News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by djoldman on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @04:30PM (#44370696)
It appears that taking advantage of human imperfections and irrationality are taking up more and more of companies' strategies and time.

You've got folks thinking constantly about advertising, pricing strategies, dark patterns, network effects that prevent or discourage churn, etc., in ways that tend to exploit flaws in the consumer's decisioning process or gaps in their knowledge, to the consumer's disadvantage.

It feels rare to see an actual new valuable product or improvement.

Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by slg on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @05:11PM (#44371107)
I think the biggest change in general corporate management in my lifetime was the deprioritizing of the concept of goodwill. I’m not naive, businesses have always prioritized profit. However, there used to be this idea that pure profit maximization ruined your brand and reputation. You didn’t want to be known as the asshole company that nickel and dimes everyone or has draconian policies that make people hate dealing with you. Now the corporate mindset is seemingly that if anyone leaves any interaction with you with any positive feelings, you didn’t squeeze enough money out of them.
Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by sfifs on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @07:51PM (#44372295)
The biggest driver i feel is increased financialization of company ownership. Since the 80s, financiers essentially punish any boards or CEO who prioritizes longer term impact items like goodwill at the cost of short term quarterly results. This massively influences incentives - as a CEO or board you may know what is the right thing for long term success but you'll be fired if you choose that over short term results.
Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by m463 on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @09:34PM (#44372897)
I also think that brands are being attacked and devalued.

Look at all the ASKJKL type uppercase brands on amazon.

Meanwhile trusted/established brands are impossible to search for specifically.

And established brands are bought and sold to bad new owners. Pyrex was sold and doesn't make good (borosilicate) glass products anymore. Segway went to ninebot.

I'm sure there are lots of examples of this...

Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by nradov on Wednesday June 25, 2025 @01:02PM (#44379529)
Many established brands now have official stores on Amazon. Like here's one for Bose (not an endorsement). Search takes you right there.

https://www.amazon.com/stores/Bose/page/9E24AFD5-B420-4859-B...

I don't think that Segway was ever considered trusted or established. It has always been kind of a goofy niche product used by guided tour groups and mall security.

Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by 7thaccount on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @10:49PM (#44373244)
Milton Friedman and Jack Welch were pioneers of this nonsense.
Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by nradov on Wednesday June 25, 2025 @01:06PM (#44379583)
Nope. Financiers don't punish CEOs who prioritize longer term impacts, as long as the CEO maintains credibility by communicating a viable business plan and consistently delivering on commitments. The classic example is Amazon which had huge stock price appreciation while being unprofitable. Activist investors only step in to demand changes when the CEO and Board are incompetent.
Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by robbiewxyz on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @06:32PM (#44371737)
My gut is this comes down to lack of real antitrust enforcement. If your customers have no choice but to come crawling back to you then why treat them well?
Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by quantified on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @09:35PM (#44372908)
As in, it doesn't matter that you're "an" asshole. It would matter if you were "the" asshole, but all of you together can do what you want.
Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by steveBK123 on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @09:58PM (#44373017)
Seems like the opposite as the origin was Delta trying to compete with Spirit and then all the legacy carriers following.
Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @10:57PM (#44373280)
Those are two different things.

One is, you want a phone with drivers in the kernel tree so you can keep putting the latest version of vanilla Android on it without relying on the OEM. Except the market is too concentrated and then nobody makes that. Competition fixes this.

The other is, if you give people the choice between a $200 plane ticket with two checked bags and lots of leg room and a $170 plane ticket where it's standing room only and you can't check bags because the airline is reselling the cargo area of the plane to UPS, customers pick the second one. And then a competitive market provides you with that option which people choose and then complain about it even though the alternative is available. Choosing differently fixes this.

Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by steveBK123 on Wednesday June 25, 2025 @08:44AM (#44376666)
Everyone loves to complain about flying but generally all search by lowest price sort, click the first one. Flying is quite cheap in inflation adjusted dollars and customers could be a bit more selective, but are not.
Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by cosmic_cheese on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @05:18PM (#44371164)
It may just be a misperception on my part, but it appears to me that on average publicly traded companies are more likely to engage in this behavior and to greater extents than private companies. Startups can be pretty bad about it once the VCs come knocking, too. Maybe bootstrapped and private forever is the way.
Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by amonroe805-2 on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @06:02PM (#44371535)
Broadly agree, with the one caveat that private-equity-owned businesses seem to be even worse than public companies in this regard.
Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by Analemma_ on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @07:02PM (#44371989)
I agree, although there’s a lot of selection bias at work here: companies usually don’t get bought by private equity unless they’re already in distress, so whatever they were doing before the acquisition clearly wasn’t working.
Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by fn-mote on Wednesday June 25, 2025 @02:41AM (#44374251)
C.f. Private equity entrance to the veterinary market. Were they all really distressed? The issue is valuation of company vs underlying assets, isn’t it? Distress is one way, but a solid company not squeezing all of the value out of its customers / capital is another.
Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by supertrope on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @05:22PM (#44371200)
I have no love lost for airlines but they operate in a commoditized industry where customers sort tickets by price. All of the fat in the industry has been squeezed out and they have to claw for $20 here and there on a sale.
Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by dkjaudyeqooe on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @06:40PM (#44371803)
> All of the fat in the industry has been squeezed out

I don't know where you live but in the US this is patently not true.

Airlines are an abusive oligopoly there, with landing slots and the like cementing control of certain markets for certain airlines.

Ticket prices are much higher than they used to be and are much higher than Europe (for instance).

Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by nickff on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @07:09PM (#44372038)
The airline industry is famously unprofitable; it is commonly said that on net, the sum total of airlines have made $0 over the course of their history. It is true that there are periods where they do make a profit, but these periods are offset by times when they make massive losses (such as during COVID, after the Great Recession, and after 9/11).
Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by dkjaudyeqooe on Wednesday June 25, 2025 @03:05AM (#44374385)
Globally, big airlines seem to be doing fine:

https://www.aerotime.aero/articles/most-profitable-airlines

I think there are lots of airlines that are propped up by governments that lose money leading to the meme you're quoting. Many industries were affected by the events you quoted, those sorts of things aren't specific to airlines.

Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by nickff on Wednesday June 25, 2025 @09:05PM (#44383304)
There are two issues with doing a static analysis on something like this:

1) Survivorship Bias: you are only looking at airlines that currently exist, and ignoring ones that have gone out of business.

2) Recency Bias: you're examining them at a time of relative prosperity and stability, ignoring their pasts.

Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by burlesona on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @07:15PM (#44372096)
Airfare in the US costs less today than it did in the 90s, adjusted for inflation: https://www.bts.gov/newsroom/2024-annual-average-domestic-ai...
Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by geodel on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @10:17PM (#44373105)
Its not even the same product. When one consider the crowd level at airports, the lines at security, the size of airline seats, or size of food tray which matters specially on international routes.

Though I blame no one, if people want comfort they can pay more or travel less (if possible)

Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by pseudo0 on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @11:31PM (#44373414)
> Not included: Fees for optional services, such as baggage fees.

This entire article is about how airlines are unbundling their offerings and doing market segmentation through "optional" add-ons...

Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by dkjaudyeqooe on Wednesday June 25, 2025 @02:57AM (#44374341)
Average airfare isn't a useful stat in this respect. What would be useful is comparing fares for individual routes over the years, which would tell a different story.

Average fares are skewed by low cost carriers entering the market.

Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by tonyedgecombe on Wednesday June 25, 2025 @04:08AM (#44374784)
[delayed]
Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by dkjaudyeqooe on Wednesday June 25, 2025 @07:39AM (#44376113)
The large carriers, created through mergers that should never have been allowed, have the most popular routes locked up through ownership of landing/takeoff slots and similar. On those routes, fares have substantially increased due to a lack of competition.

The low cost carriers business model is to fly new routes (to secondary airports if required) at low prices, often creating new demand (Breeze is a classic example of this).

The math is very straight forward if you consider what each group is doing in the market.

Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by zdragnar on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @07:14PM (#44372082)
Plane tickets in the US are, inflation adjusted, historically low. Further, the airlines themselves seem to be on perpetual life support and have variously gone into bankruptcy and resuscitated.

