1® Sport Watch Opioid Halo™ / Masimo SafetyNet Alert™ Radius T°® Continuous Thermometer Masimo Stork® Vitals, Masimo Stork Vitals+, and Masimo Stork Baby Monitor"

Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by boringg on Thursday August 14, 2025 @01:40PM (#44903345)
Im not saying they pay them well or not. Theres just not a comparison on comp they could do. That you don't understand the power dynamics between that is something you will hopefully learn about the world as you become more experienced. Apple would just offer more at the end of the day.
Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by runako on Thursday August 14, 2025 @02:36PM (#44903990)
I understand, and this is timely in the context of Meta making $100m offers. I have no data on this, but I would be highly surprised if Apple offered anybody more than $5m/year. Masimo has that much money.

Could Apple go higher? Sure, but again most people who like their jobs are not going to leave once their needs are met.

From a competitive standpoint: Masimo has lost $8B in market cap during this kerfuffle. It's entirely possible it would have been rational for Masimo to pay these employees higher than Apple possibly would go in order to not lose those billions in value.

Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by terminalshort on Thursday August 14, 2025 @03:39PM (#44904693)
Not my problem. The owners of a small company have no right to force their financial constraints onto their employees.
Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by scarface_74 on Thursday August 14, 2025 @12:52PM (#44902739)
And as a hypothetical sought after employee, how is that my problem? If another company wants to roll a shit ton of money up to my doorstep, why shouldn’t I take it?

Should I be treating my employer “like family” and care about “the mission”?

Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by hu3 on Thursday August 14, 2025 @01:04PM (#44902894)
It's about the company anti-competitive behaviour. No one said anything about the employees.
Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by tshaddox on Thursday August 14, 2025 @01:37PM (#44903314)
This is the exact opposite of being anti-competitive.
Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by JustExAWS on Thursday August 14, 2025 @01:10PM (#44902976)
The company is being “anticompetitive” by offering someone more money? Should we now make that illegal too?
Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by lurk2 on Thursday August 14, 2025 @01:22PM (#44903125)
Acquisitions can be considered anticompetitive. The only thing that appears to differentiate this situation from an acquisition is that the investors didn’t get paid.
Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by Dylan16807 on Thursday August 14, 2025 @03:51PM (#44904842)
How about the fact that both companies are still healthy?

And even if you do look at this like an acquisition, acquisitions are almost always not anticompetitive.

Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by JustExAWS on Thursday August 14, 2025 @01:37PM (#44903307)
Are you suggesting that the FRC should step in when a company offers employment to a large number of employees at another company? How exactly would you propose to put this into law where it doesn’t hurt the employees?
Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by Dayshine on Thursday August 14, 2025 @01:18PM (#44903090)
Well, we've made other situations where companies offer people money illegal. Such as bribery, or paying someone to steal trade secrets.
Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by JustExAWS on Thursday August 14, 2025 @01:24PM (#44903153)
And neither is alleged. It was a patent that we are discussing which by definition isn’t a trade secret.

But you are coming awfully close to advocating for non competes which is explicitly not allowed in CA.

Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by arcfour on Thursday August 14, 2025 @02:55PM (#44904197)
This is almost farcical. This is literally the opposite of anti-competitive. Please take a basic economics course and pass it before spouting off about economics online.
Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by do_not_redeem on Thursday August 14, 2025 @01:05PM (#44902905)
As an employee you shouldn't care, but if you're someone who wants technological progress to continue, you should care whether companies with a slush fund of billions are able to bully those with less money.
Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by lovich on Thursday August 14, 2025 @02:46PM (#44904094)
Massimo did not appear to respond to Apple by trying to compete on compensation with them. The levels.fyi data is showing that they appear to pay their engineers between 140-180 while they are making hundreds of millions in profit.

It seems like Masimo wasn’t bullied because they had less money. They decided to run to the government to protect them instead of doing actual competition

Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by JustExAWS on Thursday August 14, 2025 @01:12PM (#44903001)
You mean like the innovation that someone else here said that was denied a patent in Japan because of prior art?

We like software patents now?

Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by do_not_redeem on Thursday August 14, 2025 @01:24PM (#44903154)
I skimmed this and it doesn't look like a software patent to me. It's a giant long description of the hardware.

https://patents.google.com/patent/US10912502B2/

Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by hu3 on Thursday August 14, 2025 @12:24PM (#44902374)
that doesn't work when Apple can pay them multiples "more well".

the sensible thing would be to license the tech

Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by soperj on Thursday August 14, 2025 @12:46PM (#44902655)
Or just collude with your rival companies ala Steve Jobs.
Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by 7thpower on Thursday August 14, 2025 @12:48PM (#44902680)
- is what Tim Cook told himself to vanquish the last bit of uneasiness. Then he took of his glasses, set them on the night stand, and slept better than he had in years.
Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by geodel on Thursday August 14, 2025 @02:12PM (#44903730)
Absolutely. Similarly, I tell parents who keep whining about soaring education costs and employability: Educate them well, and get them high paying jobs.
Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by DesiLurker on Thursday August 14, 2025 @08:23PM (#44907301)
right, just learn to outrun the chubby guys when the bear chases.
Re:Blood Oxygen Monitoring Returning to Apple Watch in the US by DesiLurker on Thursday August 14, 2025 @08:19PM (#44907282)
yes, and ribcage should be mesh-gridded if it did not want to be knifed, Right?