News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Palantir gets $10B contract from U.S. Army by kubbelz on Friday August 01, 2025 @06:06AM (#44754824)
It's suicidally naive not to pursue military supremacy. Your enemies will.

What are you going to do when they appear on your shores to begin the slaughter, enslavement, rape, and pillaging? Write an angry letter? Start an online petition?

Re:Palantir gets $10B contract from U.S. Army by thefz on Friday August 01, 2025 @06:29AM (#44754995)
Can't really understand if this is the boutade of a 13 years old COD player, but: lots of countries don't have military supremacy nor enslavement and pillaging on their shores. There are LOTS of shades in between which you obviously don't get.
Re:Palantir gets $10B contract from U.S. Army by shepherdjerred on Friday August 01, 2025 @09:38AM (#44756657)
Can you name some countries that don't have military supremacy, e.g. through alliances?
Re:Palantir gets $10B contract from U.S. Army by thefz on Saturday August 02, 2025 @03:54PM (#44770826)
Many non-EU eastern Europe countries; middle African countries; south American countries
Re:Palantir gets $10B contract from U.S. Army by bootsmann on Friday August 01, 2025 @06:22AM (#44754945)
An easy way to avoid having to dump billions into defense is simply to have less enemies in the first place.
Re:Palantir gets $10B contract from U.S. Army by benterix on Friday August 01, 2025 @06:32AM (#44755023)
Although I upvoted you, it's a variable that you control only to some extent. At some point you will have an enemy that is irrational, power-hungry and unwilling to negotiate.
Re:Palantir gets $10B contract from U.S. Army by bootsmann on Friday August 01, 2025 @06:49AM (#44755127)
This is true, which is why Europe is now back to spending on defense, but you also have to consider the incentives here. Power-hungry people can use threats only if their populace can be whipped up by them. The fact that its largely impossible to gain approval in France by threatening Germany with invasion is a large part in why peace in Europe is so persistent.
Re:Palantir gets $10B contract from U.S. Army by XorNot on Friday August 01, 2025 @09:18AM (#44756379)
This is hardly historically true. What actually happened was Europe was devastated by two industrial total wars which is what led to this circumstance.

And then in the aftermath faced a Russia which promptly seized a whole bunch of Baltic states.

Or to put it another way: up till this year Canada was not planning it's strategic defence strategy with the US as a possible threat actor.

Re:Palantir gets $10B contract from U.S. Army by npteljes on Friday August 01, 2025 @06:23AM (#44754948)
I think it's not about the truth in that message, but rather how the message is delivered, and how the kernel of truth is planted into what context.

For example, the same message could be told by referring to respect instead of fear.

"I want less war. You only stop war by having the best technology so much that earns the respect of your adversaries. If they don't respect you, if they don’t respect the might that your army can summon, you. Instead of going along with you, they will attack you at the next opportunity"

Re:Palantir gets $10B contract from U.S. Army by benterix on Friday August 01, 2025 @06:31AM (#44755011)
Although I agree with you in principle, after having seen what Putin is doing in Ukraine, I believe the original message would reach the target better than yours.

To add to the confusion, you can have military intelligence assess your potential target and still fail miserably just like Putin failed in his blitzkrieg. So a little bit of saber-rattling might serve a purpose, I guess.

Re:Palantir gets $10B contract from U.S. Army by npteljes on Friday August 01, 2025 @07:53AM (#44755524)
Yeah, I'm inclined to agree. To be honest, I'm relieved that I don't have even a fraction of that responsibility.
Re:Palantir gets $10B contract from U.S. Army by bakuninsbart on Friday August 01, 2025 @08:49AM (#44756021)
The issue is that by introducing hyperbole, the meaning changes completely. Take the two statements:

1. I want peace.

2. a) Therefore I need to be strong enough to deter any attack.

2. b) Therefore I need to be so strong that all my enemies fear me.

2. a) is sound. Nobody attacks if they believe the cost is higher than benefit. ("Believe" is doing heavy lifting here, most wars start when countries belief about cost/value is misaligned)

2. b) is incompatible with 1. Either you believe that a stronger party does not necessarily attack weaker parties, thus peace could also be maintained without supremacy, or you believe supremacy leads to wars, but then your own goal of supremacy cannot be in the name of peace.

Unless, of course, you're a race supremacist, who believes you're so much wiser and more moral than anyone else that only you can be trusted with unchecked power. An idiotic and immoral position to take.

Re:Palantir gets $10B contract from U.S. Army by kubbelz on Friday August 01, 2025 @11:56AM (#44758660)
Wrong. 2b is compatible with 1. You can have peace without military supremacy, for a time at least. But you can guarantee peace with military supremacy. That's the difference.

You are at your enemy's mercy without it. They may conquer you on a whim, and there's not a thing you can do about it.

I would much prefer that military supremacy in the hands of the wise and moral, there's nothing idiotic or immoral about that (indeed, the opposite is idiotic and arguably immoral).

Re:Palantir gets $10B contract from U.S. Army by westpfelia on Friday August 01, 2025 @06:10AM (#44754856)
might as well use it then right? I mean think about it if there was only 1 country on the whole world. Then we would be safe. I mean we would still need to use the military equipment on the people. Anything else but absolute control over everyone would be suicidally naive.

Right?

Re:Palantir gets $10B contract from U.S. Army by usrusr on Friday August 01, 2025 @06:50AM (#44755142)
You seem to greatly underestimate how much of the fighting Roman legions did was against other Roman legions.
Re:Palantir gets $10B contract from U.S. Army by benterix on Friday August 01, 2025 @06:36AM (#44755047)
> I mean think about it if there was only 1 country on the whole world. Then we would be safe.

