News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by shafyy on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:01AM (#44660006)
I think the direction we should go in is not to separate genders, but unify them. For example, there shouldn't be separate bathrooms or parking spaces. The more you make the separation, the more divided a society becomes. Just look at many muslim socities like Arabic countries where almost everything is separated.

Now, I am a male, but many females, including my partner, actually advance this point of view. Also look at more equal socities like in Nordic countries, and you'll see that there's much less separation than in countries with more gender inequality.

Of course, we can argue cause and effect and what not, but I still stand by the opinion that separation also has an effect on gender equality, not only the other way round.

Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by jasode on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:12AM (#44660125)
>I think the direction we should go in is not to separate genders, but unify them. For example, there shouldn't be separate bathrooms

This Uber gender option is about safety for women.

Some women are afraid of male Uber drivers stalking them and learning of their home address. To avoid that, they have to follow "best practice" hacks such as entering a decoy address of a nearby intersection for pickup and dropoff. This makes it more inconvenient but a little harder for Uber drivers to figure out exactly where they live.

Allowing for "female-only" drivers may help passengers avoid the cloak-and-dagger workarounds.

Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by shafyy on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:20AM (#44660214)
> This Uber gender segregation is about safety for women.

It's always about "safety for women". Or so they say. The argument for disallowing trans women in female bathrooms is also "safety for women". Complete bullshit. Similar argument with end-to-end encryption and safety for children.

However, often times these separations make society more unequal und unsafer for women.

It's a sad world if you think this to it's conclusion: Should females only ride with female taxi drivers? What about trains? Should we have separate train cars for females? Should we disallow females going out on the street alone without a male companion because they might get raped? It's about the safety for women, after all.

No, let's not start down this road. Are there men that harass and rape women? Of course! Will it happen a bit less if there's separation? Maybe. But it has many second-order effects that are not desirable.

Instead, as others have said, we need to think as a society why men are harassing women in the first place, and what we can attack this problem at the root.

Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by n4r9 on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:26AM (#44660293)
You keep confusing "giving women the option to X" with "forcing women to X".

> It's always about "safety for women" ... Complete bullshit.

It's not bullshit. What underhand motivation do you think is at work here? Uber famously had a terrible track record on sexual assault (overwhelmingly by men against women), but through policies like this have gradually been working it down.

> Should we have separate train cars for females?

It's not a terrible idea. From talking to women, there is a lot of fear of getting on trains alone at night. If they felt safer about it then it could be a net positive both for public safety and the economy. It has actually been floated in UK politics recently: https://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/women-only-train-carr...

Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by shafyy on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:46AM (#44660539)
I am not saying Uber is doing this with some underhand motivation. Not blaming Uber here. My point is broader one. That the more separation (even if optional) we introduce, the worse its impact on gender equality. What we should do is try to tackle the root causes.
Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by n4r9 on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @12:02PM (#44660721)
What do you think Uber could do to tackle the root causes? What would you say are the root causes?
Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by shafyy on Thursday July 24, 2025 @06:18AM (#44669020)
I don't work at Uber, so I don't know what they are doing. But what some things Uber could do, just off of the top of my head:

- Take complaints more seriously

- When selecting drivers, have a more rigourous selection procedure regarding this topic

What we as society can do? Many things, but let me list some that just spring to mind:

- Stop objectifying women in ads, movies, porn, popular culture and other places

- Stop treating nudity as some kind of crazy thing (of both genders, but again, double standards here because male topless nudity is not a big deal, but female is)

- Providing more suport for women who have been stalked or harassed or raped by men (ideally, so that we can pre-emptively stop those activities, not after it's too late)

- Education: Include gender education early on in school, mixed gender sports classes, mixed bathrooms, etc.

Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by n4r9 on Thursday July 24, 2025 @06:53AM (#44669217)
It's a great list. I believe Uber has improved on both of those items although could still do better (see e.g. [0]).

The issue with the second list is that it takes a long time to encourage that sort of social progress. It's extremely difficult to undo years of conditioning, so I think we have to wait it out until that generation ages out. In the meantime providing safety options for women in limited high-risk scenarios feels very jutifiable. And we continually reassess what those scenarios are so that we're allocating those measures in an efficient and moderated way.

[0] https://helpingsurvivors.org/rideshare-sexual-assault/how-ar...

Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by fizzler on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @02:55PM (#44662685)
> The argument for disallowing trans women in female bathrooms is also "safety for women".

