News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by leviathant on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @12:18PM (#44445563)
I live in Philadelphia. We had a lot of manufacturing here, but most of that vacated the city center in the 1970s and 1980s. I recently was doing some research into urban renewal around my neighborhood, and found a paper about the city's efforts to address a concentrated population of perpetually drunk homeless men, mostly centered in my neighborhood, mostly squatting in abandoned buildings or living in flophouses. The city's approach was effectively to remove them and spread them out - and bulldoze the neighborhood to make way for a federally funded highway, now I-95. A lot of manufacturing businesses just called it quits - the owners had made their money on the backs of cheap labor and hadn't really set up any kind of succession plan, but could retire comfortably. Others moved, mostly out of the city, and by the 90s, that labor was moving overseas.

And that's why I don't really foresee that kind of manufacturing coming back here. In order to survive the race-to-the-bottom pricing that the majority of Americans crave, you need a large labor force that will accept some form of sub-par living conditions. But if you can't earn a living wage, you can't afford to participate in the economy in a way that supports the manufacturing, and then you're back to those mid-century slums.

I'm dramatically oversimplifying things, my main point here is, I didn't really put together how much of early 20th century American manufacturing relied on chronically drunk homeless men.

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by bluefirebrand on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @12:39PM (#44445804)
> In order to survive the race-to-the-bottom pricing that the majority of Americans crave

I do wonder if this is an inherent "craving" or just tied to the reality that Americans cannot really afford things anymore

The middle class being eaten means that most people have much less discretionary spending, so every single purchase must be a bargain

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by h2zizzle on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @01:00PM (#44446094)
It's the second thing. Americans are proud to pay for things they can afford. They look down on people who aren't paying their "fair share." For example, music and movie piracy was never the domain of the average consumer; it's mostly been for broke young people and enthusiasts who don't like DRM and the limits it puts on use. And part of the reason for that is that Spotify and Netflix et al. made it possible to continue consuming "respectably". If physical media were still the norm, piracy would be rampant, but not because Americans tend towards it naturally; bevause they would have been pushed toward it by the imperative consume wedded with the inability to pay.

A lot of dumb "just so" tales in economics are willful miscategorization of desperation as choice.

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by bluefirebrand on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @01:34PM (#44446527)
> A lot of dumb "just so" tales in economics are willful miscategorization of desperation as choice

This is a great way of describing it, I like it

Incidentally, I'm starting a new business model to capture this market opportunity, I call it "DAAS", desperation as a service

It's where people pay me their excess money and get nothing in return, increasing their desperation

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by dmonitor on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @02:23PM (#44447144)
If you adjusted your business model to make other people miserable, you can sell yourself as a marketing agency
Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by UncleEntity on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @03:03PM (#44447560)
> It's where people pay me their excess money and get nothing in return, increasing their desperation

Wait, isn't that called 'campaign finance'?

The problem with competing with entrenched market interests is they can use their economic advantages to make the market impossible for newcomers to enter leading to de facto monopolies.

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by taeric on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @12:49PM (#44445943)
It is less a craving and more just a general response to availability? It isn't that people have a craving to spend less on things. But, if something is readily available for less, why would you pay more? Indeed, would you expect people to pay more for your goods, if someone else has equivalent goods for cheaper? Why?
Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by bluefirebrand on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @01:32PM (#44446504)
> someone else has equivalent goods for cheaper

They are never actually equivalent goods though

They are cheaper goods

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by taeric on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @01:39PM (#44446593)
Maybe? Clothing is a big counter to your claim here. As is anything that can be reliably machined.

Yes, there is "cheap" clothing. No, the more expensive clothing isn't necessarily better. A bog standard t-shirt is a bog standard t-shirt. With a minimum of quality control, and anything on top of that is not adding to the utility of it.

The machining revolution really hurts a lot of the idea that labor in is indicative of quality.

