News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by bmacho on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @04:18PM (#44251360)
> The Big Bang is often described as the explosive birth of the universe – a singular moment when space, time and matter sprang into existence.

It is indeed "often described" in the media as such. However, that is _not_ the currently accepted theory. "What if there were no space and time before the Big Bang" is just Stephen Hawking's pet theory.

Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by jerf on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @04:39PM (#44251570)
A more accurate summation would be that our theories do not permit us to go back beyond what appears to be the "Big Bang", and indeed, we can't quite get to it either, since the need for Quantum Gravity becomes too great as we get to what seems to be the "zero time". We have no principled, reasonable way to make any claims about what came before the point where our theories break down, and that includes the claim that there was no space or time at all before then.

Thus, anything and everything you've heard about what is there "before the big bang" has always been speculation. I mention this because sometimes people read the science media, which is always reporting on this speculation, and think that the reporting on the speculation constitutes "science" constantly changing its mind, but that's not the case here. Science has consistently not had a justifiable position on this topic, ever. It has always been speculation. It is the press that often fails to make this clear and writes stories in terms of what "science" has "discovered", but any claims of certainty in this area are not the claims of "science".

Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by _alternator_ on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @05:20PM (#44251944)
Interesting thing with this work is that it does create an observable, testable hypothesis: slightly positive curvature of the universe.
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by koakuma-chan on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @04:39PM (#44251567)
What is the currently accepted theory?
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by bmacho on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @05:08PM (#44251825)
We have no theories working at those conditions. Wiki says

> General relativity also predicts that the initial state of the universe, at the beginning of the Big Bang, was a singularity of infinite density and temperature.[6][obsolete source] However, classical gravitational theories are not expected to be accurate under these conditions, and a quantum description is likely needed[7].

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravitational_singularity

Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by DrammBA on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @05:40PM (#44252112)
> [6][obsolete source]

I didn't know but apparently wikipedia treats old sources as obsolete, doesn't matter if there's new information or not that would make it obsolete.

I wonder if any sources supporting the notion that the earth is round must be updated every couple of years with a new source or study.

Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by cwmoore on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @06:01PM (#44252309)
That exemplifies a much deeper problem than good information, “Good Law”: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Good_law

As an aside, the earth is almost flat, just not nearly as flat as the Universe.

Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by DrammBA on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @06:05PM (#44252340)
> As an aside, the earth is almost flat, just not nearly as flat as the Universe.

Source? And make sure to update your response every few years.

Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by cwmoore on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @08:55PM (#44253404)
It’s in the Library of Babylon. My standing citation.
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by mkl on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @06:06PM (#44252351)
Obsolete doesn't just mean old, it means superseded by newer information.
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by DrammBA on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @06:17PM (#44252430)
I agree with you, wikipedia seems to disagree with both of us
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by arbll on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @05:08PM (#44251827)
At t=0 or "before" none
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by joquarky on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @10:11PM (#44253697)
This is the best theory we have:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Last_Question

Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by smadsen on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @04:45PM (#44251632)
What people seem to not be able to conceptualize, consciously or not, is that there really is no "before" the Big Bang in the standard model (Lambda-CDM), if time itself exists only after t=0.
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by nathan_compton on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @05:47PM (#44252177)
The Lambda CDM does not really say that. As other commenters have pointed out, Lambda-CDM is silent on the very earliest few moments of the universe where quantum gravity would be required.
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by AtlasBarfed on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @05:22PM (#44251961)
Seems inevitable that we'll discover we aren't the only universe / only cycle.

We went from thinking the Earth was the center of the universe, to the sun being the center of the universe, and the next obvious step is our universe isn't at the center of universes.

Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by twodave on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @04:26PM (#44251440)
Might as well believe in God if you’re going to believe in spontaneous accidental creation…
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by kibwen on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @04:30PM (#44251478)
Why not? If you can't observe it, test it, and reproduce it, then it lies outside the realm of science and in the realm of belief. Until someone figures out a way to experimentally verify the big bang hypothesis (or any other explanation for the origin of the universe or what came "before"), it's entirely fair to attribute it to whatever you feel like, be it a god or anything else. There is no law of the universe that guarantees that science is capable of answering all questions.
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by ACow_Adonis on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @05:04PM (#44251784)
Well, I think surely the entirely fair thing to do is to just admit we don't know rather than make any attribution or imply any possession of an answer to those questions?
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by kibwen on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @05:30PM (#44252021)
Certainly, that's also perfectly fair. The thing to keep in mind is that some people derive utility from belief in some sort of creator, so ultimately it's an argument of values (specifically, you're looking to argue that people should prefer uncertainty to unprovable (but also undisprovable!) certainty).
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by tstrimple on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @10:45PM (#44253859)
Humans have created models for things they don't understand throughout human history. Certainly throughout any recorded history. We don't know, but we have a model that fits pretty well and we can guess at the underlying causes. We'll be wrong more often than right, but over time as we get more data and we can test more things, we get a more accurate model. Not necessarily the right model. We may never get that. But based on those models, "guesses" are far more reliable than "The Sun is a god who circles the world".

