But I ended up giving up and going with 400 step stepper motors instead. They're larger, draw more current, and the drive circuitry is more complicated (it can't get simpler than a PWM servo after all). But they're accurate and significantly quieter.
One of the solutions that does not add a bias that I remember is two identical flat gears on the same axis with a spring that tries to rotate them one relative to another. This removes the wiggle room between this composite gear and the next, regular gear. The motor may have wiggle room, but the gears (which carry angle sensors, don't they?) move without wiggling, and react immediately as you reverse the direction. The load is limited though: the beating surface is twice as small, and the friction is higher.
https://img.go-here.nl/unwiggle.gif
One could put those in series too and get even less range of motion in exchange for less wiggling.
One could also duplicate the contraption on both sides. Then could replace the arm with cables (under tension) and control motion further down the arm.
Furthermore it seems you could remove the motors from the moving parts?
Ill let myself out.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GCHXNcpq3OA
Check his channel for servo motor modifications.
If cost isn’t a concern, harmonic drives combined with brushless servos are excellent. I have a few harmonic drive units, and they’re truly amazing.
The second thing is low margin. When people are pricing hardware, they usually plan a 50% to 100% margin to offset various costs that happen in the real world. From what I've heard, in extreme cases, some products cost around $100 while they are being sold at close to $1000. I believe in the Prusa printer approach: you design a good product and price it a little bit above cost. So the company grows with the community.
Deep down, there are so many times that I wish I could afford a fancy tool like a Milwaukee drill or a Mitutoyo caliper. And in extreme cases, I really wish I could have a HAAS UMC-400 or even a KERN Micro HD+. Now that I can set the price, I really wish I could make someone get what they want without breaking their bank.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UwrkfHadeQQ
I’ll buy one of these for sure, but I would cheerfully spend 3x the price if it meant being sure of support and repair and software updates for a few years.
I have bins full of exciting devices that no longer integrate, many of which have open source communities, which I just don’t have the time to deal with.
For repairs, the components are inexpensive enough to simply swap in a new one, and you can always find replacements on AliExpress.
There was one robot startup (Haddington Dynamics) figured it out how to do it at a higher price. Sadly they've been acquired and shifted directions I think.
Couldn’t you preload with some form of spring?
A spring might also be an option if designed properly. I’ll probably give it a try in July.
To get better accuracy, if sticking with this kind of RC servo, it's basically required to have two servos per joint to preload each other to kill that wiggle room. It's something I've been calculating, but I just can't figure out a way to offer it at a good price.
Interestingly, for arms that are popular in academia, even when the price goes to $10k (like ARX or Trossen), the wiggle room is still there (better, but still there).