News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by bradley13 on Thursday August 07, 2025 @01:29AM (#44820921)
ChatGPT didn't ruin anything. Lazy students did.

I'm a prof, and my experience so far is that - where AI is concerned - there are two kinds of students: (1) those who use AI to support their learning, and (2) those who use AI to do their assignments, thus avoiding learning altogether.

In some classes this has flipped the bell curve on its head: lots of students at either end, and no one in the middle

Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by ViscountPenguin on Thursday August 07, 2025 @01:36AM (#44820957)
Quantity is a quality all its own, it's significantly easier to be lazy with LLMs than with oldschool cheating methods, this changes the equilibrium point at which people will cheat. So if you're a student, you're now even more likely to be dragging along deadweight than you were a decade ago.
Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by mattgreenrocks on Thursday August 07, 2025 @03:29AM (#44821600)
Yes, I think many aren’t realizing this. It is much easier to be lazy, much faster to get something plausible, and not culturally looked down upon. It is also easier to say, “I’ll ask ChatGPT to help me with my main points,” and fall into having it write the essay for you. Changing the defaults (as they were) changes the system, given enough time.

Perhaps the worst aspect of LLMs is they can support us in our “productivity,” when we’re actually trying to avoid the hard work of thinking. This sort of technology-assisted self-delusion feels very similar to social media: “I’m not hiding from life and people, I’m talking to them on Twitter!”

Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by meander_water on Thursday August 07, 2025 @02:29AM (#44821262)
Google, Anthropic and OpenAI are well aware of this. They've pushed out features like study mode and guided learning, but they're barely a band aid fix. The people who want to bypass learning and just get the degree now have a cheaper way. Instead of paying someone else to do their homework, they pay a bot.
Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by moffkalast on Thursday August 07, 2025 @02:42AM (#44821325)
Well given that a large portion of the jobs today are meaningless busywork that only exist so people have something to do, I guess we now also have the education level to match them.
Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by Frieren on Thursday August 07, 2025 @02:49AM (#44821357)
> ChatGPT didn't ruin anything. Lazy students did.

That's a very unuseful way of looking at it. It solves nothing.

ChatGPT has created a problem, we need to look ways of solving it. Unregulated technology is harmful, we need regulations that limit the bad use cases.

To just blame people so, lets be real, your shares on bit tech corporations go up is destructive for society. This tools, like social media, are harming people and should be regulated to work for us. If they cannot then shut them off.

Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by PeterStuer on Thursday August 07, 2025 @04:02AM (#44821830)
"Unregulated technology is harmful, we need regulations that limit the bad use cases"

Unfortunatly most often the cure is worse than the poison.

Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by veltas on Thursday August 07, 2025 @03:29AM (#44821597)
> That's a very unuseful way of looking at it. It solves nothing.

They're not trying to give you facts that solve things, they're just giving you facts, as they see it. You can do with that info what you will.

Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by hvb2 on Thursday August 07, 2025 @03:17AM (#44821525)
You seem to think that before ChatGPT there were no students cheating?

There will always be people that try to outsmart everyone else and not do the work. The problem here is those people, nothing else.

Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by lm28469 on Thursday August 07, 2025 @03:48AM (#44821726)
I never understood this argument... "something was somewhat possible before, hence anything enabling more of it is not a problem and we shouldn't even mention the possibility of it being harmful"
Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by mnmalst on Thursday August 07, 2025 @04:12AM (#44821917)
Totally agree, especially in cases where new technology lowers the bar to entry considerably, resulting in potentially many more people using it.
Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by integralid on Thursday August 07, 2025 @06:04AM (#44822612)
"It was always possible to buy meth if you knew where to look, so it's not a problem that meth is now sold in grocery stores. The people abusing it are at fault here" yeah, ok.
Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by hvb2 on Thursday August 07, 2025 @06:40AM (#44822842)
My point was that there's always been cheating, the tools just change. I'm sure cellphones have been a tool of choice like 10 or 15 years ago.
Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by lm28469 on Thursday August 07, 2025 @10:21AM (#44824810)
Literally everything on this planet is a slight iteration of something preexisting, that's hardly an argument. Internet is just a better mail system. A container ship is just a fast mail man. A nuke is just a very big grenade. Yet all of these things revolutionised the world.
Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by Terr_ on Thursday August 07, 2025 @03:44AM (#44821686)
Any sufficiently sharp quantitative change is also a qualitative change.

That applies here, with these academic-cheating scenarios: It's not just some incrementally cheaper and more-convenient way to hire somebody to write your paper like you could for decades.

Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by rekenaut on Thursday August 07, 2025 @03:36AM (#44821644)
Is it possible that the methods of cheating in the past were a lot more ineffective, risky, or expensive? If a tool like ChatGPT makes cheating a lot easier and less risky, of course more students will use it.
Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by bradley13 on Thursday August 07, 2025 @03:15AM (#44821515)
Seriously? Regulate use cases? That's sort of like the very short-lived attempt to regulate automobiles, by requiring someone to walk in front of every vehicle, ringing a bell.

Actual, useful AI is a disruptive technology, just as the automobile was. Trying to regulate use cases is the wrong solution. We need to find out how this technology is going to be integrated into our lives.

Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by CalRobert on Thursday August 07, 2025 @03:55AM (#44821781)
That was actually pretty useful regulation when the streets were full of people, horses, commerce, kids, etc.
Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by lmm on Thursday August 07, 2025 @04:20AM (#44821970)
It would be pretty useful regulation to bring back, then maybe the streets would be full of people, horses, commerce, and kids again.
Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by suddenlybananas on Thursday August 07, 2025 @03:16AM (#44821523)
This is why we should allow kids to drive cars in gym class.
Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by isaacfrond on Thursday August 07, 2025 @03:41AM (#44821671)
Actually gym classes are a dumb leftover from the turn of the century (no not that turn, the 1900 turn). It serves no purpose anymore. Modern students get no meaningful skills, no lasting health benefits. It's mandatory exertion for a grade.

Learning to drive a car at school would do a whole lot more good!

Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by integralid on Thursday August 07, 2025 @06:11AM (#44822653)
What's wrong with making sure every kid gets to move a bit (exert, as you put it)? It doesn't matter for kids that are already fit, but I think that it's great for health of the bottom 30% who doesn't exercise and doesn't have a proper diet (both are their parents fault, to be clear).
Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by pipes on Thursday August 07, 2025 @02:57AM (#44821408)
And who gets to decide that?
Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by delusional on Thursday August 07, 2025 @03:13AM (#44821496)
Democracy
Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by rrgok on Thursday August 07, 2025 @05:24AM (#44822371)
Ahah good one...
Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by pipes on Thursday August 07, 2025 @09:40AM (#44824332)
Where does democracy start and personal choice end?
Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by _Algernon_ on Thursday August 07, 2025 @03:50AM (#44821749)
The solution is obvious:

Go back to pen-and-paper examinations at a location where students are watched. Do the same for assignments and projects.

Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by qnleigh on Thursday August 07, 2025 @04:16AM (#44821948)
Something like this does seem like the only viable option. I wonder how much it will actually happen.
Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by rrgok on Thursday August 07, 2025 @05:31AM (#44822421)
Better: 15-30min interrogation. I loved those, I can reason through the problem without worrying about writing correct sentence and hoping the other person I understood what I wrote and I understood the question.
Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by integralid on Thursday August 07, 2025 @06:08AM (#44822628)
As a person who used to teach at uni a bit, they sound great, but I dread the amount of work to actually spend 20 meaningful minutes with every student in a row to test their knowledge. Grading the assignments was already the most exhausting thing in the whole year.
Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by integralid on Thursday August 07, 2025 @06:05AM (#44822619)
I'm not saying I disagree, but that won't work too well for coding assignments, for example
Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by nullc on Thursday August 07, 2025 @05:05AM (#44822254)
This article is about adults who are paying considerable amounts of money to be educated, significantly undermining the education they're paying for by offloading the exercises onto chatbots.

And your response is that we need regulations??

Institutional policy, changes to lesson practices, cover the risk of wasting your education in intro materials... sure!

But state is not your parents, it's certainly not mine. Geesh.

Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by BOOSTERHIDROGEN on Thursday August 07, 2025 @02:21AM (#44821228)
For category 1, they can too fall into temptation of just not trying hard enough solving the homework/assignment. This is interesting era I think.
Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by throwaway290 on Thursday August 07, 2025 @01:36AM (#44820956)
No, now there is more people who are not learning. Previously students had to learn. Group 2 was very small because you had to be very lucky to get your assignments done for you without learning at least something yourself. And if you half assed your assignment it would be noticeable by the lecturer. Now it is a no brainer for many people to be in group 2
Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by senectus1 on Thursday August 07, 2025 @02:26AM (#44821251)
yup, AI is next level useful when treated as a rubber duck + search engine.

Its absolutely a backstabbing saboteur if you blindly trust everything it outputs.

Inquisitive skepticism is a super power in the age of AI atm.

Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by nomius10 on Thursday August 07, 2025 @04:30AM (#44822038)
> ChatGPT didn't ruin anything. Lazy students did.

This is a prime example of thinking exclusively along the lines of rugged individualism. It assigns all blame on the individual, whilst ignoring any systemic or collective causes.

It ignores the socio-economic realities of the students. Especially if they come from a challenged background. To them the important thing is getting the high paying job which represents a ticket out of the lower class, and if that can be optimized, it's a no brainer that they would take that route.

It ignores the fact that the actual credential paper is more important to recruiters than the knowledge gained though the program. Or even that networking and referrals has a much larger weight than raw skill in recruiting than we'd like to admit, from our meritocratic perception.

It ignores the fact that maybe the module itself is not that valuable? We're talking about the US here, and people literally pay out of pocket for education. And yet they cheat/skip it in a heartbeat. The only valid rationale is that there is no value there from an economics lens. They'd rather spend that time doing extracurricular activities that actually improve their chances of getting employed.

It ignores the fact that since the industrial revolution the education system has not evolved at all (merely adding a computer lab does not mean the system was reworked, it's the other way around, the new technology was adapted into the existing system).

The education system has flaws. The incentives in the job marketplace have flaws. There are many factors at play here, and simply arguing that "it's the student's fault" is the equivalent of an ostrich sticking his head in the sand.

Re:How ChatGPT spoiled my semester (2024) by BrtByte on Saturday August 09, 2025 @11:33AM (#44847309)
Yep, the curious students suddenly have a supertool to dig deeper and experiment more, while the disengaged ones now have a shortcut that lets them skip thinking entirely