While we don't "know" how gravity works we can explain it and model it much more accurately now than when logos was the explanation. Providing those details is far more useful than a simple "we don't know."

Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by mjh2539 on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @08:48PM (#44253360)
If you can't observe it, test it, and reproduce it, then it lies outside of the realm of (natural) science and may lie within the realm of mathematics, philosophy, or (gasp) theology.

> There is no law of the universe that guarantees that science is capable of answering all questions.

There's a name for a more nuanced version of this "law" and there's a good amount of work being done arguing for and against weaker and stronger versions of it: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/sufficient-reason/

Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by kibwen on Thursday June 12, 2025 @10:46AM (#44258441)
I think it's important to clarify that the question of whether or not everything has a cause is itself outside of science. Science is about determining what a cause is likely to be, using the universe itself as a source of truth, and constrained by fundamental limits on our ability to observe and experiment. Which is to say, even if the philosophers conclude that everything must have a cause, there is still no law that says that we (as scientific agents of a universe that is attempting to understand itself) are capable of determining every possible cause.
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by duped on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @05:39PM (#44252099)
There's quite a big philosophical difference between "there exists a point beyond which it is possible to make observations" and "the universe was created by an omnipotent being"
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by Terr_ on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @05:48PM (#44252180)
Verily, for all knowest that the gods live up in the sky, which is forever unreachable and unobservable by any man.
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by hshshshshsh on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @05:59PM (#44252288)
Yes. The man can never see consciousness. Only consciousness can see man.
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by hshshshshsh on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @05:44PM (#44252146)
Am omnipotent being is a necessity for making observations. A lot of religions considers consciousness as God.
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by nathan_compton on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @05:50PM (#44252207)
I don't see how this is. It seems eminently reasonable that observation can simply be performed by sub-omnipotent beings.
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by hshshshshsh on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @05:51PM (#44252218)
Life is one omnipotent being. It's just ego, thoughts and social identity that creates the illusion of multiple beings.

But ego and names are made up. Separation just thoughts. The more life believes in thoughts it becomes divided.

But the waves and ocean are one.

Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by 47282847 on Thursday June 12, 2025 @02:35AM (#44254802)
An illusion is something that disappears when you see behind it, no? How goes it for the illusion of the both of us being connected but separate beings? I think at the very least it would require consent of both parties to merge, so as long as I don’t believe it, you have to live as a being separate from me, and as such it stays „an illusion“ for you that we are one; merely an idea, a potential option maybe, no?

You can declare Life to mean the complex interplay of every living organism, but I don’t see how you can go as far as to claim our physical and mental separateness is not there at all? After all, we need boundaries between „us“ to not be utterly alone. I like to think even of „my“ body more as a federated system, like Life maybe but on a smaller scale. I have some influence on it but not full control. In fact, one could say the polarities in the physical realm are Nature (towards separation, entropy; Kaos) and Life (actively working towards one, requires energy to keep matter ordered; Order).

Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by 47282847 on Thursday June 12, 2025 @06:22AM (#44255930)
(Alone, all-one)

If we merge, by definition the „I“ and „you“ have to die; both of us stop existing. The merger creates something new, a „we“. A single entity. We can then use the definition of identity to call this new we „I“. Rinse and repeat until back to being alone/all-one?

Do you really want to be all-one? Omnipotent, full of all potentials/possibilities? I don’t know. I am already overwhelmed with my limited human potential/possibilities/options. And I prefer to not be alone. I prefer to stay separate, and keep my identity.

Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by nathan_compton on Thursday June 12, 2025 @01:56PM (#44260634)
I don't get it. Put all life together and its all pretty obviously NOT omnipotent as far as I can tell. Every living thing on earth could spontaneously have an desire about the state affairs on Pluto and I don't see any reason to believe anything on Pluto would change.
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by hshshshshsh on Tuesday June 17, 2025 @12:57PM (#44301213)
Can you find any separation in your experience without using beliefs.
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by lukas099 on Friday June 13, 2025 @11:09AM (#44269235)
To quote the philosopher Hank Hill, "Yeah, yeah, I know, everything is one way, then it's the opposite."
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by arbll on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @05:11PM (#44251849)
Anything outside of what we can observe will always be based on faith anyway. We'll probably never understand what's "before" the big bang, wether it make sense to ask that question or why something exists rather than nothing.
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by nathan_compton on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @05:49PM (#44252198)
I don't think so - god is substantially less parsimonious. But in the end, I think you're sort of using two different notions of belief as if they were the same.