This is the logic behind the old-style Jihad. Also the Chinese emperors used the same argument when conquering smaller kingdoms.

Unfortunately, what happens in practice is that even in one Islamic country Sunni vs Shia terrorists attacks happen. And in the case of China, the price you pay for superficial peace are Uighur concentration camps, Tibetan self-immolations and so on.

Re:Palantir gets $10B contract from U.S. Army by kubbelz on Friday August 01, 2025 @11:47AM (#44758548)
You then have that option, yes. Usually it's not worth it - even the "winners" of a war suffer massive short-term loss of soldiers and resources, and create long-term enemies - but it's a nice option to have.
Re:Palantir gets $10B contract from U.S. Army by selivanovp on Friday August 01, 2025 @06:33PM (#44763182)
Wrong.

1 country in the world won't make you safe from wars. There's a reason why military was and is separated from police. Just think what's going to happen when your soldiers start to kill citizens.

1 country in the world tend to degrade to dystopian regime, and it was researched by multiple books authors, and actually a modern day USA is a good example of a regime on the path to dystopia.

Re:Palantir gets $10B contract from U.S. Army by saubeidl on Friday August 01, 2025 @06:10AM (#44754851)
It's one thing to pursue military supremacy.

It's another to build an Orwellian surveillance state.

Re:Palantir gets $10B contract from U.S. Army by baq on Friday August 01, 2025 @06:14AM (#44754896)
The Constitution prevents the US Government from spying on their citizens.

So of course the job is outsourced to allies.

Re:Palantir gets $10B contract from U.S. Army by saubeidl on Friday August 01, 2025 @10:10AM (#44757109)
This also ties in neatly with recent efforts to strip people of their citizenship.
Re:Palantir gets $10B contract from U.S. Army by laurent_du on Friday August 01, 2025 @07:15AM (#44755306)
There are stickers everywhere in my city against NATO. They say "food not weapons". As though the Ukrainians could defeat the Russians with pickles and ham. Left-wing idealism is grounded in denial of reality.
Re:Palantir gets $10B contract from U.S. Army by msgodel on Friday August 01, 2025 @07:24AM (#44755349)
Anti-NATO is left wing now?
Re:Palantir gets $10B contract from U.S. Army by laurent_du on Friday August 01, 2025 @07:35AM (#44755411)
There's a right-wing (or rather far-right) anti-NATO but it's much more confidential. Anti-NATO in Europe is typically found in communist and revolutionary movements.
Re:Palantir gets $10B contract from U.S. Army by kossTKR on Friday August 01, 2025 @06:18AM (#44754919)
The ones doing what you are describing here especially lately are the western powers with millions and millions of dead each decade in wars over resources not ideology or safety. It’s about money and power resulting in thousands of dead children, women and civilians - lately in palestine via israel. It’s creating terrorism not safety - so your argument is backwards - it’s the military industrial complex keeping the war going. And to use the ‘it’s for safety’ is extremely sinister and has been debunked continuously by everyone with even the slightest interest in geopolitics.
Re:Palantir gets $10B contract from U.S. Army by ohdeargodno on Friday August 01, 2025 @06:28AM (#44754982)
Out of curiosity, which country in the world is going to "begin the slaughter, enslavement, rape and pillaging" of:

- The country already having the largest army in the world, whose internal military branches are larger than most armies in the world ?

- The country that has a ocean to ocean control of its land, with east and west being fundamentally impossible to attack ?

- The country that is surrounded north and south by either allies, or third world countries struggling to even maintain peace within their own borders ?

- The country that is already going down some of the fastest descent into fascism history has seen ?

And how exactly that relates to Palantir, whose goal is not to provide vision algorithms for bombing brown people in the middle east, but to straight up build a file about their own citizens that would have made the Gestapo drool ?

The vast majority of countries that can afford a solid military already do, and neither is at threat of whatever bullshit you're making up here. Even local tensions like Pakistan and India, Thailand and Cambodia are being handled with incredibly small portions of their militaries, despite some pretty deep hatred. The countries that cannot, either have agreements with other powers in the region, or indeed get attacked by a military so overwhelmingly strong for them that even putting 100% of their GDP into it would not suffice.

I'll tell you what "pursuing military supremacy" does though: as it stands, the vast majority of the world sees the United States as a threat, with ever renewed imperialistic needs and aspirations. The United States is always just a single dip towards madness away from being the greatest danger that currently exists in the world. And now, they are suppressing internal protesters. But hey, if you're looking to rediscover how 9/11 was like and why it happened, pop off I guess.

Re:Palantir gets $10B contract from U.S. Army by msgodel on Friday August 01, 2025 @08:47AM (#44756007)
We don't need military supremacy in Asia, Asia isn't part of the US and the Asians should have supremacy there. Anything else is insane.
Re:Palantir gets $10B contract from U.S. Army by insane_dreamer on Friday August 01, 2025 @10:23AM (#44757257)
that's the thinking that brought us a nuclear arms race, to the point where we are now capable of wiping out the entire planet; thanks.
Re:Palantir gets $10B contract from U.S. Army by kubbelz on Friday August 01, 2025 @11:49AM (#44758582)
It's the thinking that prevents anyone from using all of those nuclear weapons against whoever they please.
Re:Palantir gets $10B contract from U.S. Army by insane_dreamer on Saturday August 02, 2025 @01:29AM (#44765094)
except it actually doesn’t; but it does put us all at risk