* this phone has curved (not flat) ends
* four HW buttons on the front (rather than one)
* it's black with a black border (has any iphone had that? Usually the iphone border is in a contrasting color)
* has a big "samsung" on the front
It's pretty distinct, hardware-design wise.
That's obviously crazy, but that appears to have been criteria used.
EDIT: This isn't as ridiculous as it sounds. See this 2002 article. BT registered a patent in 1976 for "double clicking hyperlinks" (or somesuch), and then in 2000 they realised that they owned this patent, and a bunch of people were clicking hyperlinks on the WWW, and they started suing people. They lost.
(http://www.computerweekly.com/feature/BT-patent-case-raises-...)
Quicklaunch bars certainly predate the iphone
Let's not assume that we have the whole story behind the way the jury decided anything, one way or the other.