News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Panjandrum: The 'giant firework' built to break Hitler's ... by closewith on Sunday June 08, 2025 @04:35PM (#44219324)
> British Isles

Britain and occupied Northern Ireland.

> I'm always struck by how easy it is to hike into some remote part of the UK and learn that the parish school was a training ground for Italian resistance fighters or that some park in remote scotland was where they trained commandos.

You're more likely to find a memorial to a historical genocidal tyrant or crime against humanity in Britain than anything worth celebrating. Britain helped fight a greater evil in the Nazis during the Second World War, but make no mistake - they were the lesser evil, not anything to be admired or vaunted.

Re:Panjandrum: The 'giant firework' built to break Hitler's ... by codeduck on Sunday June 08, 2025 @04:43PM (#44219367)
Good Lord, how can you function with that massive chip on your shoulder?
Re:Panjandrum: The 'giant firework' built to break Hitler's ... by MangoToupe on Sunday June 08, 2025 @04:55PM (#44219445)
Most of the globe seems to function just fine.
Re:Panjandrum: The 'giant firework' built to break Hitler's ... by cperciva on Sunday June 08, 2025 @04:44PM (#44219370)
No nation is exclusively good, but I would challenge you to name a nation which did both more good and less evil.
Re:Panjandrum: The 'giant firework' built to break Hitler's ... by MangoToupe on Sunday June 08, 2025 @04:56PM (#44219450)
You'd have to articulate how you see the UK doing good to furnish a comparable example.
Re:Panjandrum: The 'giant firework' built to break Hitler's ... by hollerith on Sunday June 08, 2025 @06:11PM (#44219805)
The Europeans invented modern science and technology, with England contributing the most (particularly during the 19th Century).

Maybe most nations of the world would've followed a course of colonization and empire if they had been as dominant in wealth, technology and organizational ability as England was.

Re:Panjandrum: The 'giant firework' built to break Hitler's ... by cperciva on Sunday June 08, 2025 @05:41PM (#44219659)
Defeating Nazi Germany is a good start?
Re:Panjandrum: The 'giant firework' built to break Hitler's ... by arandomusername on Sunday June 08, 2025 @06:07PM (#44219786)
By siding with the USSR, and letting them take control over eastern Europe? The USSR was just as bad as Nazi Germany.
Re:Panjandrum: The 'giant firework' built to break Hitler's ... by cperciva on Sunday June 08, 2025 @06:30PM (#44219881)
Fair enough, but I'd say that half of Europe being free is better than none of Europe being free. I don't think there's much the UK could have done to help Eastern Europe.
Re:Panjandrum: The 'giant firework' built to break Hitler's ... by graeme on Sunday June 08, 2025 @07:03PM (#44220023)
The USSR was terrible. Remarkably, the Nazis still managed to be substantially worse.

As one example there's the Hunger Plan. Hitler's defeat stopped him from executing it, though they had started. He planned to kill 35-41 million people in eastern europe via starvation and take the land for Germany.

The USSR equivalent, Holomodor, killed 3-5 million, and was fully executed. Horrendous. Not as bad as the hunger plan.

And that was not the only Nazi mass death plan....

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hunger_Plan

Re:Panjandrum: The 'giant firework' built to break Hitler's ... by arandomusername on Sunday June 08, 2025 @07:53PM (#44220241)
That's a fair point. USSR soldiers did mass rape women in conquered territories (and even their own). And the Brits did have that famine in India that killed a lot as well.

Maybe the Nazis were worse, but wasn't really a good vs evil war.

Re:Panjandrum: The 'giant firework' built to break Hitler's ... by bee_rider on Sunday June 08, 2025 @05:28PM (#44219603)
I mean, you might be able to make some kind of argument about the good outdoing the evil (I think it would be hard, but hey, I won’t call a line of argument impossible until I see it happen). But, the idea that it would be challenging to name a country that did less evil than GB is pretty ridiculous, right?

Most countries didn’t have colonial empires, so GB is pretty high up there (arguably not at the top) in the evil rankings.

Re:Panjandrum: The 'giant firework' built to break Hitler's ... by cperciva on Sunday June 08, 2025 @05:42PM (#44219665)
Sure. The UK has done a lot, both Good and Evil. There are lots of countries which have done less Evil than the UK. There are some countries which have done more Good than the UK. I can't think of any country which is on both lists.
Re:Panjandrum: The 'giant firework' built to break Hitler's ... by bee_rider on Sunday June 08, 2025 @07:21PM (#44220118)
I don’t think it is really quantifiable. Like if I say France, how would anyone adjudicate that? In terms of “good,” both contributed in WW2, both made some contributions to the concept of liberal democracy…
Re:Panjandrum: The 'giant firework' built to break Hitler's ... by arandomusername on Sunday June 08, 2025 @06:08PM (#44219792)
Having a colonial empire isn't evil. GB also ended slavery in the western world.
Re:Panjandrum: The 'giant firework' built to break Hitler's ... by bee_rider on Sunday June 08, 2025 @07:38PM (#44220175)
Having a colonial empire involves countless horrible acts of evil.