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by fragmede on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @03:27PM (#44447828)
Not necessarily, but it's total shit when you buy a t-shirt and it unravels after only wearing it a few times. That QC doesn't always happen is what's the problem, so buying the cheapest isn't wise.
Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by taeric on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @04:03PM (#44448188)
I mean... sure? Has that been happening for you? I have had some shirts that didn't last as long as others. Oddly, I don't think they are the ones I paid the least for.
Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by fragmede on Thursday July 03, 2025 @01:49PM (#44457520)
most of my newer clothes don't last as long as my older clothes.
Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by taeric on Thursday July 03, 2025 @02:07PM (#44457690)
I'm fortunate that my clothes still last quite a while, so I don't know what to say. Still have some t-shirts from the 90s, oddly.

I can say that if you wash cottons with synthetics, that will shorten the life of the cottons. If you use any "stretch" or "no iron" clothing, you almost certainly have a synthetic mix. It isn't that they are lower quality. Nor are they designed to not last as long. They are designed for that stretch and to look flat as their main goal.

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by Anyhao on Saturday July 05, 2025 @05:02PM (#44475512)
While it's true that they aren't designed to not last as long, not lasting as long is a side effect of their design decisions.

The primary reason for the tendency of clothing to wear out faster is the textile manufacturing processes allow for the production of thinner fabrics at a cheaper cost per yard. As anyone who sews or knits can tell you, thinner fabric wears out faster. It allows companies like Zara, H&M, Walmart, Rack, et al to sell their product at marginal cost increase for higher YoY profits with a faster replacement cycle.

Furthermore, it's a plainly stated business strategy of fast fashion that fungibility and the production of disposable consumables is core to their business. As that type of fashion cannibalized market share from more traditional brands that banked on quality more than affordability in the 90s, those same brands responded by creating separate imprints ( Off Fifth, Rack, et al ) or just wholesale adoption of the approach ( e.g. H&M ).

Fast forward to 2025 and we're having a conversation about whether or not the quality delta in clothing is real or a Mandela Effect. The reality is unfortunately the more banal "number go up by any means necessary" explanation.

https://slate.com/business/2024/12/white-t-shirt-quality-dec... https://www.thecooldown.com/green-business/sustainable-cloth...

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by taeric on Monday July 07, 2025 @09:37AM (#44490259)
Mostly agreed. This is what I meant by them not necessarily being lower quality. In many ways, it is a by product of the race to super thin threads. Which, amusingly, used to be a sign of ultra high quality. :D

And clothing has always been a consumable. Always.

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by CrimsonCape on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @06:34PM (#44449556)
As a counterexample, some casual googling about cotton suggests that there is an ideal workflow which will result in superior cotton fibers before harvesting. Here is a quote from the conclusion section of the linked article:

"Cotton fiber quality is shaped by a mix of genetics, growing conditions, and field management techniques. High-grade cotton relies on precise measurements of fiber length, strength, and micronaire, along with maintaining proper color and cleanliness throughout its growth. These elements play a key role in determining processing efficiency and market value across the supply chain."

At the most basic, if one farmer harvests his cotton with no consideration of the above issues, whereas another farmer carefully studies, prepares, tests, etc based on the above considerations, wouldn't there be added value and added cost of production?

I personally believe that in a past era, farmers intuitively learned these factors and competed with each other to make their best harvests, and the bog standard t-shirt got a quality buff as a fringe benefit.

Whereas nowadays, the farmer has to drop quality for quantity to compete with digitally-connected markets.

https://cottongins.org/blog/ultimate-guide-to-cotton-fiber-q...

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by taeric on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @07:26PM (#44449915)
You can personally believe it, but you also need to provide some evidence to the claim. Farmers that can't afford the R&D team necessary to learn a lot of this stuff will have trouble competing here. Such that, I'm comfortable claiming this sort of advantage will only consolidate the profits into bigger corporations.

And, indeed, if you look into high quality cotton supply, you find there are relatively few names.