No it's because they are men.

The main reason we have separate female and male bathrooms is safety for women.

Men who insist on accessing women's bathrooms are already showing themselves to not care about boundaries, it's a huge red flag.

Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by GloomyBoots on Thursday July 24, 2025 @03:31AM (#44667968)
This is one of those situations where it becomes abundantly clear whose dedication to abstract ethics overrides their acknowledgment of material reality and respect for others in terms of real-world safety.
Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by n4r9 on Thursday July 24, 2025 @05:21AM (#44668694)
That's something that I've heard both sides say about the other in this particular debate.
Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by fizzler on Thursday July 24, 2025 @11:41AM (#44672071)
Exactly, yes.
Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by shafyy on Thursday July 24, 2025 @06:13AM (#44668992)
You can fuck right off
Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by fizzler on Thursday July 24, 2025 @11:43AM (#44672090)
A rather overemotional response to a reasonable comment.
Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by thinkingtoilet on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:08AM (#44660080)
This is so typical. "As a man..." There are countless stories of women being harassed from uber drivers, lyft drivers, door dash delivery people, etc... This is the sad reality we live in. I'm glad the women in your life haven't experienced this or if they have they are able to manage it and not have it effect them. That is legit a great thing. However, to force the women who have trauma from this to experience it again seems cruel. I don't know what the word is for this, but it's a very common view online. It seems like a deliberate dismissal of reality in favor of some ideal world that doesn't exist.
Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by shafyy on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:21AM (#44660236)
Are you a female? Have you talked to females about this? I have, and what I wrote above is their point of view. I used to think like you before I had many conversations with women in my life about this very topic.
Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by gchamonlive on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:36AM (#44660418)
I'm sorry but that experience is still anectodal and doesn't invalidate whatsoever the negative experiences of others. Or you mean to say that just because you talked to females in your close proximity that the reality must be like that for everyone?
Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by shafyy on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:49AM (#44660577)
Of course it's anectodal. And no, I am not saying that reality is like this for everyone. I am saying that many men, who have not talked to women about these topics, have a false assumption. That there are many women who do not want separate bathrooms or separate taxi drivers, even though they might sometimes feel unsafe with men. Obviously, there are women who will argue for and against.
Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by gchamonlive on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @01:28PM (#44661735)
Which is why giving the option for those who want and need this separation is important. It's also important to take culture into account. In Japan there are separate metro wagons just for women because sexual abuse there is rampant.
Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by thinkingtoilet on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @12:57PM (#44661366)
Yes. And Uber has too believe it or not. So the few women in your life are fine without this, why are you so happy to ignore other women's thoughts? Is this some grand conspiracy from the woke mob? What it the end game here in your eyes?
Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by anthk on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:27AM (#44660296)
Sexual drive because of nudity ends when I change my clothes at beaches with my female partner and her friend like nothing (we are in Europe).
Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by shafyy on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:50AM (#44660587)
Yes, or if you go into a sauna which are nude and mixed gender in many European countries.
Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by n4r9 on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:16AM (#44660171)
> separation also has an effect on gender equality, not only the other way round

Possibly. I'd argue that it's good to give women the freedom to choose separation in specific scenarios where there's a relatively higher risk of sexual violence. Uber rides have historically proven to be such a scenario.

Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by colechristensen on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:10AM (#44660102)
I think that's a good goal and in general we should be deemphasizing our differences instead of strengthening them (not in the sense that everyone has to be the same but that how you are different shouldn't matter).

However there are some changes that need to happen and some major issues that need to be improved. Some of those include the reasons why women feel uncomfortable in Ubers. Incidents of very inappropriate comments are extraordinarily common much less the worse things which also happen.

Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by tartoran on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:10AM (#44660107)
Men's use of urinals is quite efficient and timely. By un-separating bathrooms it would mean removing them as I see no other way around it and this would not benefit anyone. Unseparating the washing area is okay by me though again, men and women have different habits and comfort zones. I'd say the least disruptive option is to add gender neutral bathrooms.
Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by nerdjon on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:15AM (#44660165)
Out of curiosity, why would a combined bathroom require removing urinals?

They could still exist, and have the added benefit of anyone regardless of their presenting gender being able to use them.

Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by MITSardine on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:15AM (#44660167)
Not to defend the other person's point of view (I don't have a horse in this race) but there are already open air urinals in festivals or even in Paris:

https://parishistoryofourstreets.com/2021/03/22/the-last-pub...

Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by staticman2 on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:33AM (#44660372)
I know open air urinals used to exist in Amsterdam in my lifetime- I don't know if they still exist or not.

I'm pretty sure the idea was drunk men were going to urinate in public on the street no matter what the authorities did so they might as well be directed to a urinal.

Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by n4r9 on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:19AM (#44660205)
There's actually one by Vauxhall station in London: https://www.mylondon.news/news/south-london-news/disgusting-...

I've personally been extremely grateful for it on multiple occasions, coming back from a night out.

Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by MITSardine on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:33AM (#44660376)
In cities where no such facilities exist (public toilets of any kind), you better not walk in quiet alleys off the busy streets if you have a sensitive nose...
Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by einarfd on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:27AM (#44660304)
No, you do not need to remove the urinals. The standard way of solving this here in Norway. Is to put the urinals at the inner end of the bathrooms around a corner. So you can’t see in at them from where the stalls or the sinks are. Works like a charm.
Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by shafyy on Thursday July 24, 2025 @06:20AM (#44669033)
Exactly. Or not even hide it. What, are you afraid that a girl will see your pee pee? Oh noo, poor boy.
Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by Nullabillity on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:20AM (#44660221)
Urinals are an unsanitary disaster anyway, and shouldn't exist; regardless of the genders involved.
Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by nerdjon on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:38AM (#44660455)
How exactly are they unsanity disasters? I would much rather use a urinal and never need to touch anything (besides myself, which unless I myself am unsanitary that should be clean) than need to either sit down and make contact with a surface a bunch of other people have made contact with or need to lift down and raise a lid to use that if I am standing.

Looking online I can't find anything about how they are any less sanitary than just a public bathroom is to begin with.

Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by AlexandrB on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:28AM (#44660322)
Unsightly, maybe, but I don't see how they're unsanitary. Urine is nearly sterile.

If you're standing up, it's also a lot easier to "hit the target" into a urinal vs. a toilet. Having a bunch of people peeing standing up into normal toilets would be a lot more gross than urinals.

Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by mmh0000 on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @01:57PM (#44662065)
TO BE FAAAAAIRRRR

Urine is not sterile[1] - BUT by itself is not a huge concern.

But you know what urine is? Full of vitamins and minerals. An ideal medium for bacteria.

Urine + Time = Ew.

[1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25766599/

Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by Nullabillity on Monday July 28, 2025 @03:11AM (#44708083)
> Having a bunch of people peeing standing up into normal toilets would be a lot more gross than urinals.

So.. sit the fuck down?

Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by Mawr on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @01:30PM (#44661762)
Men peeing into toilets always results in urine sprayed all over everything. I don't see how urinals could be worse.
Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by ryandv on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:03AM (#44660035)
I disagree. Sex segregation is the only way to ensure positive, safe, and inclusive women-only spaces that are free from patriarchal and toxic male influence. Any comparisons between this policy and puritanical religious societies are purely coincidental.
Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by erdeibit on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:11AM (#44660121)
Education is the only way. Segregation or annihilation of one gender is a impractical idea that some european country did in the past and the outcome wasn't good in any way.
Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by cryptonym on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:15AM (#44660157)
> Sex segregation is the only way to ensure [...] women-only spaces

I know you can't be serious but still...

Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by raxxorraxor on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:07AM (#44660065)
I think the qualifiers you use hint at are sourced from a puritanical religous belief itself for that matter. There are respective shelters for edge cases, but this should not be generalized towards most public spaces.
Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by gchamonlive on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:10AM (#44660106)
> I think the qualifiers you use hint at are sourced from a puritanical religous belief itself for that matter.

It's not, it's self preservation.

> this should not be generalized towards most public spaces.

It's also not. It's an option for people that want the segregation. It's not imposed on people to be separated.

Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by ryandv on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:08AM (#44660077)
You are implying that public space should not be safe and inclusive?
Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by AlexandrB on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @11:20AM (#44660224)
Safety and inclusion are often in conflict with each other. The feature being discussed, for example, is meant to improve safety for one group (women) by excluding another group (men). At the extreme end, we exclude convicted criminals from participating in society for the safety of others.
Re:Uber will let women drivers and riders request to avoid b... by AlecSchueler on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @02:39PM (#44662521)
I hope it's clear that the status quo excludes women. I guess it gets into the difference between equity and equality.