GB was a little bit ahead of the curve on ending the slave trade (at least compared to particularly shitty countries on this issue, like the US). But is it also a problem that they themselves contributed massively toward, so kind of a mixed bag there.

Re:Panjandrum: The 'giant firework' built to break Hitler's ... by arandomusername on Sunday June 08, 2025 @08:03PM (#44220281)
It also involves acts of good. Those empires built a lot of infrastructure and helped advance the countries. So much so, that the infrastructure (railways, buildings, bridges, etc) built by the British are still in use today in a lot of underdeveloped countries.

Slave trade is immoral, but at the time it was very common. Most nations practised it (after all, Africans were enslaved by other Africans). GB ended it at a great cost.

Re:Panjandrum: The 'giant firework' built to break Hitler's ... by krapp on Sunday June 08, 2025 @08:24PM (#44220379)
Those empires didn't build that infrastructure out of the kindness of their hearts, they did so to more efficiently enslave the locals and extract their resources and to make life more comfortable for the colonizers occupying the territories.

Absolutely not one bit of it was done to improve the quality of life of colonized people. That it did regardless is a statement about the neutral moral dimension of technology, not the relative good of imperialism.

Re:Panjandrum: The 'giant firework' built to break Hitler's ... by FridayoLeary on Sunday June 08, 2025 @08:32PM (#44220408)
Thanks for that. For example the British ended sati in India. Colonialism wasn't all brutal exploitation even if that did happen.

Britain did mess up a lot and did many shameful things but there are also lots of things to celebrate.

Re:Panjandrum: The 'giant firework' built to break Hitler's ... by xg15 on Sunday June 08, 2025 @05:19PM (#44219562)
I mean, they did supply a substantial part of the world's independence days...
Re:Panjandrum: The 'giant firework' built to break Hitler's ... by thih9 on Sunday June 08, 2025 @05:28PM (#44219605)
Re:Panjandrum: The 'giant firework' built to break Hitler's ... by cperciva on Sunday June 08, 2025 @05:40PM (#44219658)
And most of those were voluntary, not armed rebellions.
Re:Panjandrum: The 'giant firework' built to break Hitler's ... by xg15 on Sunday June 08, 2025 @11:37PM (#44221231)
And how did they become part of the British Empire in the first place?
Re:Panjandrum: The 'giant firework' built to break Hitler's ... by closewith on Sunday June 08, 2025 @04:52PM (#44219424)
Than the United Kingdom? The obvious answer in line with my comment is Ireland.
Re:Panjandrum: The 'giant firework' built to break Hitler's ... by cperciva on Sunday June 08, 2025 @05:38PM (#44219649)
I won't argue with the statement that Ireland did less evil than the UK.

I'm unclear how you can justify claiming that Ireland did more good than the UK.

Re:Panjandrum: The 'giant firework' built to break Hitler's ... by drewcoo on Sunday June 08, 2025 @07:40PM (#44220183)
More good does not mean less evil. Or vice versa.
Re:Panjandrum: The 'giant firework' built to break Hitler's ... by pvg on Sunday June 08, 2025 @09:30PM (#44220716)
but I would challenge you to name a nation

This sort of thing is way offtopic, come on. It's puerile flameframing.

Re:Panjandrum: The 'giant firework' built to break Hitler's ... by amiga386 on Sunday June 08, 2025 @04:48PM (#44219401)
It's the same old theme since 1916

In your head, in your head, they're still fighting

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Ejga4kJUts

Re:Panjandrum: The 'giant firework' built to break Hitler's ... by weakfish on Sunday June 08, 2025 @05:20PM (#44219566)
Hear hear, most of the world is content to forget the atrocities committed by the UK in the occupied north of Ireland
Re:Panjandrum: The 'giant firework' built to break Hitler's ... by twixfel on Sunday June 08, 2025 @05:44PM (#44219673)
Most atrocities are forgotten. I go most days without thinking about the atrocities committed by anyone. Except maybe currently Russia.
Re:Panjandrum: The 'giant firework' built to break Hitler's ... by weakfish on Monday June 09, 2025 @09:22AM (#44224241)
I understand what you mean, but I meant more when discussions of historical atrocities come up in discussion, it’s often centered on other nations.
Re:Panjandrum: The 'giant firework' built to break Hitler's ... by tomhow on Sunday June 08, 2025 @08:31PM (#44220404)
We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44219215 and marked it off topic.