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by bluefirebrand on Thursday July 03, 2025 @01:15AM (#44451844)
Lower cost of a good is a generally good indicator that the good is low quality

Unfortunately the inverse is not true at all

Higher cost on a good is not at all a reliable indicator of whether or not the good is high quality

There is a pretty big incentive for producers and sellers to produce low quality goods and convince consumers they are high quality, so they can sell them for a high margin

This is unfortunately very common in clothing

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by mymythisisthis on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @01:42PM (#44446638)
The Canadian movie Goin' Down the Road (1970), is related to this. It's fictional, but seemed to capture the less rosy aspects of that time.
Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by downrightmike on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @01:23PM (#44446375)
The anecdote that I heard was about GM, They'd have two guys doing two jobs on the same line, one of them would go off drinking for the day and the other guy just did both jobs half-assed, then they would switch the next day.
Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by api on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @01:17PM (#44446291)
Everything in economics is a paradox because everything is two sided, often with yourself on more than one side.

Selling your labor? You want high wages, unions, worker protection laws, etc.

Buying something? Now you want to cut wages and bust unions, at least if you tend to choose the cheaper item.

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by sokoloff on Thursday July 03, 2025 @02:52AM (#44452359)
When a consumer is buying labor embodied in a product, they don’t care whether that labor are unionized or what their wage per hour/day is.

They do care what the wage per unit produced is, which is why we see a lot of US manufacturing moving towards higher levels of automation to let the embodied labor per finished unit be lower and thus competitive in the market.

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by mixmastamyk on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @12:37PM (#44445783)
Were the drunk/hl folks the ones working in the factory? Doesn’t sound practical.
Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by taeric on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @12:47PM (#44445905)
The assertion is that during times of high work, you have far fewer of them drinking. Pair that with low cost worker tenements and you are able to scale up manual tasks much more rapidly than what you see in most US locations nowadays.
Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by dsr_ on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @01:22PM (#44446356)
From the 1500s through 1930 or so, in any place you could see working men, you could see drunk ones.

From 1930 through 1970, it was less common but just as tolerated.

MADD did what Prohibition could not.

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by fragmede on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @03:29PM (#44447852)
selt driving cars ftw?
Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by mixmastamyk on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @07:24PM (#44449898)
I'm familiar with that for say, digging a ditch, or the n-martini lunch. Less so with "perpetually drunk and homeless" factory workers operating potentially dangerous machinery.
Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by zafka on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @11:33PM (#44451393)
I worked a summer job at a factory that made box cars. 10x10 or larger sheets of 1/4 inch plate steel lifted on stacks with chain hoists, box cars tacked together, then put on a large rotisserie, so it could be turned as all the seams were welded. Anyhow, At lunch we all went out for shots and beers, and perhaps a doobie or two. While I did not see it, people did get squished. I survived my summer, but I did pickup a nicotine habit that lasted 20 years.
Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by sokoloff on Thursday July 03, 2025 @03:02AM (#44452411)
I interned at Daimler-Benz and assembly line workers had company-employed drink trolleys which would take your order early in the shift for what partially subsidized drinks/snacks you wanted delivered for your breaks during your shift. A tone would sound in the factory and workers would converge on the break area near them and pick up what they’d ordered earlier that day. On the menu was beer and plenty of workers would have multiple beers over the course of their shift.

These weren’t what you picture when someone says “perpetually drunk and homeless”, but I think a lot of Mercedes were assembled by workers with a perpetual low-level of alcohol on-board.

Re:They tried Made in the USA – it was too expensive for the... by gnopgnip on Wednesday July 02, 2025 @07:01PM (#44449734)
There are roughly half as many employed in manufacturing compared to 25 years ago. The declining trend started before this. At the same time American manufacturing output is at an all time high, measured in dollars. Wages are up. There are more jobs for things like mechanical engineers and millrights, fewer in packaging and assembly.