http://androidspin.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/10/samsung-ga...
Let's not assume that we have the whole story behind the way the jury decided anything, one way or the other.
* this phone has curved (not flat) ends
* four HW buttons on the front (rather than one)
* it's black with a black border (has any iphone had that? Usually the iphone border is in a contrasting color)
* has a big "samsung" on the front
It's pretty distinct, hardware-design wise.
That's obviously crazy, but that appears to have been criteria used.
EDIT: This isn't as ridiculous as it sounds. See this 2002 article. BT registered a patent in 1976 for "double clicking hyperlinks" (or somesuch), and then in 2000 they realised that they owned this patent, and a bunch of people were clicking hyperlinks on the WWW, and they started suing people. They lost.
(http://www.computerweekly.com/feature/BT-patent-case-raises-...)
Quicklaunch bars certainly predate the iphone
edit - The Replenish was also granted 3.3 million http://www.prepaidreviews.com/podcast/SamsungReplenish.jpg
These are just laughable
If this is true, then it's hard to give this decision much weight at all. These two phones are vastly different and one literally says SAMSUNG on the front.