News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by atrus on Wednesday June 18, 2025 @03:10PM (#44312511)
I think the repairabilty makes it hard to even compare monetary value, since in theory, you'd be keeping the same body, while swapping out the mainboard. Is it cheaper to buy two other laptops compared to one laptop + mainboard? That's what, a 3-5 year timeline? Who knows what prices/capabilities/etc will be like then.
Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by linsomniac on Wednesday June 18, 2025 @04:14PM (#44312955)
>in theory, you'd be keeping the same body, while swapping out the mainboard.

I love the idea of Framework, but the upgradability seems questionable to me. I base this off my experience with desktops where I've rarely over the decades upgraded more than the hard drive and RAM. When I'm looking at upgrading the motherboard it seems I just end up going all the way and getting a new case/ps/etc at the same time. Maybe that's just me though?

Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by CoffeeOnWrite on Wednesday June 18, 2025 @04:31PM (#44313052)
Because the old machine is still useful intact. I don’t see a difference between laptop and desktop here. I agree I don’t see myself ever swapping in an upgraded motherboard.
Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by MetaWhirledPeas on Wednesday June 18, 2025 @05:04PM (#44313264)
I think there are some important differences. Desktops are a continually evolving space and a hobby all on their own, due to all the different cooling options and aesthetic upgrades available. And since a lot of these involve a case swap you might as well do the whole enchilada.

The niche created by Framework, in contrast, is all about reuse. It's just a different game.

Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by scheme271 on Wednesday June 18, 2025 @08:40PM (#44314449)
There's kits that let you adapt the old motherboard into a server unit. It's a nice way to get a faster laptop while reusing your old components.
Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by kelnos on Wednesday June 18, 2025 @10:19PM (#44314863)
> Because the old machine is still useful intact

I do wonder how many people repurpose old laptops when they get a new one. I have three old laptops, two of which I haven't turned on since I transferred my stuff to the next one. My partner uses the third one to game sometimes, but she's recently gotten a new laptop of her own (her old one is ancient), so I expect she'll stop using that one as well.

My current laptop is a Framework 13 (from 2022) that has already seen some upgrades and repairs that wouldn't be possible on any of my old laptops. I expect this chassis and SSD to last quite a long time, with periodic mainboard and RAM upgrades.

Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by einsteinx2 on Thursday June 19, 2025 @10:41AM (#44319134)
Maybe I’m reading into this too much, but just the fact you even had to make repairs (plural) in a 3 year old laptop doesn’t speak highly of Framework’s quality. I’d expect to make exactly zero repairs in 3 years of owning any decently built computer.
Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by bestham on Thursday June 19, 2025 @01:15PM (#44320622)
Perhaps they dropped their laptop from great height? Something would render a conventional MacBook a write off. You cannot know that led to the repairs. Only that they were successful.
Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by carlhjerpe on Wednesday June 18, 2025 @05:26PM (#44313412)
I've kept the same PSU for two motherboards and the same chassis for four motherboards. I've kept my main monitor across two motherboards and my second monitor across three motherboards.

If you're a Framework customer it's not entirely unlikely you buy a case for your older mobo and now you have a power efficient home-server (or something) at your disposal.

Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by paxys on Wednesday June 18, 2025 @05:38PM (#44313496)
You can't upgrade the hard drive or RAM on modern laptops either.
Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by stevesimmons on Wednesday June 18, 2025 @05:56PM (#44313607)
You can upgrade SSD on most laptops other that Mac.

My Dell XPS13 came with a 1TB SSD, which recently was replaced with a 4TB one...

Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by eddythompson80 on Thursday June 19, 2025 @12:18AM (#44315396)
eh, while not fitting ragebait, plenty of Lenovos, Dells, and HPs have upgradable hard drives and not few have upgradable RAM and WiFi modules too. I'm writing this on a 2019 Lenovo P2 that I upgraded both the RAM and nvme on it.
Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by carlhjerpe on Thursday June 19, 2025 @07:46AM (#44317732)
Never seen a device with soldered storage that is a laptop and isn't an Apple.