You see an oligopoly, but the barrier to entry is as much defined by the thin margins and high capital cost as anything else.

Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by walterbell on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @07:52PM (#44372299)
Airlines have substantial earnings (greater than flying?) from credit card marketing and loyalty programs.
Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by lmm on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @08:32PM (#44372548)
The factoid that they make all their profit off of loyalty programmes is just a repackaging of the fact that they make pretty much no money overall. So you can pick any one part of the airline operation, account for it in a way that makes it profitable in isolation, and go "oh ho airlines really make all their profit from fuel price arbitrage between different countries" or what have you, and it's sort of true but not really reflective of reality.
Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by tekla on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @07:49PM (#44372281)
Airlines make roughly no money.
Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by quuxplusone on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @09:55PM (#44373000)
OTOH, from TFA: "By 2017, US airlines were among the most profitable in the world, and some Senators pointed to things like Basic Economy as evidence that consumer interests were being undermined for the sake of extra profit."

Both statements could be true simultaneously, of course.

Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by cma on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @08:06PM (#44372377)
Looking at the S&P500 about 30-40% of us equities value is based on selling customers data back to them or advertising on it, and establishing network effect stuff like developer ecosystems or marketplaces (Amazon) where a majority of the value comes from the outside ecosystem. I'm counting some of nvidia in that as the profitability others get of selling back transformed free data is a big part of their margin.
Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by bluGill on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @04:59PM (#44370989)
You can find people back in 1880 (probably before, but that is as old as I've seen something) saying much the same thing. Yet we have had a lot of innovation since then.
Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by Frieren on Wednesday June 25, 2025 @02:27AM (#44374161)
* citation needed
Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by jjk166 on Thursday June 26, 2025 @09:58AM (#44387494)
People were saying that in the 1880s, which was the gilded age. People took action at the time to deal with the problem, and it was significantly reduced for many decades.

Just because an issue existed long ago does not mean it has continuously existed or is intractable.

Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by carlosjobim on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @07:37PM (#44372230)
When you have A) a customer who isn't looking for a bargain, and B) a seller who cares about their reputation – then doing business is a pleasure for both parties and very smooth.

If you're the seller, then it's easy to filter out customers who don't fit into category A, with pricing. For the customer it's harder to filter out sellers who don't fit into category B, but generally you won't find them if you're looking for a bargain.

Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by bix6 on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @04:58PM (#44370980)
Spot on. Surfline gave us a bunch of new features over the past year but you have to pay more for them. Gone are the days of delighting your customers — gotta take every penny you can from each market segment.
Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by meta_ai_x on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @09:10PM (#44372761)
Having to pay for your bags and meals are actually good for consumers and overall environment.

If passengers are forced to pack lightly because they have to pay extra fees is actually a win-win-win for everyone. Plus it is less discriminatory because my airfare is not subsidizing someone else abuse of the system.

Same goes with food. I want the option to not pay for the shitty airline food.

Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by pete762 on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @11:42PM (#44373457)
The daily and seemingly random price fluctuations of tickets are much larger than the cost of meals you'd save, basically noise.
Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by robocat on Wednesday June 25, 2025 @05:05AM (#44375127)
The "noise" is very likely intentional.

A common way to price discriminate is to make the cheaper options take time and effort to obtain. People with less money will put in more time and effort e.g. price comparison, looking for discounts (codes or whatever), taking a few days to check prices, willing to move travel dates/times to get a cheaper price. Those with more money pay more and value their time/effort more highly.

Flight prices are not random - they are highly optimised (even using genetic A/B price generation algorithms that the airlines themselves might not fully be able to predict).

PS: Avoid LATAM Airlines Chile - dark pattern on website - those bastards increased the price while I was entering the credit card to pay (a popup - was ~2% but a dirty trick - maybe discrimination after detecting card owner credit details?).

Re:The Economics Behind "Basic Economy" – A Masterclass in P... by m3kw9 on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @09:56PM (#44373004)
You got economy or business class, you really don’t have much choice