I believe (lowercase b) in all sorts of stuff, scientific and otherwise, but believing in God typically indicates some kind of act of faith, which is to say, ultimately, to believe in something despite the absence of evidence for it and for some deeper reason than can be furnished by a warrant of some kind. I can believe in the spontaneous generation of the universe in the lowercase b sense of the word without really having anything to do at all with the latter kind of belief, which I think is kind of dumb.

Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by mjh2539 on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @08:57PM (#44253414)
Historically, in the West at least, the ability or inability to reason one's way to the existence of God determined whether you needed to rely on faith or not.

https://www.vatican.va/content/pius-xii/en/encyclicals/docum...

Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by FeteCommuniste on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @09:57PM (#44253638)
Nice, paragraph 5 and he's already into "evolution is fiction and commies love it."
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by mjh2539 on Thursday June 12, 2025 @01:09PM (#44260113)
You didn't read closely enough. He is condemning the notion that evolution explains the origin of all things (as ridiculous as that sounds...it was a kind of ontological darwinism; no reasonable person holds this opinion today).
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by skellington on Thursday June 12, 2025 @12:48AM (#44254392)
Sort of like believing that we have free will.
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by kobalsky on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @05:35PM (#44252061)
You're confusing belief with accepting the current scientific consensus.
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by pharrington on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @05:14PM (#44251878)
Which God? Vishnu? Ra? Amatarasu?
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by ben_w on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @05:16PM (#44251906)
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by hshshshshsh on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @05:35PM (#44252056)
Assume God exists.

Various isolated cultures are going to come up with different names for God.

This like saying which Sun? Surya, Ra or Helios?

All are different names of sun. But there is only one sun.

Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by nathan_compton on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @05:52PM (#44252230)
On the other hand, there are a lot of stars and different cultures might give them different names and yet there really are many of them.

Furthermore, assume God doesn't exist. Lots of cultures might invent god for various reasons and they'd naturally have different names and attributes for them, which in fact seems to be the current state of affairs.

In fact, if we assume God exists and is actively in communication with humans, its actually a bit weird that different human cultures would have different conceptions and names for that being. Why didn't it just give everyone the same name and information?

Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by hshshshshsh on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @06:04PM (#44252327)
Why do you think God will have a name? Name is used by humans to identity a person among a lot of other persons. Why will God have a name if it is the only thing in existence?

To answer the question of why humans give name to God. It's to make god more relatable so that they can workshop it. And use devotion to come closer with it. Look up Bhakti Yoga.

Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by yibg on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @11:39PM (#44254102)
How about just having one God vs many? If there is a single omnipotent being, why do various cultures have multiple gods? And why do different cultures’ gods tell them different things?
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by hshshshshsh on Thursday June 12, 2025 @04:17AM (#44255242)
Fair question. So my understanding is God is consciousness. It's omnipotent, all knowing and eternal. It's the only thing which is constant in your life and it sees everything you do.

Now, you cannot worship consciousness as humans because it's invisible and you can never imagine it. You need a version of consciousness that you can see as well as you can relate to. So cultures invent localized version of God which people can relate to. And of course it will have attributes similar to that of the culture. But the properties kind of still hold. Like all knowing, powerful etc.

Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by yibg on Friday June 13, 2025 @01:02AM (#44265821)
I’m sorry but that’s a lot of words to provide no additional clarity. God is consciousness. So if there are no conscious beings in the universe there is no god? Or is this just renaming something that already has a meaning into god?
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by lukas099 on Friday June 13, 2025 @11:24AM (#44269383)
This reminds me of what Jordan Peterson does, which is to define "God" as something that we know exists. He defines it as the fundamental value upon which other values are built; you define it as consciousness.

I've always thought arguments like these are unnecessarily applying a term loaded with human conceptions and biases in a way that doesn't shed any further light on the thing it's applied to. Like, what do we gain by defining "God" as consciousness? Why can't we just say "consciousness"? And is it worth the added confusion that when we say "God", we now don't mean what most people think "God" is?

The only reason I can come up with to do this is discomfort at saying, "I don't believe in God."

Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by nathan_compton on Thursday June 12, 2025 @01:53PM (#44260608)
I didn't say he'd have a name, I said he'd give humans a uniform one since, according to, for instance, the Christian worldview he is purported to be interested in human affairs.
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by devnullbrain on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @08:19PM (#44253226)
But that sun has never been a pharoah of Egypt.

If the only common factor is a belief that 'something' created 'something', you're really not saying anything worth evaluating.

Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by steve_taylor on Thursday June 12, 2025 @01:09AM (#44254476)
> Various isolated cultures are going to come up with different names for God.

People hate not knowing the answer to the big questions so much that they'll readily accept whatever answers are served up to them.

> This like saying which Sun? Surya, Ra or Helios?

The difference is that the sun is readily observed. A conveniently invisible god isn't.

> All are different names of sun. But there is only one sun.

And there's only one human nature, which is why it's not surprising that common artefacts of human nature (e.g. religion) emerged universally throughout ancient human cultures.

Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by hshshshshsh on Thursday June 12, 2025 @07:14AM (#44256293)
Try to find who you are and you will find god.
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by lukas099 on Friday June 13, 2025 @11:18AM (#44269329)
The gods in different cultures aren't just named differently, have different properties.
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by kgwxd on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @05:08PM (#44251817)
Belief in anything is completely trivial unless you act based on those beliefs. No one is going to waste time worshiping, or murder someone over, the "nothing" from before "something".
[dead]
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by tengwar2 on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @04:33PM (#44251506)
How so? If you attribute it to an earlier universe, you are just pushing the problem further back. It doesn't seem to be a proof or even a mild indication.
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by gjsman-1000 on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @04:35PM (#44251533)
The universe casually didn't follow the laws of physics immediately after the Big Bang, an improbable event directly after an improbable event. No explanation has been found, even according to CERN, why everything that was created was not spontaneously annihilated. Attributing that to a divine intervention is the most probable explanation. CERN attributing this to "Some unknown entity" is humorous.

One theory (which CERN is using) is to argue that almost all matter was destroyed, and that the current observable universe is merely the tiny leftover due to slight differences in behavior, making the Big Bang look more like the Ludicrous Bang. This, of course, just contributes to religious snickering at how all problems are solved by adding another billion years to the timeline, over and over.

https://home.cern/science/physics/matter-antimatter-asymmetr...

Edit to reply: They behave differently; but why there is more of one than the other, remains unexplained; as regardless of how they behave, both should have been initially created in equal numbers. As for Sabine Hossenfelder's quote, that's a religious-faith level cop-out. When science requires faith, should it not be treated as a religion?

Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by ben_w on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @05:07PM (#44251814)
> No explanation has been found, even according to CERN

Incorrect.

First, let's be clear, "our understanding of the laws of physics" is not "the actual laws of physics". Every physicist knows this. The universe always follows the real laws, physicists are very excited about the difference because it's a chance to win a Nobel Prize.

For example, the one in 1980 for the discovery (in 1964, they're slow to award the prize) of CP violation in decays of neutral kaons, which is fancy physics language for "matter and antimatter do not behave the same way". This year, the LHCb experiment in CERN also discovered CP violation in baryons.

In fact, this is in your own linked article from CERN: """In the past few decades, particle-physics experiments have shown that the laws of nature do not apply equally to matter and antimatter. Physicists are keen to discover the reasons why."""

That said, personally I like the response from Sabine Hossenfelder: There's nothing to be explained, conservation laws only apply to time-evolution of a system, not to the initial conditions.

We don't look for a reason why the mass-energy was non-zero, why do we even need one for why the baryon number isn't zero?

Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by guelo on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @05:16PM (#44251901)
why do the religious like snickering at people so much?
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by lukas099 on Friday June 13, 2025 @11:27AM (#44269417)
> Attributing that to a divine intervention is the most probable explanation.

You lost me here. It seems humans have a predisposition to believe in divine beings, so this just sounds like taking human biases as a basis for truth. What's wrong with saying, "I don't know?"

Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by datadrivenangel on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @04:51PM (#44251678)
Things existing is pretty miraculous! How is any of this stuff here?!?!?
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by zthrowaway on Thursday June 12, 2025 @06:55AM (#44256156)
The Big Bang theory was created by a Catholic priest. So yes.
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by mcswell on Thursday June 12, 2025 @10:38AM (#44258342)
And the Big Bang was created by the priest's God.
Re:Research suggests Big Bang may have taken place inside a ... by lukas099 on Friday June 13, 2025 @11:17AM (#44269314)
To me, calling the unknown "God" is imposing a term loaded with human preconception and biases in exactly the place you don't want those things.