And the reason why RAM is soldered is because they need the signal integrity to run "high performance" graphics on it, it's not (just) because the manufacturer hates you. This is why FW desktop has soldered memory too.

LPCAMM is coming, which is an interface with better signal integrity than SODIMM or whatever they're called, I hope it will bring RAM upgradeability back to office machines. I really only need to render videos and a slightly animated WM on my laptop so I don't care for HIGH PERFORMANCE AI IGPU when I have a desktop at home.

Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by pdpi on Wednesday June 18, 2025 @06:02PM (#44313648)
I bought the DIY FW13 a while back, and it took me 40 minutes from receiving the box to having it fully assembled, Fedora installed and a Youtube video playing. I bought the hi-res display a month or two ago, and the whole replacement took ~20 minutes. In between those two experiences, the whole upgradeability thing feels very very real for me. If anything, it's easier to work on than my desktop PC.
Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by moltopoco on Friday June 20, 2025 @06:58AM (#44326558)
For the same money, one can also get a laptop that has a nice display right from day one. The FW12 looks interesting, but if I'm hoping to buy an upgraded screen down the road, and a better CPU, a backlit keyboard, a better camera, and maybe better speakers... then I am not taking advantage of upgradeability, I'm bending over backwards just to avoid buying a Lenovo Yoga or so.
Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by pdpi on Friday June 20, 2025 @03:04PM (#44330889)
Don't get me wrong — the real draw is repairability, not upgradability. Upgrades are just a fringe benefit for a nerd who likes tinkering, and proof that the repairability is real.
Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by jijijijij on Saturday June 21, 2025 @07:05AM (#44336533)
Specs aren’t everything.

If we’re talking Thinkpads, Framework has a better offering IMO, especially if you don’t get Lenovo edu prices. I think for a lot of IT departments the Frameworks are quite attractive, now. And that’s before they even really developed the business offering.

How’s Linux support on the cheap non-thinkpad Yoga? If it doesn’t boot, can you easily remove the SSD and protect your data before sending it in for a few weeks? Fixing a Framework yourself doesn’t void its warranty. In a deadline situation this can be quite existential.

You are seemingly also come from a place where the individual grand total is your measure, but if finances are limited, the progressive, as needed upgrade path may be more of a value in itself. Something something shoes.

I don’t think the "just buy a Mac" or the cheapest laptop possible crowds are the target audience. I can totally see something like the Framework 12 becoming the platform for eg. a school's FOSS based tech program with good maintenance scalability. Especially outside the US.

Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by ben-schaaf on Wednesday June 18, 2025 @08:15PM (#44314362)
It's definitely been different on desktop for me. My computer's been ship of thesiussed twice over, but even when I changed the case,PSU,MB,CPU,cooler that one time the GPU and storage stayed. I've changed CPU 4 times and GPU 5 times over the past >15 years.
Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by pcchristie on Wednesday June 18, 2025 @08:35PM (#44314430)
The main difference is the chassis is ~ 10% of the cost of a desktop. It's ~ 40% (?) of the cost of a Framework, so rolling it forward (with screen, speakers, mic, keyboard, webcam etc.) saves you a fair bit more value.

I haven't checked those %s but just using them notionally.

Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by carlhjerpe on Thursday June 19, 2025 @07:40AM (#44317691)
My case was 100$ and it's housed components worth maybe 4000$ over it's lifetime, I regret not getting one with dust filters now that it's been stickerbombed and has sentimental value.

But it's definitely more percentage value in a laptop with touchpads, wifi, keyboard, battery and display over a case that's just some bent metal and if you're fancy a glass panel.

Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by eikenberry on Wednesday June 18, 2025 @08:59PM (#44314545)
Parent said nothing about upgradability, it was about repairability. Modularity supports both but I buy framework laptops for the repairability. I stopped buying laptops for real work a long time ago as they were to fragile and had to be sent back to the manufacturer for repairs. Having a modular (repairable) laptop means I don't need a desktop computer just to reliably have a computer.
Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by jijijijij on Saturday June 21, 2025 @07:17AM (#44336597)
In case you must send it in, with a Framework you can also remove the SSD (in like a minute) beforehand, so you don’t have to trust the manufacturer‘s repair contractor with your digital secrets/data integrity.
Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by kelnos on Wednesday June 18, 2025 @10:08PM (#44314829)
Back when I had a desktop computer (almost 20 years ago!), I would usually keep the case and upgrade motherboard, CPU, RAM, video, etc. Unless the case was holding back something I really wanted to do (like have more drive bays or PCI slots), I'd see no reason to replace the case. In fact, a case upgrade would be independent of the component upgrades. I had a very janky, cheap case for the machine I built for college; once I graduated and had a job and some income, I replaced the case without upgrading any of the components. And then a year or two later I think I upgraded the motherboard and CPU.

I'm pretty happy with the Framework 13 form factor (though, after 3 years of use, I'd still probably prefer a 16:9 or 16:10 screen over the weird 3:2 they ship with), and absent any future catastrophic damage to it, I don't see a reason to replace the chassis.

And I've already upgraded a few things in it: I have a newer mainboard (well, to be fair, I got it due to a warranty repair where they decided it was cheaper for them to upgrade me to the 2023 model), and I upgraded the built-in speakers and the webcam. I'm thinking about upgrading the screen as well at some point. In two years I'll probably replace the mainboard and RAM (not that I want to replace the RAM, but I have DDR4 now, and I'll presumably need DDR5).

Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by eddythompson80 on Thursday June 19, 2025 @12:10AM (#44315355)
You were way over complicating the cheapest part of a build. A good keyboard, mouse and display cost way more than a case and I almost never upgrade those when upgrading a PC
Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by locusm on Thursday June 19, 2025 @12:20AM (#44315407)
Maybe you were an Intel user and couldn't be bothered upgrading to a new motherboard every CPU release?
Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by SergeAx on Friday June 20, 2025 @05:47AM (#44326115)
I bought my desktop PC about 20 years ago, and since then, I've never upgraded more than two components at once. It is literally Theseus' ship. But I put some effort into keeping it future proof, like buying memory compatible with the next generation motherboard, better modular PSU with power for future video card etc. It is actually quite fun game, especially when your vendor return policy is generous enough to not worry if something won't fit or won't work together.
Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by jijijijij on Saturday June 21, 2025 @06:11AM (#44336246)
Your mental idea of "desktop pc" probably doesn’t consider monitor, speakers, keyboard, touchpad, camera and most importantly battery. It isn’t mobile, wear risk of damage is limited. The case of a desktop pc is merely an afterthought, in a laptop it’s protection and interface, basically the thing. A desktop pc is usually also rather overpowered, since heat/energy demands and high component costs are of less concern, where laptops are often defined by compromise between physics, costs and tech at a certain time. Why would you bother upgrading an overpowered desktop CPU/RAM for slightly better energy efficiency, where in a laptop a „node size jump“, or even new ISA can mean double battery life, or less thermal throttling.
Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by benrutter on Wednesday June 18, 2025 @03:24PM (#44312619)
Yeah, this is my experience with a Fairphone 4. It seemed pricey initially, but I have saved sooo much by being able to carry out simple repairs.
Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by paldepind2 on Wednesday June 18, 2025 @04:02PM (#44312872)
How often do you break your phone that you've save sooo much? Mine is at least 2 years older (I got it 2 years before the Fairphone 4 was released) and I've spend 0$ dollars repairing it.
Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by XorNot on Wednesday June 18, 2025 @05:22PM (#44313386)
In a laptop context the advent of soldered on RAM and SSDs has made this a more significant issue though.

That 1TB I thought was enough might not be, and suddenly I need to buy a whole new machine to upgrade.

Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by christophilus on Wednesday June 18, 2025 @07:03PM (#44314029)
Are the SSDs often soldered? I thought that was only the RAM.
Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by kelnos on Wednesday June 18, 2025 @10:20PM (#44314871)
Depends on the brand/model, of course, but I think for a 13"-sized laptop, it's pretty common to solder in the storage as well.
Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by jijijijij on Saturday June 21, 2025 @07:22AM (#44336622)
So you haven’t even changed the battery? That would be impressive durability.
Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by benrutter on Saturday June 21, 2025 @02:32PM (#44339681)
Embarrasingly often! Things I've done specifically:

- Getting cement in the charger port

- Dropping the phone on its screen breaking it

With some phones both of those could be full replacements.

Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by nucleardog on Wednesday June 18, 2025 @03:16PM (#44312571)
Yeah, I personally take that into account however I can see why someone may not.

Framework has released fairly consistent upgrades for the Framework 13, but there's no guarantee that they will continue to do so, will release upgrades for the Framework 16, etc.

I think in a few years when they've been in business for closer to a decade than not and released updates across the whole product line, it'd be pretty hard for anyone to make an argument that that _shouldn't_ be factored in.

Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by leptons on Wednesday June 18, 2025 @03:55PM (#44312827)
It could also be worth it to keep the same body and upgrade over the years, just to avoid the frustration of re-learning a new laptop keyboard layout.
Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by brudgers on Wednesday June 18, 2025 @06:41PM (#44313907)
Thinkpads have had similar layouts for decades. The keyboard mechanisms have of course changed, but the Emacs friendly dual ctrl and alt symmetric about the space bar have remained.

Also being the most Linux friendly laptop also means they have very long update lifespans and being well built tend not to break…though there are plenty of repair parts and spares.

Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by paxys on Wednesday June 18, 2025 @05:41PM (#44313519)
And it isn't just about upgrading for better specs. I'd wager the majority of people's laptop replacement cycle is triggerd by a single part dying (screen, hard disk, keyboard, hinges, PSU), the device being out of warranty, and the store quoting more for the fix than a new device would cost. Being able to purchase the $50 part online and do the repair yourself will probably save the average person thousands over a 3-5 year span.
Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by richardwhiuk on Wednesday June 18, 2025 @06:05PM (#44313678)
Most laptops I know have lasted 5-7 years and then been replaced. It's totally unclear to me that a single part would have changed any of those replacements.

I'm curious if you have a different experience where you ditch a laptop after less than 3 years because a single part has broken as you imply.

Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by Tade0 on Wednesday June 18, 2025 @07:30PM (#44314136)
I did that once when I created a pressure mark on the screen via mishandling, bought a replacement only to find that it didn't fit due to some kind of nuance in the model name - never found the correct part.

I passed it down to family and bought a new laptop, as my attempt at repairing also damaged the plastic parts which were holding the bezel in place.

Overall every laptop I had suffered mechanical damage of some sort and occasionally it was just something I had to live with, as I didn't want to chance e.g. soldering.

With my Framework I know any regular repair is a 30min job, as I assembled and disassembled it several times already.

Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by dzhiurgis on Wednesday June 18, 2025 @07:34PM (#44314158)
You can get AppleCare for at least 4 years now, not sure if you can extend beyond that.

Also, while I can repair laptops myself, I for sure don't want to.

For me cheap storage is the only sell and even that I can mitigate with tiny flush external SSD stick and/or NAS.

Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by dzhiurgis on Wednesday June 18, 2025 @07:32PM (#44314148)
Why would I care when I can get at least 4 years worth of AppleCare from Apple?
Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by nmridul on Wednesday June 18, 2025 @10:24PM (#44314883)
Here you can mostly dyi the repair. So you are not stuck waiting for Apple's appointment and repair schedule which would be a week at the minimum that you are grounded. Plus easy upgradeability ..
Re:Framework Laptop 12: I'm excited to see what the 2nd gene... by dzhiurgis on Thursday June 19, 2025 @06:24AM (#44317190)
I don't really want to DIY, I want quicker turnaround from Apple (which generally can pull off same day repairs if you ask).